Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Beijing gives its blessing to bad news

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 21 November 2008
China's leaders bow to inevitable and opt for management rather than censorship
FOR decades, bad news was no news in China. The media, even if not under direct state control, avoided any mention of social or economic troubles, with Beijing particularly sensitive about China's image abroad.

However, the Communist Party has n
ow decided that the truth is best after all, and better than rumour for certain.

Recently and by degrees, Chinese media have increased reporting of protests over land, labour and investment issues – and officials say this reveals an attempt by the government to manage the impact of bad news by acknowledging it.

Propaganda authorities have issued a writ authorising news organisations to report on unrest, rather than allow rumours to take hold among Chinese worried about the impact of the global financial crisis.

Strikes by taxi drivers and protests by newly laid-off workers have been reported regularly, as have riots in north-western Gansu province this week and a mass petition in Beijing.

"The Chinese government has started to loosen its control on the negative information," an academic source close to propaganda authorities said. "They are trying to control the news by publicising the news," added the source, who, perhaps revealingly, declined to be named.

But the shift, if continued, would be a bold move for China, which only in 2005 legalised the reporting of the death toll from natural disasters.

A party official confirmed that the policy towards news had gradually changed this year.

"It's almost impossible to block anything nowadays, when information can spread very quickly on the internet," he said. "We also noticed it will benefit us if we report the news first."

Chinese media were allowed unprecedented freedom in the first week after the devastating May earthquake in Sichuan, that killed about 80,000 people and unified the country around the dramatic rescue effort. But coverage shifted to accolades of central government leaders and soldiers as soon as questions began to surface about why so many schools had collapsed.

A blackout of bad news during the Beijing Olympics in August also resulted in delayed reporting of milk tainted with melamine that ultimately killed at least four babies and made thousands sick. However, the academic added: "The central government has (now] permitted local authorities to publicise negative news themselves, with no need to report to upper governments any more.

"They have a principle of, 'Report the facts quickly, but be cautious on the causes behind the facts'."

Official news organisations still often lag behind reports posted on the internet and usually downplay any elements that might raise mistrust of the Communist Party.

But yesterday, for example, the Xinhua news agency made an unusual acknowledgement of protests in the capital, when it reported nearly 400 people, angry at losses in an illegal fundraising scheme, gathered in Beijing.





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 20 November 2008 8:14 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

2dogs in D.C.,

21/11/2008 00:06:05
Well,how 'bout that. This seems a good thing.
2

Finlang,

Switzerland 21/11/2008 02:37:17
As a regular in China I have been aware of this coming for a long time. Personally, I have had no trouble whatsoever with internet access and whatever else ill-educated cynics outside post with monotonous regularity. There is as much freedom as you can normally take for granted in the west.

People who have never set foot in China, and rely on second-hand reports, then make hysterical media comments based on duff info, really need to get on a plane and see for themselves.


3

Postmark-55,

China, 21/11/2008 03:00:39
#2 Finlang,
Well said.
I am a Canadian living in China and there's been a lot of openess since I've been here and I have full access to the internet. True, our government does tell the media to tell the truth and the internet is monitored but that is there to ensure security rather than to censor. Also to keep the west from telling lies about China which the west has done so often in the past, all because the west fears Communism, or should I say the success of Communism?
4

Hugo of Garven,

21/11/2008 05:04:16
This is a sign of increased confidence by the Chinese government. Long may it continue.

No doubt there will be many scares and horror stories - just like we have in the west.
5

Boy Wonder,

21/11/2008 08:53:58
It's a start! Perhaps we are seeing the chains of repression beginning to crack before they shatter ... and they will!
6

Banana Heid,

Ayrshire 21/11/2008 09:43:15
I wonder if the Scotsman might follow their lead at some point in the future and stop being the voice of the Scottish Labour party? I doubt it...
7

Let's have the truth,

Queensland 21/11/2008 12:16:37
#6

...Maybe the Scotsman will take China's lead and allow comment on some reports they deem "Sensitive".

