Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Hadden cuts SRU ties and ponders his next move

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 26 June 2009
FRANK Hadden last night formally severed his ties with the Scottish Rugby Union and described his reign as national coach as a "privilege".
Dundee-born Hadden, 55, who led Scotland into four full Six Nations campaigns, also wished his successor Andy Robinson well and said he would take his time before deciding what to do next.

Hadden stepped down as head coach in April at the end of the 2009 RBS Six Nations Championship, and was replaced by Robinson earlier this month.

The former Edinburgh coach had been rumoured to be earmarked for a newly-created director of performance role, which will oversee the elite game in the country. However, Hadden has decided to leave the SRU's employment and seek new challenges.

Hadden said yesterday: "It was a huge honour to be invited to coach the Scotland under-16s in 1992 and it has been a privilege to work with Scottish players at all levels since then.

"Everyone knows that coaching our national XV is a tough job, but I thoroughly enjoyed the opportunity to take up the challenge and wish Andy Robinson the best of luck.

"I have been coaching professional rugby since the end of the amateur era and it's time now to take a step back and review what I do next."

Hadden, who had guided Edinburgh to the quarter-finals of the Heineken Cup in 2004, took over the post of Scotland head coach on an interim basis in May 2005, replacing Matt Williams, before taking on the role full-time in the autumn of that year.

He hit the ground running in the 2006 Six Nations, sending his team out to defeat France 20-16 at Murrayfield in the opening match of the campaign. A narrow defeat followed away to Wales, although Scotland were hampered by the dismissal of Scott Murray in Cardiff, and soon bounced back in spectacular style by beating England at Murrayfield to win the Calcutta Cup for the first time in six years.

The victory over England helped Scotland finish third in the Six Nations and the future appeared bright under Hadden, but his two subsequent campaigns proved enormous disappointments in comparison to his debut season.

The 2007 Six Nations saw Scotland slump to the wooden spoon, reaching a new low when they were routed 37-17 by Italy in an inept performance at Murrayfield, which saw them concede three tries inside the first six minutes. Although Scotland reached the quarter-finals of the World Cup in France later that year, they lost out to Argentina, and a golden opportunity of reaching the last four had been lost.

The Calcutta Cup was recaptured in 2008 after a 15-9 win over England, but only offered brief respite to Hadden, who attracted criticism for failing to get Scotland playing consistently to their strengths. The knives were out for him when that proved to be Scotland's only triumph, as they lost to 23-20 to Italy in Rome – only avoiding the wooden spoon by points difference.

A sole Six Nations victory over Italy and two weeks after losing their final match of the competition to England at Twickenham, Hadden announced he would be stepping down.

After Hadden's departure from the SRU was confirmed yesterday, chief executive Gordon McKie said: "I want to place on record Scottish Rugby's gratitude for Frank's utmost dedication and commitment. Frank was, and remains, first and foremost a passionate follower of the Scotland team and he always knew the honour and great responsibility that goes with the post of Scotland head coach.

"Prior to Frank's appointment, Scotland had not won an away international against a top tier southern hemisphere nation since 1982 and we had only recorded one victory over England in 16 matches.

"Frank can be rightly proud of coaching Scotland to our first ever Test victory in Argentina; of securing wins against four of our five opponents in the RBS Six Nations Championship; beating current Grand Slam champions Ireland in our preparations for RWC 2007; of ensuring Scotland maintained its tremendous record of always qualifying for the knockout stages of every Rugby World Cup; and, most memorably, plotting back-to-back Murrayfield Calcutta Cup triumphs."




Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 25 June 2009 9:28 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Fat one,

Edinburgh 26/06/2009 00:11:04
All the best to Frank Hadden. Its unfortunate that his reputation was tarnished by staying too long but I think it is fair to say that he has done a fantastic job given the circumstances. He worked his way up from the grass roots into the top job, some of his decisions may have been extremely poor on occasion but if the SRU had developed the player base over the last 15 years then things may have been better, did a good job with a poor lot!
2

Reiver1,

Banglamung 26/06/2009 05:36:54
Best of luck Frank from Guy and the other Wallaces, we will always remember your kindness and wish you every sucess in the future, maybe coach for London Scottish one day, who knows!! Damned glad we didn't fork out for a Lions trip though
3

Media at One,

26/06/2009 06:40:32
Hadden should look at a sales job for Canterbury or one of the other rugby brands. He isnt a manager!
4

Rabbit10,

26/06/2009 08:45:51
fat one - totally agree. he made some poor decisions towards the end of his tenure, but that just illuminated the lack of depth we have as a nation. think he did a fine job with a mediocre set of players. think he is a fine coach who lost a little direction towards the end, but the players have to stand up and be counted and not go into every away game thinking they've lost before the national anthems are even sung.
5

Delboy29,

26/06/2009 08:47:33
All good points.

