Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


T in the Park

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Venice - Having a splashing time, wish you were here



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 December 2008
WATER made the city, but ultimately it threatens to destroy it.
Huge swathes of Venice lay submerged yesterday after the worst floods to hit the city in more than two decades.

High winds and days of heavy rain raised the level of the city's lagoon to more than 5ft above its average height, stranding sightseers and residents and prompting the mayor to issue a stay-away warning to tourists.

Elderly people were carried to safety by firefighters as sirens blared and homeowners and shopkeepers used pumps to bail out the waist-deep water. Such was the severity of the flooding, the duckboards and pontoons which normally cope with Venice's high tides floated away.

The landmark St Mark's Square was among areas submerged under a metre of water after the sea level topped 156cm, well beyond the 110cm flood mark.

The flooding, the highest acqua alta since 158cm in 1986, has reignited arguments over how the historic city in northern Italy can fend off the increasing threat of rising sea levels. Work is under way on a flood defence system, but rows over its impact on the environmental stability of area have led to lengthy delays.

Yesterday, Massimo Cacciari, the mayor, urged people to stay indoors, and appealed to those planning a trip to "think again". Though the water was receding after a change in wind direction, further bad weather is forecast.

The plight of Venetians was compounded by a national transport strike which affected the Venice vaporetto, or water bus service.

Laurence Llewelyn-Bowen, the interior designer and television presenter, in Venice on a shopping trip with his wife, described his hotel lobby as "like a swimming pool".

He added: "We found probably the only café that's open in Venice. About 80 per cent of the people there were British. We were all drinking brandy. There was a Blitz spirit."

One shopkeeper said: "It all happened so quickly – within 20 minutes we were up to our waists in water."

The highest flood level ever recorded was 194cm in 1966. But high water levels of 100-130cm above sea level are fairly common in Venice, which is built on a series of small islands. Flooding, experts warn, is on the increase due to silt deposits raising the floor of the lagoon and the effects of global warming.

In 1900, St Mark's Square flooded ten times a year but now it floods as many as 60 times a year. The city is said to have sunk by 10cm during the 20th century, and the rate is increasing.

The Italian government has spent more than £3 billion on a flood defence system similar to the Thames Barrier. However, its installation has been slowed by controversy over claims it affects the area's stability.

Yesterday, a spokesman for the council which runs the Venice Tides Centre said the high water level had peaked at around 10:45am and that minor flooding was expected today.

BACKGROUND

VENICE is not the only city whose long-term future is under threat due to rising sea levels.

The Worldwatch Institute, an independent research organisation that promotes sustainable development, warns that of the 33 cities projected to have at least eight million residents each by 2015, some 21 are coastal cities that will have to contend with the impacts of rising seas.

One such city is Bangkok, which sits 3ft 6in to 5ft above the Gulf of Thailand, although some low-lying areas are already below sea level.

The gulf's waters have been rising by about a tenth of an inch a year, about the same as the world average. But the city, built on clay rather than bedrock, has been sinking at a far faster pace, of up to 4in annually.

In Mexico City, meanwhile, land has subsided more than 23ft since 1900 and is still dropping up to 1ft 4in a year.

Other cities under threat according to Worldwatch include New York, Los Angeles, Buenos Aires, Rio de Janeiro, Shanghai, Tianjin and Tokyo.

The full article contains 674 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 December 2008 9:51 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

D. Feste - Illyria, OH,

02/12/2008 01:28:43

Watch out that you don't step on that "Frito Misto di Mare !"

2

drunken proffet,

Tassy 02/12/2008 01:40:13
Is the picture an advert for a holiday cottage by the river or a generic one covering floods as and when they rise?
3

Dave Crass,

02/12/2008 03:57:10
Can't imagine it would do a lot for the real estate business
4

Lanna,

02/12/2008 04:28:15
o sole mio!
5

,

02/12/2008 05:15:17
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

They Call Me Bruce,

02/12/2008 05:16:30
A tidal wave would cause a lot of destruction to some of these countries
7

They Call Me Bruce,

02/12/2008 05:18:09
A tidal wave would cause a lot of destruction to some of these countries
8

They Call Me Bruce,

02/12/2008 05:29:13
A tidal wave would cause a lot of destruction to some of these countries
9

Lanna,

02/12/2008 07:20:00
Well, perhaps they could advertise... scuba tours of Venice? :/
10

Louis Catorze,

02/12/2008 07:44:17
Dredging the lagoon would be a good start.
11

,

02/12/2008 08:37:11
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
12

tbj,

02/12/2008 08:38:57
Mexico City may be subsiding at 1ft 4in a year, however as it is 7,347 ft above sea level, it probably has a little time before it is under threat.
13

Highland Mist,

02/12/2008 08:49:26
#3, Dave, the Real Estate business is pretty sunk at the moment anyway!

Having been in Venice right after the 1966 floods I saw a lot of damage and hope that this gets cleared soon and some plan put in place to save the city as it would be a great loss to civilisation were it to be submerged forever.

And wtf is Laurence Llewelyn-Bowen on about? My heart breaks for his 'shopping trip'. How VERY shallow!
14

James, Edinburgh,

02/12/2008 09:04:10
My wife and I were there a year ago. We woke to the sound of a siren which was like a cross between the 'take cover' and the 'all clear' for those of you old enough to remember the air raid sirens.The water was lapping the hotel entrance and we had to wade over to get the vaporetto. My wife turned and said, "Thank goodness we live 600 feet a.s.l." She drips sympathy!
15

Antonina,

Edinburgh 02/12/2008 09:41:19
#2 - I believe it's Cipriani's, a Venice landmark, and looking across the lagoon to the city proper.
16

Bruce K,

02/12/2008 10:09:48
The whole world is sinking
17

Bruce K,

02/12/2008 10:11:01
The whole world is sinking
18

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 02/12/2008 10:16:50
Only the Italians would be so daft as to build the roads out of water!

