Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Rosyth ferry service to continent to be axed

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 29 May 2008
THE only direct ferry link between mainland Scotland and Europe is to be axed, it was announced yesterday, as sources blamed fuel costs and passenger numbers for the decision.
The Greek owners of Superfast Ferries, which connects Rosyth and Zeebrugge in Belgium, say the service will sail for the last time on 13 September

but have not revealed how many jobs, if any, will be lost following the move.

Superfast stopped short of announcing why they are to stop operating the service. However, sailings were halved in 2005, as a lack of demand for freight traffic meant a daily crossing was no longer viable.

Experts have described the Superfast ferry as a "gas-guzzler" and as fuel prices have soared, the firm introduced a surcharge last year which added almost £30 to family return trips.

Stewart Stevenson, transport minister, last night said the Scottish Government had been working with parent company Attica to continue the route.

"Ultimately, this is a commercial decision," he added. "We will continue to work with Forth Ports, Attica and others in seeking to identify an alternative commercial operator."

Forth Ports, who operate the Port of Rosyth, warned the closure could hit Scotland's access to European markets.

"This is disappointing news as the ferry link is an important part of Scotland's access to European markets," a spokesman said. "Our own analysis shows that the route could easily attract 60,000 freight units, within a potential marketplace of 200,000 freight units, making this a viable, profitable route for an operator with the right mix of vessels and frequency of sailings."

MSPs described the news as "devastating" for the Fife economy and Labour politicians demanded that Alex Salmond, the First Minister, step in.

Iain Gray, Labour's finance spokesman, said: "Alex Salmond needs to immediately personally intervene and ensure that representations are made to the company at the highest level."

Helen Eadie, the Labour MSP for Dunfermline East, said she would be trying to clarify the situation for passengers who had reservations on the service: "I appeal to Superfast to stay until the end of the year – giving us more time to find an alternative."

Superfast said they would assist travellers who booked journeys scheduled after the date the service is due to end.

David Lonsdale, CBI Scotland's assistant director, said: "If this service is to cease, it would reduce the range of affordable, practical and reliable transport options open to freight operators and manufacturers."

Showcase service is sinking fast

SINCE the inaugural sailing in May 2002, Superfast has carried more than 800,000 passengers, 200,000 cars and 165,000 freight units.

• The ferry company received over £500,000 in public subsidy in 2005, in a failed attempt to retain nightly sailings between Scotland and Belgium.

• Green campaigners welcomed the service for relieving UK roads of more than 3.2 million tonnes of freight.

• Superfast was voted Best Ferry Operator by the Scottish Passenger Agents' Association in 2006.

• Parent company Attica was recording dips in passenger numbers from 2004.

• Attica Group runs the Superfast Ferries fleet and the Blue Star Ferries fleet, and also offers connections between Greece and Italy and between mainland Greece and the Cycladic and Dodecanese Islands.

• Attica axed its Baltic route and sold the ferry to an Estonian operator.

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 28 May 2008 11:45 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Rosyth ferry link
 
1

Willie,

29/05/2008 00:29:29
A Sad Day.
I trust Superfast will be required to give an explanation and repay public monies including cost for new road links?
I wonder what excuse Phil Flanders and the Road Haulage Industry will have for the loss of this vital link. Of course they will say it was used to full freight capacity saving fuel costs for hard pressed hauliers, but it seems that Superfast thought otherwise.
This was a wonderful opportunity for Scotland although given the operators track record the decision to award them the operating contract may now be considered unwise.
Forth Ports PLC too have been willing participants in this service, but seem incapable of promoting other services from this modern facility.
The Scottish Government will seek a new Operator, but this time I hope they will insist on proper guarantees for the taxpayer, and persuade the freight industry to ensure that freight from the continent uses the service and not alternative English Ferry Ports to the detriment of our workers and infrastructure.
2

Ken W,

29/05/2008 01:48:25
'...the service was not making money.'

Can we see the books? Not making money... or not making 'enough ' money for the private equity company?

the Jean Nichole (now SEAFRANCE MOLIERE) has been sold to Seafrance for operation on the Dover-Calais route...

Asset stripping it used to be called.
3

W Smith,

Middle East 29/05/2008 04:03:29
I doubt if ferries to Ireland will be cut.

