Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Opera makes overtures to new generation



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
18 June 2007
WHEN Welsh singing diva Katherine Jenkins replaced the traditional 20-stone heroine and G4 stormed the charts, suddenly opera seemed sexy. Now it appears opera is the new rock and roll - with tickets sales to younger audiences in Scotland up sevenfold this season.
More than 700 people under 26 came to the recent run of Madama Butterfly, Puccini's classic opera, in Glasgow, Scottish Opera revealed yesterday. That was up on just 100 a year ago.

And the same pattern of a surprisingly young turn-out is showing in Edinburgh, where both Puccini's Madama Butterfly and Donizetti's Lucia di Lammermoor are on stage this week.

Opera has often suffered in Britain from the perception it is an artform for a wealthy elite - and that its audience is growing older and older.

But the company has been aggressively marketing the £10 tickets for the under-26 group it introduced last year. In Glasgow, it took out adverts on the underground for the first time, and in both cities it targeted the student population.

"If we don't attract the young audiences now, where are we gong to be in ten years?" a spokeswoman said. "They are cheaper than going to a gig."

A recent experiment at the Cameo cinema has underlined the appetite for opera. Two operas were beamed live to the Edinburgh screen from the New York Metropolitan Opera, one of the world's finest.

"They were incredibly successful and it brought in a completely different market," said Lynn Morrison, the cinema's business manager.

People taking their seats in the Cameo watched people in New York doing the same at the afternoon performance.

"We were getting people who had daughters in America who were watching it live at the same time as they were watching it in Edinburgh," Ms Morrison said.

Scottish Opera is earning some enthusiastic reviews two years after a debt crisis - the latest of several - saw it lay off its full-time chorus along with other staff.

In Edinburgh and Glasgow, the company's marketing campaign has stressed that the £10 tickets are bookable in advance for any ticket in the house.

The £10 under-26 ticket scheme was launched last season but has taken off this year, with Glasgow sales rising from just 100 to 700.

"It's about accessibility, making people able to come to the opera, and attracting a younger audience," the Scottish Opera spokeswoman said.

"We are delighted with the results. You'll notice a lot of young people in the audience. It balances out because we sell £10 tickets on the day anyway. The benefit of getting young people through the doors is that it adds to the atmosphere, and we have to be accessible. We have to open doors and we want people to come and hear these wonderful stories."

The opera has already beaten its financial targets for ticket sales.

AN ISSUE OF IMAGE

SARAH McNeil, 17, is everything Scottish Opera hopes for the future. The East Renfrewshire school pupil went to her first opera, Madama Butterfly, with her mother.

"I thought everyone would be really stuck-up, but everyone was really nice," she said afterwards. "It was so emotional... me and my mum came home humming all the tunes."

Scottish Opera has used a "before and after" interview with Sarah as part of the promotion for its productions, ranging from ordinary opera-goers to celebrities like the actor Tam Dean Burn.

"It wasn't what I expected, it wasn't as formal as I thought, it was much more relaxed," she said. "All day at school I was really excited and everyone wanted to come too. I told them I loved it all and they are all going to try and come now."

But the struggle opera still faces with young people was described by Edinburgh University medical student Amreet Battu, 21.

She has studied music at an advanced level and travelled to London last weekend to see the Benjamn Britten opera, Death in Venice. She had not heard of Scottish Opera's £10 tickets.

"I'm not sure if young people were ever really that into opera. None of my friends at University are into it," she said.

"I guess people probably think it's boring, or doesn't speak to them.

The full article contains 708 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 17 June 2007 8:44 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Arts , Scottish Opera
 
1

Paul Voltaire,

18/06/2007 05:17:14

Even Pol Pot is making a comeback singing opera, for heaven's sake!
I remember him when he was a mass murderer.

2

Boy Wonder,

18/06/2007 05:54:44

#1. I made that connection too! But you just beat me to the punch! :(

3

Paul Voltaire,

18/06/2007 06:14:35

#2
He He.
You nedd to be up early etc.......
Boom ! Boom!

