Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 16th May 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Bringing students back to the sciences



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 23 February 2008
CONCERN has been growing about the falling number of students in the fields of science, technology, engineering and maths (Stem).
Throughout Scotland and the rest of the UK, colleges and universities are struggling to recruit suitably prepared and interested students into these vital areas, and the lack of graduates entering the job market is having a detrimental effect on a wi
de range of industries.

Within this situation, Stow College in Glasgow has emerged as proof that students are still interested in the Stem subjects, if the course if right. Against the national and international trend, applications to advanced science courses are steadily growing, with almost all available courses full to capacity. This success is so notable that senior staff members travelled to New York earlier this week, to speak at the 2008 World Congress and International Association of Colleges Conference. It was a fantastic opportunity to share experiences with international colleagues who face similar educational challenges.

As a key member of the Stem-Ed Scotland Group, based at Glasgow University, Stow has been working closely with partners in government, industry and universities to tackle the issue. The group has established that the current approach to teaching Stem subjects is comprehensive and robust, but it distorts what is seen as important to learn, focuses on taught facts and procedures, and is too assessment-driven, cumbersome and excessive. The findings suggest the curriculum needs reform to focus more on skills, and involve testing of the application of key ideas and approaches.

At the conference, Stow highlighted that, in contrast to mainstream current provision, a Stem curriculum must bring the subject to life, addressing contemporary issues, particularly those receiving media attention. There needs to be more engagement between learning institutions and employers, and professional development for teachers.

Within this context, the college role is incredibly important. Colleges have a key role to play in working directly with students, with industry and with schools. In terms of students, colleges can "rescue" those that have disengaged with school-taught science subjects and reintroduce them to the sciences. When it comes to industry, colleges engage with employers and ensure the courses on offer are tailored to their business needs. When it comes to schools, colleges can support them through changing their teaching of science and engineering, collaborate to provide a portion of their mainstream delivery and offer professional development for teachers.

All the courses offered by the science and health department at Stow College have been closely developed in consultation with employers, universities, the Scottish Qualifications Authority and students themselves. In particular, the college's close links with local universities mean students have good progression routes to degree-level courses, and close links with employers mean courses are relevant and practical. We are offering students what they want: attractive, relevant courses with tangible prospects upon graduation.

One example is the higher national certificate in diagnostic imaging and radiotherapy, which helps radiography assistants to "up-skill". Three groups immediately benefit from this new qualification: the students now have a career path where previously there was none; busy hospital radiography departments will be able to ease pressure on staff when the assistants qualify, and waiting times for patients will be reduced as a result.

It has been reassuring to learn at this week's conference that some of the solutions proposed here in Scotland by Stow College to the problem of recruiting students into Stem subjects are being noted on an international scale.

However, there is still much work to be done by Scotland's colleges, the education sector more broadly and industry itself. If we really are to see Scotland developing into the healthier, wealthier, greener and smarter nation envisaged by the Scottish Government, then encouraging more of our young people to pursue a career in science, technology, engineering or maths is absolutely essential.

• Calyn McNab is head of the science and health department at Stow College, in Glasgow.





The full article contains 656 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

truthsleuth,

South of the Border 23/02/2008 01:09:47
Mathematics Engineering and the Science subjects (MESS) are seen as 'difficult and hard work by students result they opt for the subjects seen as easier ie media studies, social sciences the arts and liesure and tourism.
We therefore have the situation in this consumer led target oriented educational system where MESS are
1.grossly undersubscribed with a coninuing reduction in the number of courses.
2.dumbed down to the lowest denominator to achieve 'accep[table' pass levels to please the politicians.
3. consequetially industry cannot find the qualified engineers/scientists it needs.

You find many of those students who do take MESS are really not up to it and 'drop down' to what they see as the less demanding subjects with obvious cosequences for later years of any of the MESS disiplines.

The results of two or three decades of consumer/target led education are plain for all to see where we now have a nation that has to go overseas for the skilled qualified engineers and technologists and for the students to 'fill' its MESS courses. We are entering a cycle where the UK (and the West in general) is in effect 'promotin' its own destruction in the industrial/technological field and we will be the third world nations in the years to come.
2

Tom in Belmont,

Belmont 23/02/2008 02:18:18
We scratch our heads over here, too, on this issue. Unfortunately, our students perceive (rightly or wrongly) that The Good Life can be had for less labour by going into fields other than MESS.
But we are partly to blame for letting them lead lives that require so little of their efforts or imagination. We overprotect them and let them enjoy "canned" entertainment without stint. Our schools spend endless efforts with the nasties and lay-abouts and tell the bright kids to make do on their own.
H.G. Wells would warn us that we are breeding a class of Eloi.
3

C.U. Jimmy,

China 23/02/2008 03:25:42
The point is that the MESS ARE harder than the softer subjects like Social Anthropology or whatever. I can well remember toiling away at the King's Buildings in Edinburgh in the 70s, studying Physics, with a compulsory programme of morning lectures and afternoon lab work. Compare and contrast the English, Psychology, History etc students in the Old College and its environs like George Square, who would turn up for the occasional lecture and then repair to the Teviot Row coffee bar for the rest of the day.

To add insult to injury, the salaries available for MESS graduates in no way compensate for the additional workload. That's why I changed career some 3 years after graduating (to Corporate Finance, since you ask) and have not looked back.

