Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Made in Scotland: Japan's gourmet beef

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 June 2009
NORMALLY it is pop stars who boast of being "big in Japan" but some of Scotland's iconic Aberdeen Angus cattle could soon have a similar claim to fame.
Scottish farmers have started to cross the breed with Japanese Wagyu cattle, which provide beef that is said to be the most expensive in the world.

Up to 700 Scots-Japanese calves are due next spring on dozens of farms in Caithness in the north-east Highlands, in one of the biggest cattle breeding initiatives in the UK.

The Wagyu beef, prized for its deeply marbled appearance, will be exported to Japan because imports are cheaper than home-reared Wagyu.

Wagyu in Japan are pampered with massages to help create the marbling, and beer or sake is added to their feeding regime.

A seven-ounce Wagyu steak sells in Tokyo restaurants for more than £95 and has become a regular fixture on menus at celebrity gatherings. Guy Ritchie included kosher Wagyu beef burgers on the menu, along with pink Krug champagne and caviare, for Madonna's 50th birthday party last summer.

Businessman John Sutherland from Wick spotted the potential for breeding Scottish Wagyu after visiting a stud farm for the ancient Japanese breed in Australia.

Mr Sutherland, managing director of Caithness Beef and Lamb, said: "Aberdeen Angus used to be similar to Wagyu but the market changed, pushing farmers into producing redder and leaner beef.

"I imported 1,000 straws of Japanese Wagyu bull semen and we should see a 70 per cent success rate. I'm opening a new meat works later this month where the animals will be slaughtered and finished in the traditional Wagyu style when they are just over two years old."

Mr Sutherland also plans to produce Wagyu steaks, burgers and sausages for the UK market.

Danny Coghill, of Stemster Mains farm in Caithness, one of the farmers involved in the project, said: "Some people are laughing about this but it's something totally different and I've got nothing to lose by trying something new."

However, Mr Coghill said he would not be offering the cattle massages or feeding them beer.

Ron McHattie, chief executive of the Aberdeen Angus Cattle Society, said there was no threat to the genetic purity of the Aberdeen Angus breed.

"If this is a straight commercial decision by farmers to make money in the market then good luck to them," Mr McHattie said.

"The main point is that it won't directly impact on our herd book. The herd book is like researching your family tree in Register House in Edinburgh and records the parents and grandparents of genuine Aberdeen Angus. Crossed animals will never come within a million miles of our herd book."

Nick Nairn, one of Scotland's top chefs, and one of the presenters of the BBC Scotland's Landward rural affairs television programme, said: "This could be great for Scotland. I'm delighted with any initiative which gets farmers talking to those who buy their produce.

"There are two camps of farmers – those who are very savvy and stick their heads above the parapet to develop niche markets and those who just want to concentrate on doing things the traditional way. But in order to get decent prices, they need to know what customers want."

Sarah Anderson, of NFU Scotland, said: "The livestock sector has been struggling so much in recent years. This is an excellent way for farmers to develop their herds and create the ultimate product for a high-end market."

SECRETS OF THE STEAK'S SUCCESS

WAGYU beef is a legendary Japanese delicacy.

The breed is genetically predisposed to intense marbling and produces a higher percentage of oleaginous, unsaturated fat than any other breed of cattle known in the world.

It is highly rich in omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, and the meat is described as having a smooth, velvety, sweet taste.

It can be called "Kobe beef" only if the animal is raised and finished in the Kobe region of Japan.

Wagyu were introduced to Japan in the second century as a beast of burden to help cultivate rice.

The cattle herd in Japan was closed and eating meat from any four-legged animal was prohibited from 1635 to 1838.

Different methods were used to raise the animals, including massage to avoid cramp on small farms. Beer and sake were added to the feed to increase the animals' appetites during warm weather.

These practices continue and have increased the overall price of the product.

The meat is fragile under heat and is usually quickly seared on the outside to avoid destroying the fat.

Wagyu sashimi – thin raw strips of beef marinated in soy sauce, dashi broth and green onion – is popular in Japan.


The full article contains 789 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 07 June 2009 9:15 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 08/06/2009 00:57:02

As I have said 3Zillion times, our Sottish Whisky, is next!, and it looks like it will have started with the,......'cattle trail'.

