Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

The hunt is On.
Sponsored by
Can you track down Scotland's wildest beastie?
 
 
Friday, 5th December 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Quadriplegic knife victim calls for hard line on thugs



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 18 September 2008
A MAN who was left paralysed from the neck down after being stabbed spoke yesterday of the devastating impact knife crime had on his life.

Scott Breslin was just 16 when he was the victim of an unprovoked attack by a group of teenagers. During the assault he was knifed in the neck, which severed his spinal cord, rendering him a quadriplegic.

Mr Breslin, now 23, who grew up in the
east end of Glasgow, told a Scottish conference examining the impact of violence on victims and perpetrators details of the impact on his life.

It now takes him three hours to get up every day, he has to take 32 tablets daily and his life expectancy has been considerably shortened.

The Violence Reduction Seminar was held by the Violence Reduction Unit in Glasgow and aimed to brief delegates on how to engage and support both the victims and those who carried out the crimes.

Senior figures at the seminar included justice secretary Kenny MacAskill along with academic Susan McVie, from the Scottish Centre for Crime and Justice Research.

Mr Breslin described how he had been at a chip shop with friends when they were "ambushed" by a group of teenagers. While trying to run away he felt what was like a "punch in the neck", which sent him tumbling to the ground, breaking his nose and smashing six of his teeth.

"I had never seen them before. I think someone was going to get it and I was just the unlucky one," he said. "I was in hospital for nine months which was almost like a jail sentence."

Mr Breslin, now a media and communications student, said he felt "betrayed" when he found out his attackers would be released halfway through their sentences of ten years and four-and-a-half years.

He said: "It's totally unjust. The sentences are disgusting. It is a betrayal."

The conference also heard from Ms McVie on the complex link between offenders and victims.

She described how somebody who is subject to a violent assault at a young age, because of social factors such as economic and family background, is much more likely to become a violent offender themselves.

At the meeting, Mr MacAskill said action was being taken to improve safety on Scotland's streets.

He said: "Our streets are safe and those who perpetrate crime face the consequences of their actions. There is so much more to be proud of in Scotland than alcohol-fuelled violence."

He also said additional legislation to tackle knife crime is something under consideration in the upcoming Criminal Justice Bill.





The full article contains 442 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 17 September 2008 9:38 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Knife culture
 
1

Mark Renton,

Edinburgh 18/09/2008 05:04:11
There are no words to respond to this. Knife crime and anybody who carries a knife need to have their goolies cut off.
2

tomi,

18/09/2008 05:52:04
Who cares??

Clearly not the lawmakers and the judges who sentence the thugs who attack innocent peoople!
3

fife runner,

18/09/2008 06:06:02
Lord Carment at the High Court in Glasgow in the 50s virtually put an end to razor slashing overnight. It was rife then. He told one teenager as this is your fist offence I will only give you 12 years.

Perhaps the time has now come to go back to real sentencing.
4

Boy Wonder,

18/09/2008 07:08:24
Stop knives being sold in these Army & Navy and outdoor centres for a start. I passed a display in one quite recently.
5

Brodric,

18/09/2008 08:41:07
Agree with Boy Wonder.

Take the knives out of shops. Perhaps even license them for fishermen. In reality, who needs a knife for ordinary everyday life.
6

Helmut Smegma,

Edinburgh 18/09/2008 08:58:39
There`s a shop in Argyle Street,Glasgow (Victor Morris) which openly displays and sells knives,crossbows,air guns and air pistols.Crawling with neds and would-be hard men every day salvitating at what`s on display.
7

Astarte,

Giffnock 18/09/2008 10:52:28
A terrible tragedy has befallen this young man and the hooligan who carried out the violent act against him will be free to continue his life, possibly without remorse, and may gain the sympathy of society if one has to fall on the belief of Ms McVie, who is referred to as an academic, and can show that her dissertation contains empirical material. I can also claim the distinction to being an academic and can therefore debunk her theory as many criminal phsychologists have already done so in discussing the path of criminal behaviour. It is true that the human product of a depraved home in socially unpleasant demographic can engender crime, and even find a peer group within that demographic to encourage its pattern and this is also the likely thread which criminal defence barristers grasp to make a case. However, empirical data shows that this example takes a minority place when the study is perpetuated in examining the behaviour of child units in under-privileged society. Persons being tried for criminal violence must be charged and sentenced on that premise alone.
8

JG,

Fife 18/09/2008 11:06:00
#7 Astarte
And while you 'academics' discuss the theory of crime and its causes people are being attacked on our streets.
It's time people took responsibility for their actions - if someone undertakes to rob a shop, for example, and the owner is killed by the robber who is carrying a knife, it's not 'culpable homicide' or any other watered down crime; IT'S MURDER! Stop making excuses for criminal behaviour.
9

