Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 5th July 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Postnatal depression 'is grieving for your old self'



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
30 November 2007
THE loss of identity a woman feels after having a baby is so strong it can feel like they have suffered a bereavement, researchers say.
Losing their financial independence, work status and freedom has such as profound effect that they can find themselves grieving for their former self, a conference in Falkirk is due to hear tomorrow.

Melanie Clarke and Dr Cynthia McVey, from Glas
gow Caledonian University, said that the pressures of modern life had led to rising rates of postnatal depression as women felt they had to "have it all".

It is estimated between 10 and 28 per cent of women will suffer postnatal depression. The British Psychological Society conference will hear that rates of postnatal depression could be reduced if this "bereavement" for the loss of their old self was considered a natural reaction which most will experience.

Mrs Clarke and Dr McVey interviewed new mothers with a history of postnatal depression. The women reported a feeling of being "lost". They had problems because of unrealistic expectations about childbirth and motherhood and because they had lost sight of the person they used to be.

Mrs Clarke said this led women to start grieving for their previous identity. "There are so many losses you experience when you have a child - the loss of your former freedom, your financial independence and so many other things which you had before.

"But the birth of a child is never framed as a loss. It is all roses around the door and this feeling that everyone should be happy," Mrs Clarke said. "This is especially so these days where women are under pressure to have great careers and a great family as well. They feel they have to have it all.

"But many women go through a grieving process over the loss of their former self when they have a child."

The researcher said there was a lot of pressure on new mothers to accept the losses, but this meant a grieving process - akin to normal bereavement - was necessary. She said that if post-natal depression was treated as a grieving process, women would have hope that they would emerge from the other side, as with any other bereavement.

Belinda Phipps, of the National Childbirth Trust, said: "

There is a lot of talk about getting back to your normal self, but when you go from being a daughter, sister, wife and add the identity of mother, it's is an irreversible condition."

• FEELING tearful and depressed after having a baby is common among many new mothers.

It can range from the less severe "baby blues" - lasting just a few days after birth - to postnatal depression which can take months to develop.

In the most serious but rare cases, postnatal psychosis may develop, leading to irrational behaviour, and confusion and suicidal thoughts. Experts say that women should seek treatment early if they think they have depression, and there are many treatments which can help stop postnatal depression.

This can include medication and counselling, while taking regular exercise is also thought to help.

But women are warned it can take a long time to fully recover from the condition.



The full article contains 531 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 29 November 2007 9:38 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Pregnancy and birth
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Chairman for the 'Babies-Union' 30/11/2007 01:38:15

Getting on for 30%, of Woman that has a BaBA, then suffers PND , is high.
Being a Male and never having to suffer this, I cant imagine what its like for a Woman.
I think that as Men, if we understand a little about PND, and give our Love and Support, this will go a long way, to help 'New-Mums', get back their,
'Self-Worth', which is 'Worth' Millions.!!

2

Alasdair,

30/11/2007 09:42:35

I just hope to be able to one day provide as many extraneous apostrophes as you.

3

Boy Wonder,

30/11/2007 10:13:49

PND is a terrible thing new mothers go through. And it isn't hard to recognise the syptoms either. When a child is born, the mother needs 110% total support from family, friends, doctors and social services to cope with the trauma of giving birth and the after-effects.

I know some will come on and go on about women giving birth for thousand of years and never needed all that support. They didn't have it then, so why now?

Well, I'll tell you why. We've evolved somewhat from even the medieaval and Restoration periods. We are not the same as our ancestors were. We do not have the same challenges in life. That forces change in us even down to the cellular level ... because acquired characteristics passed through generations can becomer inherited. Not that we are any lesser for it ... just different.

So women are different today. Birth is harder for some and nature's balancing of the scale can become upset. Why else would we rquire HIV birthing techniques?

But whatever you want to believe ... doesn't supporting and caring for a new mother just make a lot of sense anyway?

