Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Miliband admits: I nearly quit the Cabinet

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 13 June 2009
DAVID Miliband was on the verge of quitting as Foreign Secretary on the same day as the European elections, he revealed last night.
Mr Miliband admitted that last week, he had been considering whether to follow cabinet colleague and long-standing friend James Purnell, the former Work and Pensions Secretary, out the door.

However, he quickly decided to stay loyal to Gordon Brown during the reshuffle, which saw 10 ministers leave the government.

"I'd made my decision on Thursday," Mr Miliband said"Sometimes you can make your decisions with great planning and calculation and sometimes you have to make them rather more quickly.

"James made his decision in good faith, I made my decision in good faith…we all have to live with our decisions."

However, last night also saw Lord Mandelson, the Business Secretary, predict the Prime Minister can expect another challenge to his position around the time of Labour's annual conference in September.

Lord Mandelson said a "small group" within the party would never be reconciled to Mr Brown's leadership, but insisted he would not "lose any sleep" over it.

The comments came as former Home Secretary Charles Clarke ratcheted up the pressure on Mr Brown by saying he must win two upcoming by-elections, in Glasgow North-East and Norwich North, as well as boosting Labour's standing in the polls, if he was to escape calls for his removal.

Mr Clarke is expected to use a BBC interview today to indicate that he still wants Mr Brown to go.

And prominent backbencher Jon Cruddas warned that Labour could be finished as a major force in British politics unless it had a fundamental rethink of its policies and approach.

Lord Mandelson acknowledged that Mr Brown had not silenced his internal party critics when he faced down demands for his resignation at a meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party in Westminster on Monday.

"There's a small group who keep coming back. They won't be reconciled to the Prime Minister's leadership," said Lord Mandelson, who was last week named First Secretary of State – effectively deputy prime minister.

However, he added that he would not "lose any sleep" over the threat they posed.

Political analysts believe that, had Mr Miliband followed Mr Purnell in quitting as polls in the council and European elections closed on Thursday night, he would have forced Mr Brown out of office.

He was not one of the ministers who flocked to the television studios to declare their loyalty to the Prime Minister that night, although he let it be known he would not be resigning.

Speaking after a three-hour special session of Cabinet in Downing Street yesterday, Mr Miliband said Labour's leadership had been given an "electric shock" by the disastrous European election results, which saw the party finish third with just over 15 per cent of the vote.

He urged fellow ministers to get out and prepare for "the fight of our life", saying that all Cabinet members should be given "free rein" to go out and make the case for Labour.

Voters do not know what the party and Mr Brown stand for, he admitted.

"We need to make sure the talents and energies of not just the whole of the Cabinet, but the whole of the Labour movement are given free rein because one in 20 people voted for us," said Mr Miliband.

"The truth is that we are not automatons. We all have to get out there."

Mr Clarke said Mr Brown had several hurdles to overcome if he is to remain leader.

The former Home Secretary said:"If, for example, our poll ratings go up or we win these by-elections, I think the issue will go away and he can be confident he leads us into the next election.

"If, on the other hand, he somehow doesn't fulfil these things or electorally we do badly or whatever, it might be that the issue will still be there."

After Mr Brown acknowledged in his speech to the PLP that he had "weaknesses", Lord Mandelson appeared to offer him hints in how to improve his performance as leader.

The Business Secretary said:"I believe in leadership and in being decisive. Secondly, in listening to people and respecting official advice you receive. And thirdly, introducing a bit of humour and jollity to your work."


