Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Monday, 8th September 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Isle to emerge from dark ages in new year as Eiggtricity switched on



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 31 December 2007
RESIDENTS of a Hebridean island are set to be switched on to mains power for the first time.
Some of the 87 people living on Eigg are planning to hold parties to celebrate the fact they will finally be able to use electric toasters and kettles.

The change will be part of one of the greenest power schemes in the country – a £1.5 million so
lar, wind and hydro generating station.

It had been hoped to get all the island's residents connected to "Eiggtricity" – as it has been dubbed – before Christmas.

But weather and other commissioning issues have delayed the big switch-on until the new year.

Eigg's newest resident, Saira Renny, whose cottage currently has bottled gas, said: "I will be literally coming out of the dark ages. Mains electricity is going to revolutionise life here – as well as cut power bills substantially. I'm going to have an electricity party.

She went on: "All the parts of the new system are working, but they could not be synchronised in time for Christmas. But in the next couple of weeks, when the workmen return, we should be celebrating the arrival of mains electricity, and nobody will be more pleased than me."

The big switch-on comes just after the tenth anniversary of islanders buying Eigg.

The 87 people who live there have donated nearly £100,000 to the scheme.

Other funding has come from the European Union – through its regional development programme – the National Lottery and the Highlands and Islands Community Energy Company.

However, using green energy to give the neighbouring island of Muck mains electricity was hit by a series of disasters.

For much of last winter, its 35 residents had to do without electricity for five hours a day. Its 60ft high wind-turbine scheme was also broken for months.

But the people of Eigg, who have used their own diesel and small hydro-powered generators to provide energy for their homes, say they have learned from Muck's problems.

The aim of the Eigg project is to develop an electricity supply that is environmentally and economically sustainable.

At the heart of its scheme will be five wind turbines. The new "power station" will also incorporate solar-energy panels and three hydro-generation systems.

The grid will be supported by stand-by diesel generators and batteries, to guarantee continuous availability of power.

The Isle of Eigg Heritage Trust has formed a company, Eigg Electric Ltd, to operate the network, which will provide electricity for the island's 37 houses and ten businesses.

Marie Carr, a guesthouse owner who currently relies on a small hydro generator for power, said: "There is a slightly different timescale to life here. People don't have nine-to-five lives, and so we don't get the morning and evening surges of electricity use.

"At the moment, people don't have electric kettles or toasters because of the demand on electricity.

"It seems inevitable that people will get more electrical appliances once the supply is reliable and affordable. We still want to encourage energy efficiency, but we can't police people.

"We need an uninterrupted electricity supply for computers. Even television is a bit of a luxury – you can't always switch it on when you would like to. It might mean missing an episode of a soap. There are lots of things that you take for granted until you don't have them."

She went on: "The island shop has fridges and freezers to store food. Although we've now improved the electricity supply quite drastically with the hydro system, there have been times when the power has gone off overnight and the freezer has defrosted. Food has had to be thrown away.

"It is the same in people's houses. The supply run to the island is once a fortnight and in the winter, when the weather is bad, sometimes the boat doesn't come, so people rely on food stored in freezers."

Islanders bought Eigg from its German owner in a £1.5 million community buy-out in 1997.



The full article contains 681 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 30 December 2007 10:49 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 31/12/2007 01:01:05
I truly believe this is a backward step,
2

Iain fae Elgin,

London 31/12/2007 07:49:52
How do you work that one out Ross?

Would you rather they live in some in "Heilan idyll" so that tourists are still left with impression that scotland is all quaint and couthy?

If you do live there yourself you must be a right pain in the ars@.

If you don't, why don't you try having no guaranteed supply of 'leccy until, lets say, June. See if that's a step forward.



Ah, first day back at work after a long lay off....cynisism overdrive.. :)
3

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 31/12/2007 09:33:14
What a truly STUPID comment from Ross Fyffe, as usual.

Are the residents of Eigg to live in 18th century conditions forever.

I am heartened to see that "Eiggtricity" is green and may be a trend-setting harbinger of things to come throughout Scotland and the world.

Now MY comments are cogent and NOT stupid, Rossie baby.
4

Mikey,

31/12/2007 09:47:26
Good to see that the residents are taking care of their own future instead of waiting for something to happen.

Roos, you remind me of Keith Schellinger, wanting to keep the residents in the dark....
5

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 31/12/2007 10:11:37
Absolutely brilliant! Well done the Eiggmen and women. I had a look for the technical details and found them here:

http://www.windandsun.co.uk/projects_eigg.htm

It looks very professional; it will be interesting to see how it works out. This could become a pattern for other isolated communities.
6

MoragfraeEdinburgh,

Edinburgh 31/12/2007 10:37:59
All very laudable but reading the technical details methinks they will be relying on the backup generator most of the time. Apart from the £100,000 who paid for all this and how much does it work out for each of the 87 "residents" - none of whom are native to the island of course?
7

rural wifie,

Elgin 31/12/2007 10:56:01
for goodness sake, 90% of the population of Eigg have been using their own electricity generators for years, and all this talk of the dark ages - 50 years ago large parts of rural scotland did not have mains electricity, but they lived happy normal lives. You can get gas fridges, cookers, freezers, also oil fired cookers, fridges and freezers. Central heating can be by wood or peat or coal or oil, you can recharge your laptop or mobile phone using small solar cells. There are wind up radios and torches. All that is missing is TV and what loss is that. I have no doubt that Eigg residents will find mains electricity handy - but it is not essential.
8

Neil,

Glasgow 31/12/2007 11:17:04
So the subsidy is about £20,000 per head but it is "green". Indeed we can be sure that if it wasn't "green" it could have been done at a small fraction of the price except that politics would have assured no subsidy was available.

