Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Ogilvie offers heartfelt defence of Romanov and insists: no 'war' with SFA



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 27 November 2008
HEARTS BEAT

Exclusive series

PART 1: How the club is run: managing director Campbell Ogilvie on working with the Romanovs
ANYONE with the perception Campbell Ogilvie is merely a football administrator caught between the devil and the deep blue sea cannot have spent much time in the company of the man himself.

Hearts' managing director, who has earned plaudits across Europe during a 39-season career within the game, has been the focus of much attention due to his "other" job; that as a vice president of the Scottish Football Association. Given that Vladimir Romanov has never been slow to criticise those who govern the club he bought in 2005, a theory exists that Ogilvie must cringe every time the Lithuanian tycoon opens his mouth.

Not so, says the Glaswegian; who yesterday mounted as bullish a defence of Romanov as anyone who hails east of Harthill could reasonably offer. There is, he says, no question of a conflict of interests and should be no fears over Romanov's ultimate aims.

"We have had negative publicity, some of it justified," explained Ogilvie, who was first appointed to the role of deputy chief executive at Tynecastle in November 2005 after leaving Rangers. "But a lot of it is built on and embellished, there is no doubt about that. I hear about the club getting into trouble for Vladimir's comments regarding the SFA; if you look back, that has not been the case since early 2006.

"We still suffer for that, people speak as if these things are happening every day. On the other hand, he has been quiet for a while. Because he has not been in the press, people say he is not interested any more when in reality he has certainly not taken a back seat as far as interest in the club is concerned.

"I have no problems with him, no problems dealing with him. He does care about the club, I know that. I still live in Glasgow and this myth has built up of what it must be like in here."

That assumption often relates to an antipathy towards authority, something which emanated from Romanov's outspoken stance during his early months as Hearts' owner. "Wearing my SFA hat, it is not the case that Hearts are at constant war with the SFA," Ogilvie explained. "If there is a case involving Hearts at the SFA I am obviously not involved, but I remember being on the disciplinary committee when I was at Rangers and having to leave the same meeting four times.

"There is a perception that refereeing decisions go against Hearts but there are other clubs with the same issues. There is no agenda at work, absolutely not. I feel more than comfortable being at the SFA and being with Hearts. This 'loggerheads with the SFA' theory is not my take on things. We are not the only club to make comments about referees, it is all part of the rough and tumble."

Romanov's influence these days may be from far afield rather than exerted via regular visits to Edinburgh but Ogilvie draws a direct comparison between the problems the Lithuanian's early struggles with a football club and those encountered by another high-profile owner. Ogilvie was at Ibrox, after all, when David Murray bought a controlling stake two decades ago.

"There is a similarity; David was a self-made businessman who wanted to do things all his own way when he came in," he said. "He discovered at that time that you had to take the other nine teams in the league with you, you had to play the game to an extent.

"If that was difficult for David, a businessman coming into football, you can understand how it would be even more difficult for Vladimir doing that from another country."

Ogilvie's Tynecastle office is that once occupied by Chris Robinson. While the former chief executive was reviled by a significant proportion of the Hearts support, Ogilvie's willingness to remain under the Romanov regime is viewed positively by those who have become accustomed to a rollercoaster ride.

"I go to see Mr Romanov about five times a year," Ogilvie explained. "Our relationship is good, as good as it can be considering there is a language barrier there. We have Lithuanian and Russian people working in here and it works well.

"It would have made no difference if I had come here at the same time as Vladimir. He came in as an owner and with his own opinion, which is natural. (Roman] Abramovich was the same. Vladimir, or anyone in his position, would come in with their own views on how the club should be run.

"There is an eastern European business culture and a Scottish business culture. Nobody is saying one is right and one is wrong, we have had a learning process together. We all want the same thing, success for the football club."

Engaging, while calm and straight-talking, Ogilvie dispelled the myth that his reluctance to court the media is on account of him having little to say. Indeed, few people have put forward as confident an explanation of where Hearts will be in five years' time as their managing director.

"In my time here, I have never doubted Vladimir's aims," he said. "He wants to take the club as far as he can. We must always aim to be at the top while having realism.