The full article contains 729 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 June 2009 12:37 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Labour Party
 
1

nabodican,

Newton Stewart 13/06/2009 00:51:53
Would anyone have noticed if Milliband had quit?
Personally I think he is doing a village idiot out of a job somewhere.
2

Iainbroch,

13/06/2009 00:56:54
It is a great pity he didn't! Perhaps we can all look forward to a Portillo moment now!
3

Observer,,

Glasgow 13/06/2009 00:57:41
this is like the political equivalent of hello magazine.
4

redcliffe62,

13/06/2009 01:13:58
the red rosette in springburn, sorry glasgow north east, at the by election will have a duplicitous monkey attached, and there is at least 50% of people who will support the benefits party.
springburn has one of the highest areas for bad backs and alcoholism in the country. the great swathes of greater lanarkshire unwashed sadly living up to their scurrilous reputation.
this is a seat labour cannot lose. and will not lose. they have too many people DEPENDENT on them.
means testing of bad backs and general skiving as a policy by labour would of course hit their majority substantially, so do not expect that sort of policy anytime soon.
the other by election will have a third aprty the grens, which will take a lot of labour protest votes, allowing tories to win.
if labour put off springburn by election then they must really be worried about the snp for this is one seat they can win with an arm behind their back, which is a nice way to describe brown's leadership.
the cynic in me says what can brown offer glasgow in september to try to sway voters. anyone got any ideas? a new royal mail centre?
5

Scotindy,

Los Angeles 13/06/2009 01:21:03
Someone is going to make a movie out of this lot, probably be a comedy. The liebor party are the laughing stock of this disunited kingdom and should quietly pack their bags and go. Roll on Referendum day so that we Scots and others who live here can show the unionists the door to hell forever.............INDEPENDENCE AT ANY COST........
6

redcliffe62,

13/06/2009 01:22:22
miliband said he would quit and then changed his mind when he was offered some additional incentives. my guess is he agreed to probably support miliband in leadership battle when brown eventually goes, supposedly in a few years time. once a pollie always a trougher.
7

Iainbroch,

13/06/2009 01:26:07
re4

The Lord Protector of England will ensure a Liebore victory. It was one of the seats that SNP did not win at Euros. The Lord Protector will however arranged for a decent distraction just in case though.
8

Observer,,

Glasgow 13/06/2009 01:28:07
4 could I make a suggestion that you don't go canvassing ? With an opinion like yours, you are hardly likely to persuade people unto the cause.

I also would hazard a guess that some SNP voters may be disabled and unable to work.

For the avoidance of doubt I work and always have done, but I find views like yours so contemptuous of my fellow citizens really quite offensive.
9

Edward,

13/06/2009 01:37:22
WHO CARES!!!
This is just another trivial story about a nobody
what a waste of newsprint
10

Brianwci,

13/06/2009 01:58:31
Nearly doesn't cut it. Are we supposed to believe a politician in this current climate.

And what are we supposed to do when he says he NEARLY quit....draw a deep breath, look heavenward and say a prayer of thanks?

Nearly resigned??? Who cares??
11

donald,

glasgow 13/06/2009 03:06:29
Bleary is so sorry she quit. She is missing the perks already.
12

cabrach loon,

inverness 13/06/2009 06:37:58
Why say it? Either he did it or did not. So what is his game ploy now? At one time he wanted to be PM. Just fancy that, Mr Bean for PM? I suppose that is a reflection of Britain today, so why not fill up the cabinet from X-factor, BGT and the like?
Presumably he stayed in for money and status - a great pity, he would not be missed from that too big cabinet of nonentities!
Bring on democracy and an election.
13

Phil C,

13/06/2009 09:02:46
"However, last night also saw Lord Mandelson, the Business Secretary, predict the Prime Minister can expect another challenge to his position around the time of Labour's annual conference in September."

Keep playing for time, Mandy. Try to get some breathing space.

Most of us won't forget the complete Horlicks that Brown has made of the economy, the hundreds of thousands of deaths for which he is largely responsible, the pantomime he is making of 'cleaning up' parliament with the aid of his cabinet full of flippin' fraudsters and non-elected charlies, the increased tax burden, particularly those causing huge energy price hikes....

Unfortunately those who can make a difference have turned a blind eye and sit shame-faced in 'support' of the Kirkcaldy clown. Play all you want Mandy, we won't forget!
14

tommy M,

Scotland 13/06/2009 09:48:15
he "nearly" quit? So his support and belief in his own party is wavering - yet he remained? For the perks?