Nothing to do with the fact that Scotland's economy is underperforming thanks to one of the highest corporation tax regimes in Europe then, eh?
4

,

29/05/2008 07:05:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

gus1940,

Edinburgh 29/05/2008 07:19:27
This closure must not happen - it would be a great leap backwards for Scotland.

I have used this servicw twice, the last time being 3 weeks ago, and have been highly impressed with the service on both occasions.

It is typical of The Scotsman to report this development negatively - how about the paper starting a campaign to save the service or is saving something that is a considerable asset to Scotland not on the paper's political agenda.

'Showcase service is sinking fast' - what has this sub headline got to do with what follows? - typical negative reporting.

Apart from the travel companies who advertise Bruge Mini Cruises using Superfast the service receives virtually no publicity.

Why haven't the BBC and/or STV taken some of the vast percentage of their budget spent promoting football and more bl---y football (football clubs are businesses after all) and sent camera crews on a trip to Zeebrugge to make a promotional program for the ferry service. It would make a change from the almost daily trip to Glasgow Airport to record the departure/arrival of Rangers and/or Celtic. and the inane remarks of the management/players.

And another thing - I cannot understand why so many ferry holidays from Scotland use the ferry services from Newcastle instead of using Superfast - there is even one that drives all the way to Dover before catching a ferry.

It's time for the Government, Local Authorities Visit Scotland, National & Local Media and other tourist bodies to get their act together and try to save the service - even if it means a larger subsidy.

SAVE OUR SUPERFAST NOW.
6

Iain green,

Haddington 29/05/2008 07:33:16
Good for Iain Gray.
Is this the same 'swivel eyed incoherent' (recent quote by Tom Brown, journalist and commentator)who was jumping up and down over the Trump affair, falsely accusing Salmond of using his influence unduly?
7

allan58,

edinburgh 29/05/2008 07:38:20
Can somebody enlighten me here. Does the Scottish parliament actually have the authority to to alter Corporation Tax rates?

As far as I was aware, this,remains firmly within the jurisdiction of Westminster?

If that is the case,then surely #3 & #4 should directing their collective ire at Gordon Tory-Brown & Darling Alistair?

My understanding is that an Independent Scotland would have full authority over tax rates & could then (speculating here)offer reduced Corporation Tax rates ( like Ireland) thereby ATTRACTING companies to these shores by undercutting the rest of the UK?

By the way, while on the subject of crossing water, does anyone know whatever happened to the Stagecoach hovercraft? Has this been seen or heard of since its 2 week jaunt?
8

,

29/05/2008 07:45:07
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
9

HughB,

Edinburgh 29/05/2008 08:06:28
I've been on both previous ships (as shown in the picture) and the Blue Star 1 that they now operate.
The trip does not take any longer. They switched to a more fuel efficient ship that could take more passengers a few years ago (the picture at the top is out of date).

Why doesn't Scotland buy the ferry, and then we can operate it. I don't know how much a ship like this costs, but surely it would be much better value that the money they are throwing at the Edinburgh tram line.

We need this link to stay. It means that people who would not normally travel to Europe have easy and civilised access. It also means that people from the rest of Europe have direct access to Scotland.

I assume that the ferry only pays high fuel costs when it is at Rosyth, and I assume that when it is at Zeebrugge, then it will be able to fill up on cheaper Belgian fuel.

I suppose there is a lot less money to go around at the moment for everybody, and so people are less likely to pay to travel on a ferry when air fairs are lower and quicker. But really, travel on these ships is much more civilised and enjoyable, and your holiday begins when you get on the bus in the centre of Edinburgh to take you out to the ferry.

Scrap the trams, keep the ferry.
10

capy,

embra 29/05/2008 08:28:39
im sorry to see this service under threat. but im also disappointed if not surprised to see iain gray,s rant. maybe if his dear leader did somthing about fuel prices this might not happen.
his government (london branch)is raking in exra vat etc.when will we some movement mr gray, you could intervene,mr brown is always happy to hear from scottish(sic) labour
11

gus1940,

Edinburgh 29/05/2008 08:38:01
At least The Herald's coverage of this sad news is less negative than that of The Scotsman.
12

scunnin,

Germany 29/05/2008 09:01:50
The price of the ferry service was/is way too high. I was considering using the ferry but for the price what they were asking for, I can fly to Edinburgh, pick up a rental and use it for a week and fly back with another person for about 300 quid cheaper than the ferry. So what would the point be for me to use it?
13

Doug Imrie,

Colinton 29/05/2008 09:20:13
Too few cabins and no daily sailing have killed the service. Tried booking for this summer but impossible to get 4 berth for return journey. Expensive? Yes but so much better than driving down to Newcastle or Hull and a great service to boot.

