Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Toulouse 26 - 33 Glasgow: win increases Scottish rugby's feelgood factor

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 19 January 2009
GLASGOW revealed their bubbling 'Warriors' spirit to Europe on Saturday to stun a full-strength Toulouse and claim the best result in Scotland's Heineken Cup history.
This glorious success trumped Edinburgh's fine first win in France, over Castres three months ago, because Toulouse are three-times Heineken Cup champions and currently a king-pin of European rugby. That it came a day after Edinburgh had sealed the double over Castres added to the feelgood factor in Scottish rugby.

Watch a slideshow of pictures from the match here

In tournament terms, the victory meant nothing to Glasgow, as their hopes of reaching the quarter-finals were dashed by early defeats to the Dragons and Toulouse, though it leaves the French club now needing a good win over Bath in England this weekend to seal a last eight spot they had thought was in the bag pre-Christmas.

But this was a special, quite unbelievable 80 minutes to watch. Glasgow put themselves into a terrific position when Graeme Morrison got to a Max Evans' grubber to score after 12 minutes and Kelly Brown finished off a scintillating try featuring the quite superb Evans', Max and Thom, and John Barclay, after 26 minutes. Dan Parks converted both and added two penalties and a neat drop-goal for a scarcely believable 23-3 half-time lead.

Toulouse sent on four substitutes at half-time, squeezing every bit of talent from a 22-man squad of 21 internationalists, but in a crucial third quarter the only in-roads they could make to a formidable visiting defence – take a bow defence coach Gary Mercer – was two Jean-Baptiste Ellisalde penalties. It was significant when Yannick Nyanga, a France Test star, was replaced on the hour-mark, having been wholly outplayed by John Barclay, who was himself just part of a tremendous back row display.

Ironically, Glasgow then lost Barclay to the sin-bin, largely for defending himself as a frustrated Ellisalde – also shown the yellow card - threw a flurry of punches at the flanker in response to a ball being kicked from a Toulouse scrum.

Ellisalde had slotted a third penalty before going off, the scrum-half having shifted to stand-off at half-time when Byron Kelleher, the All Black who revels in a challenge, replaced Frederic Michalak.

Parks missed the penalty given for Ellisalde's boxing, in a stadium now ringing with jeers, but the stand-off made amends with a 45-metre effort in the 66th minute. Then, incredibly, as Toulouse ramped up the pressure, Max Evans wrapped up a Glasgow victory. He got his toe to a loose ball around halfway, hacked on and when it bobbled away from Hefin O'Hare over the Toulouse line the speedy centre was on the spot to dive on the ball for a try easily confirmed by the television match official. Parks converted.

Against most teams, a lead of 33-9 with the clock ticking into the last ten minutes would easily be enough to canter to victory, but, with their great urgency, power-packed forward and back play and breathtaking verve in attack, Toulouse are the one team in world rugby that could defy such odds, and they certainly gave it a go.

They created four or five genuine try-scoring chances in a pulsating denouement; the Glasgow defence was finally burst open for two tries - one a penalty-try after a series of collapsed scrummages on the Glasgow line and the other involving a hint of crossing before Vincent Clerc broke through - but the other chances ran aground on the intensity and accuracy of Glasgow's tackling and breakdown work inside their own 22.

O'Hare's tackle on Clerc, which denied the winger another score – which, converted, would have pulled the scores to 33-30 with still four minutes remaining – underlined the mammoth team effort to hold on to an historic victory. Andy Henderson left just 15 minutes after he had come on, the victim of a yellow card as Glasgow piled into every breakdown to stop the hosts.

Gaffie Du Toit, the Springbok, missed a 78th minute penalty, Cedric Heymans spilled the ball in the tackle ten metres out and then Du Toit converted a penalty award. But, that was the final minute, and Du Toit's demeanour as the ball sailed between the uprights highlighted the disinterest in the bonus point the kick garnered. The final whistle blew, Toulouse players looked to the skies, stunned, a record of 15 straight wins ended; the first home defeat in nearly two years, by a lowly-ranked but near-impregnable Scottish team.

