Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Thursday, 28th August 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

African states bite bullet to seek 'unity' government in Zimbabwe



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 July 2008
THE African Union called last night for a national unity government in Zimbabwe, summit delegates said, after the widely condemned re-election of President Robert Mugabe in a poll scarred by violence.
The pan-African body, which had been divided over what to do about Zimbabwe, adopted the resolution after Botswana called for the AU and the Southern African Development Community (SADC) to bar Mugabe.

It was the toughest public statement from one
of Zimbabwe's neighbours since Mugabe was sworn in on Sunday following a one-candidate election condemned by monitors as violent and unfair.

Botswana's vice-president, Mompati Merafhe, said: "In our considered view... the representatives of the current government in Zimbabwe should be excluded from attending SADC and African Union meetings."

Botswana said Mugabe's participation in African meetings "would give unqualified legitimacy to a process which cannot be considered legitimate."

It said the government and opposition must be treated as equal in any mediation.

Raila Odinga, Kenya's prime minister, has also called for Mugabe, 84, to be suspended from the African Union after an election which extended the veteran leader's 28-year rule.

The Botswana statement underlined the deep rifts both within Africa as a whole and among Zimbabwe's neighbours.

South Africa, the designated mediator in Zimbabwe, has resisted open condemnation of Mugabe. The AU summit in the resort of Sharm el-Sheikh has been dominated by the deepening crisis in Zimbabwe, where a once-prosperous economy is racked by the world's worst hyper-inflation.

Mugabe, 84, addressed the final session of the two-day summit, senior delegates said.

His spokesman, George Charamba, earlier sounded resistant to proposals to share power. He insisted the leader would not step down.

"He's a few days into office and you expect him to retire, do you? ... Five days have expired, not even a week after. ... Why is the issue of the retirement of the president of Zimbabwe such an obsession for the West?"

He said Zimbabwe's ruling party had offered dialogue to the opposition, but would not promise anything more.

Mr Charamba had harsh words for western pressure: "They can go hang. They can go and hang a thousand times."

Opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai withdrew from the poll because of the violence, which he said had killed 86 of his supporters in the Movement for Democratic Change.

Delegates said leaders had been divided between those wanting a strong statement on Zimbabwe and those reluctant to censure Mugabe publicly.



The full article contains 417 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 July 2008 10:06 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Zimbabwe
 
1

Scullion,

Canada 02/07/2008 02:37:20
Charamba is the typical goon which thugocracies produce. He has to support the madman who made him; he's a sort of Frankenstein's monster who differs from the original in that he loves his creator. Without him, what good is he?
2

KampungHighlander,

Jakarta 02/07/2008 04:18:26
This summit was an effective test to gauge individual African Governments commitment to good governance standards. Measuring a countries commitment to human rights, the rule of law and democracy should be the primary criteria in the allocation of foreign assistance.

Countries that do not meet good governance standards tend also to be unaccountable when it comes to making sure that aid is delivered effectively and without corruption.

Kenya, Nigeria, Zambia, Senegal and Botswana all showed their commitment to good governance standards.
The rest came up wanting. Some like President for Life Omar Bongo showed they have no commitment at all. I hope that Western Governments use this summit as a yardstick to measure which countries in Africa should receive aid.
3

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 07:53:15
Not all white nations are affluent and orderly, but most are affluent and orderly. Not all Black nations are chaotic and poverty stricken, but most black nations are chaotic and poverty stricken.
If this was a dictator in Europe, he would not last 30 odd years, no way! The EU would take action and they would not care less if the dictator in question felt offended. But in Africa it is different because only one or two leaders will stand up and be counted, whereas the majority will keep quiet for fear that they may offend a fellow leader who in essence is doing what they want to do, or have already done.
Thus Europe will always flourish and Africa will always toil and sweat.
4

El Sabio,

Sibbertoft 02/07/2008 08:00:12
I wrote a while ago that nothing would be done. There would much huffing and puffing and rhetoric etc..

