Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

The hunt is On.
Sponsored by
The hunt is On.
Can you track down Scotland's wildest beastie?
 
 
Thursday, 4th December 2008 Change Date

The Scotsman Digital Archive - Special Christmas Offer

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Sign In
Register

Royal National Mod: Freeview campaign hots up



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 October 2008
By Murray MacLeod
A CRUCIAL meeting takes place today at the 2008 Royal National Mod in a bid to expand the coverage by the new Gaelic digital channel, BBC Alba.
The £14 million service, launched in August as a partnership between BBC Scotland and fund holders MG Alba, is at present only available through a Sky subscription or on Freesat.

However, many households in the Highlands and Islands rely on the F
reeview network, meaning many Gaels are unable to access the new publicly-funded service set up on their behalf.

Despite sanctioning the launch of the new channel, the BBC Trust board of governors refused to make it available on Freeview on the grounds that it would need time to prove its long-term worth by attracting a wider audience in the Scottish community.

MG Alba chairman, Alasdair Morrison, will meet Jeremy Peat, the BBC Trust representative, in Falkirk today for talks on extending distribution.

"I'll bring him up to date on the positive reaction to the new channel and also the dismay that it's not available on Freeview," he said. "Clearly it's easier to make the case to secure Freeview now the channel is up and running."

Allan Campbell, who was at the forefront of many Gaelic initiatives before retiring as chief executive of the national development agency, Bord na Gaidhlig, two years ago, said:

"It seems perverse that this long-awaited service is being denied to a substantial proportion of the potential audience."

Both Western Isles Council and Highland Council have also officially joined the Freeview campaign.

FULL RESULTS - WEDNESDAY


A220 Solo - Ladies (Fluent) Singing of a prescribed song

Qualifying Competition for Gold Medal
1st The Mary C MacNiven Memorial Salver
£5 (James Grant Memorial Fund)
Kerrie Finlay, Inverness.
2nd Eilidh J Davies, Invergarry.
3rd equal Ceitidh Smith, Kyle of Lochalsh.
Satunum McElroy, Crosslee.


A221 Solo - Men (Fluent) Singing of a prescribed song

Qualifying Competition for Gold Medal
1st The Caledonian MacBrayne Trophy
£5 (Lachlan Maclean Watt Memorial Prize)
John Boa, Edinburgh.
2nd Lyle Kennedy, Stirlinghsire.
3rd John Howieson, Portree.
4th equal Eòghann Alasdair Pinkerton, London.
Alastair Gray, Caithness.

The John MacArthur Memorial Trophy for the highest mark in A220 and A221 was awarded to
Kerrie Finlay, Inverness and John Boa, Edinburgh.


A222 Oran Mòr - Ladies(Fluent) Singing of a prescribed song

Qualifying Competition for Gold Medal

1st The Mr and Mrs Archibald MacDonald Memorial Trophy
£10 (Jessie M MacLachlan Memorial Prize)
Kerrie Finlay, Inverness.
2nd £5 (Jessie M MacLachlan Memorial Prize)
Ceitidh Smith, Kyle of Lochalsh.
3rd Sìneag MacIntyre, South Uist.
4th Joy Dunlop, Connel.


A223 Oran Mòr - Mens (Fluent) Singing of a prescribed song

Qualifying Competition for Gold Medal

1st The F S Cameron-Head Memorial Trophy
£10 ( John A MacRae, Glasgow)
Lyle Kennedy, Stirlinghsire.
2nd £5 (Bessie Campbell Memorial Fund)
John Howieson, Portree.
3rd John Boa, Edinburgh.
4th Sandy Mollison, Blairgowrie.


A233 Puirt-a-beul (Fluent) Singing of own choice

1st The Duncan Johnston Memorial Trophy
£10 (John A MacRae, Glasgow)
Darren MacLean, Isle of Skye.
2nd Sandy NicDhòmhnaill Jones, Lunnainn agus Uibhist a Deas.
3rd equal Nicola Pearson, Carnoustie.
Joy Dunlop, Connel.


A234 Solo Singing(Fluent) Prescribed song by Lorn Bard

1st The 'Oban Times' Gold Medal
F Ann MacLean, North Connel.
2nd Brus Caimbeul, Crieff.
3rd John Howieson, Portree.


A248 Solo Singing(Learners) Sing a song in traditional style.

1st The George Clavey Memorial Quaich
Nicola Pearson, Carnoustie.
2nd Catriona Watt, Glasgow.
3rd Linn Phipps, Isle of Lewis.