Lineen added: "We knew there would be a backlash, and sure enough it came. It was never a done deal until the final whistle - Toulouse have great strike runners all over the park and they can and will hurt you if they have a sight of the line.

"But I'm delighted with how we defended. We showed great character. Our team showed true 'Glasgow spirit' and it's about time we recorded a win like that. We ran Bath close twice and we knew we could perform on the biggest stage against the biggest teams. In Toulouse, we proved it and I'm just so proud of that performance."

As the Glasgow players recover today and begin to turn thoughts to the final Heineken Cup match of the season, at home to the Dragons on Friday night, the challenge they face is still one of consistency.

They proved on Saturday that they do have what it takes to beat them the best in European rugby – Toulouse and Munster at full-strength away from home inside a year - and the levels of work-rate, concentration and aggression they reached must be the targets they set every week from here on in.

Coaches and players talk of learning curves, and this is one major, confidence-boosting lesson they can grasp and put to good use in the coming months and years. Only then will Glasgow and Scottish rugby be able to ascertain the true worth of this historic day in Toulouse.

Scorers

Toulouse: Tries – Clerc, penalty; Pen – Ellisalde 3, Du Toit; Con – Jauzion, Du Toit.

Glasgow: Tries – Morrison, Brown, M Evans; Pens – Parks 3; Cons – Parks 3.

Toulouse: C Poitrenaud, V Clerc, M Kunavore, Y Jauzion, C Heymans; F Michalak, J-B Elissalde; J-B Poux, V Lacombe, S Perugini, R Millo-Chluski, P Albacete, J Bouilhou, S Sowerby, Y Nyanga.

Subs: A Vernet Basualdo for Lacombe 25mins, D Human for Poux, F Pelous for Millo-Chluski, F Fritz for Kunavore, B Kelleher for Michalak, all 40, G Lamboley for Nyanga 60, G du Toit for Ellisalde 74.

Glasgow: B Stortoni; J Maria Nunez Piossek, M Evans, G Morrison, T Evans; R Jackson, C Gregor; J Va'a, D Hall, M Low, D Turner, A Kellock (capt), J Eddie, K Brown, J Barclay.

Subs: J Beattie for Eddie 43mins, E Kalman for Va'a 52, R Vernon, J Beattie, D Parks, F Thomson for Hall, A Henderson for Morrison, H O'Hare for Nunez Piossek, all 60, R Vernon for Brown 75.

Ref: W Barnes (RFU). Att: 18,720.

Hadden hails victories

SCOTLAND head coach Frank Hadden last night hailed Glasgow and Edinburgh after the most memorable Heineken Cup weekend ever for the nation's pro teams, writes David Kelso.

With less than three weeks to go until Hadden's side launch their Six Nations campaign, the coach admitted the victories over French opposition had given him plenty to think about in terms of selection.

Hadden, who is due to reveal his pre-tournament squad tomorrow, declared: "I was delighted with Glasgow's win in Toulouse on Saturday – especially as it came so soon after Edinburgh's success over Castres at Murrayfield. It wasn't only the results that were outstanding – it was the manner in which they were achieved.

"There is no doubt that a lot of players are putting their hands up for selection – and that is great from my point of view."

Meanwhile, speculation is rising that Glasgow will snap up Lions and Scotland scrum-half Chris Cusiter, whose contract with Perpignan expires at the end of the season.

Stevie Swindall is set to ease Edinburgh's back-row injury crisis by completing a loan deal from Glasgow.

He is likely to make a permanent move at the end of the season.

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 19 January 2009 11:46 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Heineken Cup
 
1

MT,

Toulouse 19/01/2009 09:51:26
It was very satisfying indeed to stand in a pub full of arrogant Toulousians and watch Glasgow tear them to peices. the sound of silence was music to my ears!
Definately one of the best games Ive ever seen!

