Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Forth waterfront walkway may be capital's answer to the boardwalk

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 09 May 2009
IT IS to be modelled on the sun-kissed waterfronts of San Tropez and Nice. Now council leaders in Edinburgh hope the city's tourism fortunes will be transformed – with the creation of a continental-style promenade along its shoreline.
Long-awaited plans to transform Edinburgh's waterfront with a ten-mile walkway were unveiled yesterday. Twenty key areas will be linked by a promenade expected to create around 1,000 jobs and generate more than £12 million a year for the city's economy.

It is hoped the "Edinburgh Promenade", as the project has been branded, will become a magnet for cyclists, wildlife enthusiasts, and families.

New public parks and piazzas, barbecue areas, cafés and restaurants and works of art are planned to be created between Cramond and Portobello.

Landmarks, sites of historic interest, wildlife-spotting areas and cultural attractions will be promoted under one banner.

Neglected areas such as Granton, Silverknowes and Portobello are among those expected to be transformed under a campaign to be launched within the next few months.

Officials at Edinburgh City Council, who unveiled plans for the venture yesterday, have studies the waterfronts of Copenhagen, Nice and Hamburg in planning for their own venture.

It is hoped Edinburgh Promenade will become Scotland's answer to the South Bank area of the Thames, where thousands flock every day.

Edinburgh Promenade will be promoted alongside the Fife Coastal Trail and John Muir Way, in East Lothian to form part of a North Sea Trail.

However, the success of the project rests on developers helping to pay for the creation of sections of the promenade, and the council admits it could take up to 30 years for it to be completed.

A key goal is to ensure that a high-quality walkway is created along the entire length of the route, accompanied by new promotional signs and interpretation boards, while each section should boast its own identity.

The first new section has already been completed, between Silverknowes and Granton, and a section of Granton Harbour will be overhauled over the next year.

Project manager Steve McGavin said: "The promenade is more than just a cycleway and footpath. It is a key ingredient in making the waterfront an attractive and high-quality visitor destination.

"Experience elsewhere points to a promenade being a crucial ingredient in making a successful waterfront. Annual expenditure associated with the Fife Coastal Path is estimated to be between £24m and £29m."

Councillor Tom Buchanan, the city's economic development leader, said: "This project will rejuvenate the whole waterfront and utilise coastal areas which have been lying dormant. The promenade will help connect the unique communities along our city's coastline and will provide an inspiring location for people to exercise, explore and enjoy the beautiful scenery."

However Ross McEwen, of the Leith-based campaign group Jump (Joined Up Master Planning), said: "There has been a lot of talk about this project over the years and very little progress.

"It's vital for the council to take the lead on this and ensure developers and landowners get the whole thing moving. Edinburgh's waterfront is very poor compared to other cities across Europe."

SITES ON THE SHORE

Cramond: Popular thanks to its historic sites and attractions, there is already a large stretch of walkway in place linking Cramond with Silverknowes.

Granton: Although there are coastal walkways, some of them are unlit and access to part of the shore is blocked by industrial units.

Newhaven Harbour: Although rich with maritime history, the council admits the current environment is "potentially intimidating". The area would be linked to a planned new lighthouse park.

Leith Docks: Home to Ocean Terminal and the Royal Yacht Britannia, public access is barred along its waterfront.

Portobello: By far the biggest section of existing promenade and already boasting several works of art.


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 May 2009 9:19 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Chuck.U.Farley,

09/05/2009 00:23:50
This space is reserved for Charles Linskail to fill with inane drivel.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2

Brodric,

09/05/2009 00:35:49
Chuck, please - or should I say Charles? After all Chuck is Charles and Charles is Chuck. And Farley, isn't that baby rusks? Haven't you just been banned for having too much trans fats?

Ho, ho. Just having a bit of fun, Chuck.

Nevertheless, f you cannot say anything good, please don't attack Charles, he is of national stature on the Hootsmon. Doesn't mean you agree with all he says, but he is one of our regulars. Don't knock him too much.
3

Brianwci,

09/05/2009 00:56:43
Excellent idea but for goodness sake let's make sure we A) use the best of materials so that they still look good decades down the line and B)put the piazzas under glass so they can be used all the year round, lots of ventilation in the summer of course.

Otherwise a bold, very worthwhile initiative for tourists and natives alike.
4

Brodric,

09/05/2009 00:59:52
No 3 Brianwci - spot on!
5

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 09/05/2009 01:19:42

As long as it does not go all 'Topsy Turvy' and the sewerage comes floating down the shoreline!
Hardly a romantic walk down the boardwalk!



