Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 9th May 2008 Change Date

Evening News / Sony Centre Reverse Auction

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Britons losing religious beliefs



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 March 2008
ALMOST half of Britons doubt the existence of God or are confirmed atheists, research has found.
The think-tank, Theos, has found that most of those who say they are Christians do not practise their religion.

And as the country's supermarkets fill up with chocolate eggs, it appears that many do not believe in the fundamentals of the Easter st
ory.

The Scottish Atheist Council welcomed the Theos findings and said they showed being a non-believer was no longer socially unacceptable.

A leading theology professor said they reflected previous research which showed that in countries where religion was part of public life, such as Britain, it was less a feature of personal lives.

The survey found that 23 per cent of Britons, and 19 per cent of Scots, considered themselves atheists. And 25 per cent of Britons and 32 per cent of Scots are not sure if they believe in God.

The Church of Scotland claimed the sample north of the Border was too small to draw conclusions.

However, Fred Drummond, the Evangelical Alliance's national director for Scotland, said he thought it was "a fair reflection of the nation" and that society was becoming increasingly spiritual but not necessarily religious.

He said: "It's encouraging that churches are much more open to looking for some meaning to life, but not always equating that to Christian faith.

"It's a general discussion about spirituality and spiritual life, and it must be more than what we have at present, but it doesn't necessarily relate to a firm belief in religion."

He said the modern world's problems were a factor in declining faith, with individuals holding far fewer certainties.

He said that unlike 30 years ago, religion was no longer "one size fits all".

Professor Larry Hurtado, of Glasgow University's school of divinity, said religion had gone through phases of popularity, with atheism common in the 17th century, followed by a major resurgence of faith in the 19th century.

"Now we seem to be heading back into another trough period," he said.

"Among the chattering classes, religion is passé, except for getting your kid done or getting a church when you want to get wedded, but in other areas of society you'll find fairly significant pockets of quite intensive religious faith and activity."

He added: "Religion is very much a part of the official culture – bishops in the House of Lords and so on."

Alan Holmes, of the Scottish Atheist Council, said it was positive that so many respondents admitted having doubts. "It's saying it's OK to not subscribe to previous beliefs of the culture," he said. "Looking at the news, traditionally, the religious minorities have had absolutely disproportionate influence.

The vocal majority in religious groups tends to be the extreme element."

A spokesman for the Catholic Church in Scotland said: "In reality twice as many Scots go to Church each weekend as go to the cinema, and five times as many as attend a football match."

He said that each week an average of 600,000 attended church, of whom 200,000 were Catholic.

The current number of communicant members of the Church of Scotland is 504,000 – down from more than 1 million in 1976.

The poll, by ComRes for Theo, found that just 30 per cent of Brits accept the traditional Christian belief in the bodily resurrection of Christ. Almost the same again believe he rose in spirit.

More than half of respondents said they believe in some kind of existence after death. Only 9 per cent said they believe in a personal physical resurrection.

Two in five said they believe that Jesus was the son of God and nearly half that he was a holy prophet. More than one in eight (13 per cent) believe he never existed.

On the question of Easter's significance, 43 per cent of the public believe that the Easter story is about Jesus dying for the sins of the world while 26 per cent think it has no meaning.



The full article contains 667 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 14 March 2008 11:55 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Rozz Fyffe,

Scotland 15/03/2008 00:28:21
if true it is because there has been a liberalisation of the true Church.

Far to much PC and not enough condemnation of sin.

Far to much inclusion without question
2

Dougie Douglas,

Brisbane 15/03/2008 00:33:39
After the comments of the Rev during the week about gays it hardly comes as a surprise that people are becoming less religious.

Religion has to be relevant to peoples lives - the established churches are failing to grapple this basic concept.

The only churches that are, seemingly, going to grow are hands-in-the-air nicey, nicey, fluffy pentecostal types, at least they have a bit of fun whilst filling people with $hit
3

Col.Chi Man,

15/03/2008 00:35:29
If true it is because church has little relevance. Religion is no longer the opiate of the masses - TV is.
4

Dougie Douglas,

Brisbane 15/03/2008 00:36:23
There speaks the voice of unionist reason and tolerance at #1
5

Col.Chi Man,

15/03/2008 00:53:49
4 Dougie Douglas, Brisbane 15/03/2008 00:36:23

Appreciate your irony on tolerance, but thought unionists would be inclusive, which that poster clearly isn't.
6

Thorson ,

Peterborough , Canada 15/03/2008 01:16:25
A Catholic spokesperson sez.

