Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Monday, 12th May 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Aberdeen scrape into top six with late winner



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 April 2008
ABERDEEN manager Jimmy Calderwood last night paid tribute to his players as they prepared for Saturday's Scottish Cup semi-final trip to Hampden Park by sealing their place among the top six in the Scottish Premier League.
A resourceful if rarely inspired win over Falkirk saw Aberdeen leap-frog their opponents into sixth place. The victory, achieved with a double from 19-year-old striker Chris Maguire, was not entirely deserved, and Calderwood himself sensed some injustice in Falkirk's failure to claim a first-ever place in the top half of the SPL.

However, the manager was grateful for his players helping maintain a record of top-six involvement in each of his four seasons at the club. Aberdeen also kept up an impressive run of home midweek matches without defeat, a total which now stands at 15 and includes games against the likes of Bayern Munich and FC Copenhagen. Falkirk proved just as tough opponents, but again Aberdeen prevailed.

"We have no divine right to be in the top six," Calderwood pointed out. "By our own standards over the last three years we have been poor (this season]. But to be fair the players have answered some questions in big, big games, especially at home. And they have done it again tonight in a difficult situation.

"There is a fine line between success and failure," he continued. "I have been angry many, many times this season. But with any luck we could be sitting in the sun with a cup in May, and suddenly it's not been a bad season."

Aberdeen face Queen of the South on Saturday in the semi-final of the Scottish Cup and can already reflect on a season where they have held Bayern Munich at home, and qualified from the group section of the Uefa Cup. This was another high-octane occasion at Pittodrie although in front of a crowd of 11,484 Aberdeen did not make it easy for themselves. Having taken the lead in the 21st minute through Maguire the home side let Falkirk back into it just after half-time, when Carl Finnigan capitalised on an error from Aberdeen goalkeeper Derek Soutar. But Maguire pounced seven minutes from the end to puncture Falkirk's hopes of a top-six finish.

"We can play a lot better but we went out and got a result – a very good result," said Calderwood. "We were not creating many chances but Chris has managed to get a goal from an unbelievable angle."

There was some debate about whether the ball had gone out of play as Sone Aluko recovered it in the build-up to Maguire's winner, but Falkirk manager John Hughes had no complaints. "That's football," he said. "I have spoken to one or two people, and they felt the ball was in. You just need to take it on the chin.

"It's all about results," he continued. "All credit to Aberdeen. I felt we were the better team and that we created the better chances, and I am so, so proud of my players. It's just disappointing that it didn't go our way. This was a cup final for us. One or two maybe stopped playing when we scored the equaliser, but they are a young team.

" If I have one apology to make then it's to the supporters, and I am just sorry we never got them there (into the top six]. But it wasn't from not having a go."

Calderwood is not a fan of the split in the league, but appreciates the reward of bigger pay-days against the top teams in Scotland. While a third-place finish seems beyond the Pittodrie side they can at least fix their sights on Hibs and Dundee United, who are both six points in front.

"You just wonder about it (the split], but it's there and we have to get on with it," said Calderwood. "And we are very proud that since we have been here we have never been out of it. Three years at this club has aged me 20 years – I am really only 30! You want to win everything you are involved in, and you want to play Rangers and Celtic, and Hibs, Motherwell and Dundee United. And luckily we are there."

The full article contains 720 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 April 2008 12:27 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Aberdeen FC , Falkirk FC
 
1

royal & ancient,

sydney 08/04/2008 00:24:39
really hard luck for a good falkirk side and very gracious comments from john hughes their manager

aberdeen - we really dont deserve to be top six - simple as that

bad luck also to some of those bitter hearts fans out there - not!
2

bring them on,

08/04/2008 03:27:36
Well done.

Hearts...... Sorry
3

GeorgeCowieOrWalterKidd?,

08/04/2008 03:45:44
#1 and #2 What's this got to do with Hearts? They were out on Saturday. Honestly, if half the people who obsess over Hearts actually just went out and got tickets, the club would wipe out their debt in no time and you'd be able to spend your time being more constructive.
4

bring them on,

08/04/2008 03:52:11
#3

Hey, I would be the first to donate to help Hearts oot, if they were really in trouble.