4

Steve Evans,

Malta 18/06/2007 06:16:14

With the looks of Katherine, it makes one proud to be Welsh a great lassie.

5

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Erewhon 18/06/2007 07:04:16

Music people actually keep quiet and listen to!

Words people can actually hear and understand!

Audiences that are sweet smelling, drug-free and polite to one another!

Performers who have actually studied music and are real musicians!

Opera'll never catch on.

6

Yane,

Melbourne 18/06/2007 07:16:11

#5 You should hear the Hilltop Hoods playing with the Adelaide Symphony Orchestra!

7

Heidegger,

Beyreuth 18/06/2007 07:19:21

Madam Butterfly is tawdry trash & any
opera company caught performing it should
be immediately shut down.

8

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Erewhon 18/06/2007 07:38:48

#6 Adelaide doesn't have a symphony orchestra. It doesn't even have a decent cricket pitch. Nor does it serve ale at room temperature. As for those Hoods, I'm sure their mums are proud of them.

9

The Sheriff of Nottingham,

18/06/2007 08:43:51

#5 "Words people can actually hear and understand!" yeh, if you're Italian!

10

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Erewhon 18/06/2007 08:55:53

#9. I'm not Italian, but I have learned enough to enjoy opera in that language. One has to work at things sometimes to gain real benefit. I enjoyed the Beijing Opera although I didn't understand a word, however. The thing was the audience allowed one to listen!

I am British, but I rarely catch a word of any song in a pop concert, regardless of the language.

11

Florestan,

Aachen 18/06/2007 09:16:14

#5

"Performers who have actually studied music and are real musicians"

Do pop musicians actually practice their instruments? You never actually hear any of them discuss this side of their work. Classical and jazz musicians put in hours of individual practice, day after day, in order to remain at the top of their abilities. Yet the pampered, over-indulged rock "musos" just seem to swan from one drugs and drink binge to another, being lauded by idiot media types. When do they practice? And does it matter if they don't?

12

AlecJ,

18/06/2007 10:04:25

Kathrine Jenkins has a beautiful voice which is still maturing. When it does, in about 5 years time, I understand she plans to become an opera singer. In the meantime, she needs to eat and pay for her tuition, just like a lot of the buskers that can be seen on our streets. It's just the location of her busking that attracts attention.

13

Glenn,

Dorset 18/06/2007 10:15:26

What's wrong with keeping something viewed by the ignorant as "stuffy".

Why does it have to suddenly be "sexy" rather than just as it always has been..."beautiful"?

There are some "death metal" bands out there...why don't they adapt themselves too and start prancing around with daisies in their hair, dressed in Edwardian costume on beds of rose petals to appeal to an older audience? Utterly rediculous.

Opera is what opera is...that is what its appeal is and it should not be tampered with to give a "new improved formula", we all know what happens with those, they become tasteless.

14

Yane,

Melbourne 18/06/2007 11:47:08

#8 Pour yersel a glass o warm beer an look it up ...

15

andrewt,

inverness 18/06/2007 13:58:34

what a voice , what a body , what a looker, that girl has it all.---and she seems a very nice person, good luck for the future Katherine !!!

16

andrewt,

inverness 18/06/2007 14:03:47

PDT --who wrote to you on 18th June is just jealous, I bet the two opera singers in that family dont look or sound like the gorgeous Katherine ,who could !!!

17

Paul S.,

Mauricetown, NJ, USA 18/06/2007 14:19:48

Listening to Italian nowadays should be no problem if the production used super-titles. Few don't nowadays. Certainly any broadcast from the Met had the Met-titles which are in front of every seat in the house. Very effective.

As for Butterfly: I'm not sure it's a great one for the kids, though I guess there is enough of lying men, naive and idealistic women and betrayal to go around on TV. Unfortunately, as too often happens in Puccini, the scenes I really want to see are not there. Leave it to Verdi to show the crucial confrontations!

