Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 16th May 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Fears of ecological disaster for St Kilda



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 February 2008
URGENT action was being taken last night to protect the fragile environment of St Kilda – Britain's first World Heritage Site – amid fears that rats could leap ashore from a stricken fishing boat
.

Following a dramatic day in which 14 Spanish fishermen were airlifted to safety when their vessel foundered on rocks in a force-nine gale and mountainous seas, it emerged that the islands' seabird colony could be under threat from rodents.

Experts believe it is possible that rats on board the vessel, which is currently trapped against rocks on the main island's coast, will move on to land, where at present the only mammals are mice and sheep.

The National Trust for Scotland (NTS) – which owns the group of islands, 44 miles west of Benbecula – said St Kilda's seabird colony could be decimated if rats get ashore.

Rat traps were laid yesterday by military staff on Hirta, the main island, in an attempt to stop the rats before they ate birds' eggs.

The eggs are laid in ground nests because of the absence of trees. An NTS team plan to fly out as soon as it can.

Susan Bain, the trust's property manager, said rats could pose "a huge problem": "(The island's] isolation means that there are no land-based predators on the bird colonies, and we've got strict guidelines to make sure people don't accidentally bring non-native species, such as cats or rats, on to the islands.

"There are only two mammal species – sheep and the St Kilda mouse, a unique sub-species – that inhabit the islands. So any possibility of rats being introduced would be a concern."

Abbie Patterson, the trust's national species recovery officer, said: "This is potentially very worrying if any rats aboard the vessel get ashore as they could put the seabird colony at risk by eating eggs and chicks."

St Kilda, a remote cluster of rocky islands on the edge of the Continental Shelf, was designated a World Heritage Site for its massive cliffs and profusion of seabirds, such as the world's biggest colony of 60,000 pairs of northern gannets.

The islands are the most important seabird station in the north-east Atlantic and also have large colonies of puffin, fulmar and Leach's storm petrel.

There are also concerns about the impact of the trawler's estimated 8,000 litres of diesel and oil if it leaked.

Dr Dan Barlow, WWF Scotland's acting director, warned: "It is a very sensitive marine environment and were a spill to occur, there is a risk that it could have a big impact on the biological marine environment and wildlife in that area."

Concerns about the potential environmental disaster came as Britain was battered by 75mph winds, with blizzards causing chaos on roads.

Details of the dramatic rescue of the crew by the coastguard also emerged yesterday. The 169-tonne trawler was virtually lifted ashore by the huge waves in a force-nine gale.

At one stage, the pilot of the helicopter was forced to hover dangerously close to the cliffs of the island, the rotor blades just 20ft from the rock face.

The drama began shortly after 5am yesterday, when the 82ft trawler, the Spinning Dale, was driven on to rocks on Village Bay, on the eastern edge of Hirta.

A digital distress signal was picked up at the coastguard station at Stornoway.

Captain Liz Forsyth, a former RAF search and rescue helicopter pilot, said: "When we got there it was still pitch black and there was severe turbulence and high seas.

"The vessel was in a 'V' of rocks and as each wave swept right over, it was being washed in and washed out. The winchman, once he was on the deck, said at one point he thought it was actually going right over."

She stressed: "To go in there without being able to see the rising ground in that turbulence would have just been madness. We waited for about half an hour or so until it was light enough to go in."

Capt Forsyth and her crew managed to lower a winchman, Phil Warrington, on to the deck of the trawler. Mr Warrington was repeatedly struck by heavy waves crashing over the vessel, its stern already submerged, as he helped to winch the stranded seamen to safety.

Capt Forsyth was forced to maintain a stable hovering position in the winds buffeting the aircraft close to the cliff.

She said: "The boat was hard in towards the base of the cliff, but the cliff face was sloping away. Where we were hovering, the tips of the rotors were about 20ft away from the cliff face. It was quite a tricky operation.

"We had to put the winchman on the bow because the back of the boat was under the water. The main problem was for the winchman, who was having the waves crashing over this head. He had bruises up his arm just from hanging on to the deck as each wave went through."

Capt Forsyth, 34, continued: "They were very relieved when they got on board. It was one of the most hazardous operations I have ever been involved in."

At 9:06am all 14 fishermen were safely on board the helicopter. One man had an injury to his hand and four were suffering from suspected hypothermia.