The killer is
"The grid will be supported by stand-by diesel generators and batteries, to guarantee continuous availability of power."

Had they just used diesel it would have cost slightly more than £100,000 & the locals couldn't have afforded it. This is therefore not a £1.4 million subsidy to Eigg it is a £100,000 subsidy to Eigg (of which I approve) & a £1.3 million subsidy to "greens" (of which I don't).
9

BK,

Cyberspace 31/12/2007 11:24:23
The big value of this is the example it sets - proving that it can be done. Admittedly on a small scale her, but the concept will grow.
10

Gothic Rose,

31/12/2007 11:27:55
Happy New Year,to all Residents of Eigg.As for the Wee Reactionaries,Here`s back to the cave and candles for you.Your bound to appreciate,the atmospheric aesthetics.
11

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 31/12/2007 11:40:16
8. Diesel stinks, is noisy and pollutes the atmosphere. They will only have to use it on the rare occasions when there is no sun, wind or water and the batteries are flat.
Subsidy is normal for renewables; it is the price we must pay to prevent the atmosphere from overheating and is peanuts compared to the environmental damage that will occur if we continue with 'business as usual'.
12

The Strategist,

31/12/2007 12:38:27
Neil #8 ... Actually a much smarter idea would be to have a small scale methanol plant and fuel the generators with that.. Use wind to power an electrolyser to produce the hydrogen and store that as methanol.

Anyway - I've been looking for some info on the hydro plant... Anyone found that?
13

Ard Righ,

The Rock Of Edinburgh 31/12/2007 12:56:39
Schoolboy technology wind mills with battery back up, which will need the battery arrays totally replaced every ten years(hugely unenvironmental) is daft.

Micro hydro generators are one of the most constant sources of power, needing only minor regulation. and rely on the water flow, which if you have been keeping an eye on which burns and streams run dry in a dry dry summer, simple, use those that don't run dry.

Ground source heating for homes is good.

Are those the panels that run off UV? is so, that is a good idea also as they run through the night,still cloud cover dependent, so essentially daft, again in Scotland.

14

Ard Righ,

The Rock Of Edinburgh 31/12/2007 12:59:04
The future

http://www.searlsolution.com/

You won't need any long distance wiring or stupid intermittent mechanical sources.

The future is magnetic.
15

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 31/12/2007 13:46:45
Hydrogen sucks:

http://www.fuelcellsworks.com/Supppage1834.html
16

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 31/12/2007 13:57:30
15. Or maybe not:

http://www.physorg.com/news87494382.html

but the efficiency is problematic...
17

Margaret L,

Edinburgh 31/12/2007 14:03:06
#9 A good example? At this cost it would be £90 thousand million to supply the whole of Scotland with a not very reliable source of power. Be serious.
18

fred bloggs,

Edinburgh 31/12/2007 14:13:03
Another interesting wind -> hydrogen -> electricity scheme at Utsira in Norway:

http://www.hydro.com/library/attachments/en/press_room/utsira_facts_inauguration_1july2004.pdf

14. Unfortunately, the 'Searle Solution' looks like a junk science investment con.
19

Benjamin,

31/12/2007 16:30:42
Ross #1, I've lived without electric power. It's NOT easy. I would suggest you try it before counting coming into the previous century technologically a step backwards.
20

Dave from Barra ©,

Western Isles 31/12/2007 18:43:30
"Eigg's newest resident, Saira Renny, whose cottage currently has bottled gas,"

And so shall she remain on bottled gas unless she buys a new cooker (from gas to electric) and re-wires her house to accomodate electric storage heating.

Yup, sound.
21

RedSwanie,

31/12/2007 19:00:30
What? No one cracks a joke about Muck? Whatzamadda yous?
22

The Fly Fifer,

Fife 31/12/2007 19:09:36
# 19 Hi good of you to ask if I had ever lived without leccy, but since you ask yes I did, for my formative years, and also some of my world travels were to places with no leccy.

Many's a night after some progress I have dropped to slumber as the Jenny ticked away to silence and in the morning to be awoken by it starting as my mother rose to begin the day.
23

vprice5612,

31/12/2007 20:21:48
It's at the very least, a good start. There are some kinks in it, though at least theyre willing to make the effort, and be an example to others. As they have learned from the problems/failures of Muck, others will learn from those of Eigg - and so forth. We have to start somewhere.
24

Canmac,

Haney 31/12/2007 21:44:12
As a wanderer of the Hebrides for many years, it gives me the gretaest of pleasure to see the Islands being made more liveable for the Islanders. Well done Eigg, one of my favourite Isles. JBH

 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.