"You always have to aim for the top and see where you end up on account of that. I keep hearing about Vladimir saying he was going to win the Champions League with Hearts; I'm yet to find a direct quote from him on that. I don't think, being honest, he thought he could come in here and win the Champions League."

Part of Ogilvie's remit is to overhaul the structure of the club whereby the wages to turnover ratio drops to 50 per cent. Thereafter, plans to directly reinvest transfer fees received for players who have graduated from Hearts' youth academy into buying others up to the age of 16 from other clubs are afoot. Ogilvie has played a leading role in the Heart of Midlothian Community and Education Trust, a body which looks to encourage fans of the future and gained recognition at Downing Street earlier this year.

Two "positive and major commercial partnerships" are due to be announced within the next few weeks; on the field, Ogilvie wants to see Hearts play in front of average crowds of 20,000 at the new Tynecastle, regularly featuring in Europe while having the possibility of "pipping" the Old Firm. A key to all of these aspirations, he insists, is stability.

"We are trying to create a solid foundation here," he said. "We realise that only actions, not words, will work now.

"In the short term we have had and will have a situation where we receive funding from our parent company (UBIG] and we are fortunate to have that. The aim, though, is to make the club totally self-sufficient. It is good to have a parent company but we accept here that we have to stand on our own two feet. We cannot rely on outside funding, we must create a model.

"The main stand development is essential to the club moving forward. It is just a question of timing now, the scheme is in the hands of planning at the moment. It is a case of 'when' that will happen, not 'if'."

Such words should placate onlookers, who have been concerned that the current global economic downturn may have a direct impact on Hearts' stadium plans. "It is a current climate, things will change," Ogilvie insisted. "It is now a new stand development which is starting today," Ogilvie insisted. "It has been a long process, we are just at another stage at the moment."

Hearts, buoyant under Csaba Laszlo after four wins in succession, face a proverbial acid test on Saturday as Rangers visit Edinburgh's western outskirts. Ironically, Ogilvie's first away match as a Hearts official was at Ibrox in 2005. "That was slightly strange," he conceded. "I still have a lot of friends at Rangers.

"But there is absolutely no question about who I want to win on Saturday, or any other Saturday. There is a tradition at this club and a special feeling, even driving along Gorgie Road each morning. I used to come here when I worked for the Scottish Football League and always felt a warmth.

"And the supporters have stuck by Hearts."

That Ogilvie did likewise in times of – whether he opts to admit it or not – turmoil, represents no mean feat.


TOMORROW: PART 2

Hearts go head-to-head with the Old Firm for the best young Scots

The full article contains 1472 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Forward not Back,

27/11/2008 00:10:12
Good interview. Wonder how Sir Gay will try and destroy the thread as usual though?
2

GOA-JAMBO,

India 27/11/2008 02:21:37
Good reading a real insight into our beloved Heart of Midlothian, Campbell Ogilvie is a respected man in world football, I'm glad he has set his roots at Tynecastle, like most of us he has fell in love with the club, here's to the future.

C'mon the Gorgie !!
3

Away down In Gorgie (2),

27/11/2008 07:42:56
I spoke to EWAN last night. Another well written piece mate.

He told me that CO was very upbeat about he club.
4

Jambo Dave,

Edinburgh 27/11/2008 08:00:37
Great news for a change just before an old firm match.Lets hope the players drive on from here.Theres still a long way to go but the signs are all there for the future.
JT for life.
5

Southsider once upon a time,

27/11/2008 08:17:26
A great article that provides some insight into the principles that are driving some of the decisions being made at Tynie.
I will follow this series and look forward to tomorrow's offering.
Goes a way to addressing the clamour of those interested only in short term answers - although in football most of what happens is short term!
6

Nellie Rogers,

27/11/2008 08:37:10
reinvest transfer fees received for players who have graduated from Hearts' youth academy into buying others up to the age of 16 from other clubs

Ah the old "feeder club method" eh !

