Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Edinburgh: The greenest place to live in Scotland

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 May 2009
THERE is limited green space, high levels of pollution and constant traffic. But now a major report has said residents of Edinburgh city centre care more about the environment than do people from anywhere else in Scotland.
Research has revealed nearly six out of ten people living in the EH2 postcode – around George Street and Princes Street – regard the environment as important.

In contrast, Kirknewton, in West Lothian, came bottom of the list, with more than a quarter of residents not caring at all about green issues. It is the first such wide-scale study of green behaviour and attitudes. It was carried out by market information analyst CACI, which combined its own data with the results of a Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs national survey into public attitudes and the environment to draw up the rankings based on postcodes.

Those with the most eco-friendly lifestyles, who recycled or bought locally grown food, were classed as "enthusiastic greens" in the survey. And those who dismissed energy saving or green issues were "environmentally unconcerned".

In Scotland overall, an average of 18.5 per cent of residents were enthusiastic greens, which was slightly higher than England's average of 18 per cent.

However, England's greenest districts had far higher percentages of residents with eco-friendly attitudes than the top areas in Scotland.

Jonathan Burston, the director of CACI, said: "Seen as the home of the metropolitan elite, we might predict that Edinburgh's more affluent areas boast residents with the greenest tendencies, as they have more money to put behind sustainable lifestyles – particularly in a recession.

"However, although the capital's residents make up half of Scotland's top ten, its outer suburbs are also home to some of the least environmentally concerned. This classification shows exactly how diverse our attitudes can be – with Scotland's green heroes and villains found all across the country, falling far behind England's finest but also not as bad as England's worst."

He added that a large proportion of those classed as "unconcerned" were young men.

"They have little or no concern for the environment," he said. "They are very disengaged."

The majority of the "enthusiastic greens" were "more up-market, better-educated and with families", he added.

Dr Richard Dixon, the director of environment group WWF Scotland, said it was "good news" that people in Scotland were, on average, more concerned about the environment than were people in England.

"People in Scotland are clearly taking things seriously," he said.

He suggested that some of the differences in behaviour were probably due to the opportunities available to people.

"Some of these things are based on what your council provides," he said.

"You can't do much recycling if there are no facilities."


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 May 2009 11:43 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

For Scotlands Future,

Vote for the SNP 16/05/2009 01:16:56
It must be green in order to have been taken in by the story that a single tram line would:
1) be built on time
2) have no significant effect on traffic during it's construction
3) be completed within budget
4) would reduce cars in the city significantly
5) solve Edinburgh's traffic problems

TIE must also be green to have imagined that politicians and businesses would stand by them and support then when the wheels started to come off.
2

Mallory,

Edinburgh 16/05/2009 01:23:19
We care so much because the 'council' has flogged off quantities of green land and public space to a motley crew of speculative developers.

We care so much because this gem of a city is under threat from insensitive architecture and corporate greed which seeks to pollute the skyline and overshadow past triumphs of urban design.

We care because the infestation of 'traffic calming measures' started by the 'blessed' David Begg has merely displaced vehicles and increased further the quantity of noxious gases and diesel particulates which damage the health of our citizens.












3

danbob,

16/05/2009 01:25:29
The problem with surveys involving the public is you have no way of measuring how honest they are being with their answers.
4

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 16/05/2009 01:37:27


Really!?

I thought living in a tent in the Scottish Highlands, beside the cows and sheep, would be the 'Greenest' place to live! :)
5

Observer,,

Glasgow 16/05/2009 01:52:04
I thought we were the Dear Green Place ?
6

Iainbroch,

16/05/2009 02:17:05
Eh!

Last time I was there it was a building site or should I say a building site where no one was working because the contractors wanted to squeeze more money out of the citizens for a disreputable Tram project.

So does Green = Black as in Blackmail = Breach of contract?

