Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Buy-to-let market 'immune in crisis'


Landlords with long-term view look set to avoid credit-crunch

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 19 April 2008
SCOTLAND'S buy-to-let market is holding up despite the credit crunch – or even because of it – as potential house buyers are nervous about a possible drop in prices and many are struggling to obtain a mortgage.
New figures from Citylets, a Scottish rental portal, have revealed the country's rental index was 3.6 per cent higher at the end of the first quarter of this year than at the same time in 2007. It stands at 108, up from a base of 100 in January 2006.
This rate of increase in rent is the highest Citylets has recorded, although it is still below inflation.

The average Scottish rent is now £633, up from £607 two years ago.

But there is a mixed picture across Scotland. While the Edinburgh rental market continues its upward trend to reach an average monthly rent of £720 from £612 in the first quarter of 2007, Aberdeen's average rent has dropped to £855 from £870 at the end of last year. Despite this decline, the granite city remains the most expensive place to rent in Scotland.

Thomas Ashdown, managing director of Citylets, said: "Demand for residential rental property remained strong throughout the first quarter of the year with traffic to Citylets.co.uk averaging 47 per cent higher than Q1 of 2007. A higher volume of properties were let than we would normally expect for the time of year and, in general, they let more quickly and for a higher rent than in the same quarter of 2007."

The average rent paid for a one-bedroom flat in Edinburgh is now £523, in Glasgow it is £454 and in Aberdeen it stands at £500. But Glasgow also seems to be suffering from an over-supply of new-build flats which is pushing down rent for two-bedroom apartments, in particular.

Statistics from Citylets show that rent for such properties fell to £671 at the end of the first quarter of this year, from £718 at the end of 2007.

In contrast, within Edinburgh, an area that stands out as booming is the EH3 postcode which takes in parts of the ever-popular New Town and Stockbridge. The average rent for a one-bedroom apartment, for example, shot up to £595 at the end of the third quarter of the year from £538 at the end of 2007. And people pay £831 for a two-bedroom, up from £799 at the end of last year.

Landlords are not having to cope for long with void periods – 52 per cent of all properties marketed in Citylets are let within one month.

But Ashdown points out that the credit squeeze has brought some bad news for landlords having to remortgage and for those looking for finance to add to their property portfolios.

He said: "Despite interest rate cuts and liquidity injections into wholesale money markets by the Bank of England, UK lenders continue to rein in and reprice their lending. The withdrawal of many mortgage products and increased arrangement fees, interest rates and deposit requirements has made financing a property purchase more difficult and more expensive."

Other commentators believe Edinburgh's rental sector will be immune from the credit crunch because of the number of long-term landlords with little debt.

Letting specialist Braemore Property Management, which manages more than 800 properties in Edinburgh, believes a core group of "cash-rich" investors dominate the market and will be unaffected by economic turmoil.

It said the result will be a solid rental market that will escape wild fluctuations, while ensuring rental levels for tenants remain affordable.

Braemore director Colette Murphy said figures from its 15 years in business show that Edinburgh's rental market is consistently strong and is relatively untouched by the national economic downturn.

She said: "When you read the various media reports you would be forgiven for thinking that investing in property would be madness.

"This is simply not true. There was a period some years ago where the typical man on the street was turning his hand to property investment. Although there were a fair number of these landlords, they never made up the majority of the market and also tended to exit pretty swiftly. Therefore anyone who geared highly and expected the rent to cover borrowings would have got out years ago."

According to Braemore, this has left a core investment group who view property as a long-term, capital-gain investment – rather than a way to make a quick buck. Murphy added: "For every person who puts the rent up to cover the mortgage there are three investors out there who won't, just to ensure their property has no void periods."

And Warners, an Edinburgh firm of estate agents and solicitors, agrees that any slight glitches in the market will not cause lasting damage on the buy-to-let sector for those in it for the long haul.

Scott Brown, estate agency partner at Warners, said: "It is important to reiterate that property is not a short-term investment.

"By viewing the longer-term, potential bumps in the markets will not make a huge difference overall.

"And the buy-to-let sector will continue to remain buoyant, as it has through recessions before. Edinburgh's property investors have a prime letting area with a number of universities and a transient workforce.

"By taking the view of increasing capital gains, rather than upping rent month-by-month, Edinburgh's investors will continue to remain strong through recessions to come, as they have in the past."