With DFDS also announcing the end of the Newcastle/Norway route that used to be operated by Fjordline is there not an opportunity for another commercial operator to step in and retain, even expand services out of Rosyth?
14

Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 29/05/2008 10:06:11
I have used Superfast several times and found it to be an excellent service.

It will be a pity if it goes.
15

Luke Skywalker,

United Kingdom 29/05/2008 11:00:59
Mario - I agree about it being sad that someone does not even know which country they are arriving in. That's because Belguim is a small country. Moral of the story is that we should be careful of the Sentimental Nonsense Party killing off our Union and leaving us in a small country known to us as Scotland or Alba or something but known by most of the rest of the world as England. At least just now we have a say in the UK (English) parliament which will not be the case if we leave.
16

HughB,

Edinburgh 29/05/2008 11:12:22
Mario, which small country with loads of beer and chocolate wouldn't be a draw for tourists from Scotland?
17

Zedd,

Fife 29/05/2008 13:10:47
I like the "buy the ship" idea. With fuel prices ever rising, taking traffic off the roads and onto the sea must be the obvious long term investement. I know that capitalism is incapable of such long term planning, but the Scottish government could be more socially responsible? We might need it as a replacement for the Forth Road Bridge anyway.
18

Upbeat,

29/05/2008 13:32:44
Superfast and the Scottish government both assumed that people would switch to the most logical service just because it was available. But the logic was flawed by the pricing structure and the duration and inherent delays of the crossing.

It was always quicker and cheaper for freight and private motorists to use other ports...and even with the recent hike in Fuel costs this argument will remain proportionately exactly as it always has been. Costs for Ferry fuel do not rise in isolation from that for haulage as a whole, so this excuse for closing this service can be seen as brinkmanship posturing by the ferry company, in some attempt to cover up for failure to provide what passengers sought.

A Recent trip to the Netherlands via Calais: Return crossing car and 5 passengers £48.00 (Sea France online booking. ) 1500 Km return from home in Scotland to Dover plus 100 km to motorway junction to Zeebrugge. Fuel consumed at 10km :1 litre this is around £200 at current prices. Total time one way to that Belgian motorway junction 12 hours ....cost around £250 return. Price on Superfast return for same car but only three passengers £650.00 one sailing every two days, and a crossing time of at least 14 hours .

It does not take a rocket scientist to work out that Superfast could not compete for private passengers on time, cost or convenience. But this is no reason not to try a more attractive fare structure regime . Cut passenger fares by 2/5ths and the bookings from scottish paseengers would increase. The profit on catering for these extra passengers would compensate.

Meanwhile Transport companies now will really need to work out new strategies in the face of the Global increase in fuel. Just at this moment Superfast plls the plug....you could not imagine a better moment for the Attica board to " up the anti" and try to increase pressure for more subsidy.
19

Dr. James Wilkie,

Vienna 29/05/2008 15:59:32
As a regular commuter between Scotland and the continent I have used the Rosyth-Zeebrugge service since it started, and I would not change it for any other route. it must be kept going by some means or another, preferably under Scottish management.

20

SouthernSkye,

Bonnie Bonn 29/05/2008 16:56:26
I often check this service for prices but it always comes out much more expensive for the car and I than the DFDS service to Newcastle from Ijmuiden (north of Amsterdam). Even taking the extra time and fuel (for me) into account, it's never been worth using. Shame really and I am sad to see it stopped.
Perhaps DFDS should be approached to run a mainland europe to Scotland direct service?
21

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 29/05/2008 18:29:03
The Superfast ferry was much better than the smaller Blue Star one. Thing is, all ferries are pretty much the same rip off on food.

Another thing is Brugges is boring after a couple of trips. It has ruined itself by going French style up market. And it's closed on a Sunday.