"each week an average of 600,000 attended church, of whom 200,000 were Catholic"

Taking the 600,000 figure, that means that about 6 in 10 people go to church every week in Scotland. Now that I don't believe or is this just another example of anything goes in the name of encouraging religious belief. Even if two in ten people went to church at 11 am every Sunday morning then most towns would have solid traffic jams.
Maybe someone could write a letter to the Editor correcting the good spokesperson's "holy error".
7

Robert,

Kirriemuir 15/03/2008 01:17:21
I find those statistics interesting and I subscribe to Fred Drummond's view of becoming more spiritualist but less religious. There does appear to be more to existence than this secular plane of which we inhabit but religion seems stuck in antiquity and is failing to review the situation and update itself. I guess that many of us have the need to belong to a church but if it does not meet our needs then why bother? For anyone to believe that the Jewish carpenter's son from Nazareth is divine, then it is tantamount to admitting that the archangel Gabriel was a womaniser! While it is accepted that we are part of a greater intelligence, few seem to realise that this intelligence rolls-on impotently with no concern of the disasters it creates in its wake; it is certainly not a forgiving God, the idea which has served in the past as political propaganda and the same continues today. Many of us go through a phase to life wondering what our existence is about but that's usually a transitional phase in the progress to maturation. I said in another post that I am neither an atheist nor an agnostic but I am anti-religious and regard religions as political organisations seeking to win the battle for the minds of people but maybe I have got it wrong and my damnation may lie in having voted for the wrong political party.
8

Tom in Belmont,

Belmont 15/03/2008 01:18:02
The reports of religion's (in this case Christianity's death) are usually greatly exaggerated. Popular religion in Britain wasn't too healthy in the early 18th century or the early 19th century. Then came the Wesleys and the Anglican Revival. (The Scots even rediscovered a taste for stained glass!) It's no different in the States: in the 1960s it was "The Secular City"; in the 1980s came the "Moral Majority" and an Evangelical Revival of historic proportions. My own church (RC) added over 100 million members world-wide last year. We'll be back. Just wait.
9

Robert,

Kirriemuir 15/03/2008 01:29:32
Is that statistics Tom or just propaganda? The Roman church has been endevouring to do a take-over bid for the past millennium but it looks as if the Moslins are about to win the race. Me, I'm humpty-dumpty and cheering for whoever wins.
10

Tom in Belmont,

Belmont 15/03/2008 01:53:48
#9. No, you can find the stats in almanacs and such. As for the takeover issue: we were told to "preach the Gospel to all nations", after all. As for the Muslims, their numbers should worry some Europeans, but their geographic dominance is about where it was about 1450.
11

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 15/03/2008 02:21:55
The believe in GOD, is with the beholder!
12

Guga II,

Rockall 15/03/2008 02:24:08
All it means is that more people are growing up, and no longer believe in fairy tales.
13

Snuffy Ivy,

Aberdeen 15/03/2008 02:29:10
Oh deary me: The kirk seems irrelevant? That's probably because the average Joe wants clear cut guarantees about everything. Everything is about "ME".

Last time I checked, Christianity was about "faith" and a "value system" was it not? Value system and ethics in secularism doesn't exist as we well know from the numbers of kids doing community service and the rising number of felons still waiting for jail cell. Interesting! I don't think the church was the cause of that or was it?
14

Furchrissake,

15/03/2008 02:42:04
13# Where are the ethics in religions that glorify death and limit the individual in living a fulfilling life?

I would rather have secular social values and ethics than live according the rantings of ancient scholars. It was not religions that changed society's views towards women, children, homosexuals etc. - it was society.

The fairy tales flouted by the religious are nonsensical and people who believe blindly are failing themselves and their society.
15

Furchrissake,

15/03/2008 02:48:13
It also appears that the RCs are on a crusade to polarise society in the light of all the controversy stirred up by the rabid christian Bush and the wannabe pope, Blair, around Muslims and Israel. It's incredible that in the 21st century people still believe the rantings of paedophile priests, suicide bomber muslims, and terrorist zionist jews.
16

The Pict.,

15/03/2008 03:04:24
#13 Chistianity is about using FEAR to keep the average person POOR while thanking a non-existant thing for the priviledge. Again, The bible was written for Jews BY Jews. Get it through your head.