Seriously though, I have been there and it is truly a unique experience, however it must be a civil engineering nightmare.

19

WKKB,

02/12/2008 10:32:46
dredging would be a good start it's true but also not throwing your waste in the lagoon would help. They've been throwing their rubbish in the lagoon for centuries. My Venetian friend says in warm weather the water stinks from sewage and rubbish. Venice is in real trouble and unless they can figure out how to turn this problem around I'm afraid Venice will be a ghost town sometime in the future.
20

Harbinger,

An octopus's garden 02/12/2008 11:21:41
"the increasing threat of rising sea levels." The mantra is repeated but no evidence is offered. Sea level rise is not accelerating and is certainly not meeting model expectations. This has happened before and not just 22 years ago, so what caused it then?

The constant nonsense about global warming takes resources and intellect away from solving real world every day problems like repair and renewal of the engineeing structures.
21

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 02/12/2008 11:50:51
5 Lanna

Where HAVE you been, my dear.

I have missed your kind words and sometimes wacky asides.

Venice is sinking and also suffering from the effects of global warming.

PACE all you "global warming skeptics". It is a fact, it is here, get used to it, and stop being so stupid.

Now, Lanna, behave yourself and comport yourself with all the ladylike demeanour you can muster.
22

eyeswide,

02/12/2008 13:10:34
Cold in here isn't it?

I am 60 and the sea level where I was brought up is EXACTLY where it was when I was 10. I have spent my entire working life at sea and nowhere I ever docked is there more than an inch of change over that period.

There is no global warming caused by CO2(man's nor nature's) either - especially this century.
23

,

02/12/2008 13:53:39
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
24

They Call Me Bruce,

02/12/2008 14:20:21
The way things are going with global warming we'll all be living on top of mountains soon
25

AJ Fife,

02/12/2008 14:44:51
Couldn't they dismantle the best bits and build them somewhere a bit drier? The Yanks and Japs are a dabhand at doing stuff like that. Venice could be sold off for a fortune!
26

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 02/12/2008 14:50:19
18 AJ Fife

Oh, really now AJ.

And where would you relocate the Venetians?

Mumbai, Zimbabwe or the Congo on your short list to locate displaced citizens?

Or perhaps the REALLY dry climes of Saudi Arabia or Egypt or Algeria are to your liking
27

Erik Van,

02/12/2008 15:12:38
The flood reached the highest level in 22 years.
28

Harry Carnie,

British Colubia , Canada 02/12/2008 19:09:46
This IS sad.......Venice is a beautiful unique city.
My wife and I, in times past, enjoyed visiting there.


To be a "bit flippant" There are solutions:

1)Ask the Italian Mafia (unlimited money)to pay for implementing whatever the solutions to the problems there are.

2) Sell it to Dubai to "develop" as a tourist attraction.
29

eyeswide,

02/12/2008 20:57:48

City officials said the tide peaked at 61 inches (156 centimeters), well past the 40-inch (110-centimeter) flood mark, as strong winds pushed the sea into the city.

It was the fourth highest tide since 1872, when the city started keeping records. The last time Venice saw such high waters was in 1986, while the all-time record was 76 inches (194 centimeters) in 1966.

A combination of events.

The sea level worldwide is rising at the same rate as it has for centuries. Sometimes less, as now.

30

Not a taxi lover.,

02/12/2008 21:02:20
Chi se ne frega.
31

Let's have the truth,

Queensland 03/12/2008 09:56:16
#16 eyeswide

"nowhere I ever docked is there more than an inch of change over that period".

....Then you evidently haven't docked at a south Pacific island where inhabitants are being evacuated as we speak frrom rising sea levels.
32

eyeswide,

04/12/2008 00:08:42
#24

"....where inhabitants are being evacuated as we speak frrom rising sea levels."

Could you give me a link to that please?

Let's have the truth.
33

eyeswide,

04/12/2008 00:26:38
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200506/ldselect/ldeconaf/12/12we18.htm

"Venice is notorious for its flooding problems. It lies on a delta area subjected to subsidence. Therefore, the sea level variations are superposed on a long-term subsidence trend (Fig 8). Any rise in sea level would immediately worsen the situation. The last 30 years lack signs of any rise or accelerated rise, on the contrary sea level fell (partly as a function of engineering work)."

"In conclusion; observational data do not support the sea level rise scenario. On the contrary, they seriously contradict it. Therefore, we should free the world from the condemnation of becoming extensively flooded in the near future. There are more urgent natural problems to consider on Planet Earth like tsunamis, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, etc."

Kolker, A. S., and S. Hameed. 2007. Meteorologically driven trends in sea level rise. Geophysical Research Letters, 34, L23616, doi:10.1029/2007GL031814.

“Determining GSLR rates is complicated by non-tidal, year-to-year variability in local mean sea level that is one to two orders of magnitude greater than the long-term trend, potentially masking changes in the rate of rise. The cause of this variability is largely unknown, although it has been linked to storms, winds and floods, wind driven Rossby waves, shifts in major ocean currents such as the Gulf Stream, volcanically induced ocean heat content variations, and in the Pacific Ocean, the El Nino Southern Oscillation.”
34

eyeswide,

05/12/2008 17:03:46
in fact (albeit according to one of the distorted agencies) it would seem that the sea level has fallen globally since 2005 - I guess all those "south Pacific island ..... inhabitants" can go back home.

http://sealevel.colorado.edu/

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.