2

MT,

19/01/2009 09:54:50
On selection: Surely after this both Evans brothers HAVE to start for Scotland. We need Cairns on the feild so I think we have no other option but to put Max evans on the wing. The backline should be:

9.Blair
10.Godman
11.T Evans
12. Deluca
13. Cairns
14. M evans
15. Southwell
(cusiter, Patterson, Morrison on the bench)

What are your thoughts?
3

GAR,

Dublin 19/01/2009 10:19:02
#1 that must have been great, got to say I watched this game on line and could not believe what I was watching. The glasgow pack was especially good. Lots and lots of selection ?s which is a good place to be in. Here's my starting 15.

Paterson, T Evans, Cairns, Morrison, Lamont, Godman, Blair, Barclay, Taylor, Strokosh, Hines, Hamilton, Dickinson, Ford, Murray.

De Luca, Cuisiter, Evans, White, Jacabson, Glasgow hooker!!

4

Tobias Smyth,

Edinburgh 19/01/2009 10:41:58
It's all that bloody Dan Parks fault they lost..er, wait a second.
5

Buccaneer,

Alva 19/01/2009 11:04:45
I'm a season ticket holder at Edinburgh, but this was a stunning result, and great for the pro game in Scotland. Well done Glasgow, and one in the eye for Dan Parks' detractors.

I'd still go for Lamont on the wing - did anyone see the try against Montpellier last Thursday?
6

Doc Martin,

Dundee 19/01/2009 11:17:28
#3 GAR - Think that is pretty close to what I would like to see... Maybe Kelly Brown in the 22.

I am really excited we can start showing some form in this 6N (I hope it all doesn't turn to sh**e) I like the fact Gregor has come in as backs coach. He seemed to have got the A's scoring with ruthless abandonment. Hopefully that can rub off on the 1st team.

BTW. Fantastic result for Glasgow and Edinburgh.... and to Dan Parks who while I don't think he is international class had a good game. SRU are you watching?? How about thinking about re-instating another pro team
7

Arbroath1320,

19/01/2009 11:36:57
Great result! Only wish I could have seen the game. Let's not get carried away thinking this means Scotland are going to create the same excitement in the 6N.
The 6N is a totally different ball-game. And Glasgow could come out on Sunday and get cuffed again by the Dragons. (Hope not I'll be at the game!)
Let's just hope for some consistency from Glasgow and Edinburgh and some confident players stepping up to the international stage.
I think I would go with MT's selection for the backs with the same bench. Though, I will always have doubts about Godman, and Parks may have played himself into contention with the performance against Toulouse. It will remain to be a thorny issue among Scotland supporters. I haven't seen enough of the forwards to give comment, but sounds like a few of the Glasgow pack must be included?
8

Arbroath1320,

19/01/2009 11:40:35
#6 Doc Martin.
Agree, these threads are always full of people wanting to create a third pro-team. It's what Scottish rugby needs. Or do we give the clubs a chance? Disband Glasgow and Edinburgh except for inter district matches and go back to the good old-fashioned club system? Could any of the clubs support professional players?
9

Venachar,

19/01/2009 12:04:57
#8, The clubs have their fine traditions and history. So have the clubs in Ireland and Wales. Yet in the pro era the game is evolving into regional sides within the Celtic nations. To suggest that we revert to "club" representation is exactly the attitude that has been holding back professional rugby in Scotland since the mid nineties. Unfashionable Caledonia Reds were the best team at the start of the pro era yet they were disbanded when they had better support than Edinburgh have at the moment. The Caledonia team should be reinstated to increase the home based player pool. Mr McKie has again this weekend stated that he is not operating a "Fortress Scotland policy" as advocated by Matt Williams. Anyone with half a brain knows exactly that he is being economical with the truth. Returnees over the last season McMillan, Paterson and rumours of Danielli,Cusiter and others returning do nothing to dispel the Fortress Scotland policy no matter what Mr McKie says.
10