Value system ? Oh you must mean the burning of 'witches'. The torture of anyone ( usually to the death) disagreeing with the xtain fable. The bombing of other countries based on lies. The kids in trouble are usually religous following the Christian values just mentioned. Secular VALUES respect all people. Do not want to kill or maim anyone.
Time to check again # 13 and read church history to find out how, when any why the 'church' started. With being a secular humanist comes the added burden of accepting responsibility for our actions....Not blaming a non-existant 'entity' and giving the responsiblilty to it. That's the problem.

For Lindsay McIntosh. An athiest can only be a Jew who has become a secular humanist because as we all know the xtian bible was written by Jews for Jews. Before you wrote this article you should have tried to get the FACTS straight. Unless you are saying that almost half of the English are Jewish.
17

Mercutio,

FALKIRK 15/03/2008 03:49:24
Atheism is popular because it is an easy option.
18

Rozz Fyffe,

Scotland 15/03/2008 05:07:22
#17 so true,
19

Beth Boyle,

NY 15/03/2008 06:27:28
We are in an age where people worship things and God gets in the way of that. It's no different here in the US or in most of the West. Being a Christian has never been an easy way unless you are faking it, LOL People don't read much these days either eh?
20

GalacticCannibal,

Murrieta, CA........captured from Mexico 1845 15/03/2008 06:38:31
Hey Dudes,

I never go into a church . For if I did the roof would cave in and kill me.

And if there is a Dog, sorry I mean God, let it create a rock so big , it cannot lift.

GC
21

clarry,

15/03/2008 07:26:17



Make religion history. It was only used as state control in the eighteen century, that is why there was such a big increase in church attendance on Industrialisation. Terrible conditions - captive audience. A day out and somewhere to go. With a bit of song(hymns) and dance on the side (eternal damnation). Nothing like a bit of horror to get folks going.

One of the biggest divisive influence on society is separate religious school.

Separate schools - Gang rules.

Kids that play together stay together.
Religious bigotry most divisive ABC
22

clarry,

15/03/2008 07:27:57

Jews cult of devil worshippers based on a biased book.
23

donald,

glasgow 15/03/2008 08:13:20
The Church of England is still the established religion of the Yookay and the Jelly bean, as its head, is still a god. Englsuh Bishops still sit in the class based House of Lords and are appointed by the English (Broon) Prime Meenister.
24

Selgovae,

15/03/2008 08:20:11
#17 "Atheism is popular because it is an easy option."

Let's see. If you choose Christianity and you're right, you get an eternity in paradise. If you're wrong, oblivion. If you're a non-believer and you're right, it's oblivion. If you're wrong, it's an eternity in hell.

Christianity sounds the soft option to me.
25

Pontificatus Maximus of Avignon,

15/03/2008 08:39:06
Britons losing religious beliefs

Hallelujah! At long last.
26

walter,

15/03/2008 08:46:57
Religion is the tool of the bigot.
27

Spoot,

Third rock pool on the left 15/03/2008 08:58:18
#23

"The Church of England is still the established
religion of the Yookay" - shurely shome mishtake? The CofE is not a religion, it's a sect of a religion, and it certainly isn't the established church of anywhere outside England.

However, I'm entirely with you on the need to put an end to the "Westminster question", i.e., the presence of CofE bishops in the house of Lords.
28

Infidel,

Dar ul harb 15/03/2008 09:01:38
At last, some good news!

Could it be that with the likes of the Bigot of Motherwell, sorry, Bishop, and the daily explodings of devout Mohammedans in public places, people are beginning to think that religions suck?

It would be nice to think that the increase in atheism is due to careful considered appraisal of the evidence, perhaps stimulated by atheist heros like Richard Dawkins, but I suspect much of it is to do with the antics of the pious themselves. Rampant pedophilia in the Catholic clergy, Mohammedans going berserk over a teddy bear called "Mohammed", and now Bishop Devine's outburst are all far better propaganda for atheism than "The God Delusion".
29

Boy Wonder,

15/03/2008 09:05:02
Slowly but surely the shackles of the superstition of religion are being broken. And the "religious" ones brought it about themselves, with their bigoted rants like the Bish of Motherwell recently.

