Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 30th August 2008 Change Date

RBS Ambassador, Luke Donald

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Junta 'hoarding aid from abroad'



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 May 2008
ONLY a tiny portion of international relief is reaching Burma's cyclone victims, the UN said yesterday, amid reports the country's military regime is hoarding high-quality foreign aid for itself while people make do with rotten food.
"There is obviously still a lot of frustration that this aid effort hasn't picked up pace" ten days after the cyclone hit, said Richard Horsey, the spokesman for the UN humanitarian operation in Bangkok.

The UN said the World Food Programme is get
ting in 20 per cent of the food needed because of bottlenecks, logistics problems and government-imposed restrictions.

The delays have only served to bolster complaints that the military is appropriating the aid for itself.

A long-term foreign resident of the country's biggest city, Rangoon, said government officials have complained to him about military leaders misappropriating aid, though the UN could not confirm the report.

He said the officials told him that quantities of the high- energy biscuits rushed in on the World Food Programme's first flights were sent to a military warehouse.

They were exchanged with what the officials said were "tasteless and low-quality" biscuits produced by the industry ministry to be handed out to victims of the cyclone, the foreign resident said in a telephone interview.

The WFP said it had not heard of its supplies disappearing.

"We've had no reports whatsoever about any incidents of this kind," Marcus Prior, a WFP spokesman, said in Bangkok.

A Burma government spokesman refused to comment. The allegations were impossible to confirm independently because of the massive restrictions imposed by the junta on journalists.

The military – which has ruled the country with an iron fist since 1962 – has taken control of most of the aid sent by other countries.

State television said the death toll had gone up by 2,335 to 34,273, and the number of missing stood at 27,838 after many of those listed as missing were accounted for. The United Nations says the actual death toll could be between 62,000 and 100,000.

Unicef estimates a third of those killed were children, based largely on population data from the affected areas as well as the scant information on those who survived.

"Our figures in the camps show a lot of adults, but very few children and very few elderly," said Care Australia's country director in Burma, Brian Agland.

"The worst-case scenario is that a lot of children may have lost their lives because of drowning," he said. "In one village there were 500 survivors and they were all adults. So that's the kind of despair people are living with, wondering where their children are."

State television said the navy's commander-in-chief, Rear-Admiral Soe Thein, told Admiral Timothy Keating, commander of the US Pacific forces, that basic needs of the storm victims are being fulfilled and that "skilful humanitarian workers are not necessary".

Mr Agland, said members of his local staff brought back some of the rotting rice that's being distributed in the devastated Irawaddy Delta. "It's some of the poorest quality rice we've seen," he said. "It's affected by salt water and it's very old.

"It's unclear whether the rice, which is dark grey in colour and consists of very small grains, is coming from the government or from mills in the area or warehouses hit by the cyclone."

Many survivors also said they were either not getting any aid or were being handed rotten, mouldy rice. "There is obviously still a lot of frustration that this aid effort hasn't picked up pace" ten days after the cyclone hit, said Mr Horsey.

Cyclone Nargis devastated the delta on 2-3 May, washing away homes and submerging large tracts of land. Some two million survivors, mostly poor rice farmers, are living in abject misery, facing disease and starvation.

Tens of thousands of people throughout the delta are crammed into Buddhist monasteries and schools after arriving in towns that were on the breadline even before the disaster.

Lacking food, water and sanitation, they face the threat of killer diseases such as cholera. Heavy tropical rains added to their misery.

"Where I am now there's over 10,000 homeless people and it's pouring rain," Bridget Gardener of the International Red Cross said during a rare tour of the delta by a foreign aid official.

The government has also barred nearly all foreigners experienced in managing such catastrophes from going to the delta west of Rangoon, and is expelling those who have managed to go in.

Jean-Sebastien Matte, an emergency co-ordinator with Doctors Without Borders, said his staff have repeatedly been forced to return to Rangoon from the delta. Armed police checkpoints were set up on the roads to the delta, and all foreigners were being turned away by policemen who took down their names and passport numbers. "No foreigners allowed," a policeman said, after waving a car back.

EU call to bypass generals

FRANCE, Britain and Germany yesterday called for the world to deliver aid to cyclone victims in Burma – if necessary without the military junta's permission

"We have called for the 'responsibility to protect' to be applied in the case of Burma," Rama Yade, France's junior minister for human rights, told reporters as EU development ministers met to discuss emergency aid for Burma.

The little-used UN principle could allow the delivery of aid without the accord of the government, if the military rulers continue to bar foreign aid teams from entering the country.

Ms Yade said France, backed by the two other major EU powers, would put the proposal to the UN Security Council, but she acknowledged it did not have unanimous support among the 27 EU member states.

A first French attempt to have the Security Council adopt its idea of aid without authorisation was rebuffed last week by China, Vietnam, South Africa and Russia, but also Britain.

