Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Edinburgh 15 - 13 Leinster: Deserved win for Robinson's men ensures Magners League champions-elect must wait



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 19 April 2008
Edinburgh put Leinster's title party on hold
EDINBURGH claimed a second win of the season over Leinster at Murrayfield last night and rejoiced in spiking the Irishmen's hopes of a Magners League title celebration in Scotland.

They fully deserved to end Leinster's 11-game unbeaten run in the
league, and though there was no great flourish to their last home game of the season, this was perhaps as pleasing a performance in the manner in which Edinburgh came back from early scrummage problems, coped with lengthy periods under pressure and, with a clutch of players missing, doused the fire of a side intent on earning champions' status inside these 80 minutes.

They were helped by Felipe Contepomi uncharacteristically missing a last-minute penalty – it came back off a post in a dramatic finale – but Andy Robinson, the Edinburgh coach, said afterwards: "Whether (Contepomi] kicked it or not, I thought our players responded today. There was a lot of courage, and that was an important team performance. We're not beating the top teams by 20 or 30 points so it takes great effort and concentration, and that's what you saw out there.

"Leinster are a quality side and deserve to be where they are; they've been the most consistent side this year."

There were no stars, but many heroes for Edinburgh last night. Robinson pinpointed the work of the midfield trio of Phil Godman, Nick De Luca and Ben Cairns in stifling the Leinster backs, and taking the game to them, while the pack earned praise for their ability to overcome the early hiccups and defend heroically on their line through concerted minutes of Leinster pressure.

Defence, Robinson revealed, had been a particular concern when he joined Edinburgh, but the fact the team has lost just one try in a host of games with top opposition this term – this was Leinster's first in their last two Murrayfield matches – and the growing strength in depth lent substance to his belief that this season had laid firm foundations on which to build success.

There was precious little fluidity in the first half but an eagerness to work hard and an appetite for kicking deep and chasing. At times it was almost like sevens as the kicks were run back and tackles missed, and attacks swept into and petered out in 22s.

There, the teams dug in and Edinburgh, largely, were forced to endure some heavy tackling practice to protect their line, but they stood up to that task. Contepomi opened the scoring with a penalty in the sixth minute, but the hosts finished their first real chance eight minutes later when John Houston thumped Luke Fitzgerald in the tackle – leading to the Scot's withdrawal soon after – and they counter-attacked.

Cairns, the inside centre, latched on to a hack ahead by skipper Allister Hogg and though he was caught as he collected the ball and raced into the visitors' 22, by winger Rob Kearney, ball was swiftly recycled and moved crossfield where Ross Ford, the hooker, crashed into the right-hand corner. Phil Godman converted superbly from the touchline.

Leinster tried to tighten the game with their forwards mauling deep into the home half, but this played into Edinburgh's hands and lifted the home pack. Referee Nigel Owens made a bizarre call on Alan MacDonald, the impressive openside flanker, awarding Leinster a penalty in front of the home posts for apparently seizing on a loose ball at a ruck too quickly, and Contepomi converted.

Godman quickly responded with a penalty at the other end, but though Edinburgh then lost Hogg to the sin-bin, after one ruck infringement too many, they produced a solid backs-to-the-wall display either side of the break. The Irish side had not been beaten in the league since last October, winning ten on the trot, but as Edinburgh picked up again with their skipper back on the field a strong feeling coursed through the home support that this game had become their side's to lose.

Hugo Southwell just missed a drop-goal and Godman a penalty, when suddenly MacDonald made a half-burst and Dave Callam, the No 8, took his flanker's pass at terrific pace to touch down.

Fitzgerald threw Leinster a lifeline with a try, converted by Contepomi, with nine minutes to go, but the Argentine's failure to grasp the last-minute opportunity ensured a gutsy home win and pleased supporters who, it was confirmed yesterday, will be returning to Murrayfield next season, after the planned move to club grounds was ruled out as a positive result of the rising attendances.

Scorers: Edinburgh: Tries: Ford, Callam; Pen: Godman; Con: Godman. Leinster: Try: Fitzgerald; Pens: Contepomi 2; Con: Contepomi.

Edinburgh: H Southwell; S Webster, B Cairns, N De Luca, J Houston; P Godman, G Laidlaw; A Allori, R Ford, G Kerr, M Mustchin, B Gissing, A Hogg (capt), D Callam, A MacDonald. Subs: C MacRae for Houston 28mins, G Cross for Kerr 40, D Blair for Webster 60-63, B Meyer for Laidlaw 75,

Leinster: G Dempsey; L Fitzgerald, B O'Driscoll, F Contepomi, R Kearney; J Sexton, C Whitaker; O Le Roux, B Jackman, S Wright, L Cullen (capt), T Hogan, S Keogh, J Heaslip, S Jennings. Subs: M O'Kelly for Cullen 36mins, K Gleeson for Jennings 54, C Warner for O'Driscoll 67,

Referee: N Owens (Wal). Attendance: 3138.