The injured trawlermen were transferred to the Western Isles Hospital for treatment, while the other crewmen were cared for by officials from the local fishermen's mission.

One of the rescued men, Christino Andre, said: "It was very frightening. I was asleep in my bunk when the captain came in shouting 'Come on, come on, come on'. The captain radioed a mayday."

PREVIOUS SCOTS RAT RUNS

THIS is not the first time that professional rat-catchers have been brought in to protect the indigenous wildlife of a Scottish island.

In 2006, a team purged 10,000 rodents from the island of Canna, part of the Inner Hebrides, where they had almost destroyed a local seabird colony.

Over an eight-month period the pest controllers, who travelled from New Zealand, exterminated the brown rats which had overrun the island, having arrived on ships 100 years ago.

Before the rat eradication could begin, a team from the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland removed a population of wood mice from the island to protect them from the poison.

Rescuers battle wind and waves to pluck 14 fishermen to safety

FRANK URQUHART

THE seas around St Kilda, the remote cluster of rocky islands on the edge of the Continental Shelf in the stormy waters of the Atlantic, have never been a place for faint-hearted seafarers.

And yesterday, 14 Spanish fisherman experienced the danger first-hand when their 169-tonne trawler was virtually lifted ashore by the huge waves in a force-nine gale.

Details emerged after a dramatic rescue of the crew by the Coastguard.

At one stage, the pilot of the helicopter was forced to hovver dangerously close to the cliffs of the World Heritage Site, her rotor blades just 20ft from the rock face.

The drama began shortly after 5am yesterday, when the 82ft trawler, the Spinning Dale, was driven on to rocks on Village Bay, on the eastern edge of the main island of Hirta.

A digital distress signal was picked up at the Coastguard station at Stornoway in the Western Isles.

Captain Liz Forsyth, a former RAF search and rescue helicopter pilot, said: "When we got there it was still pitch black and there was severe turbulence and high seas.

"The vessel was in a V of rocks and as each wave swept right over, it was being washed in and washed out. The winchman, once he was on the deck, said at one point he thought it was actually going right over."

She stressed: "To go in there without being able to see the rising ground in that turbulence would have just been madness. We waited for about half an hour or so until it was light enough to go in."

Capt Forsyth and her crew managed to lower a winchman, Phil Warrington, on to the deck of the trawler. Mr Warrington was repeatedly struck by heavy waves crashing over the vessel, its stern already submerged, as he helped to winch the stranded seamen to safety.

Capt Forsyth was forced to maintain a stable hovering position in the winds buffeting the aircraft close to the cliff.

She said: "The boat was hard in towards the base of the cliff, but the cliff face was sloping away. Where we were hovering, the tips of the rotors were about 20ft away from the cliff face. It was quite a tricky operation.

"We had to put the winchman on the bow because the back of the boat was submerged under the water. The main problem was for the winchman, who was having the waves crashing over this head. He had bruises up his arm just from hanging on to the deck as each wave went through."

They winched the crew off two at a time. Capt Forsyth, 34, said: "They were very relieved when they got on board.

"It was one of the most hazardous operations I have ever been involved in."

At 9:06am all 14 fishermen were safely on board the helicopter. One man had an injury to his hand and four were suffering from suspected hypothermia.

The injured trawlermen were transferred to the Western Isles Hospital for treatment, while the other crewmen were cared for by officials from the local fishermen's mission.

TRIBUTE TO RESCUE TEAMS

RESCUERS were hailed for their bravery today after saving 23 people stranded on a ferry battered by a massive storm.

Rescue teams were scrambled to help the Riverdance, after a huge wave hit the vessel at about 7:30pm on Thursday, 12 miles off the Lancashire coast, causing it to list.

Airman Rich Taylor was winched down from the helicopter in the 70mph winds, while below, a lifeboat crew battled 20ft waves to reach the scene.

Tom Harris, the UK transport minister, thanked the rescuers, including crews from the RAF, Royal Navy, and the English and Irish coastguard services.

"These people put their lives at risk and I'm sure the 23 people on board are going to be eternally grateful," he said.

The Riverdance, a truck ferry which was crossing from Warrenpoint in Northern Ireland to Heysham in Lancashire, is now beached about 400 yards off Blackpool, listing to one side.