And of course we have seen what has been perpetrated by paedophile priests ... and the terrorism of Islam.

The sooner religion disappears from the face of the Earth, the better off we'll all be.

Of course, the spiritual aspect we have is unlikely to be lost, but we'll find something to fill that role that doesn't lecture or proselytise us!



30

Fifi la Bonbon,

15/03/2008 09:06:56
I think that it's wonderful that there's such a thing as the Scottish Atheist Council. I hope that their minutes are openly published for all to see, and that it is routinely consulted by government in the same way as the Scottish Interfaith Council is consulted and that it gets its share of grant funding.
31

Atheist Ian,

Airdrie 15/03/2008 09:11:05
Atheism is the easy option?

When a family member dies the religious wheel out their candy coated "gone to a better place" and "you'll see them again" re-assurances, whilst atheists have to confront the naked truth.

Atheists live in the real world and want to make this life better - the religious live in happy clappy la la land and care more about their fantasy future in heaven than in helping real people hear and now.

The catholic church's stance on condoms or the cervical cancer vaccine is a clear example - they think it's better for young girls to die of cancer than run the risk that they might have some sex.

Atheism isn't the easy option - but it's certainly the rational one.
32

PAUL 01,

London . 15/03/2008 10:27:32
Atheist Ian 31 . I do agree that atheism is a rational option but not the only one . While I contend that orthodox , organised religion is a self indulgent nonsense , the idea that all we experience on this planet and in the universe has come about by accident is , for me , a nonsense too . Call it God or whatever you like , its clear , at least to me , that there is a strong argument for intelligent design . Your second paragraph point is a good one . What about being held in purgatory until you hand over a few bob to some bloke ! Not a bad scheme that . But the LIFE AFTER DEATH etc bit may be , as you would have considered , a naturally occuring mechanism in each of us to ease us at the moment of our final demise , a mechanism I contend of intelligent design , but which has been hijacked by organised religion .
33

Miss H,

15/03/2008 10:46:49
1 It's actually beause of people like you.

Improvements in education as well as the development of the internet were always going to lead to this. I'm oversimplifying things a bit but essentially w live in a world where information is free, where people can not only question established wisdoms but seek out the answers and the alternatives.

Blind obedience to dogma cannot survive in a world like that. There will always be people who hold to dogmas because it provides security in a world they may find frightening but religion will never regain the power it once had over peoples lives. our society has evolved beyond that stage and it would take a catastrophe to return us to that level again.
34

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

15/03/2008 10:56:55
31....And logical.
35

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

15/03/2008 10:57:32
Whaurs aw the defenders o' the faith?...oh aye right...must aw be in church...sorry...firgoat aboot that....
36

PAUL 01,

London . 15/03/2008 11:16:14
MISS H . I do doubt that society has evolved in any meaningful way . Human nature remains , in my view , unchanging and dogmas of the past will simply be replaced by more terrifying dogmas of the future .The internet at this moment of time has led , to some degree , an ability to question and answer in a way not previously known . However the internet of the future will simply become the instrument of control previously undreamt of . The current use of the internet has coincided with the widespread adoption of the most illiberal laws in history . Wait for the next step !
37

Gothic Rose,

15/03/2008 11:37:59
29#Boy Wonder.
You, by your ranting are showing your solidarity with the bigotry you protest against.Its not a them and us situation,Its live and let live,and do no harm.However the road to Hell[figuretivly speaking]is paved with good intentions.
38

The Pict.,

15/03/2008 14:38:42
# 19 Beth Boyle. You say people are not reading much anymore. You are obviously including yourself in that statement. Here's a good one for you ( If You have the GUTS). 'THE PAGAN CHRIST' by Tom Harpur. Thomas Allen Publishers.
Now you may have to get this book in CANADA because I'm not sure if your if your gov't allows it to be sold in America. Your controlled media don't want you to read this.
39

Atheist Ian,

Airdrie... 15/03/2008 15:51:57
#35 "Whaurs aw the defenders o' the faith?..."

