Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Message on a bottle goes down drain as consumers spurn free tap water

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 09 June 2008
SALES of bottled water soared last month as consumers rejected appeals by a government minister to turn their backs on the industry and use tap water.
Figures for bottled water sales for the week ending 10 May show that they were 23.2 per cent higher than the same period the previous year.

The report, compiled using data from market analysts AC Nielsen, says that the quantity of water sales is
5.5 per cent up year on year – an additional 5.6 million litres.

The surge in sales comes despite a stinging attack on the bottled water industry by Environment Minister Phil Woolas, who described it as bordering on the morally unacceptable for Britons to drink millions of litres of bottled water every day when safe tap water is available everywhere.

He raised concerns about water being imported to Britain when other countries faced problems with supplies.

Reacting to the new figures yesterday, Mr Woolas insisted: "I'm not going to tell people what to drink but we've got some of the best-quality water in the world and we should be more proud of it.

"To me, it's absurd to use up the Earth's resources, including oil and lots more water, to manufacture a bottle and then fill it with water from elsewhere, transporting it hundreds or even thousands of miles, only for the bottle to end up being sent to landfill or using energy to be recycled – when the alternative is turning on the tap."

Mr Woolas's campaign has been supported by Tim Lang, the government's natural resources commissioner, who has said that the only way to combat the problem would be to make "people think that it's unfashionable just as we have with smoking. We need a similar campaign to convince people that this is wrong." However, in the UK alone, £2 billion a year is spent on bottled water. Despite this, the industry says that sales slumped in April in the wake of the minister's criticism aired on a BBC Panorama programme, which showed that in terms of production, a bottle of Evian or Volvic generates up to 600 times more than a litre of tap water.

But the Bottled Water Information Office says that the dip was purely down to the cold weather.

Richard Laming, communications director of the Bottled Water Information Office, said: "Bottled water remains as popular as it has ever been, with more than 30 million people in the UK making an informed choice to drink it.

"Bottled water producers have worked hard to make sure everyone is in possession of all the facts and people like drinking water that is pure and natural."

Jo Jacobius of British Bottled Water Producers, which represents small UK bottling companies, said that consumers were making balanced judgments in choosing bottled water. "Certainly, tap water is perfectly good, but inevitably it does contain chlorine and other chemicals used in the cleaning process that people want to avoid, and there is a body of scientific opinion that agrees with this view.

"I think there is an increasing preponderance of people wanting natural and locally produced products. British water is what people are looking for because in terms of environmental impact it has travelled the shortest distance to the shops."

Ms Jacobius added that in comparison with other bottled drinks, water's impact on the environment was small.

IN QUOTES

"It borders on being morally unacceptable to spend hundreds of millions of pounds on bottled water when we have pure drinking water, and at the same time one of the crises that is facing the world is the supply of water." Phil Woolas, environment minister

"Huge amounts are imported from other countries – some now ludicrously from the Far East. This is an ecological nightmare and it doesn't make economic sense either. " Peter Ainsworth, shadow Tory environment secretary

"We've now tracked plastics particles smaller than a human hair, to 20 microns, and we've found nine different polymers, consistent with water bottles, all over the UK and further afield as well." Richard Thompson, a marine scientist from Plymouth University

"We think it's unfortunate it's turned into this either-or battle. We do feel like we're being unfairly targeted." Joseph Doss of the International Bottled Water Association



The full article contains 718 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 June 2008 11:00 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 00:36:22

Well quite frankly can you blame us,?

You put 'fluoride' in our tap water! what else do you put in it!,?

Mass Contraceptives,?

Mass Brain-Washing Drugs,?

We Don't Trust You!! We ain't Stupid!

Flushing is all 'Tap Water' Now Deserves!
2

lobout,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 02:34:46
I say if anyone is moronic enough to pay hard earned cash for plain old water, let them waste their money
3

Mist001,

Marseille 09/06/2008 06:56:18
I used to be a sales rep for an American company in the mis 1990s called NSA. Their principle lines were water filters and air filters.

Maybe I'm just a rubbish salesman but I couldn't sell these things because people would say 'But Scotland has the best water in the world, so why would I want a water filter?'

I think I sold two in all the time I was involved!!

But with all these stories appearing, now might be a better time to flog water filters!!