Javier Solana, the EU's foreign policy chief, called for the world to use all necessary means to help. "The UN charter opens some avenues if things cannot be resolved in order to get the humanitarian aid (to] arrive," he told reporters.

Asked if aid could be flown in without the approval of the Burmese authorities, he said: "Whatever is necessary to help the people who are suffering."





The full article contains 1051 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 May 2008 10:01 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Guga II,

Rockall 14/05/2008 03:25:31
"A first French attempt to have the Security Council adopt its idea of aid without authorisation was rebuffed last week by China, Vietnam, South Africa and Russia, but also Britain."

Well we know why the war criminal Maggie Broon would vote against a measure such as this. He already has most of our troops and equipment committed to his illegal wars, there is nothing left to spare for anything else.
2

Anne,

Eaglesham 14/05/2008 05:04:29
Sorry as i am for the plight of the people of burma, I will be donating nothing to this appeal until the distribution is taken over by NGAs.

I will not be a party to propping up that rotten regime.

Now if only we could withhold taxes as a way of getting rid of the rotten regime in this country!
3

Tatties ower the side,

Johannesburg 14/05/2008 05:40:21
#2 Anne It seems to me that the Labour Party is doing a pretty good job of getting rid of itself right now.....
4

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 14/05/2008 06:51:56
The UN security council is a joke. Everytime there is a measure to get members to live up to their charter oblegations is brought forward the representatives of the CCP in Beijing veto it.

This is a club that is not worth belonging to. Maybe it is high time that the democratic governments of the world formed a new organization. Make one of the requirements of membership having a democratic form of government and a willingness to honour your human rights commitments. Then leave the rump UN to be what it is best at, a talking shop for despots and dictators.

We will have to see if the Western Governments will act unilaterally to make sure the necessary aid reaches the victims of this tragedy. As their attempt to force the issue of making Junta accountable to the UN charter will inevitably fail when China vetos it.
5

Itchy,

14/05/2008 07:24:09
"ONLY a tiny portion of international relief is reaching Burma's cyclone victims, the UN said yesterday, amid reports the country's military regime is hoarding high-quality foreign aid for itself while people make do with rotten food."

As surprises go, this is on a par with the Pope announcing that he is a Catholic.
6

Boy Wonder,

14/05/2008 07:38:29
Like we didn't see this coming??

I'm really sorry, but I will donate nothing until the proper people take charge ... and by that time, who knows how many will have died because their own (unelected) leaders have killed them.
7

bill2,

14/05/2008 08:25:36
4
KampungHighlander,

"Maybe it is high time that the democratic governments of the world formed a new organization. Make one of the requirements of membership having a democratic form of government and a willingness to honour your human rights commitments."

Nice to see an alternative proposal, but I can't think of any countries that would meet your membership criteria.

The UN is all we have and we have to make it work.
8

Subodai,

China 14/05/2008 08:52:15
#4 Define democracy.
9

Iain's,

14/05/2008 09:45:53
The government in Myanmar sounds like a branch of the Glasgow Labour Party.

10

Biker,

Ayr 14/05/2008 10:56:07
Bill 2 Yes indeed it is the only option we have (The UN) but it is need of complete overhaul. The Veto needs to be removed as a way of abstaining and the only options being for or against. The winning vote wins the day. All this provarication and obfuscation only attempts to cover national self interest.
It's no surprise that China and Vietnam veto the the UK????? What the hell is going on here?
The Uk government shows its self for what it is.
11

Subodai,

China 14/05/2008 11:19:20
#10 Oh yes, wait until vote does not go your way to want change rules
12

Stefan,

NYC 14/05/2008 14:01:37
#11. Typical. Zero concern for the suffering of others just an over-riding desire to stick it to your colonial masters. Get you head out.
13

mike - across the pond,

Bill2 & Biker... 14/05/2008 14:46:18
the UN is fundamentally flawed... just as the League of Nations was before that...

if you knew your history you would KNOW that it is a product of Stalin being the "wiley veteran" in a post WW2 world... where the US & UK had the rather naive duo of Harry Truman & Clement Attlee at their helms...

China (having a permanent seat on the security council) can veto ANYTHING that comes to a vote... it can be 7-0 and china can say "nope, aint gonna happen"

just as the US and UK can... we however have the ability to hold our political leaders accountable for their actions... China... not so much...

the idea of a "United DEMOCRATIC Nations"... is a great one, the larger the block of nations, the larger the influence... however I fear that the pendulum may be quickly swinging away from us... and like any democratic body, unless everyone agrees to go along with the majority regardless of the decisions made, it quickly factionalizes and risks falling appart...

besides... wouldnt something like that smack of "New Order" or one of the other consipiracy theorists uber-control groups?
14

Subodai,

China 14/05/2008 23:43:13
#13 The pendulum has long time swung already.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.