Be prepared for grubby weegies waving mis-spelt banners with names of your former players at you at home games.
7

petegeneva,

geneva 27/11/2008 08:46:47
nit-picking here: "Edinburgh's western outskirts"
What? Gorgie? Has been nearer the centre of the toun than the "outskirts" for decades. Has sombdy told Ewan that Edinburgh actually extends beyond Saughton?
8

WE ARE WE ARE WE ARE THE HEARTS,

27/11/2008 08:49:57
Well done EM - great article
9

Johnny Jambo,

27/11/2008 08:57:43
How many parts will there be to this interview, I hope one of them will tell us more about the stadium rebuild and when it will happen.
10

GeorgeCowieOrWalterKidd?,

27/11/2008 09:08:12
#10 Ogilvie states the stadium's in planning so I don't think a time can be put on it. He does it's a matter of when not if which sounds good. It's in the hands of the council - with a development like this there's always going to be lots of amendments going back and forwards. It's all freely available to view on the council planning site though.

If you mean more info on funding, I don't think CO will have info on that - it's all internal UBIG stuff. They've stated in the past they want partners for the various non-football parts of the development and want a sponsor for the stand part. They're an investment group and funding projects is what they do, so they appear to have a plan.
11

_NB_,

27/11/2008 09:29:42
This "Admin man happy at Hearts" story is another major scoop for the Scotsman; following on from yesterday's scoop on the 3 injured Hibs players recovering from injury, the Scotsman is setting standards that the other Scottish media organisation will struggle to emulate. Keep up the good work Scotsman.
12

GeorgeCowieOrWalterKidd?,

27/11/2008 09:44:38
#12 This is an interesting story if you're a Hearts fan - we don't get enough info from the people running the non-playing side of things.
13

busbyfh,

27/11/2008 10:31:04
Had a meeting with CO a year and a half ago one on one - he comes across as honest so if he says a stand will be built I have no reason to doubt him.

One thing though - "It is now a new stand development which is starting today". That is CO's quote - does this mean that past plans are scrapped and the new ones will be for a stand only and not the daft original ones that incorporated amongst other things a new hotel. Sorry , but hotel , restaurant,gymn,bar etc would probably not work where they were going to be sited.
Go with the new stand only.
14

Andy1,

27/11/2008 10:36:45
So Hearts radical new business plan is to get wages down belwo 50% of turniover and then bring kids thorugh the academy.

Well done Hearts, only ten years behind everyone else realising that.

Looks like a story to put out now just to ally some obvious fears. not a good sign.

Mind you, the real detail of it doesn't make that pretty reading. The wage bill looks like it will still need to be halved from what it is now. Some cutting has been done but is probably still about 100%.

What will happen to the team then? What will ahppen to crowds thereafter?

A big, big correction ahead and still a non copliliant stadium to deal with.

Hearts are miles behind the rst of the SPL on this and if they do surive there are years of difficult time ahead.
15

GeorgeCowieOrWalterKidd?,

27/11/2008 10:51:54
#15 Extra, extra... "Hibee Posts Rambling, Incoherent Negative Response to Positive Hearts Story Shock"

Ten years behind with a youth academy? That's a strange comment given that Hearts were one of the first in Scotland to put one in place - in 2004 - and we're now starting to reap the rewards with Berra, Jonsson, Driver and Wallace in the first team and a bunch of talented players in the reserves and U-19s.
16

you can`t go wrong,

workin for the man 27/11/2008 11:32:48
i think the much ridiculed coment about winning
the CL was made at an early press conferance
in which vlad is clearly joking with the press.
here it is in part on youtube
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?
v=JHO8mVeRTP8&feature=related

17

We love fitba,

google! 27/11/2008 11:34:23
Enlightening stuff. Perhaps in future editions of this "exclusive series", Ewan Murray might get round to asking a question.

When do Hearts plan to cut wages to 50% of turnover? Does this mean players will be leaving in January?
Why did planning submission for the new stand take so long?
Why does he not remember Vlad's grand pronouncements on winning the League, the Champions League and all the others?
18

Andy1,

27/11/2008 11:52:04
#17

No, about ten years behind in thinking that the way to go is to lower the wage budget to levels your income can afford and to realy on youth. I do realise Hearts have done pretty well in terms of youth, what I am getting at is the business plan recently of trying to spend to accumulate - the rest of the teams decided a long time ago that things had to change in that respect.