Arbroath1320,

19/01/2009 12:38:28
#9 Agree with you. I was asking a rhetorical question in asking if the clubs could support pro rugby. It seemed in the Borders, the club support was so strong for the historical sides that none of the supporters would turn out to pay to watch the Border Reivers.
Yes, the Caledonia team or a team based in Stirling, should be started and should be helped to make it competitive, not just a development side. Would it attract the well paid Anglo and French based Scots back to Scotland? Maybe depends on the salary differential and if a 'Fortress Scotland' policy was adopted.
I posted last week that there SHOULD be enough talent in Glasgow and Edinburgh to field a National XV from those players already playing in Scotland. ? .
I am not, at the moment, advocating a 'Fortress Scotland' policy. This was in answer to the fact that England and now Wales will have their elite players together longer than Scotland.
11

daffy_b,

19/01/2009 12:52:25
Great performance!

This match and the away one at Bath (athough it was a loss), show Glasgow can compete in Europe. If only they could play like this every week !!

2 points from the match though:-

1. What have we Scots done to upset Wayne Barnes? His refereeing in the last quarter was dreadfully one-sided, missing numerous Toulouse infringements, but penalising everything he could against Glasgow (reminded me of his 1-sided performance in Scots-vs-NZ in the Autumn).

2. How unsporting are the French fans?? I watched a few games over the weekend with French teams involved, and in ALL of them, the French fans were jeering and booing the opposition constantly - poor show mes amis !
12

monto,

Edinburgh 19/01/2009 13:02:49

Tremendous win for Glasgow.Hadden simply must include certain of their players in the team not just the squad. In the forwards; Kelly Brown and Barclay in the backs; Morrison,both Evans On the bench Thomson or Hall at hooker;Low at tight head ;Kellock and Eddie if fit In the backs would like to see jackson encouraged in every way at stand off.

Rest of team; I agree Dickenson at loose hd Ford and Murray
Hines and Hamilton Strokosch with Brown and Barclay at 7 Blair,regrettably Godman who does not convince -hopefully Jackson soon. Morison and Cairns;the Evans boys on the wings Definitely Rory Lamont at 15 if he was fit, if not then Southall as Paterson defence is simply too weak This is the equitable mix of Edin Glas and Anglo players
13

J.A.,

19/01/2009 14:32:41
Tremendous win for Glasgow and a fine win for Edinburgh, it was a bit disappointing that Sky only manages a very short review of the Edinburgh Game.
Arbroath1320
I am in agreement with lots of your points and I agree that if the SRU has learned anything from last weekend’s results is that our clubs would not stand a chance of competing at the top level in Europe. The club game should be run in the way Selkirk are doing it, developing their own players and cutting out the ridiculous wage bills paid by some of our so called top clubs.
One point I think you should stand corrected on, you said, “It seemed in the Borders, the club support was so strong for the historical sides that none of the supporters would turn out to pay to watch the Border Reivers” Yes it perhaps would seem that way to someone reading the guff spouted out by some of the readers and scribes in this paper. The fact is the support of the reivers after their reincarnation matched the support of Glasgow and was slightly below Edinburgh. To those who think starting up a third pro team is easy, don’t be fooled, once your pro team has been disbanded for a number of years and the traditional support has drifted off to do other things, getting them back into on a permanent basis is far harder than it may seem. It certainly takes more than a couple of years of poor results then the axe hanging over it for the third year.
I’m not for a minute saying that Caledonia does not deserve a pro team, however, they certainly do not deserve one at the expense of the Borders. It would be fair to say that these two districts have suffered enough at the hands of Scottish rugby’s governing body.
14

Doc Martin,

Dundee 19/01/2009 14:52:12
Lots of good points everyone. Would I be right in saying that the Irish use Connacht as a development club? Why not start one up here in Dundee or Aberdeen... getting a couple of old heads in the team and start bleeding all the rising talent of the game here and get them Magners league experience... just a thought.

