Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 22nd November 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

'Fat map' reveals how weighty issue of obesity is spread across Scotland



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 28 August 2008
THIS map shows for the first time the startling variation in obesity levels across Scotland.
Dubbed "the fat map", it pulls together data from the country's 14 health boards to reveal that Shetland, Orkney and the Western Isles have the highest proportion of patients with a body mass index (BMI) of 30 or above.

This means they have been officially diagnosed as being obese, a condition that places them at risk of serious health consequences such as diabetes, heart and circulatory disease and shortened life expectancy.

BMI measures body fat based on a person's height to weight ratio. A BMI of under 20 is underweight, 20-25 is normal, 25-30 is overweight and above 30 is obese.

The map was collated by Dr Foster Research using figures from GP practices relating to the Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF) for 2006-7.

The organisation started drawing up "fat maps" in 2005 but this is the first time Scotland and Wales has been included.

The map also shows high levels of obesity in parts of Angus, Perth and Kinross. Tayside health board has Scotland's next highest percentage of obese patients, at 8.09 per cent.

The Dumfries and Galloway, Grampian and Lanarkshire health boards all fell into the medium category for obesity.

The health boards of Fife, the Forth Valley, Argyll and Clyde, Ayrshire and Arran, Borders, Greater Glasgow and Highland had among the lowest levels of obesity.

The fewest number of obese people were registered at doctors' surgeries in Lothian, at 5.72 per cent.

The map shows that Shetland has the most obese people in Britain according to GP records, with 15.54 per cent of patients weighing in with a BMI of 30 or above, closely followed by many parts of Wales.

The data, from GP practices across the UK, shows that more than one in ten patients registered with GPs in some parts of the country are obese.

Despite a report by the Scottish Public Health Observatory last September, which found more than 70 per cent of men and 65 per cent of women in Orkney, Shetland and the Western Isles are the least active and either overweight or obese, health experts are divided as to why this should be.

Professor Iain Broom, of the Centre for Obesity Research and Epidemiology at Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen, suggests the "fat map" figures under-estimate of the scale of the problem compared to other official statistics.

He said: "There is no easy answer as to why these islands have such high levels of obesity. Perhaps it is because the islands are outwith mainstream agriculture and so there is more ready-made food imported."

Colin Waine, director of the national obesity forum, suggested that obesity in communities may occur when diet requiring high calorie intake stays the same even though heavy industry, such as fishing, decreases.

A spokesman for Dr Foster Research said one explanation could be the way the data is collected, with some GPs better at reporting numbers of obese patients to health boards than others.

However, Tavish Scott, the Shetland MSP and newly elected leader of the Scottish Liberal Democrats, rejected the "fat map" findings.

He said: "Shetlanders are very active. We have great leisure facilities and lots of people use them all the time. I am highly sceptical about this survey. It is absolutely ridiculous to suggest that Shetland is an obesity hotspot.

"Yesterday Scotland's Olympians, including Chris Hoy and Katherine Grainger, returned home to a heroes' welcome. The Scottish Government should be asking these great sporting role models to help Scotland's youngsters see the benefits of active lifestyles."

Dr Ewan Bell, NHS Consultant in Dumfries and Galloway, said: "The rates of obesity in Scotland are extremely worrying.

"It is important that people understand both the risks of obesity, and the benefits to their health of modest weight loss.

"This is why it is so important that there is a funded national intervention strategy in place for the evidence-based treatment of obesity."

The "fat map" comes after the Scottish Government announced in January that it will spend an extra £15 million directly on targeting obesity, as part of an overall package of £40 million set aside for health improvement initiatives. Obesity could cost the UK £50 billion by 2050, the Westminster government has calculated.

On Tuesday the shadow health secretary, Andrew Lansley, called on overweight people to face up to reality to conquer obesity and live healthily. The Tory MP said it was time to "take away the excuses" so overweight people started exercising and eating more fruit and vegetables.

