Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Alan Pattullo: Tall order to replace Jones' towering presence if defence's rock quits Hibs

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 20 May 2009
SOME players begin in a blaze of glory, and then suffer as their subsequent performances fail to match up to their original promise. Rob Jones, however, has continued to burrow deeper into Hibs fans' affections since one supporter informed him that the jury was still out after his first weeks at Easter Road.
Jones was left stunned, since he had only played two or three games. But he vowed to prove him wrong, and was thankful that the fan possessed the guts to make this comment to his face. There was, Jones also knew, grumbling in the stands as the defend
er initially struggled to find his feet following a £150,000 move from Grimsby Town.

It has now proved a piece of business which further commends Tony Mowbray, the former Hibs manager. John Collins, Mowbray's successor, appointed Jones captain after Kevin Thomson made it clear that his future lay away from Easter Road. Jones then became the first Hibs skipper since 1991 to lift a major honour into the sky above Hampden Park and, if he goes, will likely earn Hibs four times what they paid out for him in 2006.

However, the thought of this windfall will not appeal to Hibs if it means a future without Jones. Over the last three seasons he has been as central to the team as Steven Fletcher, twice named young player of the season by the football writers in Scotland. And while Derek Riordan might be the most talented player at the club, any poll conducted among supporters who regularly attend matches would reveal Jones to be the most indispensable.

The fear is that he might now be entering the last days of his Hibs career. Defender David Van Zanten is the latest to make an impassioned plea to the skipper to remain with Hibs. "He's the players' player of the year, and deservedly so, for all season he has been a rock," he said yesterday.

Jones has one more year left on his contract, but handed his jersey to a member of the crowd following the second of two towering performances against the Old Firm over the last week. Perhaps we should avoid reading too much into this act. His sustained applause to all four sides of Easter Road at the end of last season's final match against Motherwell was interpreted as a sign he would soon depart. Even during the latest transfer window there was intense speculation that he would be on his way. Colchester United joined those clubs to be credited with an interest in the player in January. It is a list which also includes Leeds United, Derby County and Nottingham Forest.

The Easter Road club can only hold out for so long in the face of such interest, while Jones, too, is conscious of the need to seize the chance of playing south of the Border once more. He has been frank in the past about the likelihood of him moving south before long for family reasons.

Given that he turned full-time at the relatively late age of 23, he will rightly view the time spent at Hibs as a decent chunk of his career. With no prospect of European football to entice him to stay next season, only the most delusional Hibs supporter will be convinced the team can rely on his services again next season. Sol Bamba seems more likely to step back into centre-half, though the former Dunfermline player lacks the authority and dependability provided by Jones.

The Englishman has become the figure of influence at Easter Road. He can reflect on a time at Hibs where he has gained experience both on the pitch and off it. He was the spokesman for the players after a rift developed between the first-team squad and Collins, who they accused of lacking man-management skills. In the end Jones read out a statement which apologised to Collins for any embarrassment resulting from the players' actions, after they demanded a meeting with then chief executive Rod Petrie.

It was a chastening experience for Jones, but was a lesson in taking responsibility. Many argued he should have taken the situation by the scruff of its neck earlier, but few in their mid-twenties would have negotiated such a tricky situation without mishap. Just as he took faltering steps in his early days as a player, Jones grew into the role of captain. His presence on the pitch is now defined by his leadership qualities as well as defensive capabilities. At no time in his Easter Road career has this been more obvious than in that last seven days, when Hibs faced the challenge presented by successive matches against Rangers and Celtic. This is demanding at the best of times, but further scrutiny was provided by the circumstances, with the Old Firm neck and neck at the top of the league, and alert to the need for goals.

Jones responded by posting perhaps his finest performances in a Hibs shirt. Fans of the club might be tempted to treat the defender's likely departure more philosophically, since it is not expected he will be turning up again in a Rangers or Celtic shirt. But then it can't be said that he failed to catch their eye in either of the recent meetings, while the Old Firm could both do with reinforcements in the heart of their defence.

Having been the dominant figure for Hibs in recent years, Jones will be central in the thoughts of the club's supporters as they pray that somehow he might remain in Leith next season. It seems more likely that he will leave them only with a small mercy; a rare instance of a player of worth departing Easter Road, but not via the M8.





The full article contains 977 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Aitchie,

Craig Gordon Stand 20/05/2009 00:46:21
The manager doesn't want him to leave and he is still under contract.

If the Board believes Mixu should stay, then they should back him and keep Jones.

Not a wind-up - Hibs is well run financially (although not as well run as they think), and they don't need to sell their best players.
2

uncle bulgaria,

20/05/2009 00:50:33
Dont go to games so unable to comment formyself but many posters seem less convinced than Allan Pattullo.