I wonder how may MESS graduates, if they had their time over again, would choose the same course of study? I know I wouldn't.
4

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 23/02/2008 08:17:14
Neither maths nor science are well taught. It is possible to teach them much better, but the way is NOT to kid kids on that they are 'fun' or 'exciting'. Trying to jazz them up leads only to disillusionment later. Like learning the piano, there's a lot of hard work involved and the rewards are intrinsic rather more often than extrinsic.
5

Max Born,

Crois na Cìse 23/02/2008 08:33:04
The upside of this is that even at my time of life I have job security due to the lack of qaulified engineers.
6

Unimpressed one,

23/02/2008 08:41:07
It's unfortunate that our manufacturing base has declined to the level that it is since this absorbed so much of our engineering talent. this and the fact that so much PC has infiltrated our leading edge sciences in the form of animal rights targeting, GM crop destruction and anti-virtually-anything related to power generating, that most scientifically trained people will have realised that their futures lie beyond our shores.
7

Fairfax,

23/02/2008 09:25:11
CU Jimmy (3): "To add insult to injury, the salaries available for MESS graduates in no way compensate for the additional workload."

I don't believe this is generally true.
More than half of my mathematics students here in Cambridge go into finance, where their salary typically exceeds £50K within five years; in many cases it's much higher. Similar numbers obtain for, say MESS students from Imperial College, London. Thus available salaries for MESS graduates are much higher than for many other disciplines (and certainly the humanities).

Non-finance careers pay less well, but the many technology companies in Cambridge still pay fairly well.
8

Fairfax,

23/02/2008 09:27:47
CU Jimmy (3): "That's why I changed career some 3 years after graduating (to Corporate Finance)"

Corporate Finance is not highly mathematical, but many other areas of finance are both highly mathematical and extremely interesting. I don't think a MESS student who becomes a quant should be regarded as one who has left mathematics.
9

The Strategist,

23/02/2008 12:13:03
It's a question of opportunity and demand. Kids aren't stupid and look at what's going on in the jobs world. If there are very high tech, interesting and well paid jobs around then they're not going to choose that career path.

Scotland in particular but the UK in general now has very few well known companies in the tech and engineering sector.
10

McMicrogal,

23/02/2008 17:45:59
With a degree in microbiology and biotechnology I had a far lower earning power than many other graduates in "softer" disciplines. Combine that with the fear of being targetted by the animal terrorists and you can see why people would want to avoid the field.
11

Resolutions,

23/02/2008 18:49:27
A good few of the folk on here are complaining about the poor teaching of the Science subjects as they are not inspiring the youngsters and are hard!

Has it ever occurred to any of them, that the Health and Safety have a lot to answer for? Teachers are no longer allowed to do some experiments let alone the youngsters. Now I recollect, many years ago, that 'the experiments' were the highlight of science classes and provoked many questions about how and why - the basis of enquiring inquisitive minds. It is not the same as seeing pretty pictures of it. It also taught us that you had to be careful with certain things - skills for life I would say. We also saw the point of the correct 'writing up' and the calculations and data that had to be collected to prove a point. The application of science if you like!
And not all 'social sciences' are 'soft' by any means. Many make you ask questions and to search out answers - involvement, which is sadly lacking in school science. If you want interest, you have to grab 'em young and not bemoan the fall. Search for the reasons why.
Mind you it is not helped by stupid 'careers' people, who do not know that biology is needed for forestry and veterinary, that physics is used in a wide variety of things and is essential for physiotherapy(try doing a course without it, even if you get in), chemistry is in food and nutrition and more examples could be cited.

Start at school with the courses and kick the Health and Safety into an appropriate position and not stifling everything and there will be a turnaround.Ask why the kids are disillusioned and do something about it!
12

cynicalm,

Edinburgh 23/02/2008 21:24:31
When will we recognise that a certificate in managing a burger bar will probably be more useful to the community than a degree in English literature, or whatever.
We should not support courses other than those which have a positive potential for the nation, namely science and engineering.
Soft options should be available only on a commercial basis.
13

Resolutions,

23/02/2008 23:39:12
So you think that all writers do not need a degree do you cynicalm! And that they do not have a positive potential for the nation.

Poor Stephenson, Walter Scott, Nigel Trantor, Rabbie Burns,Hugh McDiarmuid et al.

What a blinkered view of 'education'!
14

C.U. Jimmy,

24/02/2008 02:13:46
7,8 Fairfax, I accept that all generalisations are tenuous (including this one) but if you look at say, the jobs pages of the New Scientist, and then at the jobs pages of the Financial Times, you will see what I mean. Both can be accessed on the internet, by the way.

As for "leaving" mathematics, when struggling at University to master non-relativistic Quantum Mechanics, Degenerate Functions, and the like, I used to have the strong impression that Mathematics was leaving me!
15

Resolutions,

25/02/2008 12:11:42
Notice in todays printed Scotsman, how highly selective they are about comments!
16

Liberal for life,

Dunblane 27/02/2008 17:54:39
There is no doubt the standard of teaching from primary school upwards has to be improved first and foremost. Anything else is papering over the cracks.

As a society Scotland and the rest of the UK will have to find new innovative ways to compete in the global market thats for sure.

The travesty is at a time investement is required the priorities on show by this Scottish administration fails to live up to any kind of expectations. We all know they won the election with no clear strategy but its a scandal when they prefer to pursue populist agendas rather than work on the bigger picture. I suppose they are awaiting the next policy debate at the next LibDem conference to come up with another good idea for a plan.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Do you think it’s over the top to threaten celebrating students with the police?
No, drunk students are a menace
Yes, the authorities are just killjoys
Yes, just focus on the individual troublemakers

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.