You are also starting that process with a very high level of debt and have a very major stand issue to sort out as well.

Confirmation that Hearts plan is to adress all that the old fashioned way and that you won't be getting hand outs from a rich guy with a plaything should be of a bit of concern to you in how much pain will have to be gone through on the playing side over the coming years.

If you find that rambling and incoherent then fair enough, says a fair bit about what you can actually understand!

19

Andy1,

27/11/2008 11:58:42
And I can't wait until tomorrow - how Hearts single handedly go head to head with just the Old Firm for the best of the Scottish kids around! What absolute tosh. It really is no wonder most people in Scottish football would be quite happy to see Hearts no longer here!
20

Skiver,

27/11/2008 12:19:35
#14 interesting point about the stadium. I'm not sure myself where it's at but spending £51 million on a stand which increased the capacity by only 5,000 seemed a bit mind-boggling. I'm pretty sure that's how much Hampden cost.
21

GeorgeCowieOrWalterKidd?,

27/11/2008 12:33:26
#20 "And I can't wait until tomorrow - how Hearts single handedly go head to head with just the Old Firm for the best of the Scottish kids around! What absolute tosh."

a) Hearts didn't write the headline "Hearts single handedly go head to head with just the Old Firm for the best of the Scottish kids" and b) The word "single-handedly" isn't there so if it's "tosh" it's your tosh. Your inferiority complex is showing up loud and clear.

As for the rest - "most people in Scottish football would be quite happy to see Hearts no longer here". Laughable - could your chip on the shoulder BE any bigger? What's wrong - is no other team apart form hibs allowed to receive praise for their youth policy? Is no-one allowed to challenge the OF?

#21 5000 seats is about a 20% increase. A potential revenue increase of 20% a year is not to be sniffed at. Even if those 5000 seats are only full for OF and Hibs games, that could be an extra £1m a year, before any corporate boxes and other stuff that's part of the planning app is taken into account. It would help if people would actually read the application details before commenting.
22

GeorgeCowieOrWalterKidd?,

27/11/2008 12:48:25
#19 Dear Andy1

Just because my club tried a different business plan to your club doesn't mean we deserve to go out of business. There is an argument that the speculate to accumulate policy worked - we accumulated a Scottish Cup and a 2nd spot after all. And some commentators are saying that the debt could now be closer to what it was when Romanov took over than it's peak at 35m or whatever (ie closer to 20m than 35m) taking into account Gordon, Bednar and other transfer fees, lower wages and the 12m share issue thing.

I actually believe that Romanov showed the way forward to the other SPL clubs with his initial actions - appointing and investing in a good, ambitious manager and upping the wages to attract a better quality of layer and keep good young players. Even though wages have never been near OF levels, we did pretty well that season. He messed it up by sacking Burley and interfering. If he hadn't, who knows the speculate to accumulate plan could have worked. But you don't want to hear anything like that - conflicting views not acceptable it seems in your world.
23

Tartan Jambo,

27/11/2008 13:32:19
Why has Ogilvie made no mention of the four redundancies as of 31st December? Surely that's something the fans should know about, or is that a secret he would rather keep?

He can put all the positive spin on buying up youth players that he likes. The bottom line is we're about to lose our highest paid players and replace them with guys who are on peanuts and just starting out in the game.

This charm offensive won't be persuading me to buy a half season ticket.
24

Skiver,

27/11/2008 14:01:13
I'm just saying that £51 million seems a bit steep for what they are supposedly getting.
25

Salvatori,

27/11/2008 14:05:43
As a long term season ticket holder that became disaffected with the club and gave up my season ticket in favour of a walk up ticket policy, this is exactly the kind of insight into the club I've been looking for over the last few seasons.

Glad to see Ogilvie coming out and speaking to the press. It certainly goes some way to helping me feel better about the club I've supported since a young lad. More of the same Hearts and some of the 3 - 4,000 thousand who've gone missing might come back through the turnstiles again.
26

East at Easter,

Edinburgh 27/11/2008 14:55:58
Ogilvie = TUBE


(or is that puppet #45 ?)

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.