3

neil1986,

20/05/2009 01:32:35
#1 All good points and in a lot of ways I would like to see him stay aswell but a number of factors mean that his sale (for the right price) makes sense:

1) He only has a year on his contract so its either cash in now or he leaves for nothing as...
2) He's publicly stated that he wants to move back to England so I cant see us keeping him any longer than till the end of his contract
3) We also have Bamba, Thicot, Murray, Hogg and McCormack who can all play CB, plus Sean Welsh from the U-19s coming in who seems very promising

I guess my point is that if we get an offer of 1m for him now then it might be better to take that and (hopefully) invest it in the squad rather than lose him for nothing in 12 months, which will almost certainly happen.
4

Aitchie,

Craig Gordon Stand 20/05/2009 01:38:53
#3 - I didn't rate him at first TBH (then again I don't rate any Hibs players!), but he's turned into a leader.

I think the others have the ability to replace him, but not yet the calmness/leadership.
5

Aitchie,

Craig Gordon Stand 20/05/2009 01:39:18
If a big offer comes along though, take it.
6

neil1986,

20/05/2009 01:51:29
#4&5 If we could secure him on a 3 year deal I would like to see him stay but that just isnt gonna happen.
As you say, same as with Hearts players like Driver, Wallace etc all depends on how big the offers are, if its only £250K then no but £1m for a guy nearly 30 who'll leave in a year anyway for nothing - no brainer IMO.

RE leadership you might be right there altho I think Murray has some of the same qualities and has already been captain so knows the role
7

Broonie,

Wellington. 20/05/2009 02:28:33
I thought he played well in his first season, scored a good few goals and was more often than not my MotM. Then the transfer stuff started and he got too big for his boots (pardon the pun). When he was made captain I think his form suffered massively - he was never a born leader. Then there was the Collins debacle after which I thought he was mince but the last season he has improved a fair bit, even if the goals haven't come back. All in all a pretty good signing but by no means will we fail apart after he has gone.

Pattullo, as always, goes over the top with his emotive, flowery, over-exaggerated non-sense.
8

Cammy,

Edinburgh 20/05/2009 04:13:48
Rob Jones has done well and he has earned a move to pastures new. I'm sure with only one year left of his contract the club will cash in and we all wish him well.

Hopefully he'll get the move he wants and we'll get a good chunk of cash to soften the blow.

I'm sure will be be able to replace him with another solid defender. Players move on, and new ones take over, that's always been the same for every team.
9

mixu62,

Sunny Leitgh 20/05/2009 06:37:57
If yiou want last ditch heroic tackles and, sometimes, commanding ariel displays Ok. BUT any club looking to build a solid defence doesn't need a centre hal;f like Jones. He doesn't organise, lead or hold his position and has casued more goals than he's ever stopped.

Honets but second rate........ bit like the premier league really!
10

Away down In Gorgie (2),

20/05/2009 07:47:04
I am happy to let Jones go.

But I am genuinely worried that the Hibs board have not acted quick enough to-date and sorted out the extension to Mixu's contract.

C'mon Petrie - you know it makes sense.
11

Hibernia,

20/05/2009 08:09:33
#10 that awfully decent of you to say that you are happy to let Jones go.
12

Big Red,

Aberdeen 20/05/2009 08:19:39

As ever, The Hibsman manages to go over the top with some gushing platitudes about a fairly average player.
Jones is nothing more than a journeyman SPL player and as somebody said has probably been as guilty of conceding as many goals as he's helped keep out.
I've seen him being tied in knots by Darren Mackie for God's sake, and if he was that good he wouldn't be at the heart of a team that will finish a poor 6th in the league.
Of course, all this sort of nonsense gives the deluded down at Easter Road, Hibs.net etc the chance to spout off about him being worth a million quid.
In reality he'll end up at someplace like Rotherham for a fifth of that.
13

Dublin 7 Hibby,

20/05/2009 08:54:41
The big man is English and quite reasonably wants to end his career there. To my mind he is a good CB and a very good leader. Not necessarily as captain, but someone dependable who takes responsibility. Once he got his comms with Maka sorted out, the defence improved. For the future, Ian Murray's best position is CB. and Bamba, my payer of the season, is best at sitting midfielder. Against Celtic he was superb, even showing elements of FFF. The problem areas remain at right back (and please not Bamba) and in midfield......oh yes, and in the manager's office!
14

,

20/05/2009 09:13:02
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

,

20/05/2009 09:13:55
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
16

Jambo-ree,

20/05/2009 09:21:25
"The first Hibs skipper since 1991 to lift a major honour into the sky above Hampden Park."

Above Hampden Park? God, I knew he was big but didn't realise he was THAT big! ;o)
17

Hibernia,

20/05/2009 10:11:00
#12 you are a chump of the highest order with some of that post. Jones is a decent centre half and will move to a club probably at Championship level for a rather healthy profit on what we paid for him.