A250 Solo Singing - Ladies(Learners) Singing of a prescribed song

Qualifying Competition for Silver Pendant

1st The Margot Campbell Trophy
Kirsten Laurie, Isle of Islay.
2nd Linn Phipps, Isle of Lewis.
3rd Jackie Cotter, Edinburgh.
4th equal Ellen L Beard, USA.
Rena Gertz, Edinburgh.


A251 Solo Singing - Men(Learners) Singing of a prescribed song

Qualifying Competition for Silver Pendant

1st The Katie Stewart Memorial Trophy
£20 (Alasdair C Gillies Memorial Prize)
Donald R MacIver, Poolewe.
2nd Iain Gordon, Nairn.
3rd Stuart Jackson, Argyll.
4th Donald A MacLeod, Edinburgh.


A252 Solo Singing - Ladies(Learners) Singing a working song - own choice

Qualifying Competition for Silver Pendant

1st The Catherine M B Dunlop Quaich
£25 (Doctor Sandey Luciano)
Linn Phipps, Isle of Lewis.
2nd £15 (Doctor Sandey Luciano)
Kirsten Laurie, Isle of Islay.
3rd £10(Doctor Sandey Luciano)
Ellen L Beard, USA.
4th Sandra Kennedy, St Andrews.


A253 Solo Singing - Men(Learners) Singing a sea song - own choice

Qualifying Competition for Silver Pendant

1st The Bank of Scotland Cup
£25 (Doctor Sandey Luciano)
Donald R MacIver, Poolewe.
2nd £15 (Doctor Sandey Luciano)
Raghnall MacAoidh, Australia.
3rd £10(Doctor Sandey Luciano)
Stuart Jackson, Argyll.
4th Iain Gordon, Nairn.


A270 Solo Singing (Open) Song from 'Songs of the Hebrides'

1st The Kennedy-Fraser Cup
The Johanna Fortune Memorial Trophy
£20 (An Comunn Gàidhealach)
Celia MacDougall, Caithness.
2nd £20 (An Comunn Gàidhealach)
Jackie Cotter, Edinburgh.
3rd Allan Bremner, Oldmeldrum.


A271 Solo Singing Singing of a prescribed song

1st The Sarah Weir Memorial Trophy
£20 (Mull and Iona Association)
Emma AC Deans, Comar nan Allt.
2nd £15 (Mull and Iona Association)
Jennifer Speirs, Isle of Lewis.
3rd Elizabeth Campbell.


A272 Solo Singing Singing of a prescribed song

1st Lochewe Branch Cup
Emma AC Deans, Comar nan Allt.
2nd John Howieson, Portree.
3rd Brian Owen, Perthshire.


A273 Precenting a Psalm Precent in a traditional manner

1st The Dr Alistair Patrick Barden Memorial Salver
£50 (Gaelic Society of The Episcopal Church)
Ailean Dòmhnullach, Inbhir Nis...


A274 Solo Singing Sing a Skye or Sutherland Song

1st The John D Gillies Memorial Trophy
Alison Campbell, Erskine.
2nd Nicola Pearson, Carnoustie.
3rd Gordon McKeeve, Glasgow.


A275 Duet Singing Own Choice

1st The Neil MacLean and Jenny MB Curry Trophy.
£10 (Mull Local Mòd)
Emma AC Deans & Rachael MJ Deans, Comar nan Allt.
2nd £6 (Mull Local Mòd)
Wilma Kennedy & Nicola Pearson, Broughty Ferry.
3rd £4 (Mull Local Mòd)
Doreen Smith & Elizabeth Campbell, Glasgow.


B320 Clarsach (Junior) Solo singing - self accompaniment

1st The Glendale Quaich
Gold Badge
Mischa MacPherson, Sgoil Mhic Neacail.
2nd Silver Badge
Calum MacLeod, City of Edinburgh Music School.
3rd Bronze Badge
Màiri Chaimbeul, St Mary's Music School.


B321 Clarsach - Introductory (Junior) One piece of Gaelic music - own choice

1st The Helmsdale Trophy
Gold Badge
Anna MacKenzie, Bun-sgoil Crois na Cìse.
2nd Silver Badge
Lewis Chan, Bun-sgoil Crois na Cìse.
3rd Bronze Badge
Ciorstaidh-Sarah Chaimbeul, Bun-sgoil Shlèite.


B322 Clarsach - Elementary (Junior) One prescribed and one own choice

1st The Florence Wilson Trophy
Gold Badge
Brìghde Chaimbeul, Bun-sgoil Shlèite.
2nd Silver Badge
Daisy Nash, Sgoil MhicNeacail.
3rd Bronze Badge
Zoe MacKay, Bun-sgoil Ealaghoil.