Ronaldo Stuffed Everyone,

18/09/2008 11:33:18
there's a simple answer to this -Lets adopt the islamic justice system.
10

lyn,,

Kirkintilloch 18/09/2008 11:56:36
They who are found guilty of killing or in this case left paralysed from the neck down should realise where they should head...Bring back the death penalty and save us decent hardworking tax payers money.
That would make these idiot's think twice.
11

JayDeeTee,

18/09/2008 13:17:03
People convicted of stabbing should be put in a room with the relatives of the victim. It's the only language they understand
12

AtheT,

Aberdeen today 18/09/2008 13:24:23
It is not the knife that does the deed. Tis the low brow ill educated thug. To lazy to study and earn his keep. More interested in impressing the floozies on the corner or his mates. If not knives it would be sharpened sticks or rocks.
13

Duke,

18/09/2008 13:38:06
I agree with number 11. Anyone convicted of a knife crime, no matter how small, should swing from the gallows. It will soon stop.
14

WKKB,

18/09/2008 14:55:41
#9 bogman - YAY! I applaud ever word you said. I agree it begins at home. Kids get away with murder these days... literally!

The article states: "At the meeting, Mr MacAskill said action was being taken to improve safety on Scotland's streets."

My daughter witnessed 5 young teenagers ambushing and kicking almost to death a 22 yr old man walking home from work in front of her house. She phoned 999 right away and did anyone ever come???? NO NO NO NO NO! The police kept her on the phone asking if they were friends feigning the attack, if she suspected there might be any serious injuries, did she phone because she thought there was a threat of life...??? What????? By the time she got off the phone the kids were gone and the man, her neighbour was struggling to stand up. She was afraid to go outside for fear of the attackers being around the corner watching so she phoned her neighbour and asked him to go outside. She then phoned for an ambulance which arrived 15 min later. Her neighbour is now in hospital with multiple fractures to the ribs and one arm, a skull fracture and he'll most likely be blind in one eye the rest of his life. From what the other neighbour says, he didn't know any of the teens but described them as 14 - 16 yrs old.

Where was the police? Clearly not available to investigate that attack.
15

Danepiper,

18/09/2008 15:19:41
Clearly you've created a society of passive civility. Self defense is a thing of the past. No guns, no knives, next to go will be gramps and his cane. Law enforcement is just that, mucking up the mess "After The Fact".

Well, now the Wolves are among you. Either lie down and die like good little sheep or stand up like men and strike them down with fire and sword.
16

nolimits,

Far North 18/09/2008 17:02:26
Well folks, this seems to be a world wide thing.Over here (across the pond) my wife and I were threatened by a gang of young thugs outside our home. After sending the wife inside to call the police, I proceeded to explain the consequences of their actions to them. 2 walked home by themselves. The rest were waiting, in some state of disrepair for the arrival of our local constabulary. The upshot of all this? We have never been bothered again by anyone, and the police while concerned about the actions taken by both sides, never pressed charges.
The self defense training I have taken over the years has stood me in good stead at the ripe old age of 60+ :)
17

GalacticCannibal,

Murrieta CA: for more WAR VOTE McCain 18/09/2008 18:19:35
Hey Dudes.

The young criminals who destroyed the life of 16 yr.old Scott Breslin. Should serve out their sentences.

Here in the states they would be locked up for 25 years and in Texas lightly to be hanged.

I show no mercy or compassion for criminals be they young or old.

GC
18

Russell M,

Stirling 18/09/2008 18:57:23
"While citizens were forced to rely upon government for protection, government adopted a more lenient approach toward criminals. Official skepticism about the virtues of prison has resulted in most offenders being released into the community. Those who are incarcerated receive sharply reduced sentences and usually serve only half of these. Concern for the welfare of the criminal fraternity has resulted in the insistence their rights must be protected even when they are committing a violent crime."

Without the fundamental human right of self-defence all other rights are ultimately meaningless. By adding, in 1967, the requirement of "reasonable" force as judged after the fact, thereby altering the traditional standard for self-defence, it is "now stated in such mitigated terms as to cast doubt on whether it still forms part of the law."

What became of the British right to protect yourself? It was teased away over the course of some 80 years as the state insisted on a monopoly over the use of force, aided and abetted by the BBC's selective reporting of violent crime.

And now many of you want to continue the extreme anti-self-defence agenda, by outlawing the carrying of knives.

