Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Hogmanay review: Edinburgh - Big sounds in the big chill prove a big success

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 January 2009
Concert in the Gardens/ Street Party

Princes Street Gardens and Princes Street, Edinburgh

4 Stars
A BIG cheer went up from the crowd, and a member of Attic Lights took his chance to dedicate the next song to his mother from the Waverley Stage. It wasn't his band the chilly but alcohol-warmed crowd were making noise for, though, but the early vol
ley of test fireworks going up in the air above the Castle.

This all kind of demonstrates how the music takes second place to the general spectacle and revelry of Edinburgh's Hogmanay – even when Glasvegas's James Allan played a song for his mum later on, it was a personal touch rather than anything the crowd could actually hear.

Bearing in mind last year's gloomy predictions that this event was either doomed or due a few dramatic cutbacks, it's worth noting that absolutely everything about this year's Street Party and Concert in the Gardens felt like a success.

A wintery chill in the air was all the revellers had to contend with, in lieu of previous years' dangerously high winds and pouring rain, while the bands were so well chosen as to offer something for almost everyone.

Glaswegian indie-poppers Attic Lights and Edinburgh's much-loved folk rockers Broken Records provided local kudos, while Paolo Nutini – on the main stage in Princes Street Gardens first to allow plenty of time for his journey across to perform in Glasgow's George Square – offered something aimed a little more towards all the parents there with their families.

The second act appearing in the Gardens, on the other hand, were for those party-goers who are probably still up now. They're a pop band as much as they're a dance music outfit, but St Albans band Friendly Fires provide for fans of either genre.

Their biggest hit is quite possibly the best song of the year, the charming and epically romantic Paris, and it sits precisely amidst their catalogue of club-ready party tracks (Ex-Lover, On Board) and light, infectious pop tracks (Jump in the Pool). To put them on a stage of this size, while their star is still relatively low on the rise, was an act of good faith from the event's organisers, and it's one which the band repaid completely.

The next time Friendly Fires will be seen in Scotland is on the NME Awards tour at the end of this month, and the projected headliners of that show also put in an appearance here.

That it was on the lesser-sized Waverley Stage was strange, but then everyone probably expects Glasvegas to make it to the status of undisputed Hogmanay headliners very soon. Not that the Glaswegian quartet seem a particularly celebratory band, with songs about absentee fathers and knife crime, but there's something about their bleary-eyed, half-hungover sonic fuzz and rowdy, singalong paeans to childhood scraps (Go Square Go) and familial divisions (Daddy's Gone) which chimes perfectly with a Scottish celebration.

When Allan unveiled special guest Carl Barat, ex of the Libertines and Dirty Pretty Things, as his co-vocalist on a haunting version of We'll Meet Again, the night was already theirs. Groove Armada's fun but frivolous post-bells house-funk in the Gardens just couldn't match such emotional depths.





The full article contains 559 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

King Richard IV,

Brisbane. 02/01/2009 02:09:49
I just spent "New Year" in the Aussie outback an reckon that would match what you've just gone on about(minus the drugs, the techno $hite, and the other 299,000 extra people you you would never get round to meeting) oh, and we done it in a pair of shorts.
2

Pocket Dictionary,

02/01/2009 07:40:06

Shame about the television though. Tuneless Leon Jackson murdering 'Auld Lang Syne'. Whoever commissioned 'Only An Excuse' needs to be fired. It was absolutely dire - Jonathon Watson, you are the weakest link, time to say goodbye.