The full article contains 924 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 18 April 2008 8:59 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

iain,

edinburgh 19/04/2008 08:52:42
This article is rubbish.Nobody yet knows the impact of the current lending crisis on the BTL market in Edinburgh.In soem areas 50% of demand has come from BTL investors.If these mortgages cease to be available then prices MUST FALL. Neither is the 'data' from Citylets worth anything as a reflection on the broader market. I know landlords who are in trouble now and unable to re-mortgage at viable rates.It is only a matter of time before banks ask for capital injections to ensure that loan to value ratios are not breached by falling prices. My son and a student friend rent a flat for £750pm which is worth over £240,000 in the market.Do the sums;£9,000 per year gross rental income versus at least £12,000 cost of capital. This rent simply does not cover the cost of the capital tied up in the flat. The only reason why the impact in Edinburgh will be less than in cities like Glasgow is that this city is more middle class and more affluent than large areas of the rest of Scotland.Last but not least why do journalists ask the opinions of people 'in the business' who only have an interest in talking up property values. Surely the role of a journalits should be to ask tough questions instead of pandering to vested interest.
2

iain,

edinburgh 19/04/2008 08:55:25
I muts ad that Citylets -given such prominence in this article deal with only a tiny percentage of total rental in Edinburgh. But this article is certainly useful de facto advertising for them!!
3

11+failed,

19/04/2008 09:23:31
"Braemore director Colette Murphy said figures from its 15 years in business show that Edinburgh's rental market is consistently strong and is relatively untouched by the national economic downturn."
Reminds me of the Titanic enough of the ship holed to sink it but the Edinburgh lounge is still completely dry.
4

11+failed,

the pans 19/04/2008 09:33:27
Today at ESPC. The boom seems to be in the escalating number of properties for sale or let.
"We currently have 8,268 properties for sale or to let"
5

ccc,

19/04/2008 10:25:31
So for 48% of landlords it takes them at least a month to rent out their properties....


Yeah, sounds like a market 'immune' to the current situation doesn't it.

This paper gets worse by the day. It is getting really embarrassing....
6

Corstorphinery,

Edinburgh 19/04/2008 10:49:51
Ah wheesht, you're all just jealous because you never had the gumption to have a tilt at property. Most BTL investors have plenty equity and can stand either falls in rentals or rises in mortgages.

Sure, there will be a few muppets who bought expensive new-build in Granton and Leith who will get fried, but the bulk of landlords will see this as a further opportunity...
7

iain,

edinburgh 19/04/2008 10:51:53
The Scotsman like the Herald is in hock to its advertisers and property generates huge amounts of advertising income....I used to write freelance for the Herald and warned that many BTL landlords were not covering the cost of their capital and that many new builds were grossly over priced.A couple of my articles were spiked. After a while I was quietly told to shut up. Every iota of influence the ESPC, and law firms can use to influence copy content will be aimed at ensuring positive coverage from the Scotsman and Herald.....
8

Evan Owen,

Snowdonia 19/04/2008 11:00:31
Well done Iain, tell it like it is. We see so many 'property experts' talking the market up, or even flat, because they will personally suffer from being so stupid with their own portfolio and for encouraging amateurs to enter the market chasing the fool's gold. Unfortunately the papers are also influenced by the politicians who don't want to see the property market fall through the cracks they themselved created.
9

iain,

edinburgh 19/04/2008 11:16:18
Solicitors in the ESPC catchment area have a virtual monopoly in the property market and charge not time based fees but commissions on the value of properties to sell them. Again I wrote articles on this and it was obvious that the solicitors colluded in de facto price fixing.As property has risen in value they have maintained the same commission levels -usually around 1.5% - and enjoyed effective pay rises based on house price inflation of up to 20% per year.This is nice work if you can get it-which most of us non solicitors cannot! Surely it is time the fearless Rosemary Gallagher looked into this small matter......while she is re-assuring us that BTL will not suffer in Edinburgh...based on expert opinions....
10

come on sense,

edinburgh 19/04/2008 16:24:03
doesn't this article clearly say that the picture across scotland is mixed and that falls have been recorded? why don't people read the article before diving head first into conspiracy theories. yes, it pays to be wary of source but Citylets seem to be telling it like it is, warts and all. the 'immune' claim in the title was taken from a later quote from a letting agency.
11

boudica,

Glasgow 19/04/2008 18:51:00
The RBS was talking itself up 7wks ago and look at in now ..and Iain you are right most properties are way above what they are worth and you would have needed to be stupid to think the property market wouldnt go boom ..now maybe the houses will get back to the real valuations ..and as for some of the rents people are asking and paying that is way overboard too ..I hope this hits all those Greedy landlords hard ..
12

baldwonder,

19/04/2008 23:36:28
what business school did these guys go to? It is clear that £831 per month rental on a 2 bedroom flat would only cover a mortgage worth £166000 with an interest payment of 6%. The average 2 bed flat in Edinburgh is £200,000 so the BTL "investor" is losing interest on £34000 equity per year (or about £2000 per year).