I don't think we will win the 6N this year but I see enough rising talent to believe that the future is looking a lot better.... it was only a few years a go that we couldn't have cut through a defense made of butter!
15

JCA REID,

Annan 19/01/2009 16:19:19
Many congrats on a victory over a top class side! However, Glasgow coughed up 17points in the final 10minutes. Still a long way to go. It doesn't mean they've arrived & can emulate this result against other top sides.
16

Barney Thomson,

Reading 19/01/2009 16:28:34
#9 and #10
Agreed. In modern rugby, Scottish clubs are no longer big enough to provide the level of competition necessary to sustain and develop international standard players. This can only be done by pro sides and with the recent emergence of a greater depth of talent a third side is essential to Scottish development.
Successful modern sides are almost exclusively identified with populous urban areas where it is convenient for people to attend the games and identify with the team. This is why the Borders never really took off. I recall talking to some Edinburgh officials (post-match mind you) who mentioned a survey that had been done which showed the greatest potential interest in rugby in Scotland (don't know how it was measured) was in Aberdeen and that Dundee was not far behind. Further research should be undertaken to establish whether a resurrected Caledonian pro side based in either of these cities would be a viable option. In my local area, the huge support that London Irish have attracted since their relocation to the Madejski stadium has certainly contributed to their recent success.
17

J.A.,

19/01/2009 17:19:19
16#

"This is why the Borders never really took off" With all due respect to you it depends on what you term as taking off. After only three years, the Borders were flying at a higher altitude than Glasgow a team which had been in existance since the pro era arrived.

As far as crowds and attendances are concerned, none of our pro teams have taken off; populous urban areas or not. Glasgow, in our most populated area has failed to get crowds that are any better than achieved by the recently axed Border Reivers. I ask you, had Glasgow been axed in the late 1990’s and then reintroduced, do you think they would have built a crowd very quickly? As I have already said, reintroducing a team is far harder than it may seem.

Yes, population obviously helps and it is unlikely a team in the Borders would ever achieve regular crowds of say 20,000. However, the Borders did get crowds in excess of 7,000 before they were disbanded in thelate 1990’s.

I don't know a great deal about London Irish, however, I suggest that success on the field has done a lot for crowd sizes in the same way as lack of success has done to Newcastle Falcons who have seen crowd sizes almost half this season.

Each area is quite different and the mistake Mckie has made is was to assumed that the Glasgow public will suddenly switch from watching their traditional sports (football) to following rugby.

It cannot be disputed that rugby is still the No 1 sport in the Borders and I can’t see that changing in the near future.
Although Borders supporters are very loyal to their team, when loyalty is not rewarded and your team is disbanded, it’s not as easy as just turning on a switch to get them back. Unfortunately, the SRU did not recognise this when they re-introduces the Border Reivers and did nothing apart from threaten those former supporters that unless they turned up they would lose their team again.



18

MT,

19/01/2009 18:59:54
#12 you brought up a good point, I would definately start Jackson if he had actually been given some game time for Glasgow. Rory Lamont at fullback for sure when he is fit.

My revised optimal Scottish backline:

9.Blair
10.Jackson
11.T.Evans
12.Deluca
13.Cairns
14.M.Evans
15.R.Lamont(when fit)

Cusiter, Patterson and Morrison on the bench.




19

Dissillusioned Supporter!,

20/01/2009 09:57:39
17. Hits the nail on the head re the Borders. Point is we have to have all four teams re-instated - but here's the key - fund them and let them develop - it may be 5 years before a Borders and Caledonian side get big crowds and start winning - but let it evolve!

18. Agree, start R. Jackson for Scotland and both Evans bros.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.