Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Scientists say they've solved riddle of the shrinking Soay sheep

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 July 2009
CLIMATE change is being blamed for shrinking an ancient herd of island sheep.
Scientists have been studying the evolution of Soay sheep in the Outer Hebrides for more than quarter of a century and believe milder winters have changed their size, trumping natural selection.

The findings are said to be the first evidence that
climate change could have an impact on animal evolution and ecology.

The mysterious decrease in the size of Soay sheep on the island of Hirta in the remote St Kilda archipelago was first reported by scientists in 2007.

A follow-up analysis suggests conditions are becoming less challenging as the planet heats up – meaning slower-growing, smaller sheep are more likely to survive the winters than they once were.

This, together with the phenomenon called "young-mum effect", where young ewes produce smaller offspring, explains why average body size among island sheep has fallen by about 5 per cent over the past 25 years.

The sheep have been studied closely since 1985. The researchers plugged their data into a numerical model that predicts how a trait such as body size will change over time due to natural selection and other factors that influence survival and reproduction in the wild.

The principal investigator, Professor Tim Coulson, of Imperial College London, said: "Sheep are getting smaller. Well, at least the wild Soay sheep living on a remote Scottish island are. But according to classic evolutionary theory, they should have been getting bigger, because larger sheep tend to be more likely to survive and reproduce than smaller ones, and offspring tend to resemble their parents."

He added: "In the past, only the big, healthy sheep and large lambs that had piled on weight in their first summer could survive the harsh winters on Hirta.

"But now, due to climate change, grass for food is available for more months of the year, and survival conditions are not so challenging – even the slower-growing sheep have a chance of making it, and this means smaller individuals are becoming increasingly prevalent in the population."

Prof Coulson suggests milder winters, caused by global climate change, mean that lambs do not need to put on as much as weight in the first months of life to survive to their first birthday as they did when winters were colder.

In addition, the research team discovered that the age at which a female sheep gives birth affects the size of her offspring. They realised that young Soay ewes are physically unable to produce offspring that are as big as they themselves were at birth.

This "young-mum effect" had not been incorporated into previous analyses of natural selection, which explains in part why the sheep of Hirta are defying biologists' expectations.

The study was released yesterday by Science, published by AAAS, the non-profit, international science society.

Andrew Sugden, deputy and international managing editor at Science, said: "This study addresses one of the major goals of population biology, namely to untangle the ways in which evolutionary and environmental changes influence a species' traits."

The researchers looked at data recorded since 1985, analysing sheep population sizes and body measurements, along with life history events, which times key milestones throughout an individual sheep's life.

A BREED APART

THE Soay sheep are closely related to the wild sheep originally domesticated by man. They run wild on the island, which was abandoned in the 1930s after 2,000 to 3,000 years of occupation.

No-one knows quite when the sheep arrived on St Kilda, but evidence suggests they came with the first human settlers about 4,000 years ago. When the Norse arrived at the St Kilda archipelago in the 9th-10th centuries AD they named the island Sauda-ey – "Island of sheep".

Until 1932, pure-bred Soays were only found on the island of Soay, then a flock of 107 were rounded up and moved on to the main island of Hirta.

Today, unmanaged populations of Soays live on both Soay and Hirta, where their population fluctuations have interested biologists since the 1950s.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 July 2009 9:51 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

,

03/07/2009 02:14:20
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Tatties ower the side,

Johannesburg 03/07/2009 04:14:47
What a wonderfully convenient issue Global Warming is. Faced with almost anything unexplained, you can get some dorf in the Scotsman to write about it if you claim it is cause by Global Warming.
3

donald,

glasgow 03/07/2009 06:05:41
Does that explain the young mum syndrome in oor housing schemes?
4

Honest Opinion 2,

Froggyland 03/07/2009 06:49:33
Bah! what a wooly-headed yarn to ge tup to this mornin'
5

Andrew Morton,

Berkshire 03/07/2009 07:52:53
In the past, these sheep were managed by the resident population and selectively bred for size i.e. only the big and virile were bred.

Naturally, without that management, they have reverted to type. Additionally, the residents would ensure some sort of fodder supply during the winters so at the very least, they were maintained.

I should hope these scientists have spoken to livestock farmers and other livestock breeders to gain an insight.