Tour operaters could have offered a more varied package destination and Superfast could have advertised the flexibility with its overall pricing policy. You could bulk buy once you had 12 passengers.

I would actually put this down to the Greek mindset, not that I have anything against the Greeks. DFDS from Newcastle to Amsterdam is actually a worse ferry but a better destination. Bigger rip off once you are on board.

Keep the route open, someone, and remember who you are catering for and price it accordingly.

DFDS offer £25 each way deals themselves. The only decent deal on Superfast was via the bulk buyers and retail sellers - with only Brugges for an overnight (bring your own kettle) stay.
22

Caora Dubh,

Croit sheasgair 29/05/2008 18:46:23
I've used both the Hull-Zeebrugge and Harwich-Hoek van Holland services when going down south. Why spend hours in a slow boat? However, I would definitely use a Rosyth-Esbjerg (Denmark) service to travel to Scandinavia, Germany, Poland, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Russia... Surely Rosyth-Esbjerg would be profitable?
23

Upbeat,

29/05/2008 18:49:58
Slightly pedantic, I know, but post 26 would be seriously challenged to reach much of Holland from Zeebrugge in under 90 minutes let alone 40. Unless of course by sayng Holland he is refering to the area to the immediate east of Breskens.

But the reason that the Superfast service operated to Zeebrugge is that it was a regional development area. It is likely that the berthing dues and port costs reflected this development status. Ijmuiden does not have the facilities or the scope for enlargement of car ferry operations. Meanwhile Europoort - the Dutch equivalent of Zeebrugge - is a long boring way from almost any other area.

The thing that many posters here have overlooked is that any cross channel ferry is simply a link to the continent. Few people will have been attracted to the service by the idea of visiting Belgium only.
24

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 29/05/2008 18:55:14
A trucker friend of mine once told me that his company prefers Newcastle-Amsterdam over Rosyth-Zeebrugge because of the sailing times. Never could quite fathom this out. Has to do with price.
25

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 29/05/2008 19:08:00
Re 33. There is also the fact that the Customs people dip your fuel tank on the way out and dip it again on the return. Apparently you are not allowed to refuel before you return.

So perhaps Amsterdam is a more favourable port for truckers in that respect also.
26

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 29/05/2008 19:14:10
Re 33 and 34. A couple of friends of mine were immigration officers. They told me that the Home Office tried to prevent the opening of Rosyth in the first place by saying that Customs and Immigration controls were not possible due to staffing. In the end they were bussed from Edinburgh airport to meet incoming ferries.

I found the Customs officers over zealous.

Not a conspiracy theory - merely an observation.
27

Stirling Sentinel,

Stirling 29/05/2008 19:48:55
Too slow and too expensive. The high Euro and exorbitant fuel costs are the main reasons for the Greek company withdrawing services. They withdrew services in the Baltic a few years ago, but I can't recall the reasons. Probably lack of passengers and freight.

Perhaps Leith or even Grangemouth would be a better bet than Rosyth. The latter was probably chosen to satisfy Gordon Brown !

I also think Holland would be more popular than Belgium and slightly nearer.
28

,

29/05/2008 19:53:54
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
29

ferryman,

fife 29/05/2008 21:45:28
With a new ferry service being started up from rosyth to kristiansund via shetland. When it was anounced to superfast, they said that they would welcome more competition on the route. Now they are bailing out of scotland. DFDS are pulling out of the Newcastle - Bergen route Tout-suite also. This is an ideal oportunity for Norshukon to pick up the ball. A full ropax ferry service, Norway,scotland and europe could all benefit from it. With a proper pricing structure in place this could be a very profitable ferry service.
30

Jock Tamson,

Scotlund, Caledunia, Alipa 29/05/2008 22:57:13
Forgot to mention that there is, or are, a single or couple of spooks on the ferry.

Their eyes nearly popped out of their heads when some middling aged wifie in twin set shouted out that you could bring back as many cigarettes as you wanted.

Just an observation - not a conspiracy theory.
31

Willie,

29/05/2008 23:33:40
#35 Are they the same two friends that said Mark MacGee was the new manager of Hearts?
Customs had nothing to do with the Home Office when Superfast started.
Another load of drivel, like most of your posts!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.