The United States of Jesus Land will be awake shortly, then no doubt the usual stream of religious twaddle will start winging it's way across the Atlantic...
40

Boy Wonder,

15/03/2008 16:16:01
#37. Gothic Rose ... my comments are hardly a rant! May I suggest you learn to understand what you're reading in the way that it is meant to be read and understood.
41

Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 15/03/2008 16:35:43
Religion used to be the opium of the masses. It has been replaced in modern times by propaganda.
42

MonoApe,

15/03/2008 17:26:17
"Last time I checked, Christianity was about "faith" and a "value system" was it not?"

I'll correct that for you:

"Last time I checked, Christianity was about delusional belief in an after-life and repellent Bronze Age morals, was it not?"

Much better.

As for anyone arguing that we need more religion and not less, I'll give a one word response: Sweden (I'll leave the reader to research and search for 'societal health').
43

Gothic Rose,

15/03/2008 19:28:32
41# Boy Wonder.
I`ve got it,by Jove Iv`e got it!
44

Rozz Fyffe,

Scotland 15/03/2008 20:51:07
One God, one Word of God and the Scots when they parted from the anti-Christ in Rome gave the world the one religion.
45

Beth Boyle,

NY 15/03/2008 21:07:09
Read it pict. Not worth the time I spent.
46

Rozz Fyffe,

Scotland 15/03/2008 21:09:23
glad you read it, but it takes more than reading.
47

Rozz Fyffe,

Scotland 15/03/2008 21:13:21
by the way unless you want me to call you a Ho Beaatch do not be disrespectful when you address me
48

weeshooie1,

Wollongong 15/03/2008 23:51:32
To all fellow Atheist's 'Go forth and multiply' :0)

G.C. #20,

Ever heard of 'Ayers Rock'? (or Uluru as it is called now). Thats one helluva rock and nae Dog or god will ever shift it.

BDub #29,

With you all the way Bruv', 100%. All of my 'spiritual' aspects come in glass specially marked 'Bottled in Scotland' these days. I was almost chucked out of primary school for daring to question the religious teachings of our in-house zealots and, retired now for close on eleven years, it has not harmed me one little bit. Get rid of all that crap and people just might be able to live side by side in harmony.
49

Stushie,

ootside Glesca 16/03/2008 04:18:47
Scots are into feel-ology rather than theology...they want to feel good about themselves and their daft ideas. It's okay, but in the end, you end up in hell..which for Scots would be watching England win the 1966 World Cup repeatedly for all of eternity...

50

Beth Boyle,

NY 16/03/2008 09:08:27
I had communion at Stobo Kirk last August. It made me cry it was so beautiful. What a shame Christianity has become a dirty word to so mamy people. Have a happy Palm Suday All!
51

truthsleuth,

16/03/2008 15:31:25
Not true
An icresing number of Britons (those born in Britain) are becoming religous fanatics.
52

Ard Righ,

The Rock Of Edinburgh 16/03/2008 15:59:48
Yeah, somewhere between A.D. 45 and A.D. 455.
53

Forky,

16/03/2008 16:07:01
In these days of scientific advances who in their right minds would believe in the sky fairy
54

Gothic Rose,

16/03/2008 16:25:28
41#Boy Wonder.
On reflection B.W. the Bishop would probably have adviced me the same.So that makes you two sides of the same coin! I rest my case.:)
55

The Pict.,

16/03/2008 18:29:23
# 52 . Beth. Don't include me in on the nonsense. Christianity has made itself a dirty word to anyone who can think for themselves and see the truth of this mind control system. Now go trembling to your non-existant jewish god Yahwey. Since you did not understand the book 'The Pagan Christ' try re-reading it. Get someone who knows how to think to interpret it for you.
56

Beth Boyle,

NY 16/03/2008 23:26:50
Go Pict a bone with someone else #57. Religion is no different than any other value system nor is it any more dangerous than any other value system. It's become a part of a culture war and that is where the real conflict begins. You seem to be at war with reality, Picty.
57

The Pianist,

17/03/2008 00:05:29
The hills are alive with the sound of music.

How do you solve a problem like Maria?

Edelweiss always works for me.
58

Gothic Rose,

17/03/2008 09:04:07
59#
And Mary Poppins to you too!!!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.