6

therevd,

Vientiane 09/05/2009 03:56:19
30 Years! Hope I'll be alive to see it - 10 miles on a zimmer will be quite a challenge.
7

Angoos,

Baku, Azerbaijan 09/05/2009 05:25:45
I can picture the scene. Open air shooting gallery for junkies, idylic hidey-holes for muggers to wait for their next victim...... not exactly Saint Tropez or Nice !!!
8

madrab,

Edinburgh 09/05/2009 06:59:04
Will they have a good supply of sick bags for those surprised by the stench of the sewage plant?
9

FTH22inarow,

09/05/2009 07:40:37
3 so it keeps the junkies and muggers dry and warm
10

dgg,

Crowthorne 09/05/2009 07:46:56
Worryingly reminiscent of plans in the 60s to demolish most of Princes Street and have buildings with a walkway one storey up. That's the reason why you have a few concrete buildings with the 2nd floor recessed compared with the ground one ... the plan bit the dust.

And having started this process but failed to carry it through, and having totally changed the nature of the buildings overall, no real reason nowadays to prevent Macdonalds or shops with bagpipe music. Bah!

Nice idea but no council will have the guts to see it through over a generation.

PS the front at Nice consists of a busy road, with various *bits* of walkway connecting points of interest like the harbour. Most of the action is in hotels and restaurants on the inland side of the road. There are certainly parts of the shoreline have been revamped, but it's not continuous. And of course you've got a lot of beach and a lot of sun-tanned people willing to use same. Porty isn't in the same league! Leith can compete with Nice harbour in some ways even though there's a lack of posh yachts here.

Forth Ports Authority have had a number of goes at the shoreline - remember the plans to join Leith and Granton harbours with a barrier and infill the entire area between? Is this project serious or are they flying a kite?
11

dgg,

Crowthorne 09/05/2009 08:01:56
"Reminiscent of South Bank". Yes there's a walkway connecting various parts of the river between S Bank and Greenwich. It's not much used. That's because a lot of it doesn't look very nice and goes through run-down areas.

People go to South Bank firstly because of the Concert and Art venues; secondly because of the bars and restaurants which have grown up round about; because of the London Eye; because transport is handy at Waterloo and elsewhere. Relatively few would use S Bank as a starting point for a walk along the Thames and I suspect those that do wont be spending large amounts in hostelries.

You don't get people in London wandering about of an evening like you do in Italy and Spain. No passegiata. In London you meet your mates in a pub or a restaurant, you don't expect to bump into them wandering along the Thames. In Mediterranean countries peope do meet up. SO a change of culture needed ...
12

FTH22inarow,

09/05/2009 08:08:44
12 or a change of climate.
13

eric,

lothian 09/05/2009 08:22:17
St Tropez and nice:)in reality and grim climate Blackpool you really mean,lets get some illuminations while we are at it,Honestly this place gets more tacky everyday.
14

Finloch,

Edinburgh 09/05/2009 08:33:38
It's really cold and inhospitable at night on the foreshore - and that is in July!
15

FrankJB,

Old York 09/05/2009 08:46:02

A brilliant idea - in theory & on paper.

They could do with a similar scheme for Glasgow - are you listening tourism planners?

You can't even walk from the Science / BBC site into the centre because greedy developers have grabbed parts of the promenade as their own - large signs say "Keep Out" - Residents only. I ignore them myself - I thought all the UK tidal coastline was to be available for access (OK, docks, shiping berths & Faslane excepted perhaps!)

I suspect a raft of similar problems in Edinburgh will rear their heads as established "flats by the sea" residents shout - "Thats a mine - get away"
16

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 09/05/2009 08:48:30
Yet another grandiose continental-style fantasy from the lunatics in charge of the Cooncil asylum. I just can't wait to go for a stroll past the palm trees, sip a Buckie-Colada by Granton on a balmy summer's evening. And Mr Ferguson - please check the spelling of the cooncil's spin-releases before you submit them as your own work - think you'll find the French place on the Med where the beautiful people go is called St. (not 'San') Tropez.
But I'll grant you, certain parts of Leith do have, erm, 'certain amenities' in common with parts of Hamburg's waterfront.
17

Boy Wonder,

09/05/2009 09:15:32
Anything to take the attention away from the awful Tram-project and destruction of the city-centre, eh???
18

A Crofter,

Broken Arce 09/05/2009 09:39:14
"Officials at Edinburgh City Council, who unveiled plans for the venture yesterday, have studies [sic] the waterfronts of Copenhagen, Nice and Hamburg in planning for their own venture."

