Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Gap widens in battle of sexes as fewer women land top jobs

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 04 September 2008
SCOTLAND'S most talented women face a "concrete ceiling" in the workplace that is continuing to prevent many landing the most powerful jobs in society, according to a report.
The investigation reveals the proportion of women in some of the most powerful positions in Scottish society has declined or stagnated in the past five years.

Female representation in the Scottish Parliament has declined from 39.5 per cent in 2003
to 34.1 per cent this year, according to the Equality and Human Rights Commission Scotland survey.

Meanwhile, the proportion of women leaders of local authorities has remained static at 18.8 per cent over the past five years.

Morag Alexander, head of the commission in Scotland, said inflexible work practices were preventing women from making their full contribution.

She said: "Young women's aspirations are giving way to frustration. They are excelling at school – in many cases outperforming boys. And they are keen to balance a family with a rewarding career.

"But workplaces forged in an era of stay-at-home mums and breadwinner dads are putting the break on their careers – with an avoidable loss of talent.

"We always speak of a glass ceiling. In some cases it appears to be made of concrete."

The commission's report, Sex and Power says achieving equal representation in Scotland's most influential public roles would require 85 more women secondary headteachers, 21 more women MPs, 13 women judges and 11 women senior police officers.

In the past year, the number of women holding top posts has fallen in four of its 14 job categories. In another six categories the number of women remains unchanged since the commission's 2007 survey. Women's representation has increased in just four areas.

The equality gap is particularly marked for women from minority ethnic backgrounds, the report says.

It highlights that, despite the slow progress towards equality in the boardroom, girls are continuing to gain better school qualifications than boys, while 57 per cent of all university students are women.

The commission will publish a report next year with recommendations on how to increase equality, with more flexible working practices likely to top the list.

A commission spokesman added: "If we are to create an ambitious, fair and confident Scotland, we cannot go on marginalising or rejecting talented people."

FACT BOX

THE UK parliament is 70th in an international gender equality league table, behind Iraq, Afghanistan and China.

The Equality and Human Rights Commission report found that only 19.7 per cent of British MPs are female.

The percentage of women MPs in Scotland is even lower – 13.6 per cent.

This compares with 25.5 per cent in Iraq, 21.3 per cent in China and 27.7 per cent in Afghanistan.

Rwanda is top of the gender equality league, with 48.8 per cent of parliament members being female.

Second is Sweden, where 47 per cent of its politicians are women.

The United States languishes behind the UK in 83rd place. Only one in six of its politicians (16.8 per cent) is female. Canada, meanwhile, is 59th on the list with 21.3 per cent representation.

LOSING THE POWER GAME

Sex and Power 2008 Scotland Index:
Women in selected 'top jobs' over the last five years







Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 September 2008 10:00 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Women and work
 
1

Colin Wilson,

Aberdeen 04/09/2008 06:54:23
There won't be equality in the workplace until there's equality in the home, i.e. with as many men as women not working but running a home full time.

That just isn't going to happen, because women themselves don't want it. Certainly, a man who looked for a relationship on that basis would find that his choices were very limited.

2

Boy Wonder,

04/09/2008 07:12:01
She Who Must Be Obeyed suggests I don't comment on this one.
3

Samcafe,

Glasgow 04/09/2008 07:23:35
Selective stats again. Why no measure of Head Teachers in Primary Education? Senior Officials in the civil service and local authorities? Dearie me, looks like some people are just desperate to hang on to their victim status.

I take it a man winning the recent Glasgow East Westminster election will be considered further evidence of a glass ceiling.
4

,

04/09/2008 07:57:31
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
5

Er!!!,

04/09/2008 08:49:05
#4 - At present, only 24% of secondary heads are female, while 52% of secondary teachers are women. In primary schools, where 83% of teachers are women, only 53% of primary heads are women (Stats for England) - So no glass ceileing there then! Even in areas where there are more women employed, they still find it harder than men to reach the top!