Perhaps some think that black lives are not worth as much as white lives.
5

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 08:20:40
El Sabio

I think you are right! It certainly seems as if White people tend to place more importantance on the value of life, whereas black people appear to be less inclined to place importance on life..generally speaking that is.....
White governments around the world offer their white masses a platform to live within, there is order and hope. Black governments for the most part, offer their people nothing.
Also, look at the old apartheid regimes in southern africa! They were out of order but they still looked after their OWN people. The same cannot be said about black governments...
6

Mashimaro,

China 02/07/2008 08:59:32
Wow Media1 you just lost any respect I had for you. What do you mean the governments looked after the OWN people? You say that like it's some sort of badge of merit. The blacks were their OWN people, as were the British.
7

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

02/07/2008 09:20:43
5...Oh aye that is "generally speaking" allright...racially stereotyping more like pal..

"White governments around the world offer their white masses a platform to live within"...!!!

Have you totally lost the plot?...I think you will find that many a "white" government has blacks within it and the people they offer a "platform" to are also composed of blacks....

This reveals your vision of the world outside of Africa somewhat.....
8

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 09:44:13
Horrible

I admire your attempt to look as if you know a thing or two about the world, but of course people like you know nothing. You try and suggest that there is no difference with white and black societies in an attempt to appease anyone who may offer you hard time for such statements. But in truth, it does not take a person like me to openly state the difference, all you need do is visit France, Germany, Austria, America, Cananda and Norway AND THEN visit Nigeria, Malaw, Zimbabwe, Somalia and Burundi.
Or compare the crime statistics in South Africa now to the crime statistics in South Africa 20 years ago.
Or compare the amount of foreign aid Africa has offered the world by comparison to the foreign aid she has been offered.
Yes there is black people living in white socieites and rightly so, why shouldnt they be? But in these societies the management, the co-ordination, the systems and the overall authority is white, so it works for all concerned.
Forget your calls of racism and start looking at the problems and the trends. YES the truth is difficult to handle, but that does not mean it must be swept under the carpet in an attempt to hide it.
Black governments need to step up to the plate. Black societies need to step up to the plate.
There is NO difference between white and black people in terms of their attributes, but when it comes to societies, the white man is so far ahead it is frightening. And it is time that black governments did someting to close this gap.
And they can start by condeming Mugabe for dragging his country to its knees.
9

El Sabio,

Sibbertoft 02/07/2008 10:13:53
There is an interesting article following on MUGABE'S LAST STAND in the FOREIGN AFFAIRS e-mail newsletter this month in which Mugabe appears to be the embodiment of reasonableness. It was published 20 years ago

PS I do not work for FOREIGN AFFAIRS
10

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 10:24:47
Mashimaro

Youa are running to play the downtrodden card again.
Read what I said! I SAID that the old apartheid was OUT OF ORDER! However, within the system that these white people managed, they provided their people with a platform to live within. They did not attack their people, they did not starve their people, they did not beat their people. THEY DID instil fear within us, we dare not question their authority, they were just as bad in that regard. But they managed to maintain order and grow an economy, create jobs and provide modern infrastructure. Even under international sanctions, the white minority rised above the challenge and began inventing and innovating their own technology.
By contrast, the ANC speak about THEIR PEOPLE, meaning black people. Zanu PF speak about their people, meaning black people. And at the moment, THEIR PEOPLE are being starved, beaten and murdered. There is no economy, no jobs and no hope.
This is the truth, whether you want to accept it or not is irrelivant. Whether you like me or not is irrelivant, all that matters is that I am telling the truth. I am NOT fabricating anything and I am NOT inventing stories or spreading mythical nonsense, I am simply commenting on the TRUTH!
11

Erchie Broon,

02/07/2008 11:48:10
Media 1
I dont know why you even bother to try and placate the self hating White and guardian of human rights Canker nor his racist partner Mashimaro. There comes a stage when you just have to accept that these are backward people with low self esteem and the internet provides them with the only platform to express their uneducated views where someone may listen.
12

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 11:56:26
Erchie Broon

Perhaps you are right, but I feel it is important to express such views to people as limited as them because Africa is dying a rapid death at the hands of some primitive people and unless we speak up and say it like it is, it may never end.

I understand where you are coming from, but I believe there is still hope and that I may one day be able to change them from racists to realists.
13

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

02/07/2008 14:41:22
Media 1...There are differences between every and all cultures...you only raise what you perceive to be the negative between black and whites....you continually to point your big white finger from your lofty position of the great white gob...you sicken me...this is not about crime stats but your attitude to black people....let me spell it out...in your statement re "White Governments" and "White masses" you fail to acknowledge the black people who exist there...no blacks in Britain, France or the USA then?....