B323 Clarsach - Intermediate (Junior) One prescribed and one own choice

1st The K Barry Milner Trophy
Gold Badge
Màiri-Louise MacDonald, Àrd-sgoil Phort Rìgh.
2nd Silver Badge
Ada Francis, Edinburgh.
3rd Bronze Badge
Elinor Evans, Edinburgh..


B324 Clarsach - Advanced(Junior) One prescribed and one own choice

1st The Duncan Chisholm Trophy
£10 (Catherine L MacDonald Memorial Fund)
Gold Badge
2nd £5 (Catherine L MacDonald Memorial Fund)
Silver Badge
3rd Bronze Badge


B326 Clarsach - Advanced One prescribed and one own choice

1st The Elspeth A Hyllsted Trophy
Janette Bain, Clackmannanshire..


B328 Clarsach - Accompanying Accompanying of a singer

1st Jean C Campbell Memorial Trophy
Gold Badge
Màiri Chaimbeul, St Mary's Music School.
2nd Silver Badge
Calum MacLeod, City of Edinburgh Music School.
3rd Bronze Badge
Elinor Nicholson, Hamilton College.


B329 Clarsach - Composition Original composition reflecting the idiom of Gaelic music

1st The Margaret Balfour Trophy
Calum MacLeod, City of Edinburgh Music School.
2nd Daisy Nash, Sgoil MhicNeacail.


B330 Clarsach Duets (U13) Music of Gaelic origin - own choice

1st The Lord Birsay Trophy
Gold Badge
Blair Hendy & Fraser Munro, Bun-sgoil Innis an Uillt.
2nd Silver Badge
Ciorstaidh-Sarah Chaimbeul & Brìghde Chaimbeul, Bun-sgoil Shlèite.
3rd Bronze Badge
Aimee Clark & Moilidh NicGriogair, Sgoil Ghàidhlig Ghlaschu.


B330A Clarsach Duets (Junior 13 - 19) Music of Gaelic origin - own choice

1st Comunn na Clarsaich Cup
Gold Badge
Calum MacLeod & Chloe Young, City of Edinburgh Music School.
2nd Silver Badge
Steaphanaidh Chaimbeul & Màiri Chaimbeul, Isle of Skye.
3rd Bronze Badge
Helen Smith & Karen Pollard, Kirkcudbright.


B331 Clarsach - Ensemble Three or more Clarsach - own choice

1st The Pilgrims Harp Trophy
Clàrsaichean DiSathairne.


B332 Additional Class(Junior) Restricted to previous winners of B324

1st The Sir Philip Christison Trophy
Gold Badge
Màiri Chaimbeul, St Mary's Music School.
2nd Silver Badge
Calum MacLeod, City of Edinburgh Music School.


B333 Clarsach Duet Music of Gaelic Origin

1st The Drumelzier Quaich
Janette Bain & Meg Carroll, Clackmannanshire.


B336 Clarsach Duo (Junior) Music of Gaelic origin - own choice

1st Comunn na Clarsaich (Edinburgh Branch) Trophy
Gold Badge
Steaphanaidh Chaimbeul & Màiri Chaimbeul, Isle of Skye.
2nd Silver Badge
Karen Pollard & Callum MacLeod, Lockerbie.
3rd Bronze Badge
Eilidh Munro & Heather Kindness, Glasgow Islay Junior Gaelic Choir..


SS254 Silver Pendant Sing two songs - one prescribed, one own choice

SILVER PENDANT WINNERS

Ladies
1st Silver Pendant
£50 (An Comunn Gàidhealach)
£10 (Charles Campbell MBE Memorial Prize)
2nd £25 (An Comunn Gàidhealach)
£5 (Charles Campbell MBE Memorial Prize)
3rd £15 (An Comunn Gàidhealach)

Men

1st Silver Pendant
£50 (An Comunn Gàidhealach)
£10 (Charles Campbell MBE Memorial Prize)
2nd £25 (An Comunn Gàidhealach)
£5 (Charles Campbell MBE Memorial Prize)
3rd £15 (An Comunn Gàidhealach)
4th


The Morag Robb Memorial Silver Salver for the highest marks in Gaelic in A250, A251, A252, A253 and SS254 was awarded to
..

The John A MacRae Quaich for the highest aggregate marks in music for competitions A250, A251, A252, A253 and SS254 was awarded to
..

