Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Saved by e-mail: The hillwalkers stranded and lost in -8C snowstorm on mountain

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 January 2009
A RESCUE operation was launched yesterday after a climber spotted an e-mail from a friend of two hillwalkers who had become stranded on a freezing mountain range.
Peter Warren and Tom Sneddon were airlifted to safety yesterday morning after spending the night shivering in sub-zero temperatures near Ben Macdui.

The pair's friend raised the alarm by sending an e-mail to the local mountain rescue team just bef
ore 9pm on Sunday. By chance, William Anderson, the team leader, checked his e-mail inbox a few minutes later.

"It was a most unusual way to get a call-out," he said. "I checked my e-mail at 9:04pm last night and noticed I had been sent a message at one minute to nine, marked 'urgent help may be required'.

"The guy who reported them missing didn't know what to do. He was on the internet and found our website and sent us an e-mail. It was just pure luck that I happened to check. Who knows what would have happened if I hadn't checked."

Mr Warren, 35, of Uddingston, and Mr Sneddon, 41, of Hamilton, had left their cars at the Cairngorms ski centre car park at 9am, and planned to reach the mountain summit before returning later that afternoon.

However, weather conditions deteriorated and a "whiteout" caused by cloud and blizzards quickly enveloped the climbers. After taking an incorrect map reading, they began walking south on to Ben Macdui.

Initially, they thought they were on Cairn Gorm, but Mr Sneddon, who had climbed the route several times before, did not recognise any features.

They tried to walk off the hill and back north towards safety but, in fading light, kept walking in the wrong direction, further south towards Glen Lui.

After several hours following a path in blizzards and in the pitch black, they came across a river but decided it was too risky to cross – and so found a sheltered spot nearby, where they spent the night in temperatures of about -8C.

They were unable to use their mobile phones so their friend, Frank Collins, raised the alarm by e-mail after Mr Warren's wife contacted him, concerned she had not heard from the pair.

Realising that the hillwalkers were potentially in serious danger due to the severe wintry conditions, Mr Anderson contacted the police and launched a full-scale rescue.

The crew of a search helicopter waited until the blizzard conditions lifted before the aircraft took off from RAF Lossie-mouth at around 3:40am.

Rescuers scoured the hillsides with night-vision goggles and the pair were discovered at about 6:30am.

Yesterday, Mr Warren spoke of his relief after their dramatic rescue in the freezing cold.

"We were heading up towards the summit of Cairn Gorm, but the weather was atrocious. We couldn't see anything. We tried to go back, but we couldn't see our tracks as they were quickly covered with snow.

"You wonder how you're going to get down, with it getting dark. We just kept going and remained determined."

The pair, who are both tradesmen, were well equipped to spend a night on the hills, having taken emergency food, extra clothes and a bivvy bag, which they put over their heads for extra warmth.

"It was absolutely freezing. We got up every two hours and walked around because it can be easy for hypothermia to set in," said Mr Warren.

Mr Anderson said they had been lucky that there was no wind, which would have sent temperatures falling further.


Warning of more snow on the way

MOTORISTS in Scotland were warned to beware icy roads today, but were assured the Arctic start to 2009 will not last long.

Temperatures were set to fall to as low as -10C last night as a blast of freezing weather continued to envelope the country.

A Met Office spokesman said: "We are looking at temperatures as low as -4C or -5C in Glasgow and Aberdeen, and as low as -10C in rural areas. There is always a chance of ice on untreated roads when it's that cold."

Some sleet and snow are forecast for parts of Scotland today but a cover of cloud is expected to slowly lift temperatures to between 3C and 7C.

Less cold air will mean the mercury will continue to rise, with temperatures of around 7C or 8C expected by Thursday.

On Sunday night, temperatures as low as -8C were recorded in northern Scotland, while they fell to -6C in some parts of England and Wales.

The weather played a part in a fatal accident in Lincolnshire, where a woman, 30, was killed as her car got stuck on a level crossing and was hit by a train.

There were problems for thousands of drivers, with the AA saying it expected to be called to more than 20,000 breakdowns by the end of the day.

The chill also prompted water company Severn Trent to appeal to its eight million customers across the Midlands and Wales to protect their homes, after reports that pipes were freezing even with the heating on full blast.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 06 January 2009 12:49 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Weather
 
1

Angoos,

Baku, Azerbaijan 06/01/2009 05:11:52
If these guys were seemingly "well equipped to spend a night on the hills" why not leave them there ?

Yet again more hillwalking muppets using the Scottish Highlands as an adventure playground and expecting others to put their lives at risk to come to their rescue when it all goes t!ts up !!
2

Jonathan,

UAE 06/01/2009 06:04:11
Interesting perspective #1.

Alternatively, walkers could pay for the joy, as (say)anglers and golfers do.

The benefit of this sort of article is that it should deter the amateurs and remind more seasoned walkers to kit out.

What this article fails to include are guidelines for those found in this jeoprady. Should they have stayed in one place? etc
3

Andrew Scalloway,

Stirling 06/01/2009 08:13:42
Angoos you're an a%$e. Do you ever venture outside? Better take a map you might get lost on the way to the chippy.
4

57vintage,

Keith 06/01/2009 08:39:25
I knew a lot of the Braemar MR team in the 80s. They were willing volunteers who took the view that they might need the help of mountain rescue themselves some day, so were happy to give their time and energy.

Genuine call outs to well-equipped and unlucky walkers do not bother them. It's the townies in trainers and flip flops who think that Air Rescue is a taxi service that they object to.
5

Donnie Murdo,

Western Isles 06/01/2009 08:42:13
4

Spot on! Angoos has obviously no taste for the outdoors.