If I have read enough posts on here to convinve me that they are in crackerjack shape.
5

Phil Lawrence,

Tallinn 08/04/2008 07:31:14
Well done Aberdeen, but it was touch and go for long periods. TV footage was somewhat inconclusive regarding Aluko's cross for the winning goal but what was not in any doubt was Finnigan being well offside when he fluffed his close-in chance at 1-1 - that could have been some talking point if he had connected properly.

Whatever the result I was very impressed with Falkirk yet again and it seems that John Hughes has got what it takes in the managerial stakes.

Aberdeen could do a lot worse than look at Carl Finnigan and Darren Barr for next season. I know that the board are rather reluctant to open the club wallet but on last night's showing Aberdeen need more than just one or two free transfers to bolster an underperforming side.

Thankfully Chris Maguire is now starting to show that the hype was not necessarily misplaced last year when he burst into the first team and he may yet have an important role to fulfil over the next few weeks.
6

Big Red,

Aberdeen 08/04/2008 07:33:04
I can't say I agree with Hughes (or The Scotsman..what a surprise).

Bar the first 15 minutes Aberdeen were the better team throughout, and deserved to win (just).
Falkirk attract credit because they pass the ball well in midfield, but they have little to offer up front, as 2 goals in 7 games testifies.

Aberdeen have attracted a lot of criticism from all quarters this season, and while 6th place is nothing to crow about, the players at least deserve a bit of credit for their fighting performances over the last month and their unwillingness to give up in games like ICT and last night.

Contrast that with Hearts meek surrender at the weekend.

Oh, and one other thing. That's 5 goals in 3 games for Chris Maguire. Do you think he'll get the same write-ups from the press as Hibs 'wonder' youngsters ?

Eh, no. I didn't think so.


7

bring them on,

08/04/2008 07:35:01
Aberdeen, go on lads
8

Rutland Don,

Middle England 08/04/2008 07:51:32
Well done lads. Overall it was fairly evenly matched last night, as with most of our meetings with Falkirk this season. However, I do feel slightly sorry for them as they have been punching above their weight (resources wise)& did probably deserve their place at the Top 6 Table this season. They do play good football & hopefully will fight another day.

And yes, for once Calderwood speaks some sense, the Top 6 split is a farce and does the Scottish game no favours in the eyes of outsiders.

Good win though and the ball was definitely still in for the Aluko's cross for the winner. Now lets not screw up another semi. QOS will be up for it and for a change we will be in the dangerous position of being favourites.

It does worry me what happens to us next season when the loanees, especially Aluko & Maybury depart, and Barry Nic & Lee Miller who have yet to re-sign.
9

Dood,

08/04/2008 08:05:56
#4 - Bring them on.

Don't worry about it. You'll not need to help them out. I assume that you've read most of the articles and the subsequent postings on Hearts recently. If so, you will have gleaned the following salient points from their BLIND followers:

The debt doesn't really exist. The UBIG group owns it so it isn't really there.

There are therefore non crippling interest payments.

The new main stand development will happen. The £50m (circa) cost will merely be added onto the debt. Which doesn't exist anyway.

Vlad will come good. He's a nice guy.

Being in the bottom six is really good preparation for winning the Champions league.

See?

Everything in the garden's rosy.
10

Boony,

08/04/2008 08:09:57
Boooooo!!! Aberdeen are mince! an naw that nice kindy mince... the fatty kind whit tastes like baw!

C'mon the Hearts!!
11

Boony,

08/04/2008 08:14:55
#9 I get and agree with all you've just said except....