How much will Aberdeen be getting for your top players during the summer? Oh thats right £0 as you cant afford to renew the contracts of Severin, Mair, Smith etc and they will be offski for nothing.
18

Phil MaGlass,

Holland 20/05/2009 10:38:09
I think he has deserved a move,he has been outstanding for the club and he will be sorely missed, just like our midfield have been sorely missed the whole season.
19

helsinki man,

finland 20/05/2009 10:53:55
He´s an average player.not our worst-not the best.sell him-get some cash-he´s gona go anyway.

2 concerns.

1-Petrie wont give all the money to replace him that we get for him.
2-Mixu can´t even pick his nose-nevermind a good player.

Petrie and Mixu have got to go......
20

Big Red,

Aberdeen 20/05/2009 12:00:42
Some of the hibees here are so far up their own over inflated erches that they don't want to see the truth.
Average player in a average team. No more than that, despite the utter twaddle that The Hibsman comes out with.
Has he been linked with Real Madrid yet ?
21

rosco.1875,

20/05/2009 13:04:00
You, mr sheep worrier, are a tool of the highest order.

Jones isn't a world beater, but, he will clear >90% of anything that comes into the box. He is excellent at what he does and would rather have him above anything you've got up there. Diamond? Considine?? Please. Although I'm sure you know more about football than Tony Mowbray, Billy Davies et al... No, you dont, your just a jumped up sheep roaster that seems to have a massive chip on your shoulder. Why do you always come on here with your mince if you hate the 'Hibsman' so much??

This average team you speak off played your mob right off the park the last time we played, how that game finished 0-0 was nothing short of unbelievable.

Fletcher was having tabs kept on him from Real, along with 8-9 others that excelled at the under 20's world cup, whats your point there caller?
22

Daillyman,

20/05/2009 14:48:16
21 rosco

I hate to say this but there were no Scotland U20 players that excelled in the U20 WC in Canada, we were thrashed every game.
23

Silence of the Yams,

20/05/2009 17:33:01
Unless we get an offer of at least £1m he should be kept.
24

Big Red,

Aberdeen 20/05/2009 19:19:11
hahahahahahahaha

The normal delusional Hibs crud.
Because The Hibsman says it's true, you actually believe it ?
Fools. Rubbish team, who'll get taken apart (again) by Aberdeen on Sunday.
Has Fletcher learned to kick with his right foot yet ?
No. Thought not.
25

Private Pike,

20/05/2009 20:34:48
#24
The difference between us is that you see him when we play Aberdeen and we see him all the time.

Nonetheless you are correct in the eyes of some Hibs supporters on these forums who have never taken to Jones, are blind to his attributions. Who say he goes walkabout and loses goals for us and is only a fraction as good as Hogg.

Fortunately they are few and far between these days and are mostly on these threads.

Elsewhere, in the real world, Jones is admired for his ability and for his dignity. Our best defender by a mile and the best CH in the SPL.
26

South Gyle Prisoner,

Edinburgh 20/05/2009 22:56:09
Jones biggest problem at Hibs has been covering Hogg's back all the time. Its been significant that in recent weeks the brilliant defensive performances have been mostly evident in Hogg's absence. Even DVZ has shown up. I think going ahead without Jones Murray is best bet at CB along side Thicot who has really impressed at the back. With Hanlon, McCormick, Hogg and DVZ competing for the wider positions.

With Fletcher likley to be off Riordan and Nish up front and a midfield built round Bamba Mixu needs to find a holding midfielder.

The teams not to far away we just need a couple of inspired signings in the summer and allow the conveyor belt to keep rolling.

The team will have learned over the past 3 games that they can do it with or without Jones.
27

Cabbage Heid,

20/05/2009 23:21:11
I could see in Jones's first game that he was just what we needed at centre half with his determined attitude and great aerial ability - the fan he spoke to was spot on though - he was lacking in game knowledge and though he's still learning he's come on miles in his 3 years at Hibs. He'll do any Championship side proud now and could do a turn in the EPL if he keeps progressing - WBA would seem a good move to me and if we got a million quid or more for him I'd reckon it good business and he'd deserve our very best wishes.
28

theguru,

21/05/2009 03:54:58
All the best if you go Jones. One of the most consistent players in the squad over the last 3 years and our best defender by a fair bit.
1m quid for him would be excellent business for a player who has made it clear he wants to go back down south and will be out of contract in a year.
Cover in the form of Murray is already here but I would hesitate at putting Bamba on the back line. Think he is much more productive in midfield and my heart can't take it when he goes in for a last man challenge.
29

Rolland,

21/05/2009 11:31:29
Another fire sale at Easter Road ?


You can't have much left after struggling to make the top six ?
30

Hibs1967,

22/05/2009 08:36:34
#29 Hoy tubby, people in glass houses and all that, what about Neilson then faf faf faf, oh and still good enough not to be beaten by your manky lot in the league.
31

John H,

edinburgh 23/05/2009 07:54:26
Roland R-- At least what we've got is mostly paid for.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.