Not even a decent film - James Bond, Von Ryan's Express and the Heroes of Telemark. It seems to have been a season for WWII films, the day before it was the Battle of the Bulge and the Great Escape - if only I could have afforded to!
3

1745,

Edinburgh 02/01/2009 09:27:26
Having read your article & seen the video our street party in Edinburgh certainly seems to have been a roaring success Why therefore is it that TV viewers were unable to enjoy this spectacle courtesy of the BBC? Oh no just that appalling Jackie Bird prancing about in our Castle's Great Hall( Not a view of the Hall itself, which would have been more entertaining.The Band with Phil Cunningham & Ali Bain was great the rest pure rubbish.
4

Edward,

02/01/2009 10:01:07
#3 1745
I agree coverage of the actual events in Edinburgh were appaling. The only bit we saw were some of the specatucular fireworks, which misteriously was excluded from the BBC national news, which prefered to go with a picture of a piper
The events in Edinburgh were the best in the whole country including London. (It should be rememberd that London only had fireworks at the London Eye and a crowd along th embankment to watch and that was that)
5

Check your facts,

Edinburgh 02/01/2009 10:22:48
While reporters with press passes to the main stages may have enjoyed Edinburgh's Hogmanay, it was a very different story for the thousands of people who paid £10 just to get stuck in a crowd on Prince's Street. Far too many tickets were sold, meaning that most of us were just stuck in a gridlock on the main street unable to hear any music and unable to move. It was total greed on the organisers' behalf. While we tried to make the best of the situation, we got absolutely no value for our money. Needless to say we won't be going again.
6

Brian Hill,

Edinburgh 02/01/2009 14:31:57
I've been abroad for many of the Hogmanay celebrations over the past 10 years and therefore reliant on BBC World News for world celebrations.

More than once Edinburgh hasn't even been mentioned but even when it has London is always portrayed as the centre of events in the UK.

The BBC's coverage of events in Scotland be it the Festival or Hogmanay is NEVER as good as events in England e.g. those awful gingoistic Last Night of The Proms or Wimbledon or anything English for that matter.

And let's not forget the saying: Who do you think you are, Stirling Moss? Stirling Moss, who never won a world championship in his life? What about multiple world champions Jim Clark or Jackie Stewart?

Ooops, they were Scots, Stirling was English, stupid question, sorry, must remember my place in the pecking order i.e. underneath the Oak table (bought with Scottish Oil money) waiting for the crumbs.
7

Moder8,

EDINBURGH 02/01/2009 15:09:05
Tuned in to the BEEB to get an accurate countdown to the New Year. Made the mistake of watching Leon Jackson desicrating Auld Lang Syne, turning the song into a tuneless dirge. Not the sort of rousing start we need for 2009 which might well be a tough year. Who is the programmer responsible for such a lackluster show? Bring back some dancing and Scottish music rather than trying to plug so and so's next record release.
8

The Pict.,

Canada & Edinburgh 02/01/2009 18:03:15
# 6 The BBC LONDON give the TV feeds to the world. NOW HOW CAN YOU EXPECT TO SEE ANYTHING FROM SCOTLAND that would take away from the English ? Awa' an' gae doon tae the shops tae buy a new bunnet, kneel like the Firefly lackie, and apologize for your inflamatory remarks. Dinny talk aboot the Edinburgh Festival because you might be overheard. Now we can have any advertising showing anything Scottish when we can enjoy the ads featuring things the English Jamican Jazz bands one of which gave a brilliant recitation at the Commonwealth games in Victoria B.C. Canada. Or the fantastic Pubs of London etc etc etc.
A guid new year tae ane an' aw' especially you Brian Hill.
Slaint Mhath
9

Brian Hill,

Edinburgh 02/01/2009 18:18:37
And a Guid New Year Tae Yersel Canadian Pict.
10

Car is not King,

02/01/2009 20:51:44
Paolo Nutini was advertised as opening the stage show in the Gardens. Well we arrived just after 9.30pm and he had long gone. What a complete scam. Instead we were left with a very fat 2nd rate singer who waddled around the stage. I will not be going back. In previous years we have had some decent groups in the Gardens.
11

Decrepit,

New Town 02/01/2009 23:31:43
I sent a query to ask@edinburgh etc asking what happened to the fireworks on the other five hills and they replied to say that that was the responsibility of: Winter Festivals, Waverley Court, 4 Marklet St, EH88BG. I await their answer with keen interest.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.