"Being in the bottom six is really good preparation for winning the Champions league." How is that?
12

GraniteCity,

08/04/2008 08:15:32
Once again have to fully agree with Big Red's post and Falkirk were undone by their blatant attempt to seriously time waste as soon as they equalised 40 mins from the end. Had to laugh at their demeanour after they equalised compared to when the Dandies went ahead with 8 mins left. There seem to be media darlings out there, Hibs under Collins and Falkirk under Hughes. Headline says it all 'Dons scrape into Top Six'....what was the headline prepared for Falkirk making it. Everything seems to be shame for Falkirk or they thoroughly deserved it. No Sorry !! as Big Red says lots of what looks like atractive footy but no end product. Don't get me wrong this is a poor Aberdeen league season and Caldo is a lucky man that the Euro games deflected attention from it but spare us the 'Falkirk deserved to be in top 6' stcuk record.
13

Dood,

08/04/2008 08:21:05
#11 - It was irony.

Never mind.
14

bring them on,

08/04/2008 08:30:47
$9


Thank for the update.

Everything rosy, then.

Phew.. Thought it might not be. Then that is just me going on, and all that,

rosy, rosy
15

Indie Rep Kid,

08/04/2008 08:43:38
Cool - another thread hijacked by a bunch of losers spouting off about hearts.

Obsessed stalkers, the lot of yer.

Well done Aberdeen and good luck if you get to Europe. But mind you don;t go rioting again and drag Scotland's name through the mud once more.....tsk tsk
16

Boony,

08/04/2008 08:45:17
ahhh irony... i shall have to learn to understand that! lol!
17

Alasdair,

08/04/2008 08:46:47
#6, Big Red & #12, GraniteCity - I totally agree, but what else do you expect from this regretable, lamentable, execrable chip-wrapper of a paper?
I gave up on expecting balance from the Hootsmon years ago.
Look back at our draw with Bayern Munich - if it had been Hearts or Hibs that achieved that, the Hootsmon would have had a centre-spread pull out, and be campaigning for a local holiday!
"Scotland's National Newspaper" my sweaty ar$e.

The Herald's report is a bit more in touch with reality, but then again, it always is compared with the drivel here.

Anyhoo, let's be happy - we're in the top six, with the other big teams.
18

bring them on,

08/04/2008 08:47:30
#15

Rosy, rosy?

Always thought the Hearts would break

19

Boony,

08/04/2008 09:09:23
#17 - "Look back at our draw with Bayern Munich - if it had been Hearts or Hibs that achieved that, the Hootsmon would have had a centre-spread pull out, and be campaigning for a local holiday!"

What a load of p1sh!
20

Food snob,

08/04/2008 09:16:53
Come on Queens on Saturday
21

victorian,

08/04/2008 09:45:01
hard luck falkirk, i was one hearts fan who was willing you to hang on to 6th place.

don't have any particular wish to see falkirk do well, i just hate aberdeen after their players cheated to get saul mikoliunas booked up at pittodrie. namely langfield, diamond the village idiot & macnamara.

oh well, can only hope they fall on their cheating faces in the cup match.

'mon whoever they are playing.

22

Indie Rep Kid,

08/04/2008 09:48:33
#21

(polite applause and murmurs of agreement)
23

Prof,

08/04/2008 09:49:28
Given the forthcoming fixture list and Aberdeen's resurgence there is a good chance instead of challenging for Europe, Hibs will end up in seventh place again this year.
24

SouthSideHibs,

08/04/2008 09:52:08
Enjoy the last game of the season Prof at Fir Park. A replay of the Cup Final of 2 years ago. How things have changed.
25

SouthSideHibs,

08/04/2008 09:53:19
#21 - even Hibs Vic?
26

JAFFNE,

08/04/2008 09:54:09
I really wish Falkirk had held on to get into the top six, next year maybe?

That said, I would rather the league did not have this ridiculous split.
27

,

08/04/2008 09:56:01
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
28

victorian,

08/04/2008 09:56:07
#22 IRK, i thank you.

#25 southside, even if it was hibs..... he lied. na that would require a great deal of soul searching.

