Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Tourists' £700,000 unpaid parking fines

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 01 March 2007
TOURISTS parking their cars illegally in Edinburgh have escaped paying £700,000 worth of fines which cannot be enforced because the owners do not live in Britain.
A loophole in the law has forced the city council to write-off thousands of parking fines issued to foreign-registered vehicles over the past four years.

Owners of British-registered vehicles can be traced through the Driver and Vehicle Licensing
Agency in Swansea if they fail to pay.

However, the council says it cannot pursue drivers responsible for almost 20,000 unpaid tickets as the DVLA has no record of foreign owners.

Motoring groups last night called for tougher action to ensure people from other countries are treated the same as British motorists.

Luke Bosdet, spokesman for the AA, said: "It will be galling for drivers in this country when they see that drivers of foreign-registered cars are getting off Scot-free with parking fines.

"No doubt the council has calculated that it would not be economically-viable to pursue these motorists in their home countries. If they were to try and do that, I assume the Edinburgh council taxpayer would be saddled with an even bigger bill.

"However, some of these motorists will be foreigners who have brought their car over when they come to live here. They are required by law to register their vehicle with the DVLA after six months. If they are not doing this, then I suggest the most regular and persistent offenders should be taken to court."

Sheila Rainger, campaign manager for the RAC Foundation, added: "This is a problem across the country. It also applies to drivers who have been flashed by a speed camera.

"There is anecdotal evidence in London that people are actively trying to buy foreign-registered cars in this country."

The city council is supporting a campaign by the British Parking Association to close the loophole.

Councillor Ricky Henderson, executive member for transport, said: "This is a problem across the UK and I can understand how frustrating it must be for motorists who dutifully pay their parking fines.

"There are currently no cross-border warrants for parking tickets within Europe. I hope to see a solution to this nationally and this loophole closed.

"If there was a strong agreement in place between countries in the European Union on the recovery of parking fines then perhaps the figure owed to the council would be lower."

Allan Jackson, the council's Conservative transport spokesman, said: "This comes as no surprise. It is a well-known fact in Britain that if is difficult to trace foreign vehicle owners.

"It is something councils have been looking at for a long time and more action needs to be taken through the European Union. We could understand if a driver made a one-off mistake but to visit someone's country and abuse our hospitality is another matter."



Page 1 of 1

 
1

Conan,

Here 01/03/2007 07:37:56

Think of it as a modest refund of the outragous prices those tourists were forced to pay for accomodations, meals, petrol, etc. while they brought employment to a disgustingly ungrateful and greedy Scotland. Tourists, tear up those tickets as soon as you get them.

2

Alexander,

Edinburgh 01/03/2007 09:02:50

Yes, clamp down on the tourists and empty the shops of tourists just as has been done with local motorists.

3

Iain's,

London 01/03/2007 09:07:45

It is not just parking. A Spanish mate of mine left Embra by car at 10 am and phoned me from near Toulouse that evening.

4

Jane95,

Edinburgh 01/03/2007 09:30:21

#4 - he must have been using rocket fuel!

5

Dayvan Cowboy,

01/03/2007 09:55:06

As a non UK resident , you can play the same game . Its Great !

6

alex paterson,

embra 01/03/2007 10:18:37

How or why do they get away with it,A large percentage of hire cars maybe.

7

Moody,

01/03/2007 10:22:01

How many UK drivers have escaped fines in other countries ?We cannot complain

8

Agent 99,

01/03/2007 10:56:27

>>A loophole in the law has forced the city council to write-off ...

Wrong. This is just plain wrong. Shan Ross doesn't appear to have a clue. It's nothing to do with the law. It's about procedures.

It's further no suprise that the DVLA has no details on foreign registered vehicles; it's outwith their remit.

This is simply yet another case of British insularity. Countries in central Europe routinely exchange vehicle and driver details, especially where excessive speed and other traffic infringements occur. You don't need a law to do that, it's simply co-operation between different national authorities. For example, Swiss drivers can and do receive fines from the German traffic authorities for speeding, having been caught on camera on the authobahn. And they have to pay the fines too!

If this really was a serious problem rather than something to fill up the newspaper then the DVLA would have implemented electronic data exchanges with their European counterparts. The fact is that the UK authorities either don't consider it important enough, or just can't be bothered. You can be sure if there was a terrorist incident the details would be instantly available. Clearly, overstaying your welcome in a Grassmarket parking bay isn't in the same league as terrorism.

9

Cynic,

Dalkeith 01/03/2007 11:14:03

Simple solution, impound illegally parked vehicles bearing foreign number plates. Or recover the money when they return to the country at the port of entry. That would allow the council to claw back a fine percentage of lost revenue.

10

SouthernSkye,

Currently Köln 01/03/2007 11:43:27

The tourists could be located.
A colleague, Polish but living in Germany, was caught on speed camera in Switzerland. The fine arrived to his house in Germany around a month after the event.
English colleague was caught by camera in the Netherlands. The fine arrived at his home about 6 weeks after he had passed through the Netherlands.
It is possible, it just means some effort and interworking between countries.

11

Billy,

Germany 01/03/2007 14:30:51

Pure lies to say there is no cross border agreements. If I get a parking ticket in Holland
I am obliged to pay it despite living in Germany.

More british inefficency, Henderson is either ignorant
of what other countries are doing to combat this, or is a bare faced liar. Either way I don't envy Edinburgh if they rely on this "executive member for transport" to come up with a solution.

12

jim lad,

the capital 01/03/2007 16:05:23

If i was a tourist i would do exactly the same, not correct but being honest.

13

Kilted_kangaroo,

Australia. 01/03/2007 20:23:22

Aye Jim Las......me too!!

I go out of my way when in a hired car to speed past the cameras in the knowledge that I am coming back to Australia in a few weeks, hahaha.

It is the same here though with cars registered in different state. It's too hard. Stop whnging and as some other psoters have said..........see it as small recompense for the inflated proces they have to put up with for oh let me see..........EVERYTHING! :O)

14

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 02/03/2007 00:36:56

Cool .. I totally love it when folk get away with victimless crimes like parking tickets .. I am really glad the council who use this as a money spinner are getting shafted by someone ...

This loophole .. does it not give any of you good folk an idea of how to avoid paying your own parking fines?

Cousin from Australia could have been over and parked in that space for 10 seconds too long ... here's her name and address go catch her!


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.