Not exactly reassuring for the voters, is it?

As usual, no mention of SCOTLAND or the labour proportion of the Scottish vote.

15

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 13/06/2009 09:51:58
Like "nearly" winning the pools, "nearly" getting a job , etc. Symptomatic of himself and all the other losers in Brown's cabinet.
16

Mèths,

13/06/2009 10:05:38
Anyone finding it difficult to post using firefox this morning?
17

Mèths,

13/06/2009 10:06:02
Works fine with IE8 or Chrome.
18

Gdgy,

13/06/2009 10:17:08
The NEARLY man...I nearly stood up for what I believed in...THEN I realised that I don't believe in anything...no principles and no scruples....a future leader? Of what? the Millband party....
19

Gdgy,

13/06/2009 10:17:54
Meths...I use the keyboard...works every time...
20

Mèths,

13/06/2009 10:28:01
21

Weird this. Maybe it's the Firefox update.
21

Gillean,

muir of ord 13/06/2009 10:30:08
There are many good people in the UK - none of them would want to become an MP in the current climate. We have a government and a parliament brimming with crooks, sleaze merchants and buffoons. ‘All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing’ – Edmund burke. It is time for the good men (and women) of Britain to take back control. Gilleanschildren.com.
22

Sam the man15,

13/06/2009 10:36:06
23

LOL
23

,

13/06/2009 10:44:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
24

Luigiana,

Aberdeen 13/06/2009 10:58:02
Little Dave did not go last weekend, simply because Mandy told him to stay put.

As other posters have commented, Mandy is playing for time. If he can delay Brown's exit until the autumn, the new leader elect can quite reasonably hold on until May 2010 before going to the country. For obvious reasons, Gordon Brown will not be allowed to take Labour into the next election.

Gordon Brown is being prepared as the sacrificial lamb and he knows it. Forget the fake smile and tough posturing. Brown's body language indicates that the game is up and he knows it. The next few weeks will be very painful for him. At least he has the coming recess opportunity to do a McCavity and hide away for a while.
25

Courtney,

East Molesey 13/06/2009 11:15:58
I don't believe him: another lie for political gain. What a shower of tossers!
26

Number 6,

Germany 13/06/2009 11:51:13
MMMMMM, should I stay loyal to gordon or should I jump ship with the rest of them ?.

Let me see, what's best for ME ?
27

scully,

colchester 13/06/2009 11:55:41
David Milliband says he was going to quit. Why did he not do us all a favour , AND DO SO.
28

The Tin Man,

13/06/2009 12:38:02
#25 Sam

You will no doubt be devestated by the news that David Milliband is a 'friend of Dorothy'. Complaints can be lodged with the Munchkinland police department, ducky.
29

Mèths,

13/06/2009 13:05:08
Put me out of my misery. Is anybody here using Firefox?
If so is it working here? I can post on chrome or IE, but not firefox.
30

Pagan,

Fife 13/06/2009 13:08:42
Who is this Guy ? Another piece of toilet paper for Broon. Certainly not a potential Sergiey Lavrov.
31

Auld-Yin,

Musselburgh 13/06/2009 13:22:54
I am begining to feel slightly sorry for Gordy. His 'friends' are more dangerous than his enemies. No wonder he is packing his cabinet with people from the Lords, the ones in the Commons are spending all their time talking to the media about how bad Gordon is or variations thereof; they don't have time to do any cabinet work.
32

scully,

colchester 13/06/2009 14:41:16

Gordon Brown is not as daft as he is painted

There was once a wily old Ruler. who knew that those around him were plotting his down fall, So what did he do, he gathered all his enemies close to him. elevated then to powerful positions and gave them rewards beyond they dreams, lulling them into a false sense of security. For he knew that when his down fall came he would take all of them down with him. Very wise Gordon. You only have to watch the reward system to know who the enemies of the people are. And God Bless all who sail in Her/Him
33

scully,

Colchester 13/06/2009 14:45:24
I would go now Mr Milliband. while you still have time. Remember it is the voters who decide who goes and who stays.
34

mr broon,

Edinburgh 13/06/2009 15:12:16
Like thousands of others, I nearly voted Labour?