Of course the brigade that thinks this is PC nonsense will complain, but usually from their position of privilege and power!
6

Voice of reason,

EDINBURGH 04/09/2008 08:59:02
Maybe they are not good enough ? Too many second raters in promoted jobs because they are women ?
7

King Richard IV,

Brisbane 04/09/2008 09:24:48
As John Lennon once said "Women are the N!ggers of the world!". They have no chance whatsoever at the "Top" jobs because of the type of Men who hold these jobs! From the Vanderbilt group of company's down to the Club of Rome,the Rockefeller institution,corrupt politicians and local councillor's,even Freemasonry promotes "Men Only " environments in which to perpetuate this one sided equation. Ladies if you think a bunch of fat middle aged men sitting round a table are just going to give you things,think again. You are going to have to take them of someone the same way we did in the first place! Good luck!
8

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 04/09/2008 09:29:11
Hang on - what happened to the story yesterday about twice as many women earning over £75K? Well OK maybe it was 2 of them instead of 1.

9

JT,

04/09/2008 13:23:01
The problem with the lack of opportunities for women in high positions is the expectation that we are going to want to take time off to have children. Newsflash! there are women who cant have or dont want children, I know Im one of them, yet I have been asked in interviews when i plan to have children which apart from none of anyones business its illegal. It should be the best person for the job irrespective of gender or anything else. All we ask for equal pay for equal work and opportunities.
10

JG,

Fife 04/09/2008 13:25:01
#15 JayDeeTee
Those jobs are left to you guys because you do menial tasks SO well!!
11

GlenB,

04/09/2008 14:10:34
It's not so clear cut as to what is actually happening - I know of a government dept who recruited for a number of management level positions where the qualified applicants are at least 10 to 1 men to women. Remarkably the ratio of those recruited was 50:50.
Somehow I don't believe it was all down to merit alone because there was pressure to get equal representation at higher levels.

Strangely at the same time lower levels of management with a similar ratio of applicants was almost exclusively filled by men.
12

The Former Mr. Angry,

Perth 04/09/2008 14:10:40
#17 JG

Go to the top of the class for flattery! You know it works every time.
13

RSBuff,

GA / USA 04/09/2008 14:43:03
Government positions are fairly wide-open, while positions in the private sector are generally less so. You have Wendy... We'll soon have Sarah. Life is good!

Besides, we allow them to play golf now, so what's to complain about?
14

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 04/09/2008 18:14:30
I'v had some excellent female bosses in my time but try working in an environment where women are in the majority and the boss is also female. Talk about bitchiness....
15

,

04/09/2008 21:51:32
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
16

,

04/09/2008 21:53:26
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
17

JG,

Fife 04/09/2008 23:18:27
#22 JayDeeTee
That'll be why the 'gals' are doing so much better at school and uni than the guys then, will it? You keep doing the heavy, dirty jobs and leave the intellectual stuff that requires doing more than one thing at a time to the girls!
18

Brodric,

04/09/2008 23:37:45
Women are just as good at most jobs as men, with the exception perhaps of jobs which require the kind of physical strength that women don't have. Men and women are different in that respect.

I am a woman, and also an employer. I wouldn't be able to afford to employ a woman of child bearing age. The fact is simply that children take up your time. I gave up a good career with prospects to look after my kids and worked freelance as it just was not possible to cover all eventualities on the kids front. Its easier when they are pre-school. But school means early finishing, complicated arrangements to cover the period after school until work finishes; not to mention school holidays, half terms, Monday holidays - and sick days. And prior to all that - maternity leave.

I am all for trying to make the world a fairer place. But in trying to make it fairer for one group of people, another group is disadvantaged. Giving women priorities can cause problems for SMEs, or for other female colleagues who don't have children, or for male colleagues, the latter two of whom have to work all the odd hours and so on, whilst their colleague-mums go home early. In some jobs, mums are not allowed to do dangerous elements of the job because they are mums, but they are paid the same, and so on.

Where's the equality in this.



 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.