2

Stephen Maturin,

, HMS Surprise at sea , 08/06/2009 01:25:30
As usual Chuck, you are late and out of date. The Japanese have owned distilleries in Scotland for ages and import Scottish water to make whisky in Japan. I can't remember which years but the Japanese whisky makers have won top prize in world whisky making contests. Try to keep up.

Saor Alba
3

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 08/06/2009 02:14:28

Stephen Maturin ~2,

Thankyou for that info!, The last time that I made reference to this subject, I was told by other commentators that I was ridiculous to think that there was any link to our Whisky and the Japaneses, the laugh is on them now, after you clarifying the situation.



4

,

08/06/2009 06:02:25
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

,

08/06/2009 06:03:26
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

Dave From Barra,

Western Isles 08/06/2009 08:06:20
Never had the good fortune to try Wagyu beef but some associates of mine have and they said it was a "taste of heaven".

While not detracting from our fine Aberdeen Angus (which, as it happens, it much sought after all over the World. Right now they are clear felling acres of virgin rain forest in Brazil to accomodate AA beef cattle to sell back to America and Europe) Wagyu beef is simply devine by all accounts.

I look forward to the results of the cross breeding and wonder too if they will pamper these beasts.
7

Wynn,

GLASGOW 08/06/2009 08:33:25
Canny,lads,canny...
a big factor in the final "to table" result of Wagyu beef is in the treatment the cattle receive..I doubt if Kobe cattle would know what an open hill was for..they are cossetted, and I don't think there are a lot of Japanese Kobe cattle masseurs queueing up at your local labour exchange to give the Scottish animals the treatment they'd receive in Japan... I fear that after all your effort and investment, you'll find the Japanese may class free-rangeScottish Wagyu an inferior product and low prices will be the result.
Think hard,lads... Mr.Nairn's ideas encouraging progressive farmers to go for what the customer wants should be interpreted carefully....since the Scottish customer has been bombarded with a government-led "fat bad, lean good"and shrinks away from well marbled meat for "health reasons", I'd ask any progressive farmer which steak would he, and perhaps, Mr. Nairn's diners, prefer, Aberdeen Angus or Limousin?
I'll go for traditional Aberdeen Angus every time.
8

Dave From Barra,

Western Isles 08/06/2009 08:37:35
7

I'd say Limousine since ti's cheaper and most folks can't really tell the difference between the beef or whether it's hung or not.

The catering trade makes up around 50% of beef sales, they can legally sell beef from Argentina as AA since it will come from AA blood lines. We are regularly deluded in restaurants.
9

Stan Butler,

08/06/2009 09:07:09


~8 Dave From Barra

'We are regularly deluded in restaurants.'


You don't need to go to a restaurant to be deluded.

You say that 'Wagyu beef is simply devine by all accounts.'

Would that be Jim or Sydney Devine?
10

Dave From Barra,

Western Isles 08/06/2009 09:07:54
Sigh.
11

Stan Butler,

08/06/2009 09:10:05


Aberdeen Angus beef is over rated. I suspect it's popularity is more to do with its profitability for the producer rather than the quality of the meat.

Highland and Galloway cattle produce better tasting beef.

12

Dave From Barra,

Western Isles 08/06/2009 09:15:50
Ah, Highland cattle are very slow finishers, which is why their beef is good and they are generally grass finished.

While the OTM Scheme was still in operation, owning Highland and Galloway cattle for beef was not possible which is why AA took off as it could be successfully finsished before 30 months. However, that doesn't detract from the fact that it's still good beef and I hear that you like a well hung bit of beef Stan. Correct? :-)
13

Louis Catorze,

08/06/2009 09:23:57
Substutute 'fatty' for 'marbling' and see how much it sells for.
14

Tartan Viking,

08/06/2009 09:26:41
The importance of Brand Scotland is immense. Take not Unionists.
15

Tartan Viking,

08/06/2009 09:26:59
Take note Unionists I meant.
16

Stan Butler,

08/06/2009 09:37:13
#12 Dave From Barra

The problem with Highland and Galloway cattle as you identify is that they are slow maturing. Whilst that makes for better tasting meat it also increases costs for the producer. Aberdeen Angus is therefore easier, quicker and cheaper to produce, and that is the reason for its popularity, rather than the quality of the meat which is inferior to Highland and Galloway.

