Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


The article has been unable to display.
 
1

,

30/11/2007 01:32:21
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 1187231, Article id was mapped to record!
2

,

30/11/2007 02:19:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 1187342, Article id was mapped to record!
3

Support the Scotman all the way,

Stop The Trolls 30/11/2007 02:48:16

#3 is a Troll

4

,

30/11/2007 02:51:31
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 1187427, Article id was mapped to record!
5

Support the Scotman all the way,

Stop The Trolls 30/11/2007 03:09:34

#5 Suck McCrunchie

While you are "Reporting Twist & Shout" Make sure you turn yourself in for the following violations. These are just some of the violations you have commited on the Threads in the past 30 minutes.

#5 No trolling. Trolling is used to describe a post that is deliberately designed for the purpose of angering and insulting the members of a Forum.

#9 No spamming or flooding. Spamming is the posting of the same (or very similar) messages to lots of conversation threads.

#12 Don't impersonate others.

#13 Do not include anyone else's personal details.

6

,

30/11/2007 05:31:20
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 1187551, Article id was mapped to record!
7

Balushi,

Canada 30/11/2007 06:12:27

I can not understand why western media or politician are become so anxious when opposite parties or leader elect in countries which considered as a competitor for them, China and Russia are great example.

8

McGinty's words,

Team two 30/11/2007 06:28:15

7. Nuke EmAll

You can't advertise here, whst's wrong with you????

9

Toast,

30/11/2007 08:34:54

Russia is a dictatorship.

10

Heilan laddie,

30/11/2007 09:38:15

There is nothing wrong with dictatorship such as this. It protects Russian culture and heritage. Look at the state of our so called democracy! So politically correct and and slowly but surely killing off our own culture, oh and so affraid of offending Muslims. Maybe we should have something like that and rid our country's of Islamic scum.

11

Boy Wonder,

30/11/2007 10:20:10

Hands up who didn't know this was happening! Be honest now!

12

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 30/11/2007 11:36:29

My hand is up, Boy Wonder.

Putin is scaaaary.

When he first became President his dead, steely glance at all those lackeys who lined the endless corridors of the Kremlin you KNEW he had "the dirt" on ALL of them, being a former KGB operative.

If you crossed him, well Siberia is a nice place to be posted while you came to your (Putin's) senses and toed the party (Putin's) line.

13

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 30/11/2007 13:19:10

jennifer

I am NOT "scared" of Putin but just highly suspicious of him and his megalomaniacal ways and his devious ploys to hold onto power at any cost.

14

Judge&Jury,

Glasgow 30/11/2007 13:39:12

When was Russia ever anything other than a dictatorship?

15

Itchy,

30/11/2007 15:37:52

#16 never. Wonder how long it will be before posters blame America for this?

Putin has been taught well by his old KGB masters. I notice that all the usual lefties are silent here. Wonder why?

16

SouthernGent,

30/11/2007 15:43:57

#17
Its doubtful "his old KGB masters" ever went away. Just sank into the shadows to arise when the time is right. Looks like that time is now.

17

Vaquero,

Philippines 30/11/2007 16:44:48

I am slightly confused by the press presentation of the Russian elections. As I understand it (and I stan to be corrected if I am wrong), this is a democratic election, if that is the case then we must all respect the will of the Russian people. Its a simple case surely of "Let the people speak".

How can Mr. Putin be accused of being a dictator if he or his party are democratically elected? I shall be visiting Russia for a few days in January on my way home from the Far East (via the transiberian railway from Beijing), and hope to at least experiance some of the prevailing culture and see if Mr. Kasparov's views are indeed relevant.

I have to ask also the question is the following a dictatorship:

1. Maggie Thatchers rule over Britian.
2. Tony Blairs rule over Britian.
3. The two Bush's rule over America.
4. Also may I ask the question, is the Monarchy in Britian a dictatorship?

Just a few questions that I find interesting.

18

Bystander,

Edinburgh 30/11/2007 17:14:04

As in the UK,ultimately the electorate gets what it deserves.

19

Goomba,

Ohio, US 30/11/2007 19:18:42

You can take the boy out of the KGB but you can't take the KGB out of the boy.

20

Kaytoc,

Maryland 30/11/2007 19:42:37

Vaquero,
It is my understanding that Kasparov has not been allowed to speak on television. It is state run and Putin has received manipulated it well.
As to your question #3 - Only the second Bush aka The Missing Link, has dictatorial tendencies.

21

SouthernGent,

30/11/2007 21:34:03

In a democracy, everyone of legal age gets to vote. There in lies the problem. Even those that can't count to 2 are allowed to vote and therefore usually have no idea what they are even voting for.