FH has contributed a lot to Scottish Rugby (though admittedly not as national coach!) and could have contributed a lot more - but I'd not be surprised to see him get out of the whole business, after the nonsense that's been directed at him.
6

johnnyscotsman,

Hadden 26/06/2009 08:51:03
Probably a nice man & passionate scotsman but a truely dreadful coach, 6 wins in 4 years (6 Nations), it often was the defeats but the manner of the defeats. Toe curling defeats along the way, his after match interviews became an embarrassment to himself & Scottish rugby. Blinkered to the extreme in continually selecting Dan Parks. Looked ok initially due to suceeding the worst international rugby coach in history.

However I wish him well in whatever he does now.
7

JonnyS,

Edinburgh 26/06/2009 09:00:42
All the best Frank, a job too far I think. The 1st season results were great but as much to do with unshackling the players from the Williams era.

I think biggest problem was lacking confidence in his own game plan. Over his tenure we saw throw it wide, just use huge men, fill the scrum with back rows.

Hi persistant use of Parks hastened his downfall, a great club player whose game was limited at International level (unless that was the coach), the scapegoating of Godman after the Italy game (even though it was Cussiter who threw 2 interceptions), the continued perserverance of Sean Lamont and Jason White when they were on the wane, the refusal to pick Kellock when he clearly should have been and lastly the total rejection of Mossy as an option at 10 (enough has been said there).
8

expat 115,

london 26/06/2009 09:02:31
The fact that none of the Scotland squad can get into the Lions test team confirms the dearth of talent Frank had to work with, yet he never seemed to blame the players for the lack of results. Robinson goes into the job with his eyes open, well aware of the mountain he has to climb.
9

johnnyscotsman,

ex pat 26/06/2009 09:08:37
Don't you think it was having a rubbish coach with rubbish tactics that didn't allow the likes of T.Evans, Cusiter, R.Lamont, Paterson (@ 10), Barclay, Cairns, De Luca to play in an competitive team that sounded the death-knell to their Lions chances?????
10

J.A.,

26/06/2009 09:18:40
It will be easier to assess the influence of FH as Scotland coach in the coming seasons when we will have Robinson’s performance with a similar squad of players to compare against.
Although I wish Frank all the best in the future, I hope it is proven that he was a poor coach.
11

Sgian Dubh,

26/06/2009 09:21:04
#9

Agree with those comments. Scotland does have some talent and last 6N just showed up Frank's limitations as coach. A good showing in that tournament could have opened up a number of Lions places, especially following the good game against South Africa in the Autumn.

Best of luck to Frank for his future.
12

Uninterested Spectator,

26/06/2009 09:22:39
Selections: puzzling
Tactics: conflicting
press Conferences: misleading

Three tasks a national coach should be able to do blindfolded in this day and age FH struggled with continually looking out of depth.

Quite strange that the original Lions squad contained only two scots- both of whom missed the 6 nations and were picked on their domestic and european performances.
13

wright,

London 26/06/2009 09:26:44
I have no sympathy whatsoever for a man that should not have been in the job.His achievments at Edinburgh should have convinced the S.R.U. that he was not the man for the job.One of his failings was to ignore players playing outside Scotland.It seems to work well for Argentina!! Andy Robinson will prove beyond all doubt what was wrong with the Scotland team.It was without doubt the coach.I hope Frank can find a career outside rugby which will suit him better.
14

Armageddon,

Tobermory 26/06/2009 09:29:20
Good Luck Frank

A terrible national coach but a genuine, and decent man.

Unlike your former boss McKie....who should resign for crimes against Scottish rugby. How on earth can we have a creature as weak, low and self obsessed as McKie as head of a national sporting body. McKie is the Gollum of International rugby...cowardly, loathsome and complete obsessed with one goal....the elevation of his own ego.
15

lush,

26/06/2009 09:45:54
He's already been offered posts in England and France but I hear he's going to enjoy retirement for a bit - from the lions mouth.
Great coach and a true gentleman. Pity the dinosaurs @ the SRU and the paying public slated him because he did very well with the quality of the selection pool. I mean any team that has to field Hugo Southwell must be struggling (the guy can't catch a ball).
16

johnnyscotsman,

lush 26/06/2009 10:01:30
Hadden a "great coach", if you believe that you need help.

"did very well with selection pool" - that ludicrous statement would bring tears to glass eye.

Southwell - "the guy can't catch a ball" - ok he's not brilliant but a solid full back who gave his all, your critisism is at best ill founded at worst stupid
17

Colt,

26/06/2009 10:21:27
#14 has it right.
The real fault for the lack of progression in Scottish rugby lies with those who recruited Frank to the top job and then screwed him on pretty much everything including terms and conditions thereafter. The problem started when McKie appointed Frank as the cheapest option available, most folk knew then this was a probable step too far but to be fair to Frank he never really got much support from his bosses. He did sadly however begin to adopt much of their arrogance and that is not something he should be proud of.