It is your hidden agenda that scunners me boy....constantly banging on and on about "White power" under the guise of "Africa is a mess"...

As far as aparthied is concerned in South Africa...that country still reaps the fruit of its vile harvest...blacks and whites are suffering because of it....my in laws were in S.A. recently and were shocked by the attitudes and treatment towards black people....they will not be going back....

How dare you generalise by saying that "White people place more value on human life than black people"...you sicken me....try telling that to the man I met with from Rwanda, with machete scars on his arms and head...who saw his family butchered in front of him...repeat that statement to him and get back to me...really...your smug white superior arrogance turns my stomach....you are the worst kind of racist...a cowardly one who attempts to hide his views behind a'wordly wise' air of knowledge...sorry son...transparent...it dont wash....you see your attitude extends beyond Africa and towards black people...in "General"...despite your protestations..
14

Lost in Africa ,

02/07/2008 15:00:32
Why do Europeans insist on looking at Africa with rose tinted glasses?
South Africa is only one election away from becoming like the rest of the continent.
The African Union is the largest gathering of dictators, who know that they will always get hand outs from the West.
15

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 15:29:08
Horrible
You dont have a clue.
Maybe come and live in Africa!
In fact, leave Europe behind, leave their economies, their transport systems, running water and sanitation behind. Forget your electricity, forget your roads and systems and come and embrace the chaos, the genocide, the murder and the killing.
Yes horrible, come to Africa and walk the streets of Lagos or Luanda and see how long you last. Better yet, come and walk through Johannesburg city centre one evening and I bet you will die before you walk five blocks.
Yes Horrible, come and live in Hilbrow, the once beautiful and pristine suburb on the outskirts of the JHB city centre that is now a septic and disgusting hell hole of crime and destruction and utter devastation at the hands of Nigerian drug lords who come to SA to escape the attrocities in their own godforsaken country.
Come here and help the millons of aids victims whose health minister tells them to take more garlic and beetroot in order to cure themselves.
Come here and shake hands with the corrupt government officials in almost every department who steal from the very people that great men like Mandela fought to protect.
Yes Horrible, come and experience Africa or stay where you are and pretend to care from a distance.
I have said it before, but you REALLY are the sort of person my black mates refer to as "patronising trash"
If pointing out the failures of black societies offends you, then to bad because this isnt about you, its about a continent in turmoil..
16

Lost in Africa ,

02/07/2008 15:56:03
Media 1 trying to explain Africa to a European is a waste of breath, they either have some romantic notion of the continent or are out and out racists. Africa should be left to the blacks to work it out for themselves, it is the white mans fault that they were dragged into the 20th century from the stone age in one go. However in most cases Europe left its colonies with water supplies, electricity and a working government system.
As a post script;
The day Ian Smiths last demand for independance was rejected by Britain because they were not 'mature' enough to run themselves, was the week that the newly independant Nigeria started on the road to civil war with the assasination of Tafawa Balawa.
17

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 16:11:07
Lost in Africa

Yeah I guess you are right.
We all understand that African people are tribal people who were forced into an unnatural modern white mans world. If only those bloody ships had kept sailing and left the African people to live the life they were living then we would not have all these problems. But the Europeans had an inbuilt exploration unit within them, which forced them to dock their ships and take over. They are doing the same in space as we speak, the fronteirs are different but the underlying principles are the same.
Like you say, there is much to be said about the way the Europeans colonised this continent, but you would expect Africans to be able to maintain the wonderful infrastructures that were left to them. But truth is, they have failed to do in EVERY SINGLE country.
And this one is next.
18

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

02/07/2008 16:31:48
15...No denials then but a reference to the token "Black mates"...funny that...would have thought that comment would have come from your "Beautiful black Belgian(not African mind!!)fiancee"...as if that is proof that you are not a racisct..

"Why some of my best friends are gay/black/catholic/ etc etc...tick the most appropriate....

You glory in Africa's problems because it constantly (and consistantly) gives you the opportunity to bang your white drum...

Yawn.....its all getting a bit tired now...you never have anything but negative comments to make re black people...I even had to refer you to sites that listed the inventions and discoveries of black people as you preferred to gloat over that of the whites...