Hoever, for those wanting the best entry-level opera (like if you've never been to one before), Puccini's Tosca is the show to see. It has a very direct plot with all the confrontations in place, spectacle, murder, suicide, politics (pro-Bonaparte!), and really great music. I conducted Tosca about 10 years ago, and it was a ball to make that on happen.

If you have the titles and don't mind a good sit, my favorite is Wagner's Die Meistersinger. Conducting even part of Act III a couple of summers ago was a thrill.

Even though I conducted it, I'm not all that fond of Carmen unless it is very well stage directed, making some sense out of the title character, which means defining her world very specifically.

I also conducted Il Trovatore —dim story, fine music — then I went on to conducting ballet and music reviewing for a large metropolitan daily.

Were someone able to grant my opera conducting wish, I would have to flip a coin between doing Mozart's Don Giovanni or Verdi's Don Carlos. Perhaps the mix of politics, human rights issues, and the Inquisition would tip the scale toward Don Carols.

18

pollyanna,

Perthshire 18/06/2007 14:30:11

#11. I think a lot of rock musicians will be up in arms following your comment. My 17 year old nephew in Nottingham has had classical piano and clarinet lessons from a very young age and has gained passes in all the grades. From age 11 he became interested in different types of music and learnt guitar and drums. He has formed a rock band with some gifted friends and writes, plays and records their music. He saves hard to buy equipment, performing and teaching drumming lessons after school. After the summer hols he goes to college to study music technology before applying to Royal Acadamy of music. My sisters house positively leaps with his music from a specially soundproofed cellar where he spends a huge amount of time practising. Sometimes I dont like his music but the effort, skill and enthusiasm has to be commended and I don't think drug taking even gets a look in.

19

Paul S.,

Mauricetown, NJ, USA 18/06/2007 14:32:15

By the way, never heard of Katherine Jenkins over here, but 20 stone singers are not necessary. They just have to find something else to use as the leverage to supply diphragm support. Some singers, while stocky, are not fat. It takes major muscle power to pump out all that sound, and some singers have those muscles understandably in their midriff area with barely an ounce of fat. But those flabby singers who can barely move on a stage have no excuse except self-indulgence and lack of discipline.

Years ago I watched on such soprano doing Brünnhilde in Die Walküre who in the final scene had to drop to her knees (well, she just sort of flopped over) and, in spite of stage directions to the contrary, never move from the spot until, presumably after the curtain. Simon Estes, the Wotan, had to do all the stage movement. Thank God he's really good. That was at the Met. I'm not sure someone like that woman would be hired there nowadays. Deborah Voight took off the pounds and still sound fabulous. It's strengthening and adjusting vocal technique while losing weight that counts, not keeping an indulgent appearance.

20

Torrance,

RIBBLE VALLEY 18/06/2007 14:43:16

11.Florestan I trust you do not include Paul Macartney as a pampered ,overindulged rock muso.His recoprding of Mull of Kintyre with the group Wings, came no.1 in the charts in 1977 and was not surpassed until 1984.
His love of more serious music can be found in his composition "Liverpool Oratorio" which was first played by the Royal Liverpool Philarmonic Orchestra, and also in his symphonic poem "Standing Stone" which has been released on C.D. by the Israeli Symphony Orcgestra.
13. Alec I agree with you, she will make opera more popular with the masses than any 20 stone opera singer

21

Pomona man,

18/06/2007 14:46:36

At the Vienna State Opera, there is an LCD strip screen on the back of the seat infront which scrolls subtitles in a selectable language of the audience member's choice. I'm sure many others must do the same.

22

Torrance,

RIBBLE VALLEY 18/06/2007 14:47:25

19. Paul. S., re your first comment. You will.

23

Paul S.,

Mauricetown, NJ, USA 18/06/2007 15:37:11

Outside of the tourist season in Stratford-on-Avon, where Shakespeare is a shrine to be visited, not a playwright to be seen and heard, how is the audience for his plays?