The full article contains 1749 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 February 2008 11:50 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Weather , Accidents at sea
 
1

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 02/02/2008 00:16:22
The spinning Scotsman more likely, unless the rats are Lab/lib dumbs jumping ship.
2

Fanling,

Hong Kong 02/02/2008 00:36:20
Yet another "fears/disaster" headline from a newspaper that seems to have foundered on the rocks of its own imagination.
3

Kipling,

02/02/2008 00:46:10
A little sub-editing was needed here. I wasn't quite sure if I was reading double
4

jerrymanders,

rat eradicator 02/02/2008 00:56:24
Kill all rats.
5

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 02/02/2008 01:04:42
Notice how the Scotsman has lost track of the law of dynamics?

The ecology of St Kilda first then the human interest story 3rd.

This is serious heid banging.
6

W Smith,

Middle East 02/02/2008 03:21:31
There is talk in England of bin collection taking place only once every two weeks.

Increasing the risk of rats and disease while the 'greens' keep quiet.

So uninhabited St Kilda should concern us more?
7

An Beal Bacht,

02/02/2008 04:51:16
Didn't the MOD use these islands as firing ranges for all kinds of ordinance? Isn't St. Kilda still littered with unexploded shells?

BTW what the hell were Spaniards doing there at this time of year?
8

Kenny A,

02/02/2008 06:35:13
#7

Fishing
9

An Beal Bacht,

02/02/2008 07:00:41
8. Kenny - mah theory is they were smugglin plonk! Either that or they were surveilling the Islands for future colonization. Were there any arms aboard? You see these are the questions journalists often fail to ask! Perhaps if Scots had control of their seas we wouldn't have to deal with an infestation of Rattus Iberianicus. Whatever the real reason for them being parked by a cliff in the outer Outer Hebrides - we'll sort it out!
10

donald,

glasgow 02/02/2008 07:13:18
At least rats have the sense to leave a sinking ship. The Lib-Lab-Dum flounderers haven;t a brain between them to do even that. Too busy squealing about the good ship Independence being full steam ahead on course.
11

Rulesbutnotrulers,

Federation, not separation 02/02/2008 07:19:23
Get serious: rats nearly wiped out NZ birds, most of which are ground nesting. Many NZ areas are still free of indigenous birds.

Why are ships allowed to have rats? There are ways of eliminating them. This isn't the 18C.
12

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 02/02/2008 08:17:32
#11 Rulesbutnotrulers

It was possible to know whether the rats had been eliminated from Canna by leaving chunks of plastic that any rat couldn't resist nibbling in various places on the island. If after several weeks the plastic remained unnibbled, it was concluded that the rats were gone.

It is presumably possible to do the same with rats on ships, and to eliminate them if found. Perhaps that should be part of there seaworthiness certificate.

Rats (and cats and goats and rabbits and ....) have done enormous damage on being (usually unintentionally) introduced to islands. That is why the experts that dealt with the Canna rats came from New Zealand - their whole fauna and flora has been devastated by introduced species and some native species only hang on on islands off the coast where the rats and cats can't get at them.

Ships are required (as far as I am aware) to have a seaworthiness certificate before being allowed
13

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 02/02/2008 08:22:03
Sorry for the typos in #12 above. To to repeat:

Ships are required (as far as I am aware) to have a seaworthiness certificate before being allowed to sail. Perhaps showing that they are free from rats should be part of their seaworthiness certificate.
14

gus1940,

Edinburgh 02/02/2008 08:40:22
When are the Scotsman and the media at large going to learn the proper meaning of the word decimate and its derivatives - namely to reduce by a TENTH.
15

thinking,

Scotland 02/02/2008 08:50:10
#1 & 10
What on earth has politics got to do with this?
Have you got one track minds?
16

gus1940,

Edinburgh 02/02/2008 09:03:12
Wow! A whole 6 Scottish news items in a paper calling itself The Scotsman.
17

jdships,

Edinburgh 02/02/2008 09:22:56
1,2,3,5,14,16
Ever critical of the newspaper but gladly read it for free

Makes sense I suppose to those of certain persuasions !!
18

Alexander,

Edinburgh 02/02/2008 09:55:43
It is only sensible to take action to prevent a rat infestation, but, is there any evidence that the boat had rats on board? As for Dan Disaster Barlow and the 7.5t of diesel fuel a couple of days and it would all be gone, it is hardly in the category of crude or tanker residues.
19

Dave from Barra ©,

Western Isles 02/02/2008 09:55:51
Funny story to be printing considering the huge environmental damage caused daily by continental fishing fessels ripping the erse out of the sea bed and fish stocks to the detriment of the bird species on the islands.