Try to understand why African people are the way they are instead of condemning them from your white pulpit..
19

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 16:47:24
Horrible

Colour has nothing to do with forming relationships, surely EVEN you must understand that.
Relationships are formed through common interests, so when I meet a white guy who does not share an ounce of interest with me and a black guy who does, I form the relationship with the black guy. Simple really!
But when it comes to Africa, the place where I live and I met with incompetence at every level of African society day after day, week after week, year after year for fourteen years it eventually wears you down and alters your thought process.
The minister of health who wants to cure aids with beetroot and garlic is black - there is no excuse for this, not even your colonialism arguement can forgive her for this.
The minister of safety who says that people who dont like murder and rape should shut up or leave the country is black - He cannot be excused for this, and his words were supported by most in government.
98% of the murder in this country is committed by?
99% of the rape in this country is committed by?
The mini bus taxi industry that causes untold carnage on our roads and treats their passengers like pieces of sh!t is run by?
The xenophobic attacks that killed over 60 people just recently were committed by?
The ANC President who is up on corruption and racketeering charges is?
The company that used to run our electricity was white, it is now black and we are living in darkness. They fired all the whites! The water that used to run through our pipes was the best in the world. Not any more. The roads used to be good, not any more, the crime was well within what could be considered low, not any more. kids used to be able to play in the streets, not any more. Rape was something you heard about once in a blue moon, not any more.
So come on horrible, come and live in Africa why dont you.
Oh yeah, thats right, you cant because you only pretend to care in order to appear like a politically correct fellow.
20

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 17:03:34
And Horrible

Yes some of my mates are Catholic, most of my family are. But guess what, I detest everything that church stands for because that is my right and I dont hide it.
Yes some of my mates are black, but gut guess what. I am sick and tired of the f0cking incompetence at every level of black governed societies.
You dont see the day to day stupidity and utter chaos that takes shape in front of your eyes, you dont need to listen to the useless and utterly clueless government officials who cannot add 5 plus 5 telling us how to run a country.
You dont need to listen to the President of your country telling you that there is NO CRISIS in Zimbabwe. You dont need to listen to your President telling you that AIDS is actually "not real" its a myth he said. Then he changed his mind.
You dont need to watch millions of Zimbabweans begging on the streets, you dont need to stop at almost EVERY traffic light in the country and offer charity to the millions whose governmemt has fotgotten about them. You dont need to listen to the ANC Youth League President say that he will pick up arms and KILL if Zuma is convicted. It goes on and on!
And YES, there is plenty of dynamic black people who try their best to distance themselves from such thinking, there is plenty of black people who condemn Mugabe and wishe he was dead, there is plenty of black people who are hell bent on making their communities the best they can be, but unfotunately these people are called coconuts bu their own people.
White on the inside! So please dont tell me how this continent operates, you have no clue.
21

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 17:21:00
Horrible

You seem to think that there is something wrong with highlighting a very real problem in this world. And that problem is clearly evident in Africa, Haiti, Harlem and Compton.
If I turn to a bunch of drug addicts and say, "listen you lot, you are a bunch of useless good for nothing halfwits" am I being a drugist? Or am I merely pointing out the obvious?
If I turn to a bunch of alcoholic wasters and tell them they are total drunk scum, am I an alcoholoist? or merely pointing out the obvious.
Likewise, when I look at Africa and say listen guys, your countries are a total mess, your systems are a disgrace, your poverty is a total joke, your lack of basic services is pitiful, your inability to invent and innovate is backward, am I being racist? Or merely ponting out the obvious?
22

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

02/07/2008 17:27:39
Your adopted country is reaping the rewards of an unjust system only recently dismantled...dont fkn whinge when people were treated like animals and told they were scum..laws created to stop them mingling with whites..marrying whites...having an EDUCATION equivalent to that of a white.....

South Africa suffers....but then again...so do the other countries that South Africa meddled with...

Where do you watch the "Millions of Zimbabweans?" on your tv?.....