Oh and there was rubbish everywhere! Broken discarded syringes on Lothian Road, as for the ugly buildings they have replaced the Royal Infirmary with well! Green dont make me laugh. I hurt enough already!
7

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 16/05/2009 02:31:06


Aye! and in EH2, it may be, " environment important", but it is OK to get gassed by all the cancer causing chemicals our traffic fumes leave behind.

I am getting 'Dizzy' thinking about it!, maybe I would be better off, living with 'Dizzy-the-Cow' in my tent in the Scottish Highlands?

:)



8

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 16/05/2009 02:32:47


Aye! and in EH2, it may be, " environment important", but it is OK to get gassed by all the cancer causing chemicals our traffic fumes leave behind.

I am getting 'Dizzy' thinking about it!, maybe I would be better off living with,...
...'Dizzy-the-Cow' in my tent in the Scottish Highlands?



:)
9

nabodican,

Rural Scotland 16/05/2009 06:36:03
Energy saving has nothing to do with being green and everything to do with saving cash.
10

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 16/05/2009 07:44:57
Jenny, you will be the first to go when Johnston Press start the cull.
11

Media at One,

16/05/2009 08:37:30
I think #11 is correct, this is more to do with saving money that caring about the environment.
And since climate change has existed for over 3 billion years and will continue for another 3 billion years there really isnt anything to worry about - So the citizens of Edinburgh as always are showing initiative by saving money during difficult times.
12

Gdgy,

16/05/2009 08:42:50
There is talk and there is action - is there any eivdence that these people do anything differently?
I doubt it....being green has become the "right" thing to be...very few recycle enough or amke any real attempt to chaneg their lifestyles but would class themselves as "concerned"....
I bet many of the young disintereste3d men chaneg their tack if they are pursuing a young lady who is "green"....
13

Morry,

Scotland, not Edinburgh 16/05/2009 09:32:51
On a visit to the Capital four years ago, I thought the place unworthy of being a Capital city, I thought it dirty.

On a visit to Edinburgh fairly recently, I thought the town seedy and sleazy, I could not wait to get back home.

There is more to being green than recycling etc etc,

I agree with nobodican 11,
it's all about being seen as being environmentally friendly, Scotland's Capital must show willing, be an example to it's countrymen / women, it did not however, impress me one iota!!

14

green lung,

Inverness 16/05/2009 09:33:27
Could your pollsters please confirm whether the poll also included the IV36 postcode? If so, i'd be surprised whether only 6 out of ten respondents in that areaa concluded they cared about our environment. Perhaps such a poll is a convenient feelgood device to sell more local newspapers, but perhaps it's not particularly accurate. People in IV36 are making a positive difference to the way they live without downgrading their standard of living. Or having tehir cake and eating it!
15

Daff,

Edinburgh 16/05/2009 10:13:44
Are all thes whingers the same people who screamed blue murder about the congestion charge and voted against it. As the previous pollster said 'you cant have your cake and eat it!'
15
Edinburgh despite its problems is still one of the most beautiful cities in the world and is regularly voted as that. Perhaps you had been visiting a friend in Wester Hailes and never got any further!
16

Buttress,

16/05/2009 10:37:32
It's rapidly losing its appeal though.

Look at the dreadful new builds (Hotel Missoni for a start, and so much banal stuff cluttered around the St James' Centre) being allowed. Wait until SoCo is thrown up. The tram overhead wires and poles will disfigure views and clutter up Princes Street, which is a mess and set to stay that way, as the council will allow listed buildings to be demolished and crud (the new Delamore hotel and shop developmentfor example) to be put in its place.

17

Chuck.U.Farley,

16/05/2009 10:46:32
Depends on how the question was phrased;

Q.,Do you recycle and buy local produce?

A.Eh2 resident Yes of course I recycle everything and buy all my hand knitted yogurt from the farmers market.

Q.The council are proposing a £1500 levy per person for green initiatives are you in favour?
A.Shoot the communist bast@rds!
18

Chuck.U.Farley,

16/05/2009 10:52:05
Q.,Do you recycle and buy local produce?