One has the mishap of getting caught out and this is the best the Hootsman esteemed journo's can come up with? A few rats?
20

Red Tower,

Dunoon 02/02/2008 10:04:06
#15 I fully agree. I voted for Alex Salmond and his party at the last Hollyrood election and I shall probably do so again . If I don't however it will because of those heid-banging lip-strummers among the nationalist supporters who can see politiccs in everything.

St Kilda is a World Heritage site. We Scots should be proud of that. And we Scots should be doing everything possible to preserve its uniqueness. Allowing rats on Hirta would be a disaster.

My advice to the lunatic section of Nationalist support is belt up , save up their money and go and visit the place. I have recently been twice to Hirta and I found it a fascinating experience.
21

jdships,

Edinburgh 02/02/2008 10:09:11
18 Alexander,

Agree totally with your post
Spent 30 + years at sea on vessels of all sizes and ages and only once did I see a rat on board.
If you have ever been off St Kilda , as I have, you will know 7.5t of light oil will be dispersed in a few hours .
22

Van (not white) Diesel,

Amsterdam & Augsburg 02/02/2008 11:54:22
#11 & #12
All merchant vessels are required to have a beautifully named 'deratisation certificate', renewable every 6 months, and issued, following inspection of likely nooks and crannies, by the Environmental Health Dept. as far as the UK is concerned. I cannot say if the same regulations apply to trawlers, but would suggest that it is probably the case. In any event, I cannot imagine a trawler skipper of any substance allowing rat to eat his precious cargo, or help itself to marmalade on toast in the crew quarters.
23

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

02/02/2008 13:02:22
22 , you sound like you know what youre talking about , and the ship sails under EU law.

Dirtz Spaniards eh ? Is that what we are supposed to think ?

No evidence whatsover. Of course the people of St Kilda (when there were any) survived almost entirely on the produce of dead seabirds.

Theres a great book out there , island on the edge of the world .

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/low/uk_news/scotland/2134537.stm

If theres any truth here , take the opportunity to do some work with the national trust and go visit and kill the vermin.

But i doubt it.
24

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 02/02/2008 13:03:38
#22 Van (not white) Diesel

Thanks for that. I wonder if they use the tasty plastic chew bars, like they did on Canna, to detect any sign of rats. Yes, I can imagine any rat making itself known on a trawler would be pelted with haddock.
25

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

02/02/2008 13:05:25
Sorry , rubbish link heres the right one..

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Island-Edge-World-St-Kilda-Canongate/dp/0862413885

Pick it up in Waterstones.
26

Shug,

02/02/2008 13:11:08
Ships are hoaching with rats, so there is a serious point to the article. The turn around in islands that have been de-ratified is quite staggering. By the following season islands go from being silent to thronging with birds. Impressive.
27

Van (not white) Diesel,

Amsterdam & Augsburg 02/02/2008 13:59:20
#26 Shug
A very sweeping statement, 'hoaching with rats', if I may say so. I would not deny for one minute that there are not rats on ships. There are undoubtedly some rats on some ships. Rats, after all, are rats. Accordingly, there may be a degree of risk involved here, and it is being addressed.
28

Gothic Rose,

02/02/2008 14:34:19
If music be the food of love, play on.
29

bruce borland,

oshawa 02/02/2008 14:41:56
Fabulous environmental story and of the extreme bravery....isn't it sad the extreme ignorance and blatant stupidity in some of the comments..perhaps, the government of Scotland should review it's history program and include the environmental disasters caused by the introduction of alien species....then maybe the YOBS will understand.
30

Chairman Gordon,

Bannockburn 02/02/2008 15:35:36
#7-
The Army used St Kilda for test-firing Rapier missiles out over the sea. As far as I'm aware, there is NO unexploded ordnance on the island.
31

Displaced Scot,

UK 02/02/2008 16:04:15
What was a Spanish fishing boat doing in Scottish waters, these people are responsible for destroying
much of the Scottish industry. If they must have Scottish fish, they can buy it off Scottish fishermen.
32