8

Guga II,

Rockall 21/11/2008 13:06:04
So when are the Chinese gangster government going to start reporting the truth about the genocide they are committing in Tibet?
9

Postmark-55,

China, 21/11/2008 13:20:48
#8 Guga II,
Guga old buddy old pal, things never seem to sink in with you, do they. Mashimaro and I have told too many times to recall that there's no genocide taking place in Tibet. Tibetans are exempt from the one child policy, as are all other ethnic minorities in China. That only applies to the majority Han Chinese. If we are indeed guilty of genocide, then you could use the Han Chinese as an example, but since we are not guilty of genocide of any form against anyone, your accusations make you out to be rather dense, for you won't accept the truth.
I have offered to open my doors for you time and again so that you can see for yourself what I'm talikng about, but you've refused my offer time and again. The offer is still on the table. If I can make a believer out of you, by you visiting us, then maybe you will spread the word in the west that China is indeed a great country that treats all its citizens equally well, with well being the key word. Think it over, and in the meantime please stop telling lies about China, we don't tell lies about Scotland.
10

James Donald,

Newbridge 21/11/2008 14:37:12
Stop Press!! Bad news from the press of the Peoples' Republic..........Communism sucks..........
11

Bele's bane,

Scotland 21/11/2008 14:38:24
A definative step in the right direction, now if China would walk a bit further along this enlightened path and only stop persecuting dissidents the world would be so much improved!
12

SouthernGent,

21/11/2008 16:53:50
#3
Nothing like a good dose of capitalism to allow communism to "succeed".
13

Postmark-55,

China, 22/11/2008 00:57:46
#12 SouthernGent,
Considering that you usually bring up good points and present a strong argument it seems clear here that you agree that Communism indeed has succeeded.

#10 James Donald,
Rather childish statement, even for you.
14

James Donald,

Newbridge 22/11/2008 01:10:26
#13 Postmark-55,Red China - "Rather childish statement" - you do not have the monopoly on this.
15

Postmark-55,

China, 22/11/2008 01:54:41
#14 James Donald,
Go to sleep Jimmy boy, it is well past your bedtime and you don't want your mommy to see the cellar lights on at this time, she'll take your computer away from you, again.
16

SouthernGent,

22/11/2008 02:12:16
I would not characterize it as "communism succeeding", more like a hybrid form of gov't.
17

Ms Doreen in the Cyber Shebeen,

22/11/2008 03:09:47
The rock dweller patronises those whom it deems supporters of its bloody regime...no surprises there...it must bandage its abdomen every evening because of its bowing and scraping..hope its worth the trouble and pain my long haired snout nosed sniveller.....quite remarkable...how transparent it is and yet...it persists in its (paid) pursuit.
18

James Donald,

Newbridge 22/11/2008 06:22:59
#15 Postmark-55,Red China - I'll decide old man. Didn't your "invisible friend" tell you that my house doesn't have a cellar?
Carefull what you post on the internet or your Commissar will take your computer away and you with it. Don't want to be in a "re-education camp" in winter - you'll never survive it at your age.
19

Postmark-55,

China, 22/11/2008 08:52:13
#17 Ms Doreen in the Cyber Shebeen,
Still talking to yourself I see eh Horrible? What's the matter, lost your smurf again?
20

Postmark-55,

China, 22/11/2008 08:58:09
#18 James Donald,
Actually Jimmy boy it was you who told both Mashimaro and myself that if we ever wanted to escape the workers paradise, you'd find room for us in your cellar. Are you suffering from short or long term memory loss Jimmy?
Funny thing though eh Jimmy, China is the real paradise, something you can only dream of living there on your wind-swept and rain-soaked island.
21

Bele's bane,

Scotland 22/11/2008 16:06:58
Post #7 Lets Have The Truth,Queensland

Very good statement on the Scotsman's propensity for the strict censorship of the posts!

Sometimes I think the Scotman's censor believes he or she is in China!
22

Finlang,

France 24/11/2008 02:01:32
#21

You called it wrong on China. I attempted to post an innocuous few words here on the Malaysian Islam story yesterday and it was given the heave-ho, without reason as usual, by the in-house censoring machine. Also tried to post elsewhere and hit the same brick wall. China, in my experience, is truly enlightened compared to this.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.