29

Scunner,

Aberdeen 08/04/2008 09:57:01
Another good win last night. Hope Celtic can close the gap and we stop the scum winning the League at Todders in the last game of the season......Stand Free!!
30

Indie Rep Kid,

08/04/2008 10:00:56
#27 Alasdaaaaaaaaaair.....I forgot Aberdeen represent the hardcore element of the Tartan Army. I'm just disappointed there was not more sympathy for Miko after he was cruelly chopped down by that thug Fletcher.

By the way, when it comes to cheating, any club that had Miller and McLeish influencing the referee has no right to criticise any other team.

"diving Eastern Europeans"....yeah, like Kevin Thomson.

Racist sheep sh@gger
31

Indie Rep Kid,

08/04/2008 10:01:49
#27 Really hope you get back into Europe. That glorious pic of one of your Red Ultra Tamponm Crew being led away with his head streaming was my screen saver for weeks.

Beautiful!!
32

victorian,

08/04/2008 10:02:05
#27, the difference is that we jambos openly admit that miko and one or two others have not covered themselves in glory on occasion with some diving antics.

was it acceptable for diamond, langfield & macnamara to surround miko (who was clearly fouled) like a pack of snarling wolves?

there is only one thing worse than a cheat and that is someone who is selective in who they call a cheat.

you in other words.

33

Digit,

Halifax 08/04/2008 10:06:45
Nice wee result boys! Pretty embarasing having to wait this long to claim our top six spot, but given the up and down season we've had not unexpected.

Full focus on QoS on sat and will be looking forward to another European adventure next season :)


STAND FREE!!!

PS - Boony, none of yer mince borat!
34

Alasdair,

08/04/2008 10:17:36
Oh boo-hoo, the yams are clearly really hurting, eh?

Notice no-one wanted to tell me when Hearts were last in Europe after Christmas.

btw, #30, Indie Rep Kid - there is nothing in the slightest racist about acknowledging that different countries play football differently. In Scotland we play a game with closer, harder tackling for one thing. In other parts of the world such as Italy, and indeed much of the rest of Europe, including the Eastern Nations, that level of tackling is not the nome, and it is usual to go down more easily to win decisions.
Racism is based on prejudice, whereas that point is based on statistical fact. I f you can't tell the difference between the two, then you're thicker than your posts already make you out to be, which is very.
35

victorian,

08/04/2008 10:19:22
#34, in answer to your european question.

1990, uefa cup quarter final.

happy now?

36

rare indeed,

Padded Cell 08/04/2008 10:20:21
Well done the dons and hard luck the bairns. Falkirk have consistently played good football this season with very limited resources they almost reached the top 6. Aberdeen like Hearts have failed to realise their potential for years. Hibs lost half their team and still managed to make the top 6! This is a very poor league with teams who would not stay in the English first Division and that used to be the third division!

37

Indie Rep Kid,

08/04/2008 10:24:45
#34 Alasdaaaaaaair.....don't patronise me.

You have STATISTICAL fact that Eastern Europeans dive more than us Westerners? That's a belter!!

I am interested to hear your views on Kevin Thomson, Kirk Broadfoot, O'Connor, Steven Pressley and the host of other 'proud Scots' who have dived blatantly to gain an advantage. Now, THAT'S a fact.

However, making sweeping generalisations about certain cultures......wha's like us, eh??

38

Prof,

08/04/2008 10:31:35
#34 Racism includes racial stereotyping. Your comments clearly fall into that category.
39

victorian,

08/04/2008 10:32:38
aye alasdair, gonny no keep your statistics to yourself, let's see them please.

40

Prof,

08/04/2008 10:34:10
#34 Its bit like reading your comments and assuming that all Aberdeen supporters are big thick racist oafs. But of course they aren't.
41

D to the C,

Texas 08/04/2008 10:43:10
Ahh, look at all the bitter Hearts fans.

Bitter because they're not going to be winning the CL until 2010 at the earliest.
Bitter because they had the chance to sneak into the top 6 themselves but bottled it.
Bitter because they've spent millions over the past 12 years and are now a shambles.