If it is good drama with good actors, then it should be just fine. But is it?

i don't know.

But it should be the same for opera.

24

James Davies,

South Wales 18/06/2007 15:47:26

Opera is for all people. I'm please the Welsh are learning the Scottish more about Opera and Katherine Jenkins telling you Opera is for all you having problems with your National Anthem in Scotland. This why Welsh are better singing than the Scottish and English.
Come on you Scottish starting singing now put a smile on your faces.

25

Florestan,

Aachen 18/06/2007 16:12:04

#18

Your nephew is a classical musician.

#20

McCartney IS certainly pampered and overindulged. Mull of Kintyre was risible, and his so-called "classical" oratorios are pathetically unmemorable. Incidentally most of his oratorios were written by Carl Davis.

26

lynnd,

New York 18/06/2007 17:46:52

#7 Heidegger:

If you're going to pose as a pseudo-Teutonic snob, at least learn to spell Bayreuth correctly.

Puccini is populist, but "Madama Butterfly" is hardly "tawdry trash".

27

Paul S.,

Mauricetown, NJ, USA 18/06/2007 18:39:21

Paul McCartney is not really a classical composer, though I'm sure the basic melodies are his and the actual composer plays for Sir Paul whatever he has written and McC approves or disapproves.

But I do find it refreshing in a world which tends to marginalize classical music, that McCartney has pretensions in that direction. That he lends his name in this way to the world of classical music, thereby legitimizing it to many who otherwise wouldn't care, is a good thing. I'd rather have him in my classical-is-a-good-thing corner than not have him. That's for sure.

I used to do a monthly Saturday morning classical radio/webcast show with a friend of mine here in New Jersey (he did it weekly!). We felt not at all odd about celebrating the 40th anniversary of the release of "Revolver" with a full hour's "classical music style" presentation of the album. The hours on either side were devoted to more "usual" classical music. We did play some of McC's stuff once, but in the company of the other new music we were playing I'm afraid poor Sir Paul paled.

By the way, if you want to hear a really fabulous modern opera, search for Peter Westergaard's "Moby Dick" — post-Britten and quite extraordinary. I'm not sure either McCartney or Davis could even come close to the first measure.

Westergaard calls the piece "an opera of the mind," since he cannot imagine an adequate staging which requires scenes with the sea and the whale far more visible than anything in, say, Britten's "Billy Budd." How can one convey the whale or the rolling ocean without being so abstract as to make staging pointless or being so corny as to make it laughable? I'll not mention the label, etc., because that would be considered an advert - forbidden. Just look it up online.

But I shall do one quick ad — if you're in the Philadelphia/southern NJ area on November 11, the great UK violist Roger Chase (formerly of the Nas

28

Celtic Cousin,

Wales 18/06/2007 18:39:32

# 25 Pondering on why the Welsh are musical. I think it may be something to do with the Welsh language and Welsh people's accent which has a certain musical lilt to it.

On the wider point. What's wrong with sexing up classical music? It makes it more accessable. Whilst performers such as the lovely Katherine Jenkins are a feast on the eye.

29

Deana,

18/06/2007 19:05:29

#25 I doubt that the Welsh are "learning" the Scots anything about operatic singing in the guise of such as Katherine. She has a sweet voice, but is a crossover singer, period. The penchant of the Welsh for choral singing is well known and admired, but please do not confuse that trait as a knowledge of operatic singers. I was brought up in Scotland in a family where classical music is revered and we shared that love that included opera with many, many friends. Opera is alive and loved in Scotland, despite what some may have you think. It's great to read through this article that many more young people have been introduced to it through this program.

30

Steve Evans,

Malta 18/06/2007 20:55:37

We all came from Alba!!

31

Filosofo,

Fife 19/06/2007 11:59:33

#31 -did we?????
I used to live in Malta: does that mean anything?
What are you talking about, Steve?


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.