Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Eco-town would give green future to former mining communities

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 29 February 2008
DETAILED plans for what could be Scotland's first eco-town were unveiled yesterday.
Planners hope to regenerate four former mining villages on a 1,200-acre site at Cardenden in Fife – using it as a blueprint for future sustainable communities.

The proposed scheme of 5,000 wooden eco-homes, of which 1,000 would be affordable housi
ng, will be built over the next 20 years.

They will incorporate a range of innovative renewable energy features and recycling systems aimed at creating a zero-carbon community.

Planners say the eco-town would not just be a "stand-alone structure" but would also involve eco-town residents and those living alongside it, being involved in community and recycling projects and adopting a greener, healthier lifestyle.

However critics say it is an example of "greenwashing" in which large-scale housing programmes are pushed through despite local opposition because they include green features.

But Colin Anderson, managing director of Banks Property Development Limited, the company behind the plan, said the proposals were not merely about providing housing but about helping to "breath new life" into Scotland's neglected communities.

"Scotland has so many old industrial villages, fragmented communities stripped of ambition which are crying out for redevelopment.

"The Scottish Government says about 10,000 new houses are needed a year so why not build these houses where people want them and which could lead to long-term regeneration. People in Cardenden don't want another anodyne housing development and I think many have been pleasantly surprised at what we have come up with.

"When eco-towns were first proposed in England the vision was that they would be single entity settlements on greenfield sites including abandoned air fields. There was such a public outcry the focus turned to brownfield sites such as Cardenden which can be tied in with the infrastructure."

Mr Anderson added that his company has submitted bids for four out of the ten eco-towns in England

Søren Madsen, an architect at Arkitema, one of Denmark's leading building firms, which is masterminding the development, said: "This is an amazing opportunity for Scotland though some aspects of what is being proposed such as turbine technology is already part of everyday life in Denmark.

"With Cardenden I like the fact that we are building on an existing identity, but the big challenge will be weaving the old and new, locally and socially.

"People have been very curious. Their population has fallen from 20,000 to 5,000 and they want it to come up to a critical mass – the eco-town could be a way to do this."

Andrew Saunders, director of Ore Valley housing association in Cardenden, said: "The proposals are very interesting in eco terms and because of the demand for affordable housing across all tenures in this area.

"As a registered social landlord we cannot compete with this, but it has a synergy with what we have been doing in terms of energy saving. If the local community want it, it will go ahead."

The proposals do not fit in with Fife Council's structure plan and the company is now hoping it can influence the Scottish Government to look positively on the idea.

CAUTIOUS WELCOME FOR ECO-TOWN PLANS

PLANS for the eco-town received a mixed response yesterday.

• David Taylor, secretary of Cardenden and Kinglassie Community Council, said: "We are taking a cautious approach to this. We want the village to grow, but people are nervous of change.

"You also have to think about the mentality of people in the four villages – it can be difficult getting them to integrate at present, never mind bringing in a new town."

• Robin Harper, Green Party MSP, said: "This project can be an icon for all new developments, small and large, and I find it genuinely exciting. Hopefully, Cardenden will set the pace for all future development."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 29 February 2008 10:03 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Environment
 
1

John Blackley,

Winter Garden, FL 29/02/2008 01:40:29
Wonderful, marvellous, right-on.

Now what are the residents of our lovely new 'eco-town' (formerly a depressed mining village) supposed to do for a living? Or is that beside the point?
2

carrottop,

Dumfries 29/02/2008 08:13:54
We have got enough ghost towns why not invest in them.
3

AJM,

29/02/2008 10:23:15
This guy had all the sales patter last night on Newsnight and was clearly trying to get close to the SNP government by saying all the right political words. As he is trying to build 4 in England I hope that his "England Government" comment early on is not heard south. But I did enjoy his patter on what these wooden buildings are made of..... largely wood apparently.
4

W Smith,

Middle East 29/02/2008 12:41:19
"Zero carbon community" eh?

If the population has fallen from 20,000 to 5,000 sounds like 'zero employmnent' community.

Typical numpty talk from half-educated wackos.

Merchant ships are responsible for almost 10% of CO2 emissions compared to around 5% for aviation.

Guess which country has one of the world's largest merchant shipping lines?

That would be our Soren Madson's home country - DENMARK!

Obviously the 'green' dolts in Holyrood have never heard of Maersk - one of the biggest container companies and shipping lines in the world.

The biggest container ship in the world, I believe, is the 'EMMA MAERSK' a great piece of engineering and the photos of the ship can be easily found on the internet.

So much for Denmark being 'green'.

#1 John
Well spotted.

Obviously job creation was not even considered.

BTW
Ian Rankine is from the Cardenden/Bowhill area, that makes Lockerbie look like Las friggin Vegas.

Rankine doesn't like to admit it so he states on his books that he's from the 'Kingdom of Fife'.

Sounds better than Bowhill.
5

dido-bendigo,

Argyll 29/02/2008 13:08:43
Can Scotland (or the rest of the UK) produce the right sort of timber from our forests for such a development? Or will it have to be imported? Do we have the facilities for proccessing it in the UK or will it have to be sent abroad and then returned? Will the chemical treatments be environmentally friendly? Just what is Eco about such a plan and can someone please define 'affordable'.
6

Robert12,

Edinburgh 29/02/2008 14:55:40
It seems stupid for this to happen. Cardenden's population dropped when the coal stopped. Same happened in various places including Lochgelly and Cowdenbeath. To add an extra 15,000 people (estimate) is incredibly stupid. Where will these people work? I suppose a few could work in the new school, newsagents etc that will no doubt come but what of the rest? Clogging up the roads into Dunfermline and Edinburgh?

What needs to be addressed first is bringing jobs into Central Fife. How many people in Central Fife are commuting to Edinburgh each day? Given the amount why not aim to locate business where the skilled work-force is in the first place?
7

Why can't I use my usual name?,

Glasgow 29/02/2008 15:04:15
While energy-efficient houses are fine, I suspect #1 has it right. I don't suppose the promoters count the emissions from the two cars that are required to get to work, shopping, entertainment venues...

The not very developer-helpful fact is that it's dirty old cities like Glasgow and Edinburgh which are already the most eco, and have the potential to be more so. People live at higher densities, travel shorter distances and less often by car. Public transport can work in cities, as opposed to being a poor skelton service for people who have no other choice.
8

Mr Mud,

Edinburgh 29/02/2008 21:59:23
#9

Clog up the roads? Haven't you heard that Cardenden has a station capable of taking 6-coach trains?
Kirkcaldy & Glenrothes one way, Dunfermline & Edinburgh the other.
9

Why can't I use my usual name?,

Glasgow 02/03/2008 20:44:03
Most people don't travel by train, Mr Mud, even when there's a station next door. And even if there is a station next door, there's unlikely to be one next door to where they want to go. And Glenrothes doesn't have a station, not really.
10

emerald,

fife 27/03/2008 20:43:19
cardenden is a great little village and that's how we want it to stay. no one wants banks's eco town, we are happy with our village status.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.