Eleanor d'Aquitaine,

West Highlands of Scotland 02/02/2008 16:07:08
Capt Forsyth, the winchman & other crew performed an remarkable rescue of this longliner crew, deserving the highest praise for their skill & bravery.
To: 2 Fanling, 5 Jock Tamson, 7 An Beal Bacht, 12 Slioch, 18 Alexander, 21 jdships, 22 Van (not white) Diesel, 23 The Genuine Mario Antoinette, 29 bruce borland - Well said folks - after reading the banner "fragile eco-system at risk from deadly cargo of rats" (page 5 in the paper today),I felt like jumping off the end of the pier in dispair! Who owns up to writing that drivel?

19 Dave from Barra , - yes, let's rid our seas of them all too - to the further detriment of the west coast fishing villages who now need trade from these boats after sucessive governments failed to support the Scottish fishing fleet.
31 Displaced Scot - come back here & say that & note above!
33

An Beal Bacht,

02/02/2008 16:42:06
32 - Awa back tae France. Yer a wee blether!
34

Sambo,

The deep south 02/02/2008 18:25:57
Perhaps something could also be done about Glasgow's rat problem, especially the two legged one's running around with knifes.
35

An Beal Bacht,

02/02/2008 19:20:13
34 - Is that you Wullie?
36

jerrymanders,

What shores? 02/02/2008 21:09:55
#35

That's what the Captain said.
37

Strathturret,

montrose 02/02/2008 23:10:30
Non story.

Can't get excited about St Kilda. Who lives there?
38

Van (not white) Diesel,

Amsterdam & Augsburg 02/02/2008 23:31:17
#37 Strathturret
Never mind the non-population of St Kilda, I note that Eigg has given power to the people by a variety of largely eco-friendly means. So much for the good news. The 161,000 inhabitants are having their credit cards snipped. :)
39

Lastsocialist,

Europe 03/02/2008 00:06:38
If St Kild had a direct tram link to Edinburgh airport then perhaps this disaster could have been avoided.
40

Beth Boyle,

Rural, NY 03/02/2008 07:06:24
Why was this boat there, the weather forcast all over the UK was for very heavy weather? It was poor judgement. I fear rats far less than the ship breaking up and spilling it's oil. I was just on Hirta in August. It is a World Heritage Site and I think all fishing should be stopped in the area. It has some of the best diving in Europe. This is pathetic to see this happen. The most important reason to stop fishing is because of the birds who come from far and wide to nest there.
41

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 03/02/2008 11:56:47
#40 Beth Boyle

If you care about the wildlife of St Kilda you should certainly care about the possibility of rats getting there.

We do not have sufficient information to know how likely that is, but it is certainly a risk that needs to be considered and guarded against.

We do have sufficient information to know that were rats to become established on St Kilda they would have a devastating impact on the sea-bird colonies there.

The relatively small amount of oil in the ship is unlikely to cause much problem at this time of year, before the sea-birds return to breed.

On a related topic: rats are causing huge problems on Rum, particularly in the Manx Shearwater colonies. The shearwaters nest in burrows near the tops of the mountains there and the rats eat their eggs and young. There was a proposal to 'do a Canna' (ie eradicate the rats)on Rum. Does anyone know if it to go ahead?
42

is it me?,

Edinburgh 03/02/2008 20:04:11
Surely this is a "natural" event if ever there was one and maybe we shoudn't interfere ?
These are seabirds we're talking about, and if St. Kilda ceases to appeal to them they'll go elsewhere.
Meanwhile St. Kilda could be marketed as the biggest Scottish rat colony outside Glasgow and Edinburgh.
Failing that, there's always Napalm, (for St.Kilda that is.It's too late for Glasgow and Edinburgh).
43

Alan Davies,

Worcester UK 05/02/2008 00:14:26
Pilot Officer Liz Forsyth, and her winchman, Phil Warrington, carried out a very difficult Rescue, in appalling weather conditions. The helicopter, a new Sikorsky S.92 is also new to these types of incidents.
As well as putting her life, and that on the crew, at conciderable risk, she managed the Rescue of 14 lives, and upheld the hishest traditions of the Coastguard Service. She should be rewarded for her bravery. I hope the News.Scotsman will take up this requirement.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.