If BTL "investors" are looking to make a return then it has to be on capital appreciation which is this market isn't going to happen.

There is no such thing as a long term investment. It will cost you about £4000 to sell a £200000 flat and buy it back at a later stage. If the value drops more than this then you are losing money.

Muppets
13

Corstorphinery,

Edinburgh 20/04/2008 00:31:22
#12

The average landlord does not buy the average 2 bed flat in Edinburgh, worth £200,000.

I bought a 2 bed flat in an 1910s tenement in Slateford for £135k in 2006 and am doing very nicely. On income....and capital.

Who are the muppets.....baldy???
14

baldwonder,

20/04/2008 11:49:32
Clearly you, and you don't even know it...

Your average rental in Slateford is £650 pcm which covers the interest on £135000 at 6%. If you have had any capital growth at all then you are not earning interest on it.

You also have to pay for upkeep, advertising and empty months as well as provide for Capital Gains Tax if you hold it for more than 3 years (that is of course when and if you make a profit).
15

Marcoloco,

Barcelona 21/04/2008 22:26:36

I must say i do enjoy reading the papers from back home.

For those people astute enough to make sensible BLT investments in Edinburgh (ie tenement property in Marchmount, Morningside, Newington, New Town and the like) then relax, you have purchased quality property, in locations that show constant high demand, regardless of a credit crunch or not.

Young professionals, students, singles, couples, europeans workers, older families, festival lets... i could go on, this market is a banker. Voids? Come off it - i've built up a portfolio of over 15 properties in these locations and i can guarantee that the longest void i've had in 12 years is 2 weeks! Granted i do the letting myself rather than leaving it in the hands of an agent, but for those wishing the market to crash - sorry folks, not here (maybe new builds in leith, granton, Livingston etc) remember the old adage location, location, location. Quality always remains in demand despite the economic circumstances.

So as landlords remortgage, rents rise - this simply brings parity. Yes we will go a few years without any uplife, but sit tight and enjoy the ride when the cycle is reading to turn upwards once more.

Look at the history books kids - property is cyclical. Hold your nerve now and benefit during the next upturn.

As for you guys who do not have any investments - don't worry. Scratch cards and lottery tickets remain cheap nowadays.
16

jockyboy,

detroit 22/04/2008 04:17:42
Agree with Marcoloco - property is always a long term investment and in Edinburgh has proven to be a fairly risk averse one when it comes to overseas expat investors (there are loads of us), especially over the last few years. Edinburgh is unique - having lived in countless cosmopolitan cities all over the world I think Edinburgh, given its size and geographical location, universities, business, parliament blah blah blah offers so much to the flux of incoming residents. The only other place I saw similar trends was Orange County, LA, although even that hot spot is now uncoiling. Again, it's all about des-res. Location. Invest in properties most people want to live in (or would die to live in) and you not only reap rewards from continuous letting periods but secure multiple offers when selling - that is if you have to sell. It's also quite good fun as opposed to watching commodities or stocks all day long!
17

Evan Owen,

Snowdonia 22/04/2008 17:57:05
When the yield on property is less than what you can get on deposit without any hassle you have to be a muppet to be letting said property even if you paid cash for it, however, if you have a mortgage attached then I'm afraid you are in need a frontal lobotomy...
18

Marcoloco,

22/04/2008 22:41:35
Evan Owen - yes & no.

The rental yield or indeed full rental and capital appreciation yield may be poorer now, but this is dependent on the degree of gearing in each property, and only reflects current market conditions.

Property investment is not a short term investment; the stock is lumpy - so you ride out any storms. If you constantly chase the best investment yields weather its stocks, property, bonds, equity etc ... you are only following the safe money and will rarely 'win' big. This is when you should wack it in a bank at no hassle.

Property is medium to long term. Ride out the times of limited return and 'fill your boots' once the market moves back in your favour. Now where's the hassle in that?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.