4

Charles Linskaill,

Chairman for the Babies Union 30/11/2007 10:34:07

Well said, #3. BW, the Babies and 'toddler' group have just read your post and have asked me, to ask you, if you will be their mentor! ? :-D

5

Cheese burger,

Edinburgh 30/11/2007 12:21:58

I understand the article - I totally agree that the loss of the person you were is very tangible. It's almost a loss of personality as the added responsibility and tiredness grows. Much as I love my children, now quite grown up, I still miss the person that had their own flat, didn't have to live up to anybody's expectations, could idle around on a sunday without raising anyone's eyebrows, and could just be a bit selfish without having to consider anyone else. As you can see, I still have it quite badly!!! But there's no going back, so I go on, a different person, not such a fun person, a carer, a mother. A different me.

6

Taras Shevchenko,

30/11/2007 17:09:36

#9 Wini, a salient point; brains are like chemist shops - but I suppose there also must be a psychological reaction/impact to any change in your life - so, to be fair, that can affect the inbalance and thwart recovery? It may even be a root cause?

My wife didn't suffer from PND so I can't say I've felt the brunt - we do live near her parents which has been a godsend when its come to support.

I massaged my wife every night for 6months leading up to the birth of our second (I felt that bad for her after witnessing the first time what child birth entailed)...as I say, every night I would massage her for 90 minutes - without fail. When she told a bunch of her friends from a baby-group; they were all freaked out and well impressed.

The thing is, a supportive as I am, the focus goes all on the baby and the mum gets very little consideration.....its like being in a car crash and then being given the biggest responsibility of your life. The first time around is the hardest but also when you've got two you are both man marked out of the game.

I'm a bit depressed now though, knowing there are scum suckeing nimrods like #2. Alasdair bottom-feeding their way around this forum.

7

WHISTLEBLOWER,

30/11/2007 18:28:11

PND is awful, but so is the idea of treating children as a commodity, or lifestyle choice, which this article does. If you have kids, you have to look after them, otherwise you end up with broken adults, and a broken society as a result.

8

WHISTLEBLOWER,

30/11/2007 18:29:40

"Could not the shock of birthing"

Shocking indeed because it's ships that do the "berthing". Women do the "giving birth" or "bearing children".

9

MoragtheToerag,

somewhereovertherainbow 30/11/2007 22:18:21

As someone who has suffered from PND, I couldn't agree more with the first paragraph of #9's post.

The qualify my illness as losing my former self is insulting!

It had ZERO to do with grieving for the person I was, because I was a pathetic loser before becoming a mother made me realise what a selfish person I was.

PND isn't an intellectual concept, it's a biochemical ILLNESS that robs people of their hope, their peace of mind, their security, their control over even the most basic aspects of life and of years of their lives.

People nowadays often live far away from their families and support systems and work long hours far from home. Commutes are long due to high house prices forcing people to live farther nad farther from places of work. Communities are transient and fragmented and insular or worse, crime-ridden and violent. No one has time for anything but making money to pay their increasing bills.

I can't help thinking it's this isolation and loneliness that play a far greater role in the rise of PND than some abstract longing for how you lived before you had children.

10

Suzi B,

01/12/2007 02:57:03

#13 But do women really 'give' birth? Not really. They give life.
I don't have a problem with Wini using the term 'birthing', which is a word used by mothers and midwives the world over. It recognises that birth isn't that moment when the baby is born, but the entire dynamic process of bringing your child into the world, which makes the mother the central player in the whole experience rather than a passive participant in a play under the direction of medical staff. Better 'birthing' than 'delivering a baby'-or having someone deliver your baby for you.

11

Trude,

UK 01/12/2007 11:42:05

#9 Wini - It is more the case that depression (or rather negative thinking) causes the chemical imbalance, not the other way round. Think about when you've had a bad day at work - you generally feel pretty lousy. Equally when you do something great or watch a good film for example you're filled with happy feelings. It's the same with reactions to big life events such as having a baby. The huge change for some people can be overwhelming, causing negative introspection/worrying, which may in turn affect chemicals in the brain. Most importantly however it is also possible to stimulate happy chemicals (endorphins etc) by supporting the woman and helping her to come to terms with her new role. This might include introducing her to other new mums for peer support, exercise, and getting some rest...:we all know what lack of sleep does to our mood. Being proactive in this way is more beneficial in the long run than simply taking more mind altering chemicals that do nothing to address the real cause of the problem- ie the change in lifestyle.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.