Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

The hunt is On.
Sponsored by
Can you track down Scotland's wildest beastie?
 
 
Thursday, 4th December 2008 Change Date

The Scotsman Digital Archive - Special Christmas Offer

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Hawick 11 Edinburgh Accies 16: Hawick falter as absentees keenly felt



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 06 October 2008
HOW Hawick must have rued the loss of players to back-up pro-team duties. The team's display was as dreary as the weather as they struggled to put shape on their game in the face of a stodgy Accies side, who did just about enough to merit their win.
Where Hawick had benefited in recent games from the sparkle of Rory Hutton, in the regular stand-off's absence it was a rather unsure and indecisive side which attempted to add to their solitary league win so far.

Their efforts did put them in t
he lead at the break, but centre Craig Neish's usually sure boot was less than certain in the driving rain, and four goal kicks missed their target. However, it would be unfair to pin the blame on that alone since most of the Hawick display fell short.

The only bright moments involved their two Fijian replacements Macui Raiicoso and Kitione Rawala, whose inclusion at least injected a certain excitement amidst the gloom.

There were murmurings that this was the worst match witnessed for a long time – but not, unsurprisingly, from Accies coach Ian Barnes. Former Borderer Iain Berthinussen was their try scorer with full-back Stuart Walker adding the points through the conversion and three penalty goals.

Keith Hedley touched down for Hawick, with Neish slotting two penalty goals.

Scorers: Hawick: Try: Hedley; Pens: Neish 2. Edinburgh Accies: Try: I Berthinussen; Con: Walker; Pens: Walker 3

Hawick: C Murray; K Hedley, R Scott, C Neish, S Anderson; G Hogg, B Campbell; G Scott, M Landels, S Linton, G Petrie, C Charters, D Lowrie, N Mactaggart, K Davies. Subs used: M Raiicoso, K Rawala, K Reid, S Cumming.

Edinburgh Accies: S Walker; M Coupar, A Blair, I Berthinussen, D Rattray; R Bonner, M Campbell; N Lah, M Price, L Niven, E Stuart, J Turner, T Drennan, D Teague, E Milne. Subs used: J Berthinussen

Attendance: 600

Referee: A McMenemy.



The full article contains 333 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 05 October 2008 11:30 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

B.McGeek,

06/10/2008 19:03:26
losing players to back up pro teams is not the issue as clubs should be developing local players to maintain the team full season, pro players are an added bonus, however Jim Hay seems to think they are a necessity. He said in the local press about his disappointment of the loss of a young prop who wanted a year out. This is the same prop who had been at Hawick, left and trained with one of the local junior teams, he was approached by Hawick to sit on the bench against West, had a few minutes and was completely dropped the next week when the allocated pro came. What does rugby want, encouraging young players or winning games with pros at the expense of the good young players. These young players are getting fed up, disi
llusioned and losing interest in playing for their home town. I do hope Mr Clamp reconsiders as he would be a great loss to rugby long term. Hay also said when he was an 18 year old he would have loved to have played for hawick with over 130 players training then, as opposed to now in Hawick where there is approx half that number, the competition is not as strong. The benefit of allocated pros is with the development of younger players, not the need to have them to win games, share experience and knowledge of what they gain at the professional level, however this is only if they have it to share. The strength in Hawick in the past was young players playing with the experience of the likes of Renwick, Deans & co when not on official duties. When the district and internationals were played club games were not played or played friendlies.
2

B.McGeek,

06/10/2008 21:05:13
further more, it was noted in the papers about homegrown talent against Heriots at the beginning of the season, just lst week Hawick announced the arrival of an Aussie prop, that on top of the Fijians makes 3 non Homegrown, so prehaps the press officer for Hawick should reconsider. Congratulations to Selkirk which have a majority from the area, with wise recruitment.
3

Nelson Mandela,

paisley 07/10/2008 10:40:32
Yes well done to Selkirk on their start to the season - but beware of the future problems that will face you if you want to stay in the top division (not being within 20 miles of a pro club).
I think you are missing the point on the above article which was not written by Jim Hay.
All last season Hawick got less access to pro players than any of their opposition. Whilst keen to play pro's in limited numbers to develop others they were made less available to Hawick than any other team. This season as you have noted Hawick have had the services of one prop and one of their younger players as you note had to drop out of the set up to bring him in. This week because of a nonentity of a game (that I have been unable to as yet discover the outcome of) no pro players were made available to Hawick and they lost the services of players in the Academy including Rory Hutton (not a pro player). As the out come of Saturdays game could be crucial to Hawick surviving in division 1 and even the neutral reporter seems to think it affected the outcome I think that they may have a justified complaint if they wished to voice it.
Can any one of the 500 Edinburgh fans tell us the result of the back up game that was so crucial to Edinburgh to play on Monday?
4

Dissillusioned Supporter!,

07/10/2008 11:25:19
You have to feel sorry for Hawick, players like Hutton, Coutts and McNeil sitting in the stand when they should be playing for thier club, watching them get beat, and so much for pro allocation to help them out.

Similar happened to Gala when going into P1, the pro allocation to P1 was stopped that year (?) and Gala lost players and a coach - Graham, to the pro set up, and on being relegated the next season the pros were allowed back to P1 but the players Gala had produced - Cross, Miller, Berthinnussen, Kibble etc were all told they could only represent P1 teams and were duly allocated to rival clubs like Hawick and Biggar!
Now this just pi$$es off players, clubs and supporters, we really need to sort out some decent structure here for the benefit of all.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.