I'm glad the Dons making the top 6 has given you clowns some enjoyment and something to focus on. It should take your minds off the miserable situation your club is in for a couple of days. Happy to help out a club in trouble.

Hard luck to Falkirk, nae luck to Hearts.
42

Indie Rep Kid,

08/04/2008 10:46:21
#41 sssshhhh....Alasdaaaaaaaair is putting together some stats to prove that eastern Europeans dive more than Scots (like Thomson, Broadfoot, O'Conno etc).

I hope he uses pie charts. I love a good pie chart.
43

bring them on,

08/04/2008 10:52:27
While the Hearts fans cry their eyes oot, the Sons of Granite celebrate a qualifictaion of the biggest kind.

The masons hammer on the granite has never been heard louder.

Come on the mason's hammer
44

victorian,

08/04/2008 10:56:18
alasdair has legged it. the diving lee miller didn't fit into his statistical utopia of scottish players being angels and all 'johnny foreigners' being cheats.

yes you can't beat a bit of holier-than-thou hypocritical claptrap about the saintly nature of the typical scootish footballer.


45

Alasdair,

08/04/2008 11:02:14
I also like the intellectual dishonesty from the Yams on year that decides that when someone complains about the diving Eastern Europeans that they've played in the SPL, that mentioning a distase for those specific players is indecative of a dislike for Eastern Europeans in general!
Oh dear - yams can't be honest.
Oh dear - yams having the gall to throw about racism accusations, when they employ an idiot like Kingston who thinks that skin-colour matters!
Oh dear - yams in the bottom 6.
46

Alasdair,

08/04/2008 11:06:24
#44, victorian - Alasdair is at work, and has more to do than check here every 2 seconds.
Another lie from a bitter yam? Surely not.

And btw - speaking as a don, we're regularly embarrassed by Lee Miller's diving.

However, tell me this, if you watch football Italia and the SPL, in which do you see more diving?

Plus, I notice no-one challenged my point that the game is played with rougher takles here.. is it racist against Scots to make that generalisation?

You clowns must be really hurting to be scraping the barrel this clean.
47

Iain Bhern,

08/04/2008 11:09:29
#38 Racism also has to be directed at someone of a different race than the racist himself. e.g. a white person calling an Asian a packy (spelling changed to get it past the moderators). Since Lithuanians, Italians etc are the same race as white Britons then name calling them is Xenophobic not racist. It seems though that few on these boards appreciate that subtle point though.
48

,

08/04/2008 11:15:49
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
49

bring them on,

08/04/2008 11:25:23
The top six in Scotland is regarded as the highest achievment in Scottish football. No team in Europe would shrug at the chance.

Tip of the sword.
50

Alasdair,

08/04/2008 11:30:27
#48, Indie Rep Kid - you know how to get a post binned? Click the complain button - the mods on here rarely bother to read what they scalp.
Which is why hitting said button is the refuge of cowards.

Anyroad - answer my question, is it racist, or prejudiced, to say that rougher tackles get put in (and indeed allowed) in Scotland than in Italy? Nice try on deflection by bringing up the Premiership, btw.
Oh! For a yam with some integrity!
51

Pedantic_Hibee,

08/04/2008 11:30:55
Prof, just you keep peddling the myth that we can finish 7th.

I'm afraid that spot is reserved for the Jambos, even if you win all your remaining games that's as high as you'll get.
52

Indie Rep Kid,

08/04/2008 11:46:01
#50 Is it racist? No, because you are stating an opinion based on a style of play which is different from country to country. How THAT comes about is for the McIlvaney's of this world to write about. However, making sweeping 'cheating Eastern European' comments is pretty poor, to be honest. Like a bit of cricket? How about those cheating pakistanis, eh??

Anyway, i don;t actually believe that the tackling in Scotland is harder than in Italy. In Italy, the players have more technical ability so you simply cannot dive in like your average Scottish defender as you'll get skinned. But, when they tackle in Italy, they tackle as fiercely as anyone.

Are you implying that the Scots are somehow 'tougher' than the Italians when it comes to football? (Or generally).

