Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


20 years on, and repression continues – with umbrellas

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 05 June 2009
HUNDREDS of security forces stood guard at a fenced-off Tiananmen Square yesterday to prevent any attempt to mark the 20th anniversary of the killing of hundreds of pro-democracy protesters.
Two decades on, even as the country's booming economy turns it into a world power, the political repressions that Chinese students fought, and failed, to end in 1989 were in full force. Internet sites remained shut down, BBC and CNN broadcasts were
blacked out at any mention of Tiananmen, and victims' families were not allowed to mourn at the square.

Uniformed police and plain-clothes officers blanketed the area, armed mainly with walkie-talkies and umbrellas but using both efficiently to block cameras and any attempt at protest. The metal fence around the square had controlled security points with metal detectors and X-ray machines.

Even relatives of those killed in the crackdown on 4 June, 1989, were prevented from leaving their homes for quiet remembrance of their loved ones. Ding Zilin, a retired professor whose 17-year-old son was shot dead, was, for the first time in three years, prevented from a night-time visit to the site of his death to lay flowers.

Another parent, Xu Jue, was under heavier surveillance after police stopped her going to her son's grave at nightfall earlier this week. "In over 20 years, the authorities never revealed what really happened nor talked to the victims' families," Ms Xu said.

The scene in Beijing was in stark contrast to last night's annual candlelight vigil in Hong Kong – now a special administrative region of China – which drew a crowd of 100,000.

China reacted angrily to a call from US secretary of state Hillary Clinton to "examine openly the darker events of its past and provide a public accounting of those killed, detained or missing, both to learn and to heal".

A spokesman for the Chinese foreign ministry, Qin Gang, described her remarks as "crudely meddling in Chinese domestic affairs", adding: "Today is like any other day. Stable."

Officialdom's 20 years of ignoring calls for a public inquiry and the release of an official, credible death toll have had some impact on the next generation. On a quiet street less than three blocks from Tiananmen Square, manned at one end by a police van, young passers-by had little to no idea why so many officers were on duty. "What is it, swine flu?" asked a woman of 21. She conceded having heard of "that" event at Tiananmen, but dismissed it as no longer relevant to up-and-coming members of China's middle class. "I think it's important to know our history, but not necessarily to let it affect us," she said.

The only state-linked acknowledgement of the anniversary was in the Communist-controlled, English-language Global Times, which carried a front-page story about the "June 4 Tiananmen incident" – a first in the Chinese media. But it varied little from the official state line, mentioning the deaths of soldiers but not the hundreds of unarmed civilians killed, and it was not carried in the newspaper's Chinese-language version.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 04 June 2009 9:45 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

,

05/06/2009 01:21:31
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Mashimaro,

China 05/06/2009 02:11:13
I'd like to see the pictures of the mass gathering to commemorate the June 4 incident in Hong Kong
3

Arminius,

05/06/2009 02:34:13
#2 Mashimaro - Film report of the event is here:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/8083569.stm
4

Graeme,

HK 05/06/2009 03:20:33
One hundred and fifty thousand people turned up last night with candles in Victoria Park, Hong Kong SAR.

One paragraph dedicated to it in the Scotsman?
5

,

05/06/2009 03:55:58
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

Tatties ower the side,

Johannesburg 05/06/2009 04:09:15
#2 #3 Sorry, Arminius. Poor old Mushy probably won't be able to watch that because it is blocked.

BUT as Postie (the Canadian Chinaman now turned Scotsman) knows, the BBC only tells lies about China so it was probably a made up story anyway.
7

,

05/06/2009 04:53:06
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

Mashimaro,

China 05/06/2009 05:41:44
#4 Graeme it doesn't fit with the western media's idea of a lockdown in China
9

Jim A,

05/06/2009 06:11:47
Guys, 100,000 of your fellow citizens staged a candlelit, silent protest. That's a 100,000 of your fellow citizens who don't agree.
10

,

05/06/2009 06:41:07
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

Graeme,

Today HK 05/06/2009 06:57:57
Scotsmen 55 #10

I'm pro China so i get many of your points but take a look at the South China Morning Post today page A1 to A6.

Especially the front page. It all makes an interesting and enlightening read.


12

Jim A,

05/06/2009 07:22:55
#10 Scotsman, 100,000 is still a lot of people, you wouldn't want them trampling over you.
13

Jim A,

05/06/2009 07:28:57
What's this, you boys hiring new help?
14

Mashimaro,

China 05/06/2009 07:34:13
I think it was more like 150,000 who turned out to show the current chief executive of HK that he made a vast mistake when he said people didn't care.
We do care. It is a pivotal point in our history.
15

,

05/06/2009 07:37:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
16

,

05/06/2009 07:43:08
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

Jim A,

05/06/2009 07:54:26
#16 Scotsman, "Honestly Mashi, the people I've talked to really have no interest in it and openly admit to knowing nothing or very little about it,"

Why is that? Why is that they don't know anything or very little about it? The rest of the world knows. So why is it your people don't know?
18

Mashimaro,

China 05/06/2009 08:44:03
#16 because it's been kept from them, Posty. Because teachers are too afraid to teach it. Even in places like Hong Kong. Let's be honest here. Please.
19

2dogs in D.C.,

05/06/2009 09:10:23
Really,what country does not have bodies in the closet? Let me know,and I'll move there.
20

2dogs in D.C.,

05/06/2009 09:11:03
Very clever move w/the name by the way.
21

Dragonhead,

Dalian,China 06/06/2009 05:53:10
The 150,000 touted by organizers was estimated to be around 62,000, that is much less than the 90,000 here in Dalian who went on a Charity walk (over two days) recently.
Seem to remember 60,000 British casualties sent over the top before breakfast in WW1by their inept leaders.
Perhaps China will come to terms with it when the Japanese come to terms with the 300,000 to 400,000 they OPENLY massacred the helpless citizens of Nanjing (called Nanking by some westerners).This is denied much more vehemently by the Japanese. Level playing field might be nice!
#6 Blocked? When we can watch practically any news source on the planet with Broadband, are you serious? You will have more problems with Zuma to occupy you in the near future,to worry about China.Unless of course, he like others comes grovelling for guns for money etc!
22

Arminius,

Bei Uelzen 06/06/2009 08:02:07
#21 Dragonhead - Another ridiculous post. What have a charity walk in Dalian (with an estimated 90,000 participants),the Japanese and British casualties on the Somme got to do with a massacre by the Communist regime in China?
Nothing, except to apologists for a vile and repressive regime.
23

Mashimaro,

07/06/2009 06:31:31
actually those dudes with the umbrellas were really funny... ha ha ha h... we'll make it the national umbrella dance

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.