22

Vaquero,

Philippines 30/11/2007 21:48:39

#22 Why did kasparov have any right to speak on TV (I assume you are referring to a proposed election candidate for a parlimentary sea)?

As I understand the issue; Kasparov has no money to be able to register any way. I might point out that the same applies in the UK, you must meet the basic requirements of an election candidacy or you can't have your name on the ballot paper.

Also I have just seen the interview with Kasparov when he got out of jail, he gave me the clear impression that if you do not accept his view point then you are going to be shouted down.

Just looking from the outside in with respect to Russia, I see very little that I really could takke issue with, it is apparantly a democratic election.

By the way you did not explain why the referrence you nmade to my questions and your subsequent answer, how you came to the conclusion that only Bush (the father) was a person with dictatorial tendencies.

I can still say I am confused as to the intense criticism aimed at Mr. Putin. As far as I can see he has been a good leader of the Russian people. Perhaps you can prove to all of us that this is not so. I would be interested to know your view on that aspect.

Always however I am trying to gain information to help me understand the Russian culture, I have no real opinions in any direction so far on the issues I have raised!

I hope everyone including your good self can appreciate my dilemma.

23

Vaquero,

Philippines 30/11/2007 21:49:34

#22 Why did kasparov have any right to speak on TV (I assume you are referring to a proposed election candidate for a parlimentary seat)?

As I understand the issue; Kasparov has no money to be able to register any way. I might point out that the same applies in the UK, you must meet the basic requirements of an election candidacy or you can't have your name on the ballot paper.

Also I have just seen the interview with Kasparov when he got out of jail, he gave me the clear impression that if you do not accept his view point then you are going to be shouted down.

Just looking from the outside in with respect to Russia, I see very little that I really could takke issue with, it is apparantly a democratic election.

By the way you did not explain why the referrence you nmade to my questions and your subsequent answer, how you came to the conclusion that only Bush (the father) was a person with dictatorial tendencies.

I can still say I am confused as to the intense criticism aimed at Mr. Putin. As far as I can see he has been a good leader of the Russian people. Perhaps you can prove to all of us that this is not so. I would be interested to know your view on that aspect.

Always however I am trying to gain information to help me understand the Russian culture, I have no real opinions in any direction so far on the issues I have raised!

I hope everyone including your good self can appreciate my dilemma.

24

Heilan laddie,

01/12/2007 00:21:06

You may all complain or try and ridicule Russia but at least it will survive as a nation long after western europe is living under sharia law. I know where I would rather be. Look at Belaruse. They dont have half the problems that western europe has.

25

American,

USA 01/12/2007 23:18:16

#26-heilan- Although I agree that there will probably be a future londonistan, russia surely has its problems with muslims (chechnya). Who can forget the theatre with 700-800 hostages, the bombed airplane and of course the disgraceful, heartwrenching incident with the children of beslan. Russia, like many other countries, has their share of terrorists attacks from muslims-or as the libs call them "freedom fighters".

26

Guga II,

Rockall 14/12/2007 03:44:07
More old news.
27

Slokem Parum,

London 16/12/2007 23:13:29
Silence from the masses? Apathy maybe...The world has shrunk big time and nations could and should be seen as neighbours, Some bigger, stronger and better of than others. Notice I refrained from saying better in a moral or political sense! However One thing we are all concerned about is our welfare, financial social and Physical. People talk about Democracy, Dictatorship Tyranny even, but with hindsight many of the so called democratically elected nations are from from being role models of sanctity and respect.
Russia is a country that has seen a great deal of turmoil,In most cases at ground level it's populace has banded together and have made the best of a bad job, It has affected their mentality to the point that they assume they will fail but try anyway! (Something I greatly admire).
She (Russia) has tried different forms of government, failed, got used by it's own rulers, politicians, and by anybody corporate or individual who thought they could profit by it.Many people where shocked amazed and delighted to see the fall of the iron curtain.
Now Russia finds itself looking for role models as to how run their affairs... After the collapse of communism and the shaky and gutsy rebirth of the nation led by someone (Boris Yeltsin) plucked from the masses and thrown into a position of frightening responsibility and though willing to do the best, as I mentoned before, of a bad job was not cut out to be what Russia, especially at such a vulnerable period of her existence needed and even he knew it!
Try to imagine the lives of everyday Russians at that time, life is pretty humdrum but there is just about enough work and money to keep you alive then one evening you clock of, go home have supper, sleep arise the next day to find the regime you've lived under for so long where everybody lived and worked for the good of the other (OK it may not have been realistic but that was the theory)has suddenly disappeared, vanished, your place of work still exists

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.


Error displaying section details: Value cannot be null. Parameter name: String