A.Kirknewton resident,Whit flick is that aw aboot,I buy my bridies oot o Scotmid,scoff them and jist fire the wrapper on the groond

Q.The council are proposing a £1500 levy per person for green initiatives are you in favour?

A.Like a give a monkey's,my whole family have been on benefits for years!
19

Buttress,

16/05/2009 10:56:30



"121/123 Princes Street, Edinburgh

Deramore have recently submitted a planning application for a flagship 30,000 sq.ft New Look store with a 100 bedroom hotel above. Having pre let the retail to New Look in 2008 Deramore have recently prelet the hotel to Premier Inn who were keen to secure a landmark hotel in Edinburgh with spectacular views over Edinburgh Castle."

Shame about the views from the castle being spoiled!



20

,

16/05/2009 11:25:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

,

16/05/2009 11:26:22
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
22

GlenB,

16/05/2009 12:01:50
"The majority of the "enthusiastic greens" were "more up-market, better-educated and with families",

Don't you just love them -

buying organic food (flown here from some third world country where the workers are paid a pittance)

Drinking Italian wine (driven here in a juggernaut lorry)

Taking their tins and bottles to the recycling centre (in their 4x4/people carrier that they run the children to school in.)

But that's alright because they are very much in favour of wind turbines as long as they are in someone elses backyard.
23

The Strategist,

16/05/2009 12:02:18
Given that Edinburgh is the capital of Scotland's financial services sector it is therefore surprising that there is such a low level of investment in clean/green technology companies in Scotland.
24

fourthletter,

Edinburgh 16/05/2009 12:30:52
So one of the richest areas of Scotland care about the enviroment more than other areas in Scotland, what a shock I'm sure residents of West Lothian are more worried about paying their rent/mortgage and whether the CEOs that live in EH2 will be downsizing their jobs next week.
This is idiotic "news" don't let idiots near statistics they don't know what to do with them.
25

The Ayrshire Bard,

16/05/2009 13:00:54
EH2 is Alexander McCall Smith territory and much as I love his books it's obvious that he, and most of his neighbours, wouldn't dream of going any further than Valvonna and Crollas or the Balmoral Hotel, so let's not put too much faith in their utterings.
26

jockstrap,

Paphos 16/05/2009 16:20:35
Did they question every town/village in Scotland? If not this poll is meaningless.Bit like the paper reporting it
27

Geomac 1,

Scotland 16/05/2009 17:22:03
Yet more useless piffle from Jenny Haworth - what is the point of this stuff and, more importantly, who is paying for this trivial "research"?
When oh when is the Scotsman going to realise that this sort of reporting is a major turnoff for potential readers? not a week passes without such amateur and trivial reporting - and, of course, there is the usual suspect asked for input - Dixon of WWF Scotland. What about the opportunity for comment from those NOT in the ecomentalist lobby?
I very much resent and object to my classification as "villian" for not supporting this sort of garbage. Just what is CACI (CACK?)and who is funding them??
Not one gram of CO2 has been saved by this drivel - utter bo**oks.
28

Finlang,

Liaoning 16/05/2009 21:19:58
#4 Charles Linskaill

You anticipated me there, Charlie. I have a house in the highlands to which I return frequently. Doesn't get greener than our great Scottish countryside.

I've always wondered though, how this continued green governmental bombardment sits with the more fundamentalist colour-conscious Rangers supporters.
29

archie23,

london 16/05/2009 23:54:34
Well that is astonishing! 60% of those living in the EH2 postal district said they regarded the environment as important. The other 40% must have said something else. Or perhaps they didn't say anything. Perhaps they were deid. Or asleep. Were they asked? Do they know what the environment is? Princes Street Gardens? Leith? The Highlands? England? More research is needed.
30

mad moo,

edinburgh 18/05/2009 09:27:27
EH2...part of the New Town -the central commercial area of Edinburgh which includes Princes Street.

mmm....lots of 'residents' here...NOT

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.