No junketing opportunity escapes our public-spirited troughers.
19

Robert kirkwood,

09/05/2009 11:05:47
Leith's unique atmosphere, especially near Seafield, will be a knock-out.
20

Darien,

Panama 09/05/2009 11:07:13
"plans to transform Edinburgh's waterfront with a ten-mile walkway were unveiled yesterday."

Edinburgh's immense waterfront opportunity (and Glasgow riverside) is already 10-15 years behind redevelopment at almost all other great city ports such as Barcelona, Genoa, Hamburg, Yokohama etc.

We might ask why that is? Why are we so far behind the world's most successful waterfront cities? Could it be because Westminster sold the port for a couple of quid to ex port officials, and the latter don't have a clue about waterfront revitalisation? Could it also be because the City Council don't have a clue what to do with the waterfront, and have no cash to spend on it anyway? Could it be because the key actors are both clueless and cashless?

We can be sure that if waterfront redevelopment is ever completed in Edinburgh, it will take an eternity, it will cost us an arm and a leg (one way or another), and we can be sure it will end up as a bit of a dog's breakfast.
21

Brianwci,

09/05/2009 11:34:10
Let's keep our thinking positive and let's bear in mind we have an SNP Government to oversee the project once it gets underway.

Let's go for it, using best quality materials and glass, 'cathedraled' piazzas. Fantastic.
22

Darien,

Panama 09/05/2009 11:42:14
#22 Brianwci: "Let's keep our thinking positive and let's bear in mind we have an SNP Government to oversee the project once it gets underway."

The Government here do not own the city waterfront land, unlike more or less all other countries. Passing a plan is one thing, control is another. In the UK, port land is now mostly in private ownership. In other countries its in dominimum populi, and for good reason.
23

Buttress,

09/05/2009 12:02:37
'Nice' idea, wrong place.


24

PointOf View,

Bonnie Scotland 09/05/2009 14:12:45
Although I have great reservations to the causes of climate change, reasons aside if the oceans are going to rise over the next 50 years can I suggest we place the plaza on very high stilts? As per normal no long term thought put into costly projects but not too work the elite and banks will make a kill.

I’m not suggesting the project is a bad thing as working class people will earn a pittance whilst making rich people richer. However, it it were to be built for goodness sake put some thought into it before designing and building.

Incidentally lots of low lying ocean front land has been offer for sale in the likes of Canada. Do you think they know something, hoping to sell it off for desirable beach front housing, before it’s under water?
25

SandyBottoms,

Edinburgh 09/05/2009 14:37:36
Big plans. Why don't they start smaller? There's a lot of derilict shops and buildings on the water-side of Granton, why not fix them up first? And why isn't more of the waterfront open to the public?
26

Media at One,

09/05/2009 15:33:09
A good idea, it looks awesome!
Only problem is the Scottish ned culture - they WILL hang about and create a bad vibe for people.
It is a pity Scotland suffers from this illness - I doubt there is a nation on the planet that suffers the same disgusting levels of anti social behaviour. Is it the dole that causes this? Is it the lack of corporal punishment?
Who knows, but they WILL ruin this awesome looking project.
27

FourGingerWigs,

Portland, Oregon, USA 09/05/2009 17:49:19
Uhhh... doesn't anyone else think the artist was smoking something when he put together his impression? What the hell's up with the gigantic seagull? With picture so small why would The Scotsman choose the one with the giant bird?
28

Western Gael,

09/05/2009 18:27:48
#16 FrankJB
"A brilliant idea - in theory & on paper." This is the second pipe dream published in the Scotsman this week. Amidst the greatest fiscal catastrophe to hit Scotland, and the wee rest of the British Isles, in the past 80 or so years, where is any Council to get the money to see this to reality?

#28 I haven't a clue what they've all been smoking, but I'd like to know where they got it.
29

Charley,

Boston & Delhi 09/05/2009 19:26:28
Oh lovely Edinburgh...last time I was there, abused for being neither of fair skin and being a, love this one "septic-tank ******* expletives". You make the deep south seem cultured...deep south USA that is.
30

Dylan fan,

Planet earth 10/05/2009 04:35:42
#30 Spent a lot of time in the Southern States have you? Did you not receive the famous Southern hospitality? How could that be, honey?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.