Another factor is that the OTM regulations make it difficult if not impossible to provide Highland and Galloway meat on the bone.

And we all know how much you enjoy the bone.

17

Dave From Barra,

Western Isles 08/06/2009 09:39:19
16

Good repetition of my comment. Well done.

I like TO bone.
18

Pomodora,

Gravesend 08/06/2009 09:48:56
Tokyo is a city familiar to me and I agree that the restaurant prices are expensive but relative to everything else which is expensive for the traveller. Steak served in a good establishment is usually a good steak and costly. Triple A (AAA) Alberta cured beef is a favourite and expansive as is Canadian bacon. The more labour in preperation the higher the price. The most popular imported whisky selling in Japan is the Campbeltown Malt Springbank 15 year old as of last week when I left Tokyo.
19

Horrible Cankers @Cyber Shebeen,

08/06/2009 10:06:11
Carbon footprint...tch tch tch...I recommend people watch the film (free) 'Home' on the internet....
20

Blether2,

Tokyo 08/06/2009 10:44:45
Wagyu has its merits, but I prefer the grass-fed Scottish beef I grew up with. A lot of Wagyu's like eating a big piece of butter, with little or no meaty flavour.
21

Jo Flo,

08/06/2009 13:24:48
You have no idea how disturbing this is for a vegetarian.
22

Wynn,

GLASGOW 08/06/2009 13:46:14
Jo Flo,........if you can't stand the heat.............

but if you could provide some vegetarian recipes which aren't loaded with pepper and chillies....who knows?...

( for I can't stand the heat either).
23

Horrible Cankers @Cyber Shebeen,

08/06/2009 14:22:51
22..Och dont be so lazy...loadsa gorgeous veggie grub on the go that is not loaded with pepper and chillies...nor sawdust either...how about a wild mushroom quiche?...omlette and truffles?...and there are loads of protein substitutes for those who like it to look like meat...I have made food that people have refused to believe was not animal in origin...and I'll tell you what home made Maki is delicious...all those little rice parcels wrapped in seaweed with fresh healthy veg inside...some soy sauce (organic and not chinese) pickled ginger and wasabi and you are laughing...Miso soup..a dawdle!...

McDonalds and their ilk are scarring the planet folks.....
24

Stan Butler,

08/06/2009 17:31:51
23 Horrible

It's just about impossible to have organic agriculture in a vegetarian regime.

I hope your vegetarian dinners realised that.
25

CelticMo,

Falls Church 08/06/2009 18:26:52
#12 and #16 - thanks for the laugh.
26

Horrible Cankers @Cyber Shebeen,

08/06/2009 18:46:02
24...What you on about mate?...if you grow your own and you know its organic...then its organic....
27

Stan Butler,

08/06/2009 22:23:47
#26 Horrible


You grow your own soya beans and make your own soy sauce?

Aye right enough.

An organic system requires animal manure to maintain soil fertility. Animals are only kept so they can be eaten.

That's why the more clued up vegetarians have mixed feelings about organic produce.

28

Jo Flo,

08/06/2009 23:33:31
I use comfrey from our garden as a feed for our veg.

Can't get better. Good thing as we can't get rid of it. Apparently the best feed for weed also.

I recall that some Perthshire veg produced on a large scale had a high content of human effluent in the finished iceberg lettuces. Who invented that?!
29

Jo Flo,

08/06/2009 23:39:55
"Animals are only kept so they can be eaten "

Wow!
Stan, that is such a mental, unearthly statement.

Perhaps you would like to come back to this one. What animal have you eaten today that you have kept?

Had a wee look at the cat but she's having none of it.


30

Horrible Cankers @Cyber Shebeen,

09/06/2009 11:14:47
27...Seem to recall my local allotments in Glasgow use horse manure...not many horse burgers doing the rounds..

31

Dave Crassman,

23/07/2009 15:25:15
Scottish/Japanese cattle eh? I wonder what sort of eyes they'll have?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.