Evidence may suggest that if the winters are becoming less harsh, the sheep don't have to use so much of their own body reserves. The last time there was a period of warm climate, dinosaurs roamed the earth and from what I can gather, they were quite big.
6

fresian,

03/07/2009 08:20:34
Mary had a little lamb,
Its fleece was white and wispy,
Her farm got hit by foot and mouth,
And now it's black and crispy
7

fresian,

03/07/2009 08:22:06
donald, the worst case of that I ever saw, was a banner fixed to railings saying "Happy 30th Birthday Grandma!"
8

Unimpressed one,

03/07/2009 09:27:30
Climate change is responsible for everything under the sun now except better weather.
9

Andrah,

Embrugh 03/07/2009 09:32:11
#2 "What a wonderfully convenient issue Global Warming is"

I agree. It is also a rewarding one. Presumably these days if you insert the words "climate change" (or "gw") into an article you qualify for the huge sums of government/EU money now on offer to brainwash us with this nonsense. Also it ensures that a media researcher, (especially the BBC), will pick up your item on Google and provide the further dividend of massively enhanced publicity.

It would seem to me that without applying any science at all, in the 50+ years I have been a conscious individual on this planet, that humans have on average got significantly bigger?
10

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 03/07/2009 11:34:32
Notice that this reasearch uses a computer model?

"The researchers plugged their data into a numerical model that predicts how a trait such as body size will change over time due to natural selection and other factors that influence survival and reproduction in the wild."

Now, let me think, where have I heard that before?
11

Rob Royston,

Bishopbriggs 03/07/2009 11:49:50
#5 Andrew Morton,

I was just scrolling down to give the explanation when I read your post and saw you had already done it.

You can be quite sure that the scientists did not speak to anyone who has ever bred sheep. That would have been an end to this particular gravy train.
12

Rob Royston,

03/07/2009 11:56:09
Seeing as it's sheep, have they made a mint from this gravy train.
13

Geomac 1,

Scotland 03/07/2009 13:33:36
Boy - doesn't this climate change get everywhere - is there anything that can't be blamed on CC?
14

Saoghal Beag,

03/07/2009 13:47:46
Species adapt to changes in their environment, that was news over 200 years ago?
15

Unimpressed one,

03/07/2009 13:56:41
Mary had a little lamb,
She also had a duck,
She put them on her mantleplace,
To see if they would....get friendly.
16

El Franko,

03/07/2009 13:59:06
Fooled by fluctuations is what I'd guess. Yet another professor without the brains he was born with.
17

El Franko,

03/07/2009 14:02:04
Plus the theory of #5 seems more plausible than the professor's. But you can sense his excitement - positing a link with global warming means plenty of chances to publish, get mass media coverage, and further grants. More shame is this spread over the groves of academe. They will look like one complete dungheap before long.
18

danbob,

03/07/2009 14:13:47
Slowly but surly the reputations of scientists are bleeding to death. There was a time when everybody hung on to every word they muttered. Not anymore.
19

nabodican,

Newton Stewart 03/07/2009 14:44:10
Pass the mint sauce ! or has that gone with "global warming"
These scientists are a bit like some of the baby engineers we get these days, they can tell you 19 different ways to work out the square root of a biscuit tin but could could not tell you how to open it.
20

cowan,

03/07/2009 20:05:39
Andrew Morton,
The Soay sheep were not introduced to the island of Hirta until after the evacuation. This breed were never managed by the islanders pre 1930.

They have been subject to investigation and experimentation by scientists. Arguably the presence of a few cattle on the island would be better for the vegetation and for cause less damage to the structures.
21

Shellfishfarmer,

Inverness 03/07/2009 21:40:25
I know for a fact that the Soay sheep have been researched since the fifties, not 1985. I used to work with one of the animal nutritionists. His name was Graham Gunn.

As to the conclusions reached on climate warming, I always thought that Mendelian genetics within a closed breeding system such as Hirta meant more expression of recessive genes. It is quite likely that body size may be an indication of this factor - more plausible than climate warming.
22

Rob Royston,

Bishopbriggs 04/07/2009 00:36:17
20 cowan, I'm sure if the sheep were on the adjacent island they would have been husbanded by someone.
23

Andrew Morton,

Berkshire 10/07/2009 08:54:34
20 cowan

I don't think so my good chum.

http://www.kilda.org.uk/soay-sheep.htm

Nice try though. Nearly got the scientist off the hook.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.