DRAMA

Premier Award
West Highland Free Press Quaich
..
Best Producer
Susan B MacDonald Memorial Trophy
..
Best Stage
Presentation Strathspey Highland Malt Whisky Trophy
..
Best Actress
Dr Lynn Hagman Memorial Trophy
..
Best Actor
Dr Lynn Hagman Memorial Trophy
..
Best Original
Gaelic Play of the Year Badenoch Shield
..
Best Acted Play
Art MacLeod Memorial Trophy



The full article contains 1664 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 October 2008 10:09 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Royal National Mod
 
1

Fifi la Bonbon,

16/10/2008 01:20:39
Why can't we get BBC Alba programmes, that we pay for, on the BBC website? We can get eight other channels but not this one.
2

Guga II,

Rockall 16/10/2008 06:53:34
"the BBC Trust board of governors refused to make it available on Freeview on the grounds that it would need time to prove its long-term worth by attracting a wider audience in the Scottish community."

How, exactly, is the channel expected to attract a wider audience when the majority of people cannot receive it? Are the EBC Trust Board getting a kick-back from Sky and the cable companies?

In any event, there is an existing Gaelic channel on Freeview, but it only broadcasts for half an hour a day. Why can't they put BBC Alba on this channel?

This Catch 22 attitude of the EBC implies that they are out to destroy the channel before it can get started.

The EBC are already stealing the iniquitous television tax from us, though only a very small percentage of the money stolen from Scotland is actually spent in Scotland.

It's time that this iniquitous tax was scrapped, and that the control of broadcasting in Scotland was given to the Scottish people. We need to be free of the colonial control of the EBC, most of whom probably wouldn't even be able to find Scotland on a map.

The colonial attitude of the EBC can be seen the way they use reporters from England to report on a story in Scotland for their main news, despite the fact that the same story is covered on Reporting Scotland by a Scottish reporter.

They even had a story on the effects of the credit crunch in Aberdeen on their main news the other day. Yes, you guessed it, they had an English reporter interviewing an English woman living in Aberdeen.

Everyone in Scotland should refuse to pay the iniquitous television tax to the EBC, and bring down this vestige of English colonialism.
3

WL,

livingston 16/10/2008 09:25:38
BBC Alba should be available free for everyone in Scotland. In Ireland the RTE gaelic TV channel is in the basic package sothat everyone can get it. Should be the same here.
Why can we get coverage of the Mod on BBC2 only for one hour a day from 23:20 to 00:20 at night - who can watch it then ???
4

radge dug,

Dùn Eideann 16/10/2008 09:51:55
BBC Alba air Freeview sa bhad!

What a waste of money to make this service only available to a couple of hundred thousand Scots. The audience must be tiny. How can the BBC and London Labour controlled broadcasting say that this is value for money??!!
5

George MacLean,

Islington, London 16/10/2008 10:42:17
And what about us exiles who only have cable tv? We cannot see it at all! There are lots of gaelic speakers and interested learners in England who would like the opportunity to view I am sure.
6

St Andrew,

Edinburgh 16/10/2008 11:50:58
Count yourselves lucky that you are not exposed to the most boring competition on earth.
7

John1988,

Lochgilphead 16/10/2008 12:05:08
bias ebc..

it doesnt take much to work out somethings wrong here, the budget is tiny..

and im sure putting it on freeview would tripple the viewing figures without trippling the cost how can this not be value for money as opposed to it only being on sky??
8

John1988,

Lochgilphead 16/10/2008 13:48:32
is this a conspiricy or just another mess up by westminster .

either way the only way forward is for hollyrood to have power over scottish broadcasting.
9

Calum Crubag,

Alba 16/10/2008 18:13:06
Heard some singing on Radio nan Gaidheal at lunchtime. It was absymal! Tuneless, old-fashioned and boring. Bha e direach sgriosail!

Lets hope BBC Alba can ditch the auld cac and give us something more exciting.

10

John1988,

Lochgilphead 16/10/2008 21:12:07
#9

i completly agree with you, gaelic programming should be as modern as the programs on other channels or radio stations.
11

WL,

livingston 17/10/2008 17:04:34
#10
If you want modern music on BBC Scotland or BBC Alba that is fine. No one will disagree with you. But there is a lot of rubbish modern music.
There must also be space for classical and traditional music for those who want it.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
RSS Feed of this article's comments
Delivery formats: RSS, Atom, Javascript & Email
 
  

 
 

More Scotland

More Scotland >>

More Royal National Mod

More Royal National Mod >>

Features

Online Supplements
Scotsman Digital Archive

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.