Black South African people need real education...they need to feel that they are real people and equal to whites...this aint going to happen whilst attitudes still persist, like yours, that they aint equal...they listen to nutters in power because they desperately need someone to trust who is not going to fk them over yet again...and yet again this continues to happen because those in power are exploiting the trust and naivety of those who look up to them...the African nation still has the Catholic Church telling them that condoms are wicked and will cause AIDS...exploiting their religious beliefs..etc etc etc...and it will continue to be a struggle until the African people have their pride back....
23

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

02/07/2008 17:29:34
What is the problem that you are pointing out Media 1?....until you admit that you are a proud racist I will have no respect for you...have the courage of your convictions for once and for all and admit what it is you are really trying to say about black people...
24

oder,

Scotland 02/07/2008 17:30:54
19 Media 1,cape town

have to agree with Erchie Broon you waste your time with experts like Crankers,these people have no idea about Africa,to these people the Europeans in Africa is wrong regardless of any achivement or success!they always come back with the racecard,simplely when you point out the situation they don't know/understand, your the racist! what ever the problem its you. have you noticed that all these PC "fair minded"supportter`s can list the wrong doings of the whiteman in detail,but could not list one positive effect that the whiteman has done in Africa.

25

oder,

Scotland 02/07/2008 17:41:04
sorry should read "simply"
26

mike - across the pond,

media1 02/07/2008 18:42:15
here's an idea...

liberty... what if THAT is the key...

liberty begats prosperity... & oppression begats poverty...

IMHO poverty/prosperity bears a strong correlation to libety

is it any wonder that states such as those in Africa, the balkans, & Asia suffer SO much poverty... even south africa under aparthied, black poverty was attrocious... and liberties were scarce for the non-whites... now the seas of liberty are rough and so is prosperity...

even states such as India who are democratic suffer HORRIBLE poverty IMHO because the lack of liberties imposed by their caste system... and as I understand it, their caste system is changing... the question is, can their democracy survive long enough for their liberties to fuel their prosperity... and will their expanding liberties continue, or will someone step in and roll things back?? causing prosperity go faulter...

china.... horrible oppression under Mao... and horrible poverty... they are changing... and liberties are coming about... but they are 20 years behind india... and will their succeeding regimes keep progressing, or will they step back...

and then of course there IS the question... once liberty is out of the bottle, what kind of oppression will it take to get it back IN the bottle??
27

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 19:39:23
Oder

I guess you are right, cankers has never lived in Africa so how could he possibly understand. It must also be said that Cankers would not consider living in Africa because that would mean living with African people, something he obviously has no intention of ever doing.
I guess it must be difficult for people to understand what being white in Africa means. It means, as you know, that you must quickly get used to incompetence and failure. And when I say failure, I make that assessement based on what we were used to prior to 1994. Now as bad as apartheid was, the system itself did nothing to make success any easier. If white people wanted an economy they had to build one, if they wanted roads and electricty, running water and plush suburbs they needed to make that happen regarldess of the system. If we wanted to live in a crime free zone we needed to make sure we worked hard to achieve such a world, nothing came easy, it was a mammoth struggle to achieve what they achieved. I drove through Johannesburg city centre the other day when I was up, and man what an achievment. What an absolutely wonderful achievment to build a city that big in a continent this backward.
But then you look at the way the cities heart beats and you suddenly realise that all is not well. What was once a gloriously splendid, clean and pristine city, is now an awfully delapidated and dirty, unsafe place. I wish I could have visited Hillbrow, but you know as well as I do that I would have been murdered within 3 minutes.
We used to have good electricity and good water, now we have darkness and problems with the quality of our water. Our dams used to be clean, the waterways were protected, whereas now the waterways are unmanaged, thus the rivers and dams are now contaminated. Too many people in positions they are ill qualified to handle.
You know as well as I do that such faliure and total break down is evident in all areas of government. So it is quite normal for those of us who live her
28

Media 1,

cape town 02/07/2008 19:41:20
live here to be frustrated at the hands of people who dont give a t0$$ about anything, and even if they did they dont have the brains to change anything.
I suppose you are right, how could a limited mind such as cankers be expected to understand.
29

Horrible Cankers at the Cyber Shebeen,

02/07/2008 21:37:31
My heart bleeds for you....you reap what you sow...if things are so bad for you Media1 why do you remain?...could it be that financially YOU are better off...could it be that your bleating on about "leaving countries to get on with their own problems and develop at their own pace" is a crock of when it affect you?

You still have not answered my post re yours at 21...what is this problem with black people that you allude to?...come on out with it chickensh!t.....

What would you say if you turned to a "bunch of" black people living in Harlem???

Eh??
30

,

03/07/2008 10:42:24
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.