Michael.
4

albanman,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 07:16:29
#1 - You bleat about the mains water, but do you know what is in the the bottled water?
5

SouthernSkye,

09/06/2008 07:47:13
Skye tap water is great and even better if popped in the fridge for half an hour to chill (some more). I do buy sparkling water as I like the fizz and mostly avoid other carbonated drinks as they are just a bunch of chemicals.
6

Unimpressed one,

09/06/2008 07:53:38
"To me, it's absurd to use up the Earth's resources, including oil and lots more water, to manufacture a bottle and then fill it with water from elsewhere, transporting it hundreds or even thousands of miles, only for the bottle to end up being sent to landfill or using energy to be recycled – when the alternative is turning on the tap."

I think there's a whiff of a PC, eco-bam, luddite ban in the air. Bottled water's next, but not before plastic bags, cheap drink, patio heaters, light bulbs.....
7

Upbeat,

09/06/2008 08:25:19
At the simplest level it is possible to say that for every single kilometer 21,000 litres of water is transported by truck it wastes 1 litre of diesel.

Bring Evian water from its source to Scotland and around 1500 litres of diesel will be wasted. Bring Spa water from its source to Scotland and some 600 litres of diesel will disappear. ( without forgetting waste heat, vehicle wear and tear, road wear and tear, congestion, pollution from exhaust gases etc. )

People will soon learn that there are more essential things for which trucks will continue to be required in the second half of this century, after " peak oil" and when oil suplies have to be spread between even more affluent people around the world. If we waste fule on luxuries now, the moment when we are reduced to living hand to mouth on items sourced around our homes will come even closer.

Ways to transport water using aquaducts irrigation channels and pipes were one of man's earliest and most efficient discoveries....
8

GDP,

uk 09/06/2008 08:28:26
#1
there is no fluoride in scotland's tap water, unfortunately!
there is however in some bottled waters, but i thought you'd be more worried about the chemicals from the plastic bottle.
...and then there is the terrible environmental problem of oil consumption and plastic waste
we are very lucky to be able to drink the tap water in this country, people should remember that and not take it for granted with ignorant 'flushing' comments
9

Dumb Eye @,

09/06/2008 11:33:29
What's all this "It borders on being morally unacceptable to spend hundreds of millions of pounds on bottled water when we have pure drinking water" nonsense?
I usually keep a small stock of fairly locally produced bottled water for the times when Scottish Water decides to supply me with a dark brown liquid that even the dogs won't drink (and they have been known to drink some awful looking stuff), or some over-chlorinated concoction which would probably be banned under the Geneva convention if used in a water-cannon.
10

Alternative (High Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 11:39:30
#8:

"there is no fluoride in scotland's tap water, unfortunately!"

No. Fortunately.

You must be mad to buy bottled water. Absolutely stark raving mad.
11

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 09/06/2008 11:51:19
If you don't trust the tap water and don't want to fill the landfills with practically unbreakdownable plastic bottles get a jug with a filter such as Brita and your tap water will taste fresher and many harmful chemicals and some natural undesireables are removed.
12

Nic83,

09/06/2008 12:32:06
Thank you number 11, the voice of reason! A fairly simple compromise is it not?!
13

SouthernSkye,

09/06/2008 13:42:59
#11....just stick it in the fridge in a normal (cheap) non-filtered jug and it is as good. 30 mins and Bob's your Auntie.
14

gotalottosay,

09/06/2008 14:08:03
there is nothing wrong with cooncil juice!
15

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 15:01:56
Bottled water - what a con. If they ran an advertising campaign for tinned fresh air some of the trendies out there would be queueing up for it.
16

ddmc,

09/06/2008 16:24:59
bottled water mostly comes from underground sources so has small amounts of flouride present, tap water has around 100+ tests & analysis done, not sure how many tests are done on bottled water. Scottish water tastes quite nice in comparison to the taste from south east England, not sure if its because of the softness / hardness of the water.
to fluoride or not

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluoride

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_fluoridation_opposition

The FDA support adding fluoride, but coming from the people who claim aspartame is 100% safe......
17

yoric,

09/06/2008 22:05:46
The answer is quite simple.

Impose prohibitive duties on all imported bottled drinking water.
18

Louis Catorze,

09/06/2008 23:20:25
We've got great tasting tap water in Scotland. And although the stuff down here in London isn't the best tasting, it hasn't killed anyone yet.

And isn't likely to either.
19

BK,

Cyberspace 09/06/2008 23:34:59
Tap water is foul. It used to taste good here before they started doctoring it, but doesn't now. Till the water authorities stop filling it with poisonous and foul tasting chemicals people will go for bottled water. For instance chlorine, the gas that hurts your eyes at the swimming baths. Also aluminium, known to cause Alzheimers, fluoride, probably the most dangerous of the lot. Give us clean pure water from the taps and we'll drink it, but I for one will not consume the poisons forced on us by the water boards.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.