The full article contains 910 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 19 April 2008 12:21 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

KD,

19/04/2008 10:41:19
Great result from Edinburgh...made Leinster look pretty ordinary (even though they almost stole it at the end!).

Attendance...hmmm, looks like a sell out at Meggetland!!!
2

RDW,

19/04/2008 10:42:08
Great result. I'd say the missed penlty at the end was deserved because from what I saw it didn't look like tackler in the first place - Callum was the tackler and it definately didn't look like a ruck had formed. Correct me if I am wrong though - Setanta didn't give very good replays!

Oh yeh - de luca and Cairns have to be the next Scotland partnership!!!!


One more thing - well done Glasgow too!
3

RDW,

19/04/2008 10:45:18
Sorry the 2nd line should read "didn't look like a penalty in the first place" - I just woke up!
4

AlastairS,

19/04/2008 10:54:13
RDW I agree with you. DeLuca is an inside centre rather than an outside centre. The thought of Deluca, Cairns and Evans as part of the backline is exciting. I would also play Godman at standoff as he is the most likely to get the best out of them
5

GrahamH,

Edinburgh 19/04/2008 11:17:23
Like Parks, De Luca is a good player at this level but the gap to international level is too much. Been too much for Hadden as well, he never got this much out of Edinburgh.

6

AlastairS,

19/04/2008 11:30:10
GrahamH I cannot agree with you. DeLuca played at outside centre and did not play well. He has not been given an opportunity to play at inside centre which is his best position. Also he played outside Parks and Henderson and got little ball and what he got gave him little opportunity probably making him try too hard. He has shown up well against Jauzion, Darcy and Hipkiss and is a class player
7

Alain Paddy d'Poontangue l'Honky-Tonque O'Rolland,

19/04/2008 11:38:43
I personally would like to see the SRU re-enact the battle of Trafalgar, but with Caravans instead of sail powered warships, and on the M8 during several succesive Friday rush hours instead of in the Solent.

You could have the French (je suis Irlandais) going East bound and the British (Huzzah!) going West.

And King-Kong McKie could stand on the Poop deck of his brand new Elddis Twin Axle and play the part of Nelson. "Kiss me Haddock" and all that.

That would raise the profile of the game in Weegeland.
8

Venachar,

19/04/2008 12:23:58
Exciting game played at pace by Edinburgh last night.
Neil Francis on Setanta had to eat his words at the end of the match and boy did he choke LOL. Matt Mustchin whom Mr Francis thought was the most useless player on the park before the kick off ends up being Man of the Match. Good stewarding - the Leinster Corporate dude who had a bit too much to drink was removed quietly. It was never a penalty at the end.

Well done Edinburgh.
9

RDW,

19/04/2008 12:51:31
#6 - couldn't agree more. Put him outside captain slow (Henderson) and Parks anyone is going to struggle. No wonder he tried to force things. The reason Edinburgh's backs are so good is they attack the ball at pace, running good lines. That is never going to happen with PArks and Henderson.
10

Edinburgh Pete ,

19/04/2008 15:31:23
Excellent result last night and a positive win to finish the home season with.

After an iffy start in which the scrum really struggled the team got it together and defensively were excellent as demonstrated by the sensible tactics and play during Hogg’s sin binning and keeping Leinster to just one try despite their territory and possession. Two good tries scored aswell especially Callum’s, well set up by MacDonald.

What was really positive for me was the midfield trio of Godman, De Luca and Cairns who again showed they can compete against the best players. There is another option to Parks and co and once again these guys showed exactly what they can do.

In the end it was a bit of a rollercoaster but Cotemponi’s miss was justice for a poor decision in the first place.

Thanks Edinburgh, there have been some great memories from this season, two games left on the road now and then planning for next year. Be interested to see how good Robinson is in the transfer market and just how well he can boost the squad ahead of the start of next season.
11

jbascotinengland,

19/04/2008 17:29:13
#10 - Is Robinson going to have any funds to bring players in? And how much choice will he get as I'd assume the SRU will want to bring in Scottish players only.

I'd like to see AR stay on as Edinburgh coach, even if FH is sacked from Scotland. He has made massive progress this season. That was unlike any Edinburgh team I've watched in the past (except for the trying to throw it away at the end!)

Does anyone else think that the Setanta coverage is not great?

I'm looking forward to moving back North and getting myself a season ticket for next season. I'm particularly looking forward to the celebrations when Edinburgh bring the Heineken Cup home in 2009!!
12

JT,

20/04/2008 12:06:54
#5 How can you compare De Luca with Parks?? De Luca stepped up to the plate this year for his first senior start and ok he didnt have the best start to his international career however Parks lousy passing and positioning didnt help. Parks has had more time in the Scotland jumper. As for Edinburgh I cant see why we cant be challenging for the league next season as long as we can maintain the passion we have shown this year. Although I dont want to go through again the agony to elation like the last 30 seconds of the game. I spoke to Leinster fans who agreed with me when Contemponi stepped up "he never misses" but he did and justice was served as we deserved to win that.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.