Psychologists called in to help children stay healthy

OVERWEIGHT and unfit children are to be given psychological help in Scotland's battle against obesity. Experts believe that mental barriers are a major part of the problem preventing youngsters from taking more exercise and eating healthily.

Now a week-long pilot project is being launched to combine psychological support with exercise and nutritional education in an attempt to change children's behaviour in the long term.

Organisers hope the scheme, being run by the Excel Sports Academy in Edinburgh, could eventually spread across Scotland.

Figures show that more than a fifth of primary one children in Scotland are overweight, including 8.5 per cent who are obese and 4.3 per cent severely obese.

By the age of 12, over a third are overweight, including almost 20 per cent who are obese.

Jennifer Larkin, a performance psychologist taking part in the project, said changing mental attitudes towards exercise and diet was important to ensure that children changed their behaviour in the long term.

"It is about looking at the underlying root cause of the problem and about empowering children to make positive changes," she said.

Ben Brown, the director of Excel, said the course, which will run during the October half-term week, is aimed to help children change their habits, with parents invited to take part in the last session of each day so lessons could be taken home.

A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: "

We are making tackling obesity, particularly in early life, a high priority and we have set a new national target to reduce the rate of increase in the proportion of children out with the healthy weight range by 2018."





The full article contains 1059 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 27 August 2008 9:04 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 28/08/2008 01:08:18

Well thankyou Scotsman News, for the 'rear view' in the picture, are you taking mic,?

Are you 'stereotyping' Scotland by a 'BIG BUM',?

WELL HERE IS SOMETHING TO THINK ABOUT!

TAKE THIS RIDICULIOUS MAP AND,....

'STICK IT WHERE THE SUN DONT SHINE'!!!


SMOKING MAPS!

FAT MAPS!

WHAT NEXT,?

HOW MANY TIMES YOU PEE MAPS,?

OR FORNICATE WITH THE WIFE MAPS,?


SORRY I FORGOT THIS WAS THE,...'LOONY BIN'!!

'MADHOUSE'!! WHATEVER.
2

fife runner,

28/08/2008 06:16:00
and it is costing us all in extra money being paid out in type 2 diabetes, heart disease, cancers, etc etc. Billions of pounds when we have had stories about some drugs not being funded to prevent eg kidney disease. There is your answer, selfish people who will not alter lifestyles and do not wnat to be told how to live but wnat the nanny state to keep them alive when they have made themselves ill.
3

Kenny A,

28/08/2008 06:26:26
I believe these statistics were from doctors surgeries. Fit people dont tend to visit the doctor very often. The BMI is also a very poor system as it does not take into account various factors such as muscle and bone mass, just height, weight and waist size as far as I am aware. A fit muscled person can easily land in the overweight catagory and often does. Islanders then to be fit in general as they work on the land and sea a lot. Load of drivel this report.
4

fife runner,

28/08/2008 06:48:23
I think anyone can tell if someone is fat without going to BMI. A doctor would just need to look the same as anyone can do.
5

Boy Wonder,

28/08/2008 07:36:39
What's the answer to obesity? Well, closing down a few fast food outlets, sweetshops and bakeries and not opening any more would be a good start. Forcing fat kids to exercise in school would be good. Workplaces insituting a compulsory exercise programe for employees would be another good one.

Sorry, but if we REALLY mean to tackle this problem, we have to enact draconian measures and to hell with certain Human Rights!!!

btw ... how about a 'Where Chuckles Linskaill Is Today' map?? Just so people can get out of the very old curmudgeon's way!
6

,

28/08/2008 07:57:35
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
7

Resolutions,

28/08/2008 12:28:46
BW I do not recollect many fast food outlets in the Northern Isles -Dave will keep me right on the West. Islanders get a lot more exercise than most mainlanders.