The great legal scholar, A.V. Dicey said, "Discourage self-help, and loyal subjects become the slaves of ruffians."
19

Danepiper,

18/09/2008 18:59:15
GC
So your lips say but your by-line says you'd vote for Obama and bring us several steps closer to the Socialist Schlock of Britain.
The Thugs who damaged Mr. Breslin at the very least should live long lives of perpetual servitude, drudging in a cold lifeless environment with just enough food and clothing to keep them alive as their every farthing went toward Breslin's support
20

Rami,

Derry, NH 18/09/2008 20:37:53
Since we use our Nat'l Guard and Reserves in any given
emergency I recommend that Scotland's own home defenses
or some of your Reservs assist local Police Depts.,
especially in those known troubled districts. These
punks would sure turn about when confronted with a
manned vehicles with deterents mounted as such and
operated by a competent Military Trained group.
21

Rami,

Derry, NH U.S. 18/09/2008 20:39:54
I am very touched to read all the above opinions on
behalf of Mr. Breslin's plight. Just is not fair:-(
I am also a 65+ senior; really what can any of us do to
save our own lives, especially by being confronted by
either overwhelming odds, or even an individual with
superior strength as compared to his next poor victim:(
Since the United States has used our homeland defense
being the Nat'l Guard and Reserves in all kinds of
emergency's, why not have some of Scotland's Army
Reserves assist your local Police Departments especially in those areas of question! These tough
punks would change their minds real quick if they
saw some of Scotland's own in vehicles with some form
of weapon aray mounted upon it with a crew at the ready!
22

Pomodora,

Gravesend 18/09/2008 22:42:35
#8 JG. Fife, I do believe that you should re-read Astarte #7 without expressing a hostility towards academics for the comments made which are saying exactly what you say one post later. Re-read and if you can't understand it, get help!
23

JG,

Fife 19/09/2008 00:47:10
#23 Pomodora
I am well aware of what Astarte said - and the fact that he turned it into a debate between academics. That was actually my point - academics argue the finer points while no solution is found for the street violence. Is that easier for you?
24

Lanna,

Calif desert 19/09/2008 04:19:37
#16/20 Danepiper,
Interesting posts. I've often thought how it came to by that the right to self-defense is no longer a right, but if you defend yourself in your home and the bad-guy is injured, you may be the one in jail. How has this come to pass? I do agree that criminals should be made to work to pay restitution to their victims.
Scary, what of our freedoms are slowly being eroded as well.
25

Stonefish,

Prince George BC 19/09/2008 06:19:22
#24 JG. Fife. I too must agree with Pomodora's post #23
afetr reading Astarte again. Astarte was not entering the fray of academic debate but was simply alluding to
Ms McVie allowing her scholastic qualifications to be held up in justification of her opinion. This opinion was being debunked by Astarte who used her(?) own academic licence to counter. It is often referred to as fighting fire with fire. Astarte made it very clear
that a criminal must be punished on the evidence of a crime committed and not be judged on the conscience of society. Both of you agree on the same principle, Astarte just articulates better.
26

Rid_NedCulture_By_Lethal_Injections_Into_Buckfast!,

Glasgow 20/09/2008 03:17:41
I am saddened by Scott's unfortunate story and the sickness that is the justice system.. I myself have been a victim of its poor 'justice'

Criminals and thugs nowadays arent afraid of prison as they now know too well that unless its murder, then its fair to say you will get away with nearly anything if your are alcohol or drug dependant.

These idiots get themselves high on alcohol or drugs go out on a rampage not caring who they harm, and when faced with the consequences they get lawyers and social workers all claiming its their unsettled upbringing and the fact they are alcoholics/drug users etc.. It all makes me want to vomit!!

I dont know how most of the MP'S , Judges, Social Workers can sllep at night when they can sit and defend these moron's rights and say that something like community service or drug counselling etc.. will rehabilitate them into no longer wanting to go out every friday and saturday to stick a knife into the next unsuspecting victim.

The Cops nowadays dont have any street credibility and I have seen many young kids taunting them and laughing at them.. All respect has gone and Law and Order needs to be regained, the streets should be reclaimed and more police officers are needed!

Kids are now growing up without respect, they dont respect their own parents, teachers or Police etc. And I say if a youngster is too young to be sentenced then punish the parents!!

I would also love to see something in force like say .. stopping all benefits if any violent or serious crime is commited.

No giro = no smack or bucky lol

Also as I read all about Mr Breslin's unfortunate encounter, I was stunned to learn that the same Mr Breslin can be seen talking on Youtube about the 'quote-("euphoric feeling when running in a gang, its like a drug")-end quote'

Its not that im getting at Scott, but the stark reality is.. If you are part of a gang, ANY GANG.. sooner or later, you will be somewhere without your gang mates and someone you dont kn
27

Rid_NedCulture_By_Lethal_Injections_Into_Buckfast!,

Glasgow 20/09/2008 03:27:37
cont..

dont know will undoubtedly remember you from another scheme or remember seeing you chase them that night. And unfortunately this happens all too often, a youth is spotted outside his local area and is set-upon or attacked in what is seen as unprovoked.

~~~~'A pack of wolves will hunt and feast on greater enemies, but a lone wolf can starve itself to death as it doesnt impose the same threat'~~~~

Anyway enough from me.. Peace out everyone and stay safe out there in these mean streets x

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.