These guys were unlucky. It happens to the best and the best are usually prepared. They had taken precautions but due to the lies, spin and propaganda by MMGW scientists, they wern't sure how much colder and windier it was going to get so made an informed choice and called the MR.
6

Nisbet,

06/01/2009 08:48:05
Though I usually email the emergency services whenever I see a fire, mugging or someone having a heart attack, I hadn't thought about using it to contact mountain rescue. I recommend it for all emergency situations.
7

nabodican,

Rural Scotland 06/01/2009 09:18:20
#1 is clearly a plonker who never takes to the hills and thinks that the taxpayer pays for the rescue services. They are all volunteers with a love for the hills and the people who walk them.
Getting lost in a whiteout is very easy and you can easily believe your compass is wrong, I personally take two compasses to avoid the situation.
These guys were well prepared and took the correct action when they realised they would have to spend the night. They had also mad others aware of where and when they would be on the hill.
8

Suzi B,

06/01/2009 10:08:15
Not sure why their friend thought it would be an appropriate move to send an urgent email at 9pm at night to warn that his friends might be in trouble. It's like whispering 'fire, fire'.
9

Tweedmouth,

Coldstream 06/01/2009 10:36:42
#7 - I suppose the taxpayer WASN'T paying for the rescue helicopter from Lossiemouth - in which the crew who risked their lives flying at night in a snow storm were not 'volunteers'. That rescue probably cost £10,000 and if the helicopter had crashed families would have been devastated. The problem with this pair of climbers seems to have been that they chose a very remote objective on a day of appalling weather. Why could they not have chosen a low level route? Tremote glens are just as spectacular as remote summits in winter - and guess what, the deer head for the glens and the woods in this weather. D'ye think they know something we don't? A practical suggestion. Why not establish a an MRS/ National Park message service or forum. Climbers heading off in winter could post a message by phone, text or email and say: "we are going off from the ski car park at 9.a.m. and our objective is . . . . We have bivvy bags, GPS, food, extra clothes and our phone number is. . . . We will log in when we return and confirm we are safely down.

At least then the MRS would have an idea where people were and could predict who was likely to be in trouble. Just a thought.
10

drink beer, smoke tabs,

Edinburgh 06/01/2009 13:28:42
Donnie Murdo - presumably you're friends with these guys, and know for certain that they were lured up into the hills partly because of "propaganda from MMGW scientists"?

Or are you just making it up, and treating this story as just another opportunity for you to demonstrate your ignorance?
11

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 06/01/2009 14:02:40
#6 and #8
As you say, it is quite astonishing that the "alarm" was raised by email. Presumably the friend was not only unsure of how to raise the alarm but also unsure of whether there was cause for a call-out. The MRT services are co-ordinated by the police so the local police station should be the first call otherwise dial 999.

The article also highlights the danger of relying on mobile phones in the hills. They rarely work at all but occasionally a very weak signal might still carry a text message. Unfortunately this is also unreliable because in poor reception areas there can be a time lag of several hours before the text gets through so one should always state the sending time in the body of the text when sending one in such circumstances. A simple, obvious rule but lives might depend on it.

I've got mixed views on charging for rescues - the insurance is easy enough to arrange (it's mandatory in some parts of the world) but there is the danger that, having taken out insurance, walkers will then feel they have some kind of safety net and can take greater risks. Further, should rescue be denied those without insurance or the means to pay?

Finally, I hope that articles such as this encourage more people to donate to our volunteer services such as the MRTs and the RNLI - perhaps even a small bequest? They save a lot of lives and perhaps, one day might save a life close to you.
12

57vintage,

Keith 06/01/2009 15:53:56
#11

I read in the last issue of Trail that carrying an international SIM card to put into a mobile phone will usually do the trick as far as reception is concerned, but mobile phones are as much of a curse as they are a blessing for hillgoers in that they give a false sense of security to the uninitiated.

#9 Re the cost of the chopper, it seems that the RAF is quite happy to provide the service since it gives real-life practise to crews in harsh conditions, preparing them for operations in whatever sovereign state we decide to invade next. That last comment is mine, not theirs, of course.
13

Thistledhu,

06/01/2009 16:04:31
regardless of the care you take Murphys law is allways in the background. if you get in trouble due to your own stupidity fair enough you should expect an invitation to contribute to the funds of the mountian rescue teams. I beleive many of the police offficers when talking to such people often do drop heavy hints to do so.
Bu t as in this case it is down to bad luck you have to put it down to exprience that we all can learn from had these 2 guys not been as well equiped the ending may well have been far diffrent
14

57vintage,

Keith 06/01/2009 16:29:34
Aye #13, someone much wiser than me once said that experience is the sum of a series of near misses. There but for good luck go many of us who occasionally frequent the wild places. That's the attitude taken by the heroes who volunteer too and is the main reason why many are altruistic enough to give up their weekends to help others.

I used to go on an annual fundraising sponsored hike for the local MRS years ago. I'll make it my New Year resolution to do this again from 2009.
15

Tweedmouth,

Coldstream 02/02/2009 10:55:19
Did these people take even the most basic precautions?
Did they have a map? - Sounds like they didn't.
Did they have a compass - ditto?
Did they have a GPS - which can be bought for £30?
Did they leave a pre-arranged phone warning with a friend?
Did they notify the National Park or the Mountain Rescue of their intended route and arrange to phone again when they were off the mountain. Also- had they even glanced at the weather forecase - all of the UK is under threat of heavy snowfall and high winds? Great time to pick a walk eh?

They were very, very lucky.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.