The study is flawed - seriously flawed. The prportion of very overweight people seems very high in cities - you only have to look.
8

G,

dundy 28/08/2008 12:30:49
According to this map Greater glasgow has a low rating...HOW???? WHY???
9

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 28/08/2008 12:34:02
7#Dave from Barra - There are no "big boned" people in the Lothians. : )
10

It's life but not as we know it,

The Oort Clouds 28/08/2008 12:34:37
It's simple: fatties should pay more tax via a simple multiplier effect. Income Tax + (Body Mass Index x whatever the government is fair recompense for their fatness).
11

Paula,

28/08/2008 13:10:59
This map is wrong, how can anyone possibly say that Glasgow has one of the "lowest" obesity rate - have you been there recently?
12

Ribbonman,

Glasgow (east) 28/08/2008 13:31:58
Yes Paula #13...... I live in Glasgow. Walking doon the Gallowgate yesterday,I saw an obese female,so obese that you could easily play a round of golf on her rear end.

Sad! very sad!

13

IainA,

Edinburgh 28/08/2008 13:55:58
Interesting how the tw*t-o-tron seems to be posting to this site. Fat people are "Costing us money", "Draconian Measures and to hell with certain human rights" etc. etc.

Speaking as a something of a lardy b***ard myself, my view is that there is such a thing as freedom of choice - and that freedom includes the freedom to take the consequences, including diabetes, heart failure, stroke etc.

As to the NHS, let's examine this "costing the NHS umpty million pounds a year" argument.If you take it to a reductio ad absurdam (and why not? other posters have no compunction about doing so)you could argue that any "self inflicted" condition should not be treated - this would mean that in a head on vehicle collision it would be crucially important that the ambulance crews identify which driver was at fault, as they could only treat the innocent driver.

Or perhaps not, it could be argued that taking to the road in the first place is deliberately putting yourself in harms way.

Now, that is absurd as anyone can see, however, it suddenly becomes not absurd when applied to people who overeat, or smoke, or drink.
14

long live the supermarkets,

Every flight hurts 28/08/2008 14:05:50
What about charging fat people extra on airlines,every time i fly i always end up with a fat person taking up my personal space and yet the airlines charge me for excess baggage,i don't think this is fair everybody should get weighed before they get on and if your bmi is to high, charge extra, this i am sure could bring down fares.
15

Resolutions,

28/08/2008 14:11:34
And Iain#15 the study makes no reference to medically induced obesity (some drugs are horrendous), underlying conditions etc

Not all obese conditions are due to over-eating etc.

By the way, I am not in that category, but several family members are- and it is NOT over-eating and lack of exercise.

A usual one solution does not fit all!
16

IainA,

Edinburgh 28/08/2008 14:15:28
#17 Resolutions

Ah, you're preaching reason and commonsense though, when the anti-lard posters are looking for a stick with which to beat a group whose lifestyles they don't approve of.

The usual neo-puritans where the only approved excess is an excess of zeal.
17

Tom00000,

Glasgow 28/08/2008 14:34:22
Surely the point is that there IS an obesity problem in Scotland ?? NO progress has been made FOR OUR MONEY,in the last 30 years, on the subject of why only SOME people have problem appetites/energy levels and their neighbours with similar income and knowledge of food do not. The most rewarding explanation is, as ever: "Other people just don't try hard enough!" We currently pay many science graduates to recycle this quality of reasoning. Big Pharma/Food has never been so happy! Appetite is physiological, can be influenced by stress hormones so is fertile ground for Psychologists and Pharmaceutical Interests cashing in.
18

Charles Linskaill,

On the go on the mobile 28/08/2008 14:41:44

Eat, drink, and be merry!

Down with the train spottess brigade!

LONG LIVE THE REVOLUTION!
19

Chris M,

28/08/2008 16:13:39
#3 - BMI does not take waist measurement into consideration at all.