Instead, like thousands of others, I voted for the Green Party!
35

morris,

edinburgh 13/06/2009 16:34:00
He nearly quit? Thats like saying I was nearly elected !
He stayed loyal to Gordon Broon. What utter tosh!

He stayed loyal to the salary that he receives, as he needs it even more now that the rules are under review and you may not be allowed to be a crook any more!

If anybody believes anything the aParty say, they should be ashamed of themselves.

36

morris,

edinburgh 13/06/2009 16:42:46
31 Firefox works perfectly but it has been updated a few times of late,and maybe that has something to do with it?
Currently a beta version 3.5 is available. Ive not installed it as yet so I cant say whether it has issues or not.The version prior to this is functional however.
If you have Firefox open click help and choose Check for Updates .That should tell you if you are current and is one less possibility. Failing that reinstall Firefox and see if that does the trick.In theory it should correct/replace whatever is missing or corrupted.
37

morris,

edinburgh 13/06/2009 16:59:00
34

"Gordon Brown is not as daft as he is painted"

He couldn't possibly be!
38

Fletty73,

Stirling 13/06/2009 17:40:41
Doesn't want to quit. Wants to stay Foreign Secretary. Hillary Clinton has a smile on her face. It all adds up.
39

Alan B,

13/06/2009 19:33:33
If Milliband resigned and brought down brown 2 things would happen. Johnston would replace brown and Milliband would be frozen out. He would also be seen as the assassin.

By waiting and letting brown lose the election Milliband himself will be the most likely candidate to take on the labour leadership.

Also by waiting and then potentially bringing down brown in 3/4months then they could push the next election out to next yr.

But do labour really want to win the next election? The tories by winning under major meant they were not electable for 12yrs. If labour were to win a small majority or have some sort of hung parlianment they could destroy the party more than at the moment.
40

morris,

edinburgh 13/06/2009 23:17:31
Whilst a swing to the SNP seems likely but hardly enough to take the seat from the incumbent New Labour same old Tory party,I doubt that it really matters that much. Of course Labour will once again hail it as a triumph but of course the Norwich seat will be the one which really matters, because it will almost certainly guarantee that Labour are OUT at the next election,which will probably make the hollow result in Glasgow as futile as the one in Glenrothes.It simply achives sod all and any body who votes Labour just shows what little they have between their ears.
Anyone who votes for a party WHICH CANNOT POSSIBLY form a government for many years to come, needs their head examined.

Apart from anything else neighbouring Glasgow East will say " Monkey Red Rosette Country" and rightly be proud that they showed they were above that level!
I still think that the SNP will at least halve the majority !For me that would be the benchmark at which we should judge this seat.

I believe the Greens hold something like 7 of 13 wards in Norwich so that should be interesting !
41

morris,

edinburgh 13/06/2009 23:26:36
In the article it reads "He urged fellow ministers to get out and prepare for "the fight of our life", saying that all Cabinet members should be given "free rein" to go out and make the case for Labour".

What with?

They cannot use their record in office ! Thats WHY they are on 15% in England!

IOT must be negative gutter politics accusing the opposition and lies right left and centre again!

Lbour dont have anything else to throw !
42

morris,

edinburgh 13/06/2009 23:35:02
31 It has occurred to me that when you signed in you did so on a single browser only , and when you close that browser and go to say Firefox you can type and try to send but unless signed in again whilst using Firefox it may be that you have in effect left? Of course I have not tested this but it may have something to do with it.
Good luck anyway.
43

Number 6,

Germany 14/06/2009 12:20:44
I have also recently updated Firefox and can't use it
to post comments here. Internet explorer works just fine.
44

,

14/06/2009 13:47:45
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.