McKie knows Frank achieved little but he will not say that because as #14 suggests, his opwn ego precludes that. His testament to Frank is to cover his own lack of judgement. Interesting question now is, will he support his new coach more than he did Frank?

And interesting also that announcements about Frank and about a Director of Rugby come out immediately before the AGM. Helps McKie deflect attention away from the ongoing failure of the organisation under his leadership.
18

kenbo9,

26/06/2009 10:22:01
#15 may be, but he's catching a fortune in Paris!
19

Fat one,

Edinburgh 26/06/2009 11:08:04
Unfortunately the users of this forum have founf id hard to get over the FH era. Frank stayed on too long but to suggest that Dan Parks was his biggest mistake is wrong. Chris Paterson is not a good enough player to play at 10, Frank knew this because he played him there. Parks on his day could produce excellent kicking displays, something Scottish 10's have lacked over the last 7-6 years, pity Parks was inconsistent. Frank became overly reliant on stats and his assistants over the last 2 years, this can be the only reason for someof his selections. Having said all of this, he had some excellent result in his tenure!
20

johnnyscotsman,

Fat one 26/06/2009 11:17:19
Users of the forum have found it hard to get over the FH era because it was an era filled with gut wrenching disapointment & heart-breaking embarassment for Scotland fans.
Dan Parks is an average club players who could kick well sometimes & wasn't inconsistant merely out of his depth.
Chris Paterson never really got the chance to "bed in" @ 10 in a professional team, IMO Edinburgh played their best rugby with Paterson/Laney @ 10/12.
Maybe the reasoning behind some of Hadden's decisions was he too was out of his depth, to blame his assisstants beggars belief.
We did have some good results but these were far outweighed by bad ones.
21

lush,

26/06/2009 12:27:47
#16, The guy wears orange gloves for gods sake! Without them there would be no hope for him. Your approval for him is at worst ludicrous and at best misinformed. Perhaps you need re-educating as Kim Jong-il preaches. In 48 matches he has only scored 8 tries .... not a particularly great stat, one try every 6 games!! compare that stat to the Italian Andrea Masi (Full back) even he has scored more...11 in 46 games!! Finally 08&09 seasons he played in 12 games and started 8 times, do you know how many times he scored? NOT ONCE....... in fact we have to venture back to 2007 to enjoy one of his tries... yeah "solid rugby player". I'm guessing you'll now feel slightly embarrassed!
22

johnnyscotsman,

lush 26/06/2009 12:57:01
Well Mr Lush you are correct I do feel embarrassed..........................for you!!!!!!!!

When did “ok he's not brilliant but a solid full back who gave his all” become approval?

And the period you mention when clumsily trying to make your point is a period when Scotland (due to a rubbish manager & rubbish tactics) scored very very few tries, indeed 15 tries in 2 full years 2008/2009 (6 v Canada).

So belittling Southwell for a national problem is preposterous.

Furthermore Southwell was chosen more for his defensive qualities than his try scoring.

Did you berate Michael Jackson for wearing gloves?(well glove)
23

Fat one,

Edinburgh 26/06/2009 13:12:38
His defensive qualities, I'm sure I saw G Morrison steamroll him Lomuesque style this season. Southwell is not a great player, he just has a big boot! and good hair in a poor Scotland team. Paterson passed him by this year, just proves that he is nae good. Glad to see he is gone, some of the honest young guys will get a chance now! The Scotsman were talking him up for the Lions but he must be about 10th in line for a callup.
24

johnnyscotsman,

26/06/2009 13:40:42
When did “was chosen more for his defensive qualities than his try scoring” become Southwell was defensively infallible?

Agree with all your other points though, Southwell had no chance of becoming a Lion.
25

AVRENIM,

Montvalent 26/06/2009 13:54:18
Looking forward to Andy Robinson being knighted for his services to Scottish Rugby!
26

lush,

26/06/2009 14:41:01
#22 "So belittling Southwell for a national problem is preposterous"... I just checked out his stats for the Edin Gunners and they aint great.... 3 measely tries in 13 games. Also I'm not just blaming Southwell as you make out, I believe that the squad as a whole is disgracefully low on talent (a few exceptions, Patterson, Hines, Murray) and that Hadden did a great job considering.
Scotland won't win anything while players like Simon Taylor are out partying to the wee hours at his bar, like drunks. If they want to be professional rugby players they need to wake and act like ones. I spent a day with Dan Carter @ a rugby event/dinner, not once did he touch a drop of beer. I asked him why not, he said he was training the next day. That's dedication.
27

Fat one,

Edinburgh 26/06/2009 17:53:25
#26: Probably a reasonable assessment: Ireland won the 6n and Flannery went easy on the beer, said he had training with Munster on the Tuesday Unfortunately, too many Scottish players think they have made it once they have got their pro contracts. Look at the Lions, people like O'drisoll are not happy to play, they want to win!!! and their play reflects this!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.