More Braveheart nonsense?
53

Memyself&I,

08/04/2008 11:47:56
"Aberdeen Scrape Through" I wonder if that would have been the headline if Falkirk or Hearts had made it.

The best team is through. More points = best team.
Great run in Europe two great runs is the domestic cups. And people have the cheek to say we don't deserve it? What a joke never mind a stupid comment.

Time wasting by Falkirk 40mins before the game ended was ridiculous and shameful.

Maybe this paper has to be a bit more sympathetic to Falkirk fans - perhaps they are trying to increase their circulation in that area - wouldn't surprise me.


#21 Are you allowed on the pc without your parents watching you?

#38 Oh well, on that basis most of us are racist. Hey ho.;p

#42 Really no need. Anyone who knows a bit about football and enjoys watching the game knows this to be true. You really have no point. Unless of course you disagree?
54

occasional,

08/04/2008 11:54:47
Have UEFA decided to allocate a Champions League spot for the team finishing Best of The Worst in the SPL?

Was it this year or next that Count Vladimir the Great Liar predicted that the Bottom Sixers would be the Champions of Europe?

hardly the place of Champions in the league this morning -

7 Falkirk 33 -4 42
8 Hearts 33 -6 42

Still good luck to them in the SPL Consolation League for Second Tier Clubs.
55

bring them on,

08/04/2008 12:04:34
Aberdeen were Bravehearts.
56

Alasdair,

08/04/2008 12:14:00
#52, Indie Rep Kid - I don't think we're tougher, but I do think that the tackles that referees here allow are harder. Consequently I think that -with notable exceptions- in general people dive less here, because they know the refs are less likely to award a free kick or penalty from the dive.
I also think that this doesn't apply to the same degree in other countries.
I also KNOW that anyone with a modicum of intellectual honesty wouldn't paint any of the above as racism.

Your opinion?
57

bring them on,

08/04/2008 12:18:01
#56

Bravehearts
58

bring them on,

08/04/2008 12:30:31
Shug,

Two to go
59

lev,

08/04/2008 12:32:51
Indie Rep Kid
60

bring them on,

08/04/2008 12:37:23
shug.

Just oot of interest, how old are you?

If you know Eric Caldow, you must be at least 50, or your dad told you aboot him.
61

Nice 1 Simmy,

08/04/2008 12:56:35
get it up yahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh ye dirty Jambo jackey's!
62

Alasdair,

08/04/2008 15:13:36
Interesting.
They had a lot to say earlier, but seem to have disappeared when faced with superior opposition.
A bit like getting into the top six.
63

JAFFNE,

08/04/2008 15:50:51
#29 scunner

Are you an Aberdeen player? I only ask as your post would suggest you are one of that mob that lies down against Celtc and is really up for the games against the mighty Gers.

Aberdeen players are the biggest cheats in the world, they cheat thier manager, fans and employers everytime they play teams except the mighty Gers!

This is why when the mighty Gers win the league it is all the more sweet as we know we havd had to fight for every point against every team. Celtc on the other hand have cheats like Aberdeen to help them out at every opportunity!

;¬)
64

Alasdair,

08/04/2008 16:11:45
Except that we've beaten Celtic far more times over the past 5 seasons than we have Rangers.
We even got a win against them that season O'Neill made Parkhead practically impregnable.

Take your Old Firm paranoia pash away.
65

JAFFNE,

08/04/2008 17:57:08
#64 Alasdair

Did you not notice the 'wink' at the end of my post? It generally means someone is at the wind up and whatever they have just posted is in fct tongue in cheek.

I know you have beaten Celtc more often in the last few seasons, this is becuase you have a couple of good bluenose Gers men in charge with a couple in the team.

;¬)

Scotsman what's wrong with blue _nose?
66

Alasdair,

08/04/2008 18:49:11
Apologies, JAFFNE - it had been a long day!
67

JAFFNE,

08/04/2008 18:56:46
No worries mate.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Should the SPL split be scrapped?
Yes
No

Web Links:

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.