BMI is calculated by taking a person's weight in kg and dividing it by their height in metres squared;

e.g. Gordon Bulloch's BMI (ex-Scotland Rugby International with 75 caps) according to his vital stats on Wikipedia would be

100/1.8 x 1.8 (3.24)= 30.8

So, he falls into the obese category....
20

Resolutions,

28/08/2008 18:47:33
#21 Precisely Chris - the BMI is pointless as a statistic and measurement.
#19 Yes there is a problem,but see my post at #17. There are diverse reasons for the problem and one solution does not fix all!
#18 You mean there is not too much between the lugs on the reasoning side? Quite agree if the posts here are indicative of their reasoning. Thank you for reckonising reason.
21

Ribbonman,

Glasgow. where all the skinny people live. 28/08/2008 20:10:57
Last week a driver was pulled in by the polis. They informed him that he had struck an obese woman. He (the driver) said that he was aware of the incident. When asked why he did it he replyed, that he did not have enough petrol to go around her. For the record,the woman was unhurt! Sad, but true.
22

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 28/08/2008 21:49:22
Thank you for that report. I am looking for places to open a chain store of fashion items for larger people, on behalf of Michelle-Ann and Michelle-Ann Man
23

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 28/08/2008 21:53:12
Fatties Anonymous has an anthem.

Weeble, Weeble, Weeble overcome.
24

Terry53,

Norwich 28/08/2008 23:56:50
This is because the people of Shetland and Wales are shorter than the rest UK population. We know this because the good people of Shetland live in little peat roofed bothys and the Welsh are all miners. What a lot of bo--ocks.
25

Kenny A,

29/08/2008 08:02:15
7 Dave from Barra

Dainty city dwellers, like it, according to some later posts some of these creatures would scare Godzillas granny.

Liked 21's post although I am fairly sure waist measurement is considered, also the fact that some people cant help being fat.

Interesting fact I have never seen a fatty from Barra. Do you have such creatures there.
26

Dragonhead,

Dalian,China 29/08/2008 11:04:46
The usual excuses for the in denial by those who have gone beyond being chubby. Obese is obese.Whatever scale they use,some will question it's efficacy.What then do we use to judge those who are morbidly obese? There are some who are more to be pitied than scorned,due to their size being outside their control.To the rest, no amount of PC change of terminology can change the fact that there is a huge problem. The sooner folk admit their problem, the sooner it can be rectified.Strange that in England in another paper,the vast majority of respondents to the article, admitted their problem and many were now intent on doing something about it.Obviously in Alba the views are different.Wonder why?
27

Dr. Andrew Hamilton,

Shetland 08/09/2008 15:25:30
My feeling is that the situation is probably far worse than these figures show. I work in General Practice in Shetland and my practice has done a number of health promotion projects over the past several years.

As part of this process we have weiged and measured most of our patients and we have accurate figures for about 80% of our patients. This equates to nearly 97% of those aged 18 and over, so the charge that we only weigh the unfit fatties in the practice does not stand.

Our figures show that only just under 27% of our patients are in the normal range, with 42% classed as overweight. Now I'm sure some of that overweight group, with BMI between 25 and 30, are fit, muscular crofters and manual workers, so that figure doesn't bother me too much.

Now it doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out, from the above figures that we are left with a staggering 31% of patients who are either obese (BMI 30 and over- 28%) or "severely obese" (BMI over 40-3%).

Remember that figures from General Practice are usually going to be incomplete and you can see that if you find 100 obese people on a practice list of 2000 that gives you a figure of 5% until you realise that they've only got up to date weights on 30% of their population.

If we ever do get accurate heights and weights on everyone we'll be shocked at the results. I reckon about a quarter of the population will be obese and we'll all be paying a fortune for the treatment of their diabetes, heart disease etc.
28

Scotchmissed,

10/09/2008 16:04:48
# 27 - Chris M (#21) is correct in that Waist measurement is not used when calculating BMI.

There is a separate indicator using Waist measurements where for men there is an increased risk of Coronary Heart Disease when the WC >=94 cm and a substantially increased risk of CHD if it is >=102 cm. For women, the figures are: increased risk >=80cm or substantially increased risk at >=88 cm

Whatever way you look at it though, there is a big problem and it needs to be adressed, otherwise obesity will end up costing the NHS millions. Question is, what's next? The Food phoneline didn't work, the Food Tzar is no longer - suggestions on a postcard to Victoria Quay?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.